Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Philosophy of Science

Not the Measurement Problem’s Problem: Black Hole Information Loss with Schrödinger’s Cat

Saakshi Dulani

Published Sep 3, 2025• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Recently, several philosophers and physicists have increasingly noticed the hegemony of unitarity in the discourse on black hole information loss and are challenging its legitimacy in the face of the measurement problem. They proclaim that embracing non-unitarity solves two paradoxes for the price of one. Although I share their distaste regarding the philosophical bias, I disagree with their strategy of still privileging certain interpretations of quantum theory. I argue that information-restoring solutions can be interpretation-neutral because the manifestation of non-unitarity in Hawking’s original derivation is unrelated to what’s found in collapse theories or generalized stochastic approaches, thereby decoupling the two puzzles.

DOI
10.1017/psa.2025.10118

Related papers

A Modest View of the Black Hole Information Paradox

S. P. Boughn

Thirty years ago, John Preskill concluded "that the information loss paradox may well presage a revolution in fundamental physics" and mused that "Conceivably, the puzzle of black hole evaporation portends a scientific revolution as sweeping as that that led to the formulation of quantum theory in the early 20th century." Many still agree with this assessment. On the other hand, it seems to me the "paradox" has little to do with the physical world but rather, at best, simply points out the possible inconsistency of two, already disparate, theories (mathematical models) of nature, general relativity and quantum mechanics, with virtually no conceivable observational consequences. The information paradox hinges on the concepts of a pure quantum state, the unitarity of quantum mechanics, and Hawking's semi-classical calculation of black hole evaporation. I used the qualifier "at best" above because, for me, the concept of a quantum state is far more restrictive than required by the paradox while unitarity is not a property of nature but rather of a mathematical model and is already violated by the process of making a measurement. Furthermore, the semi-classical calculation of Hawking is surely of limited applicability.

arXiv:2207.09421•Jan 1, 2022•1 citation

Non-unitary Quantum Information

When Stephen Hawking discovered the evaporation of black holes, he realized at the same time that this evaporation triggered an information loss paradox. To make it short, quantum physics prevents the loss of information because the evolution of quantum state is unitary and consequently reversible. If a support of information is swallowed inside a black hole, and if the black hole completely evaporates, then the information is lost. Thus, the physics around black holes should be non-unitary because they are non-reversible. Non-unitary physics allows some very much magic effects. A non-unitary computer would be capable of cracking any NP-complete problem in polynomial time. More interestingly, non-unitarity allows faster than light telecommunication, even the possibility to transfer information backward in time. We suggest to investigate this very exciting perspective which impacts the common sense. However, such perspective is strictly different than time travel and does not generate the classic time paradox depicted in science fiction literature thanks to the pure randomness of quantum measurement. We show that time backward information transmission is strictly equivalent to non-unitary quantum physics like in the non-cloning theorem.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 1, 2025•0 citations

FUNDAMENTAL SPATIO-TEMPORAL DECOHERENCE: A KEY TO SOLVING THE CONCEPTUAL PROBLEMS OF BLACK HOLES, COSMOLOGY AND QUANTUM MECHANICS

Rodolfo Gambini, Rafael A. Porto, Jorge A. Pullin

Unitarity is a pillar of quantum theory. Nevertheless, it is also a source of several of its conceptual problems. We note that in a world where measurements are relational, as is the case in gravitation, quantum mechanics exhibits a fundamental level of loss of coherence. This can be the key to solving, among others, the puzzles posed by the black hole information paradox, the formation of inhomogeneities in cosmology and the measurement problem in quantum mechanics.

arXiv:gr-qc/0611148•International Journal of Modern Physics D•Dec 1, 2006•16 citations

Does Black Hole Complementarity Answer Hawking's Information Loss Paradox?

Peter Bokulich

A proper understanding of black hole complementarity as a response to the information loss paradox requires recognizing the essential role played by arguments for the applicability and limitations of effective semiclassical theories. I argue that this perspective sheds important light on the arguments advanced by Susskind, Thorlacius, and Uglum—although ultimately I argue that their position is unsatisfactory. I also consider the argument offered by 't Hooft for the breakdown of microcausality around black holes, and conclude that it relies on a mistaken treatment of measurement collapse. There is, however, a legitimate argumentative role for black hole complementarity, exemplified by the position of Kiem, Verlinde, and Verlinde, that calls for a more subtle analysis of the limitations facing our effective theories.

