Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

No Massless Goldstone Bosons in Hamiltonian Time Crystals

Antti J. Niemi

Published Nov 14, 2025• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We present a geometric framework for Hamiltonian quantum time crystals, emphasizing the pivotal role of continuous symmetries and their associated conserved charges. In this approach, a time crystal is identified as a minimum-energy ground state that is parallel transported along a family of Fock spaces, with time evolution realized as a symmetry transformation. This parallel transport is implemented via a generalized, time-dependent Bogoliubov transformation, ensuring coherence across the Fock spaces. Revisiting Goldstone's original analysis, we show that in the presence of a time crystal, the Goldstone mode acquires a mass and its direction oscillates periodically in Higgs space. Our formulation circumvents existing no-go theorems that would otherwise forbid quantum time-crystalline order. We place time crystals within the broader context of quantum many-body physics and field theory, drawing analogies to superconductivity and quantum field theory in time-dependent backgrounds.

DOI
10.1103/sytq-kjbr

Related papers

Absence of Quantum Time Crystals

Haruki Watanabe, Masaki Oshikawa

In analogy with crystalline solids around us, Wilczek recently proposed the idea of "time crystals" as phases that spontaneously break the continuous time translation into a discrete subgroup. The proposal stimulated further studies and vigorous debates whether it can be realized in a physical system. However, a precise definition of the time crystal is needed to resolve the issue. Here we first present a definition of time crystals based on the time-dependent correlation functions of the order parameter. We then prove a no-go theorem that rules out the possibility of time crystals defined as such, in the ground state or in the canonical ensemble of a general Hamiltonian, which consists of not-too-long-range interactions.

arXiv:1410.2143•Physical Review Letters•Jun 24, 2015•472 citations

On the dynamics of fluctuations in time crystals

Esteban Castillo, Benjamin Koch, Gonzalo A. Palma

We study the evolution of quantum fluctuations in systems known as time crystals, hypothetical systems for which the lowest energy state performs a periodic motion. We first discuss some general properties shared by time crystals, and deduce the effective field theory parametrizing the evolution of their fluctuations. We show that these fluctuations fall into categories analogous to acoustic and optical phonons, encountered in conventional crystals. The acoustic phonons correspond to gapless Goldstone boson modes parametrizing the broken time translation invariance of the crystal, whereas the optical phonons are identified with modes perpendicular to the broken symmetry of the system, which generically remain gapped. We study how these two modes decay and interact together, and discuss some observable features that could be tested in experimental realizations of time crystals.

arXiv:1410.2261•Oct 8, 2014•9 citations

Open Quantum Time Crystals without External Thermodynamic Resources: Go and No-Go Theorems

Yuri Ogami, Hiroyasu Tajima

Time crystals are phases of matter that spontaneously break time-translation symmetry. They have been ruled out in the ground and Gibbs states of isolated systems with only short-range interactions, yet they have been proposed and observed experimentally in nonequilibrium settings such as Floquet and open systems. However, existing proposals for time crystals in open quantum systems require an external supply of thermodynamic resources, such as work or energetic coherence. Whether coupling to an environment, without any such resource supply, can induce a time crystal absent in the isolated system remains open. Here, we answer this question systematically. We first construct an explicit model and prove that coupling to an environment can activate a time crystal absent in the isolated system, even without such resource supply. We consider Lindblad master equations with (i) time-independent Hamiltonian and jump operators, (ii) time-translation covariance, and (iii) detailed balance---conditions that hold in standard derivations unless thermodynamic resources are supplied externally. Our model satisfies these conditions, and the activation occurs in a stationary state of both the isolated and open systems. We give several implementations of this dynamics with a zero-temperature Gibbs environment, a time-independent, energy-conserving interaction, and only short-range Hamiltonians, one of which exactly reproduces the time-crystalline periodicity. We then prove a no-go theorem: under (i)--(iii), activation can arise only from an environment-induced Hamiltonian term, not from dissipation. Our results show that time crystals can be activated in open systems without external resource supply and identify the physical requirements on the system and environment for this activation through our general no-go theorem.

