Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conformal Prediction for Quantum Entanglement: Robustness and Detection

Davut Emre Tasar

Published Nov 24, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Certification of quantum entanglement under realistic device imperfections is central to quantum communication, cryptography, and quantum networks. Despite the nonclassical nature of entanglement and contextuality, we empirically verify that standard Conformal Prediction(CP)retainsitscoverageguaranteesintheCHSHscenario, astheoreticallyexpected under (context-conditional) exchangeability. We introduce an LHV-Calibrated Anomaly Detection framework achieving an ROC AUC ≈0.96 (Scenario A) and AUC ≈0.83 using only CP-derived features (Scenario B). Validation on IBM quantum hardware (Shw ≈2.53) confirms these results under Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) conditions, relative to an explicit LHV null manifold. Finally, we prove a no-go theorem for product-threshold Conformal Entanglement Witnesses (CEW), explaining their limited power. Our results suggest that, at least in the CHSH setting considered here, CP is best viewed as a robust statistical wrapper around quantum devices, rather than a fragile entanglement witness. To facilitate reproducibility, all code, data, and experiment configurations are available at https://github.com/detasar/QCE.

DOI
10.20944/preprints202511.1754.v1

Related papers

Robust Certification of Entanglement Structures in Noisy Quantum Systems: Device‐Independent and Semi‐Device‐Independent Approaches

Yansa Lu, Zhihua Chen, Yuan-Hong Tao

Abstract In the noisy intermediate‐scale quantum (NISQ) era, multipartite entanglement in realistic noisy environments exhibits complex structures. Characterizing entanglement structures—particularly entanglement depth and intactness—has become increasingly essential for quantum information processing tasks. Traditional methods like standard entanglement witnesses assume that experimenters can exactly implement specific quantum measurements. Even minor inaccuracies in standard witness can introduce significant errors in entanglement detection. Certification methods are proposed with relaxed assumptions about the system and measurements for entanglement structures. First, entanglement states are classified with the same intactness into three distinct types based on their depth. Next, analytical witnesses are derived to detect the entanglement structure of general n‐qubit systems in both device‐independent and semi‐device‐independent scenarios, where some observables are untrusted while others remain reliable. Furthermore, this framework is extended to account for small measurement imperfections, ensuring robustness in practical settings. It is demonstrated that this witness can detect larger entanglement regions compared to previous Bell‐type inequalities. Remarkably, for Type I 4‐partite quantum states, this entanglement witness with measurement imperfections is identical to both device‐dependent and semi‐device‐independent approaches.

Advanced Quantum Technologies•Aug 10, 2025•0 citations

Entanglement detection with quantum support vector machine (QSVM) on near-term quantum devices

M. Mahdian, Zahra Beygom Mousavi

Detecting and quantifying quantum entanglement remain significant challenges in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era. This study presents the implementation of quantum support vector machines (QSVMs) on IBM quantum devices to identify and classify entangled states. By employing quantum variational circuits, the proposed framework achieves a runtime complexity of [Formula: see text], where N is the number of qubits, t is the number of iterations, and ε is the acceptable error margin. We investigate various quantum circuits with multiple blocks and obtain the accuracy of QSVM as measures of expressibility and entangling capability. Our results demonstrate that the QSVM framework achieves over 90% accuracy in distinguishing entangled states, despite hardware noise such as decoherence and gate errors. Benchmarks across superconducting qubit platforms (e.g., IBM Perth, Lagos, and Nairobi) highlight the robustness of the model. Furthermore, the QSVM framework effectively classifies two-qubit states and extends its predictive capabilities to three-qubit entangled states. This work marks a significant advancement in quantum machine learning for entanglement detection.

arXiv:2503.23443•Scientific Reports•Apr 7, 2025•29 citations

Semi-device-independent certification of high-dimensional quantum channels

Mengyan Li, Yanning Jia, Fenzhuo Guo +3 more

Certifying high-dimensional quantum channels is essential for ensuring the reliability of quantum communication protocols. Existing certification schemes often rely on fully trusted internal devices, which is difficult to achieve in realistic scenarios. Here, we propose a semi-device-independent framework for certifying channel properties directly from observed statistics, assuming only that the system dimension is known. By explicitly incorporating the full set of structural constraints inherent to Choi states, our approach exploits the Choi-Jamiołkowski isomorphism for rigorous certification of quantum channels. The entanglement dimensionality of quantum channels is first certified by introducing a witness and numerically determining its Schmidt-number-dependent bounds. This certification method reproduces known analytical benchmarks and is applied to dephasing and depolarizing noise channels, thereby confirming its validity. To provide a more complete assessment of channel performance, the entanglement fidelity of quantum channels is also certified using a hierarchy of semidefinite programming relaxations based on localizing matrices. Lower bounds on the entanglement fidelity are obtained that are compatible with either the full set of observed statistics or a single witness value.

quant-pharXiv:2602.07823•Physical Review A•Feb 10, 2026•1 citation

Measurement-device-independent entanglement and randomness estimation in quantum networks

