Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal for General Philosophy of Science

A Philosophical Analysis of Non-Markovian Collapse Models

Cristian Mariani

Published Nov 25, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Spontaneous collapse models (SCM) employ an imaginary noise term in the modification of Schrödinger's equation in order to achieve a stochastic collapse process. Such noise term is typically assumed to be white, and therefore uncorrelated in time, which results in the dynamics being Markovian. In the first part of this paper I discuss the reasons why physicists are exploring the possibility to instead employ non-white stochastic noise terms in the dynamics of SCM, and I then briefly introduce these models. In the second part, my aim is to provide an evaluation of the major conceptual and philosophical consequences of the generalised collapse models with colored noise. In particular, I will focus on the broad class of implications having to do with the non-Markovian nature of the dynamics, with its resulting temporal non-locality, and on the possibility to consider the noise field as a real physical entity.

DOI
10.1007/s10838-025-09725-9

Related papers

Collapse models with non-white noises

Stephen L Adler, Angelo Bassi

We set up a general formalism for models of spontaneous wave function collapse with dynamics represented by a stochastic differential equation driven by general Gaussian noises, not necessarily white in time. In particular, we show that the non-Schrodinger terms of the equation induce the collapse of the wave function to one of the common eigenstates of the collapsing operators, and that the collapse occurs with the correct quantum probabilities. We also develop a perturbation expansion of the solution of the equation with respect to the parameter which sets the strength of the collapse process; such an approximation allows one to compute the leading order terms for the deviations of the predictions of collapse models with respect to those of standard quantum mechanics. This analysis shows that to leading order, the ``imaginary'' noise trick can be used for non-white Gaussian noise.

arXiv:0708.3624•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 28, 2007•112 citations

Collapse models with non-white noises: II. Particle-density coupled noises

Stephen L Adler, Angelo Bassi

We continue the analysis of models of spontaneous wave function collapse with stochastic dynamics driven by non-white Gaussian noise. We specialize to a model in which a classical "noise" field, with specified autocorrelator, is coupled to a local nonrelativistic particle density. We derive general results in this model for the rates of density matrix diagonalization and of state vector reduction, and show that (in the absence of decoherence) both processes are governed by essentially the same rate parameters. As an alternative route to our reduction results, we also derive the Fokker-Planck equations that correspond to the initial stochastic Schrödinger equation. For specific models of the noise autocorrelator, including ones motivated by the structure of thermal Green's functions, we discuss the qualitative and qantitative dependence on model parameters, with particular emphasis on possible cosmological sources of the noise field.

arXiv:0807.2846•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Sep 8, 2008•49 citations

Non-Markovian Poissonian Spontaneous Collapse Models

Nicolò Piccione

Spontaneous collapse models provide a possible solution to the measurement problem by modifying standard quantum dynamics. The modification consists of adding non-linear and stochastic terms inducing wavefunction collapse in space. Non-Markovian versions of these models are motivated by physical reasons, phenomenological consistency, and potential for relativistic extensions. Here, we investigate a non-Markovian version of the Poissonian Spontaneous Localization (PSL) model, i.e., a model characterized by instantaneous and localized collapse events. We assume that our model is characterized by a typical time scale $τ_C$ so that, given an initial state $ρ_0$ of standard quantum matter at time $t=0$, we derive an effective long-time ($t\gg τ_C$) statistical dynamics in terms of a CPTP map $Φ_t$. We then show how $Φ_t$ can be made equal to that obtained by non-Markovian CSL models. Moreover, given $Φ_t$, we obtain the associated time-convolutionless master equation by means of a supercumulant expansion. Finally, we characterize the collapse events process (for events with $t \gg τ_C$) given an initial quantum state $ρ_0$ at $t=0$.

quant-pharXiv:2607.08955•Jul 13, 2026•1 citation

Colored collapse models from the non-interferometric perspective

Matteo Carlesso, Luca Ferialdi, Angelo Bassi

Abstract Models of spontaneous wave function collapse describe the quantum-to-classical transition by assuming a progressive breakdown of the superposition principle when the mass of the system increases, providing a well-defined phenomenology in terms of a non-linearly and stochastically modified Schrödinger equation, which can be tested experimentally. The most popular of such models is the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) model: in its original version, the collapse is driven by a white noise, and more recently, generalizations in terms of colored noises, which are more realistic, have been formulated. We will analyze how current non-interferometric tests bound the model, depending on the spectrum of the noise. We will find that low frequency purely mechanical experiments provide the most stable and strongest bounds. Graphical abstract