arXiv:2611.09540•Nov 6, 2026•0 citations

Time Crystals and Broken Temporal Symmetry

Kisalaya Chakrabarti

This chapter examines the physics of time crystals and the new form of order kassociated with the emergence of broken time symmetry. Unlike ordinary spatial crystals, which have ordered structures in space, time crystals exhibit a persistent periodic behavior in time. They form temporally ordered phases that break discrete time-translation symmetry. In this chapter, after laying the groundwork with the basic concepts of Floquet dynamics and discrete time crystals, the periodically driven quantum systems are found to give rise to stable sub-harmonic oscillations that last much longer than the normal relaxation times. This chapter formulates the notion of time as a lattice-like coordinate, where the temporal evolution is determined by a translation operator like those in spatial crystals. One of the main focuses of this chapter is translational symmetry breaking (TSB) in temporal lattices and its role in coherence, entanglement, and dynamical stability This chapter uses the theory of translational symmetry and standing-wave entanglement of Chakrabarti in providing a nodal–antinodal description of temporal dynamics as it entails that the nodal regions act as coherence-preserving points, whereas antinodal regions are centers of amplified oscillatory response. This framework shows how symmetry breaking reconfigures entanglement over temporal lattices so that localized coherence structures are created that can stabilize quantum oscillations in the presence of the environment. This chapter further develops an entanglement-driven model of autonomous time crystals. Normal Floquet theory is greatly modified in this autonomous case through the use of evolution operators that are driven, not by external periodic driving but by an inherent quantum coherence. Self-organized tempo is the periodicity of the sustained oscillation of the phase-locked standing-wave entangled fields due to nonlinear quantum interference in this formulation. The occurrence of stable sub-harmonic oscillations, localization of coherence, and long-lived temporal order are demonstrated through numerical simulation, phase-space analysis, spectral study, and magnetization dynamics. The closed trajectories in phase space realize oscillations of magnetization, and spectral peaks relate to breaking of discrete time-translation symmetry, revealing an autonomous time crystal. This chapter also looks into the mechanisms to preserve entanglement and coherence in dynamical. Methods to counteract noise and retain temporal order include dynamical decoupling, decoherence-free subspaces (DFS), adaptive feedback control, and nonlinear entanglement localization. Special stress is placed on the relevance between nodal entanglement localization and DFS which suggests that internal quantum dynamics can give rise to noise-resistant coherence-preserving structures. By consolidating aspects like time-crystalline periodicity, TSB, nodal–antinodal dynamics, and entanglement preservation into one framework, this chapter can pave the way toward autonomous quantum temporal architectures and open up new paths for quantum chronodynamics, entanglement-based temporal engineering, and self-organized quantum systems.

Chapman & Hall/CRC eBooks•Nov 13, 2026•0 citations

A Brief History of Time Crystals

Vedika Khemani, Roderich Moessner, Shivaji L. Sondhi

The idea of breaking time-translation symmetry has fascinated humanity at least since ancient proposals of the perpetuum mobile. Unlike the breaking of other symmetries, such as spatial translation in a crystal or spin rotation in a magnet, time translation symmetry breaking (TTSB) has been tantalisingly elusive. We review this history up to recent developments which have shown that discrete TTSB does takes place in periodically driven (Floquet) systems in the presence of many-body localization. Such Floquet time-crystals represent a new paradigm in quantum statistical mechanics --- that of an intrinsically out-of-equilibrium many-body phase of matter. We include a compendium of necessary background, before specializing to a detailed discussion of the nature, and diagnostics, of TTSB. We formalize the notion of a time-crystal as a stable, macroscopic, conservative clock --- explaining both the need for a many-body system in the infinite volume limit, and for a lack of net energy absorption or dissipation. We also cover a range of related phenomena, including various types of long-lived prethermal time-crystals, and expose the roles played by symmetries -- exact and (emergent) approximate -- and their breaking. We clarify the distinctions between many-body time-crystals and other ostensibly similar phenomena dating as far back as the works of Faraday and Mathieu. En route, we encounter Wilczek's suggestion that macroscopic systems should exhibit TTSB in their ground states, together with a theorem ruling this out. We also analyze pioneering recent experiments detecting signatures of time crystallinity in a variety of different platforms, and provide a detailed theoretical explanation of the physics in each case. In all existing experiments, the system does not realize a `true' time-crystal phase, and we identify necessary ingredients for improvements in future experiments.