Ivan Šupić, Paul Skrzypczyk, Daniel Cavalcanti

Detection of entanglement in quantum networks consisting of many parties is one of the important steps toward building quantum communication and computation networks. We consider a scenario where the measurement devices used for this certification are uncharacterized. In this case, it is well known that by using quantum states as inputs for the measurement devices it is possible to detect any entangled state (a situation known as measurement-device-independent entanglement witnessing). Here we go beyond entanglement detection and provide methods to estimate the amount of entanglement in a quantum network. We also consider the task of randomness certification and show that randomness can be certified in a variety of cases, including single-partite experiments or setups using only separable states.

arXiv:1702.04752•Physical Review A•Apr 26, 2017•45 citations

TARA Test-by-Adaptive-Ranks for Quantum Anomaly Detection with Conformal Prediction Guarantees

Davut Emre Tasar, Ceren Ocal Tasar

Quantum key distribution (QKD) security fundamentally relies on the ability to distinguish genuine quantum correlations from classical eavesdropper simulations, yet existing certification methods lack rigorous statistical guarantees under finite-sample conditions and adversarial scenarios. We introduce TARA (Test by Adaptive Ranks), a novel framework combining conformal prediction with sequential martingale testing for quantum anomaly detection that provides distribution-free validity guarantees. TARA offers two complementary approaches. TARA k, based on Kolmogorov Smirnov calibration against local hidden variable (LHV) null distributions, achieving ROC AUC = 0.96 for quantum-classical discrimination. And TARA-m, employing betting martingales for streaming detection with anytime valid type I error control that enables real time monitoring of quantum channels. We establish theoretical guarantees proving that under (context conditional) exchangeability, conformal p-values remain uniformly distributed even for strongly contextual quantum data, confirming that quantum contextuality does not break conformal prediction validity a result with implications beyond quantum certification to any application of distribution-free methods to nonclassical data. Extensive validation on both IBM Torino (superconducting, CHSH = 2.725) and IonQ Forte Enterprise (trapped ion, CHSH = 2.716) quantum processors demonstrates cross-platform robustness, achieving 36% security margins above the classical CHSH bound of 2. Critically, our framework reveals a methodological concern affecting quantum certification more broadly: same-distribution calibration can inflate detection performance by up to 44 percentage points compared to proper cross-distribution calibration, suggesting that prior quantum certification studies using standard train test splits may have systematically overestimated adversarial robustness.

quant-pharXiv:2512.04016•Dec 4, 2025•0 citations

General framework for genuine multipartite entanglement detection

Xin-Yu Xu, Qing Fa Zhou, Shuai Zhao +4 more

The design of detection strategies for multipartite entanglement stands as a central importance on our understanding of fundamental quantum mechanics and has had a substantial impact on quantum information applications. However, accurate and robust detection approaches are severely hindered, particularly when the number of nodes grows rapidly like in a quantum network. Here we present a general and operational framework that generates alternative entanglement witness for an arbitrary targeted state. The framework enjoys a systematic and high-efficient character and allows to substantiate genuine multipartite entanglement for a variety of states that arise naturally in practical situations and to dramatically outperform currently standard methods. With excellent noise tolerance, our framework should be broadly applicable to witness genuine multipartite entanglement in various practically scenarios and to facilitate the best use of entangled resources in the emerging area of quantum network.