arXiv:1805.10100•The European Physical Journal D•Sep 1, 2018•33 citations

Non-Markovian collapse models

Luca Ferialdi

We introduce the measurement problem in quantum mechanics and we briefly \ndiscuss \nthe solutions proposed in literature. We then focus our \nattention on models of spontaneous wavefunction collapse. \nWe describe the two most popular models (GRW, CSL) and list other proposals. \nWe analyze \nin detail a third collapse \nmodel (QMUPL), which is particularly simple (but physically meaningful) to \nbe studied in great mathematical detail. We discuss its main properties. We \nalso describe a "finite \ntemperature" version of this model, which includes dissipative terms. \n \nThese models are Markovian, i.e. the collapse mechanism is driven by a \nwhite noise. Since the ultimate goal is to identify the noise responsible \nfor the \ncollapse with a random field in Nature, it becomes important to study \nnon-Markovian generalizations of collapse models, where the collapsing field \nhas a generic correlation function, likely with a cut off at high \nfrequencies. \n \nModels of this kind have already been studied, as a generalization of the \nCSL model. In this thesis \nwe describe in mathematical detail the generalization of the QMUPL model to \nnon-Markovian noises. After having proved, under suitable conditions, the \nseparation of the center-of-mass and relative \nmotions for a generic ensemble of particles, we focus our analysis on the \ntime evolution of the center of mass \nof an isolated system (free particle case). We compute the explicit \nexpression of the Green's function via the path integral formalism, for a \ngeneric Gaussian noise. We analyze in detail the case of an exponential \ncorrelation function, providing the exact analytical solution. \n \nWe next study the \ntime evolution of average quantities, such as the mean position, momentum \n(which satisfy Ehrefest's theorem) and energy (which is not conserved like \nin the other collapse models). We also compute the non-Markovian master \nequation \nfor an harmonic oscillator, according to this model, and compare \nits structure to the well-known Lindblad structure of Markovian open quantum \nsystems. \n \nWe \neventually specialize to the case of \nGaussian wave functions, and prove that all basic facts about collapse \nmodels (reduction process, amplification mechanism, etc.), which are known \nto be true in the white noise case, hold also in \nthe more general case of non-Markovian dynamics. \n \n \nWe further analyze the evolution \nof Gaussian wave function according to the three different realizations of \nthe QMUPL model so far developed (Markovian, non-Markovian and "finite \ntemperature"), comparing their fundamental features. \nFinally, by analyzing different localization criteria, we set new lower \nbounds on the \nparameters of these models, and we compare them with the upper bounds coming \nfrom known experimental data.

•Mar 26, 2010•0 citations

Non-Markovian Quantum Trajectories: An Exact Result

Angelo Bassi, Luca Ferialdi

We analyze the non-Markovian stochastic Schrödinger equation describing a particle subject to spontaneous collapses in space (in the language of collapse models), or subject to a continuous measurement of its position (in the language of continuous quantum measurement). For the first time, we give the explicit general solution for the free particle case (H=p(2)/2m) and discuss the main properties. We analyze the case of an exponential correlation function for the noise, giving a quantitative description of the dynamics and of its dependence on the correlation time.