Philosophy of Science•Dec 1, 2005•5 citations

Quantum Information Cannot Be Completely Hidden in Correlations: Implications for the Black-Hole Information Paradox

Samuel L. Braunstein, Arun Kumar Pati

Can quantum-information theory shed light on black-hole evaporation? By entangling the in-fallen matter with an external system we show that the black-hole information paradox becomes more severe, even for cosmologically sized black holes. We rule out the possibility that the information about the in-fallen matter might hide in correlations between the Hawking radiation and the internal states of the black hole. As a consequence, either unitarity or Hawking's semiclassical predictions must break down. Any resolution of the black-hole information crisis must elucidate one of these possibilities.

arXiv:gr-qc/0603046•Physical Review Letters•Feb 23, 2007•199 citations

Relativistic collapse dynamics and black hole information loss

Daniel Bedingham, Sujoy K. Modak, Daniel Sudarsky

We study a proposal for the resolution of the black hole information puzzle within the context of modified versions of quantum theory involving spontaneous reduction of the quantum state. The theories of this kind, which were developed in order to address the so-called measurement problem in quantum theory have, in the past, been framed in a nonrelativistic setting and in that form they were previously applied to the black hole information problem. Here, and for the first time, we show in a simple toy model, a treatment of the problem within a fully relativistic setting. We also discuss the issues that the present analysis leaves as open problems to be dealt with in future refinements of the present approach.

arXiv:1604.06537•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Aug 12, 2016•29 citations
Abstract Recently, several philosophers and physicists have increasingly noticed the hegemony of unitarity in the discourse on black hole information loss and are challenging its legitimacy in the face of the measurement problem. They proclaim that embracing non-unitarity solves two paradoxes for the price of one. Although I share their distaste regarding the philosophical bias, I disagree with their strategy of still privileging certain interpretations of quantum theory. I argue that information-restoring solutions can be interpretation-neutral because the manifestation of non-unitarity in Hawking’s original derivation is unrelated to what’s found in collapse theories or generalized stochastic approaches, thereby decoupling the two puzzles.
Thirty years ago, John Preskill concluded "that the information loss paradox may well presage a revolution in fundamental physics" and mused that "Conceivably, the puzzle of black hole evaporation portends a scientific revolution as sweeping as that that led to the formulation of quantum theory in the early 20th century." Many still agree with this assessment. On the other hand, it seems to me the "paradox" has little to do with the physical world but rather, at best, simply points out the possible inconsistency of two, already disparate, theories (mathematical models) of nature, general relativity and quantum mechanics, with virtually no conceivable observational consequences. The information paradox hinges on the concepts of a pure quantum state, the unitarity of quantum mechanics, and Hawking's semi-classical calculation of black hole evaporation. I used the qualifier "at best" above because, for me, the concept of a quantum state is far more restrictive than required by the paradox while unitarity is not a property of nature but rather of a mathematical model and is already violated by the process of making a measurement. Furthermore, the semi-classical calculation of Hawking is surely of limited applicability.
When Stephen Hawking discovered the evaporation of black holes, he realized at the same time that this evaporation triggered an information loss paradox. To make it short, quantum physics prevents the loss of information because the evolution of quantum state is unitary and consequently reversible. If a support of information is swallowed inside a black hole, and if the black hole completely evaporates, then the information is lost. Thus, the physics around black holes should be non-unitary because they are non-reversible. Non-unitary physics allows some very much magic effects. A non-unitary computer would be capable of cracking any NP-complete problem in polynomial time. More interestingly, non-unitarity allows faster than light telecommunication, even the possibility to transfer information backward in time. We suggest to investigate this very exciting perspective which impacts the common sense. However, such perspective is strictly different than time travel and does not generate the classic time paradox depicted in science fiction literature thanks to the pure randomness of quantum measurement. We show that time backward information transmission is strictly equivalent to non-unitary quantum physics like in the non-cloning theorem.
A proper understanding of black hole complementarity as a response to the information loss paradox requires recognizing the essential role played by arguments for the applicability and limitations of effective semiclassical theories. I argue that this perspective sheds important light on the arguments advanced by Susskind, Thorlacius, and Uglum—although ultimately I argue that their position is unsatisfactory. I also consider the argument offered by 't Hooft for the breakdown of microcausality around black holes, and conclude that it relies on a mistaken treatment of measurement collapse. There is, however, a legitimate argumentative role for black hole complementarity, exemplified by the position of Kiem, Verlinde, and Verlinde, that calls for a more subtle analysis of the limitations facing our effective theories.
Can quantum-information theory shed light on black-hole evaporation? By entangling the in-fallen matter with an external system we show that the black-hole information paradox becomes more severe, even for cosmologically sized black holes. We rule out the possibility that the information about the in-fallen matter might hide in correlations between the Hawking radiation and the internal states of the black hole. As a consequence, either unitarity or Hawking's semiclassical predictions must break down. Any resolution of the black-hole information crisis must elucidate one of these possibilities.
We study a proposal for the resolution of the black hole information puzzle within the context of modified versions of quantum theory involving spontaneous reduction of the quantum state. The theories of this kind, which were developed in order to address the so-called measurement problem in quantum theory have, in the past, been framed in a nonrelativistic setting and in that form they were previously applied to the black hole information problem. Here, and for the first time, we show in a simple toy model, a treatment of the problem within a fully relativistic setting. We also discuss the issues that the present analysis leaves as open problems to be dealt with in future refinements of the present approach.