arXiv:2211.05563•Physical Review A•May 12, 2023•9 citations
Certification of quantum entanglement under realistic device imperfections is central to quantum communication, cryptography, and quantum networks. Despite the nonclassical nature of entanglement and contextuality, we empirically verify that standard Conformal Prediction(CP)retainsitscoverageguaranteesintheCHSHscenario, astheoreticallyexpected under (context-conditional) exchangeability. We introduce an LHV-Calibrated Anomaly Detection framework achieving an ROC AUC ≈0.96 (Scenario A) and AUC ≈0.83 using only CP-derived features (Scenario B). Validation on IBM quantum hardware (Shw ≈2.53) confirms these results under Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) conditions, relative to an explicit LHV null manifold. Finally, we prove a no-go theorem for product-threshold Conformal Entanglement Witnesses (CEW), explaining their limited power. Our results suggest that, at least in the CHSH setting considered here, CP is best viewed as a robust statistical wrapper around quantum devices, rather than a fragile entanglement witness. To facilitate reproducibility, all code, data, and experiment configurations are available at https://github.com/detasar/QCE.
Abstract In the noisy intermediate‐scale quantum (NISQ) era, multipartite entanglement in realistic noisy environments exhibits complex structures. Characterizing entanglement structures—particularly entanglement depth and intactness—has become increasingly essential for quantum information processing tasks. Traditional methods like standard entanglement witnesses assume that experimenters can exactly implement specific quantum measurements. Even minor inaccuracies in standard witness can introduce significant errors in entanglement detection. Certification methods are proposed with relaxed assumptions about the system and measurements for entanglement structures. First, entanglement states are classified with the same intactness into three distinct types based on their depth. Next, analytical witnesses are derived to detect the entanglement structure of general n‐qubit systems in both device‐independent and semi‐device‐independent scenarios, where some observables are untrusted while others remain reliable. Furthermore, this framework is extended to account for small measurement imperfections, ensuring robustness in practical settings. It is demonstrated that this witness can detect larger entanglement regions compared to previous Bell‐type inequalities. Remarkably, for Type I 4‐partite quantum states, this entanglement witness with measurement imperfections is identical to both device‐dependent and semi‐device‐independent approaches.
Detecting and quantifying quantum entanglement remain significant challenges in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era. This study presents the implementation of quantum support vector machines (QSVMs) on IBM quantum devices to identify and classify entangled states. By employing quantum variational circuits, the proposed framework achieves a runtime complexity of [Formula: see text], where N is the number of qubits, t is the number of iterations, and ε is the acceptable error margin. We investigate various quantum circuits with multiple blocks and obtain the accuracy of QSVM as measures of expressibility and entangling capability. Our results demonstrate that the QSVM framework achieves over 90% accuracy in distinguishing entangled states, despite hardware noise such as decoherence and gate errors. Benchmarks across superconducting qubit platforms (e.g., IBM Perth, Lagos, and Nairobi) highlight the robustness of the model. Furthermore, the QSVM framework effectively classifies two-qubit states and extends its predictive capabilities to three-qubit entangled states. This work marks a significant advancement in quantum machine learning for entanglement detection.
Certifying high-dimensional quantum channels is essential for ensuring the reliability of quantum communication protocols. Existing certification schemes often rely on fully trusted internal devices, which is difficult to achieve in realistic scenarios. Here, we propose a semi-device-independent framework for certifying channel properties directly from observed statistics, assuming only that the system dimension is known. By explicitly incorporating the full set of structural constraints inherent to Choi states, our approach exploits the Choi-Jamiołkowski isomorphism for rigorous certification of quantum channels. The entanglement dimensionality of quantum channels is first certified by introducing a witness and numerically determining its Schmidt-number-dependent bounds. This certification method reproduces known analytical benchmarks and is applied to dephasing and depolarizing noise channels, thereby confirming its validity. To provide a more complete assessment of channel performance, the entanglement fidelity of quantum channels is also certified using a hierarchy of semidefinite programming relaxations based on localizing matrices. Lower bounds on the entanglement fidelity are obtained that are compatible with either the full set of observed statistics or a single witness value.
Detection of entanglement in quantum networks consisting of many parties is one of the important steps toward building quantum communication and computation networks. We consider a scenario where the measurement devices used for this certification are uncharacterized. In this case, it is well known that by using quantum states as inputs for the measurement devices it is possible to detect any entangled state (a situation known as measurement-device-independent entanglement witnessing). Here we go beyond entanglement detection and provide methods to estimate the amount of entanglement in a quantum network. We also consider the task of randomness certification and show that randomness can be certified in a variety of cases, including single-partite experiments or setups using only separable states.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) security fundamentally relies on the ability to distinguish genuine quantum correlations from classical eavesdropper simulations, yet existing certification methods lack rigorous statistical guarantees under finite-sample conditions and adversarial scenarios. We introduce TARA (Test by Adaptive Ranks), a novel framework combining conformal prediction with sequential martingale testing for quantum anomaly detection that provides distribution-free validity guarantees. TARA offers two complementary approaches. TARA k, based on Kolmogorov Smirnov calibration against local hidden variable (LHV) null distributions, achieving ROC AUC = 0.96 for quantum-classical discrimination. And TARA-m, employing betting martingales for streaming detection with anytime valid type I error control that enables real time monitoring of quantum channels. We establish theoretical guarantees proving that under (context conditional) exchangeability, conformal p-values remain uniformly distributed even for strongly contextual quantum data, confirming that quantum contextuality does not break conformal prediction validity a result with implications beyond quantum certification to any application of distribution-free methods to nonclassical data. Extensive validation on both IBM Torino (superconducting, CHSH = 2.725) and IonQ Forte Enterprise (trapped ion, CHSH = 2.716) quantum processors demonstrates cross-platform robustness, achieving 36% security margins above the classical CHSH bound of 2. Critically, our framework reveals a methodological concern affecting quantum certification more broadly: same-distribution calibration can inflate detection performance by up to 44 percentage points compared to proper cross-distribution calibration, suggesting that prior quantum certification studies using standard train test splits may have systematically overestimated adversarial robustness.
The design of detection strategies for multipartite entanglement stands as a central importance on our understanding of fundamental quantum mechanics and has had a substantial impact on quantum information applications. However, accurate and robust detection approaches are severely hindered, particularly when the number of nodes grows rapidly like in a quantum network. Here we present a general and operational framework that generates alternative entanglement witness for an arbitrary targeted state. The framework enjoys a systematic and high-efficient character and allows to substantiate genuine multipartite entanglement for a variety of states that arise naturally in practical situations and to dramatically outperform currently standard methods. With excellent noise tolerance, our framework should be broadly applicable to witness genuine multipartite entanglement in various practically scenarios and to facilitate the best use of entangled resources in the emerging area of quantum network.