arXiv:1910.10745•Oct 23, 2019•307 citations

Diffusive Nambu-Goldstone modes in quantum time-crystals

Tomoya Hayata, Yoshimasa Hidaka

We study the Nambu-Goldstone (NG) modes associated with spontaneous breaking of the continuous time-translation symmetry. To discuss a quantum time-crystal with the spontaneously-broken continuous time-translation symmetry, we introduce the van der Pol type nonlinear-friction to open quantum systems. By considering small fluctuations around a time-periodic mean-field solution, we show that a gapless collective mode necessarily appears; this is nothing but the NG mode associated with a time crystal. We show that its dispersion relation becomes $ω=-iC\bm p^2$. We also show that noncommutative breaking of the time-translation and U(1) symmetries results in mixing of the NG modes, and the (typically) propagating NG mode appears, whose dispersion relation becomes $ω=(\pm C_1-iC_2)\bm p^2$.

arXiv:1808.07636•Aug 23, 2018•20 citations
We present a geometric framework for Hamiltonian quantum time crystals, emphasizing the pivotal role of continuous symmetries and their associated conserved charges. In this approach, a time crystal is identified as a minimum-energy ground state that is parallel transported along a family of Fock spaces, with time evolution realized as a symmetry transformation. This parallel transport is implemented via a generalized, time-dependent Bogoliubov transformation, ensuring coherence across the Fock spaces. Revisiting Goldstone's original analysis, we show that in the presence of a time crystal, the Goldstone mode acquires a mass and its direction oscillates periodically in Higgs space. Our formulation circumvents existing no-go theorems that would otherwise forbid quantum time-crystalline order. We place time crystals within the broader context of quantum many-body physics and field theory, drawing analogies to superconductivity and quantum field theory in time-dependent backgrounds.
In analogy with crystalline solids around us, Wilczek recently proposed the idea of "time crystals" as phases that spontaneously break the continuous time translation into a discrete subgroup. The proposal stimulated further studies and vigorous debates whether it can be realized in a physical system. However, a precise definition of the time crystal is needed to resolve the issue. Here we first present a definition of time crystals based on the time-dependent correlation functions of the order parameter. We then prove a no-go theorem that rules out the possibility of time crystals defined as such, in the ground state or in the canonical ensemble of a general Hamiltonian, which consists of not-too-long-range interactions.
We study the evolution of quantum fluctuations in systems known as time crystals, hypothetical systems for which the lowest energy state performs a periodic motion. We first discuss some general properties shared by time crystals, and deduce the effective field theory parametrizing the evolution of their fluctuations. We show that these fluctuations fall into categories analogous to acoustic and optical phonons, encountered in conventional crystals. The acoustic phonons correspond to gapless Goldstone boson modes parametrizing the broken time translation invariance of the crystal, whereas the optical phonons are identified with modes perpendicular to the broken symmetry of the system, which generically remain gapped. We study how these two modes decay and interact together, and discuss some observable features that could be tested in experimental realizations of time crystals.
Time crystals are phases of matter that spontaneously break time-translation symmetry. They have been ruled out in the ground and Gibbs states of isolated systems with only short-range interactions, yet they have been proposed and observed experimentally in nonequilibrium settings such as Floquet and open systems. However, existing proposals for time crystals in open quantum systems require an external supply of thermodynamic resources, such as work or energetic coherence. Whether coupling to an environment, without any such resource supply, can induce a time crystal absent in the isolated system remains open. Here, we answer this question systematically. We first construct an explicit model and prove that coupling to an environment can activate a time crystal absent in the isolated system, even without such resource supply. We consider Lindblad master equations with (i) time-independent Hamiltonian and jump operators, (ii) time-translation covariance, and (iii) detailed balance---conditions that hold in standard derivations unless thermodynamic resources are supplied externally. Our model satisfies these conditions, and the activation occurs in a stationary state of both the isolated and open systems. We give several implementations of this dynamics with a zero-temperature Gibbs environment, a time-independent, energy-conserving interaction, and only short-range Hamiltonians, one of which exactly reproduces the time-crystalline periodicity. We then prove a no-go theorem: under (i)--(iii), activation can arise only from an environment-induced Hamiltonian term, not from dissipation. Our results show that time crystals can be activated in open systems without external resource supply and identify the physical requirements on the system and environment for this activation through our general no-go theorem.