arXiv:0907.1615•Physical Review Letters•Jul 28, 2009•38 citations
Spontaneous collapse models (SCM) employ an imaginary noise term in the modification of Schrödinger's equation in order to achieve a stochastic collapse process. Such noise term is typically assumed to be white, and therefore uncorrelated in time, which results in the dynamics being Markovian. In the first part of this paper I discuss the reasons why physicists are exploring the possibility to instead employ non-white stochastic noise terms in the dynamics of SCM, and I then briefly introduce these models. In the second part, my aim is to provide an evaluation of the major conceptual and philosophical consequences of the generalised collapse models with colored noise. In particular, I will focus on the broad class of implications having to do with the non-Markovian nature of the dynamics, with its resulting temporal non-locality, and on the possibility to consider the noise field as a real physical entity.
We set up a general formalism for models of spontaneous wave function collapse with dynamics represented by a stochastic differential equation driven by general Gaussian noises, not necessarily white in time. In particular, we show that the non-Schrodinger terms of the equation induce the collapse of the wave function to one of the common eigenstates of the collapsing operators, and that the collapse occurs with the correct quantum probabilities. We also develop a perturbation expansion of the solution of the equation with respect to the parameter which sets the strength of the collapse process; such an approximation allows one to compute the leading order terms for the deviations of the predictions of collapse models with respect to those of standard quantum mechanics. This analysis shows that to leading order, the ``imaginary'' noise trick can be used for non-white Gaussian noise.
We continue the analysis of models of spontaneous wave function collapse with stochastic dynamics driven by non-white Gaussian noise. We specialize to a model in which a classical "noise" field, with specified autocorrelator, is coupled to a local nonrelativistic particle density. We derive general results in this model for the rates of density matrix diagonalization and of state vector reduction, and show that (in the absence of decoherence) both processes are governed by essentially the same rate parameters. As an alternative route to our reduction results, we also derive the Fokker-Planck equations that correspond to the initial stochastic Schrödinger equation. For specific models of the noise autocorrelator, including ones motivated by the structure of thermal Green's functions, we discuss the qualitative and qantitative dependence on model parameters, with particular emphasis on possible cosmological sources of the noise field.
Spontaneous collapse models provide a possible solution to the measurement problem by modifying standard quantum dynamics. The modification consists of adding non-linear and stochastic terms inducing wavefunction collapse in space. Non-Markovian versions of these models are motivated by physical reasons, phenomenological consistency, and potential for relativistic extensions. Here, we investigate a non-Markovian version of the Poissonian Spontaneous Localization (PSL) model, i.e., a model characterized by instantaneous and localized collapse events. We assume that our model is characterized by a typical time scale τCτ_CτC​ so that, given an initial state ρ0ρ_0ρ0​ of standard quantum matter at time t=0t=0t=0, we derive an effective long-time (t≫τCt\gg τ_Ct≫τC​) statistical dynamics in terms of a CPTP map ΦtΦ_tΦt​. We then show how ΦtΦ_tΦt​ can be made equal to that obtained by non-Markovian CSL models. Moreover, given ΦtΦ_tΦt​, we obtain the associated time-convolutionless master equation by means of a supercumulant expansion. Finally, we characterize the collapse events process (for events with t≫τCt \gg τ_Ct≫τC​) given an initial quantum state ρ0ρ_0ρ0​ at t=0t=0t=0.
Abstract Models of spontaneous wave function collapse describe the quantum-to-classical transition by assuming a progressive breakdown of the superposition principle when the mass of the system increases, providing a well-defined phenomenology in terms of a non-linearly and stochastically modified Schrödinger equation, which can be tested experimentally. The most popular of such models is the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) model: in its original version, the collapse is driven by a white noise, and more recently, generalizations in terms of colored noises, which are more realistic, have been formulated. We will analyze how current non-interferometric tests bound the model, depending on the spectrum of the noise. We will find that low frequency purely mechanical experiments provide the most stable and strongest bounds. Graphical abstract
We introduce the measurement problem in quantum mechanics and we briefly \ndiscuss \nthe solutions proposed in literature. We then focus our \nattention on models of spontaneous wavefunction collapse. \nWe describe the two most popular models (GRW, CSL) and list other proposals. \nWe analyze \nin detail a third collapse \nmodel (QMUPL), which is particularly simple (but physically meaningful) to \nbe studied in great mathematical detail. We discuss its main properties. We \nalso describe a "finite \ntemperature" version of this model, which includes dissipative terms. \n \nThese models are Markovian, i.e. the collapse mechanism is driven by a \nwhite noise. Since the ultimate goal is to identify the noise responsible \nfor the \ncollapse with a random field in Nature, it becomes important to study \nnon-Markovian generalizations of collapse models, where the collapsing field \nhas a generic correlation function, likely with a cut off at high \nfrequencies. \n \nModels of this kind have already been studied, as a generalization of the \nCSL model. In this thesis \nwe describe in mathematical detail the generalization of the QMUPL model to \nnon-Markovian noises. After having proved, under suitable conditions, the \nseparation of the center-of-mass and relative \nmotions for a generic ensemble of particles, we focus our analysis on the \ntime evolution of the center of mass \nof an isolated system (free particle case). We compute the explicit \nexpression of the Green's function via the path integral formalism, for a \ngeneric Gaussian noise. We analyze in detail the case of an exponential \ncorrelation function, providing the exact analytical solution. \n \nWe next study the \ntime evolution of average quantities, such as the mean position, momentum \n(which satisfy Ehrefest's theorem) and energy (which is not conserved like \nin the other collapse models). We also compute the non-Markovian master \nequation \nfor an harmonic oscillator, according to this model, and compare \nits structure to the well-known Lindblad structure of Markovian open quantum \nsystems. \n \nWe \neventually specialize to the case of \nGaussian wave functions, and prove that all basic facts about collapse \nmodels (reduction process, amplification mechanism, etc.), which are known \nto be true in the white noise case, hold also in \nthe more general case of non-Markovian dynamics. \n \n \nWe further analyze the evolution \nof Gaussian wave function according to the three different realizations of \nthe QMUPL model so far developed (Markovian, non-Markovian and "finite \ntemperature"), comparing their fundamental features. \nFinally, by analyzing different localization criteria, we set new lower \nbounds on the \nparameters of these models, and we compare them with the upper bounds coming \nfrom known experimental data.
We analyze the non-Markovian stochastic Schrödinger equation describing a particle subject to spontaneous collapses in space (in the language of collapse models), or subject to a continuous measurement of its position (in the language of continuous quantum measurement). For the first time, we give the explicit general solution for the free particle case (H=p(2)/2m) and discuss the main properties. We analyze the case of an exponential correlation function for the noise, giving a quantitative description of the dynamics and of its dependence on the correlation time.