This chapter examines the physics of time crystals and the new form of order kassociated with the emergence of broken time symmetry. Unlike ordinary spatial crystals, which have ordered structures in space, time crystals exhibit a persistent periodic behavior in time. They form temporally ordered phases that break discrete time-translation symmetry. In this chapter, after laying the groundwork with the basic concepts of Floquet dynamics and discrete time crystals, the periodically driven quantum systems are found to give rise to stable sub-harmonic oscillations that last much longer than the normal relaxation times. This chapter formulates the notion of time as a lattice-like coordinate, where the temporal evolution is determined by a translation operator like those in spatial crystals. One of the main focuses of this chapter is translational symmetry breaking (TSB) in temporal lattices and its role in coherence, entanglement, and dynamical stability This chapter uses the theory of translational symmetry and standing-wave entanglement of Chakrabarti in providing a nodal–antinodal description of temporal dynamics as it entails that the nodal regions act as coherence-preserving points, whereas antinodal regions are centers of amplified oscillatory response. This framework shows how symmetry breaking reconfigures entanglement over temporal lattices so that localized coherence structures are created that can stabilize quantum oscillations in the presence of the environment. This chapter further develops an entanglement-driven model of autonomous time crystals. Normal Floquet theory is greatly modified in this autonomous case through the use of evolution operators that are driven, not by external periodic driving but by an inherent quantum coherence. Self-organized tempo is the periodicity of the sustained oscillation of the phase-locked standing-wave entangled fields due to nonlinear quantum interference in this formulation. The occurrence of stable sub-harmonic oscillations, localization of coherence, and long-lived temporal order are demonstrated through numerical simulation, phase-space analysis, spectral study, and magnetization dynamics. The closed trajectories in phase space realize oscillations of magnetization, and spectral peaks relate to breaking of discrete time-translation symmetry, revealing an autonomous time crystal. This chapter also looks into the mechanisms to preserve entanglement and coherence in dynamical. Methods to counteract noise and retain temporal order include dynamical decoupling, decoherence-free subspaces (DFS), adaptive feedback control, and nonlinear entanglement localization. Special stress is placed on the relevance between nodal entanglement localization and DFS which suggests that internal quantum dynamics can give rise to noise-resistant coherence-preserving structures. By consolidating aspects like time-crystalline periodicity, TSB, nodal–antinodal dynamics, and entanglement preservation into one framework, this chapter can pave the way toward autonomous quantum temporal architectures and open up new paths for quantum chronodynamics, entanglement-based temporal engineering, and self-organized quantum systems.
The idea of breaking time-translation symmetry has fascinated humanity at least since ancient proposals of the perpetuum mobile. Unlike the breaking of other symmetries, such as spatial translation in a crystal or spin rotation in a magnet, time translation symmetry breaking (TTSB) has been tantalisingly elusive. We review this history up to recent developments which have shown that discrete TTSB does takes place in periodically driven (Floquet) systems in the presence of many-body localization. Such Floquet time-crystals represent a new paradigm in quantum statistical mechanics --- that of an intrinsically out-of-equilibrium many-body phase of matter. We include a compendium of necessary background, before specializing to a detailed discussion of the nature, and diagnostics, of TTSB. We formalize the notion of a time-crystal as a stable, macroscopic, conservative clock --- explaining both the need for a many-body system in the infinite volume limit, and for a lack of net energy absorption or dissipation. We also cover a range of related phenomena, including various types of long-lived prethermal time-crystals, and expose the roles played by symmetries -- exact and (emergent) approximate -- and their breaking. We clarify the distinctions between many-body time-crystals and other ostensibly similar phenomena dating as far back as the works of Faraday and Mathieu. En route, we encounter Wilczek's suggestion that macroscopic systems should exhibit TTSB in their ground states, together with a theorem ruling this out. We also analyze pioneering recent experiments detecting signatures of time crystallinity in a variety of different platforms, and provide a detailed theoretical explanation of the physics in each case. In all existing experiments, the system does not realize a `true' time-crystal phase, and we identify necessary ingredients for improvements in future experiments.
We study the Nambu-Goldstone (NG) modes associated with spontaneous breaking of the continuous time-translation symmetry. To discuss a quantum time-crystal with the spontaneously-broken continuous time-translation symmetry, we introduce the van der Pol type nonlinear-friction to open quantum systems. By considering small fluctuations around a time-periodic mean-field solution, we show that a gapless collective mode necessarily appears; this is nothing but the NG mode associated with a time crystal. We show that its dispersion relation becomes ω=−iCp2ω=-iC\bm p^2ω=−iCp2. We also show that noncommutative breaking of the time-translation and U(1) symmetries results in mixing of the NG modes, and the (typically) propagating NG mode appears, whose dispersion relation becomes ω=(±C1−iC2)p2ω=(\pm C_1-iC_2)\bm p^2ω=(±C1​−iC2​)p2.