Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Quantum contextuality of spin-1 massive particles

Marco E. Fabbrichesi, Roberto Floreanini B, Emidio Gabrielli A, Luca Marzola

Published Jul 29, 2025• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The authors take a close look at how spin\leavevmode\hbox{-}1 particles, like W bosons and certain mesons, behave in high-energy collisions and find clear signs of quantum contextuality in their polarizations. Using real collider data, they show that these uniquely quantum effects can be seen in practical experimental setups.
DOI
10.1103/9bvc-2w4m

Related papers

Quantum contextuality of spin-1 massive particles

Marco E. Fabbrichesi, Roberto Floreanini B, Emidio Gabrielli A +1 more

Contextuality is a fundamental property of quantum mechanics. Contrary to entanglement, which can only exist in composite systems, contextuality is also present for single entities. The case of a three-level system is of particular interest because--in agreement with the Bell-Kochen-Specker theorem--it is the simplest in which quantum contextuality is necessarily present. We verify that the polarizations of spin-1 massive particles produced at collider experiments indeed exhibit contextuality. To this purpose we consider $W$ gauge bosons produced in top-quark decays, $J/ψ$ and $K^{*}(892)^0$ mesons created in $B$-meson decays and $ϕ$ mesons resulting from $χ^0_c$ charmonium decays, making use of the data collected and analyzed by the ATLAS, LHCb and BESIII collaborations, respectively. The polarizations of all these four particles show contextuality with a significance of more than $5σ$.

arXiv:2503.14587•Mar 18, 2025•5 citations

Tests of quantum contextuality in particle physics

Marco E. Fabbrichesi, Roberto Floreanini B, Emidio Gabrielli A +1 more

Quantum contextuality refers to the impossibility of assigning a predefined, intrinsic value to a physical property of a system independently of the context in which the property is measured. It is, perhaps, the most fundamental feature of quantum mechanics. The many states with different spin that particle physics provides are the ideal setting for testing contextuality. We verify that the polarization states of single spin-1 massive particles produced at colliders are contextual. We test W + gauge bosons produced in top-quark decays, J / ψ and K * ( 892 ) 0 mesons in B -meson decays and ϕ mesons in χ c 0 and χ c 1 charmonium decays by reinterpreting the data and the analyses of the ATLAS, LHCb, Belle II and BESIII experimental collaborations, respectively. The polarization states of these four particles show contextuality with a significance larger than 5 σ . We also discuss the presence of quantum contextuality in spin states of bipartite systems formed by spin- 1 / 2 particles. We test Λ and Σ baryons reinterpreting two BESIII data analyses, and pairs of top quarks utilizing a recent analysis of the CMS Collaboration. Quantum contextuality is present with a significance exceeding 5 σ also in these cases. In addition, we study the feasibility of testing quantum contextuality by means of Z boson production in association with the Higgs boson, Z and W bosons pairs created in Higgs boson decays and with pairs of τ leptons. For the latter, we use Monte Carlo simulations that mimic the settings of SuperKEKB and of future lepton colliders. Experiments at high energies, though not designed for the purpose, perform surprisingly well in testing for quantum contextuality.

arXiv:2504.12382•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 29, 2025•12 citations

Quantum contextuality for a relativistic spin-1/2 particle

Jing‐Ling Chen, Hong-Yi Su, Chunfeng Wu +4 more

The quantum predictions for a single nonrelativistic spin-1/2 particle can be reproduced by noncontextual hidden variables. Here we show that quantum contextuality for a relativistic electron moving in a Coulomb potential naturally emerges if relativistic effects are taken into account. The contextuality can be identified through the violation of noncontextuality inequalities. We also discuss quantum contextuality for the free Dirac electron as well as the relativistic Dirac oscillator.

arXiv:1201.5590•Physical Review A•Feb 13, 2013•3 citations

Contextuality of identical particles

Paweł Kurzyński

There exist quantum phenomena that cannot be explained by noncontextual hidden-variable theories, yet the majority of them requires measurements that are performed on a single quantum system at a time. This fact constrains the phenomenon of contextuality to the microscopic domain. It is therefore natural to ask if quantum contextuality can be observed in measurements on collections of particles. Since particles in nature are identical, one can expect that such contextuality would be linked to bosonic and fermionic properties. Analysis of quantum contextuality in such scenarios would broaden our understanding of nonclassical effects in composite systems and perhaps would give us a hint on how to observe quantum phenomena in the macroscopic world. In this work I propose a generalization of quantum contextuality to the case of many identical particles. I show that a type of contextuality exhibited by a collection of particles (state dependent, state independent, or noncontextual) depends on their type and their number. I also discuss further properties of this generalization and identify major open questions.

arXiv:1609.01250•Physical Review A•Jan 25, 2017•7 citations

Quantum contextuality in N -boson systems

Fabio Benatti, Roberto Floreanini B, Marco Genovese +1 more

Quantum contextuality in systems of identical bosonic particles is explicitly exhibited via the maximum violation of a suitable inequality of Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt type. Unlike the approaches considered so far, which make use of single-particle observables, our analysis involves collective observables constructed using multiboson operators. An exemplifying scheme to test this violation with a quantum optical setup is also discussed.

arXiv:1109.1106•Physical Review A•Sep 15, 2011•3 citations

On possible explanations for quantum contextuality

Alisson Tezzin

Recent research on quantum contextuality has been strongly centered on device-independent frameworks, such as the many graph approaches to contextuality and the celebrated sheaf-theoretical approach. Contextuality is described in these frameworks as a property of data only, making it possible to characterize and quantify the phenomena regardless of the reasons why it occurs. In this paper we look beyond the data and focus on possible explanations for this experimental fact. We show that a classical system generating contextual data can easily be found if the following conditions are satisfied (1) We only have access to a specific collection of epistemic measurements (which, all things considered, is basically Bohr's view on quantum measurements) and (2) There is a limitation on which of these measurements can be jointly performed. The way we see it, this example indicates that contextuality may be a consequence of the type of measurement taken into account, instead of an intrinsic feature of the system upon which these measurements are performed; if this is correct, the widespread idea that quantum contextuality is a non-classical feature can be avoided.

•Sep 16, 2021•0 citations
Contextuality is a fundamental property of quantum mechanics. Contrary to entanglement, which can only exist in composite systems, contextuality is also present for single entities. The case of a three-level system is of particular interest because--in agreement with the Bell-Kochen-Specker theorem--it is the simplest in which quantum contextuality is necessarily present. We verify that the polarizations of spin-1 massive particles produced at collider experiments indeed exhibit contextuality. To this purpose we consider WWW gauge bosons produced in top-quark decays, J/ψJ/ψJ/ψ and K∗(892)0K^{*}(892)^0K∗(892)0 mesons created in BBB-meson decays and ϕϕϕ mesons resulting from χc0χ^0_cχc0​ charmonium decays, making use of the data collected and analyzed by the ATLAS, LHCb and BESIII collaborations, respectively. The polarizations of all these four particles show contextuality with a significance of more than 5σ5σ5σ.
Quantum contextuality refers to the impossibility of assigning a predefined, intrinsic value to a physical property of a system independently of the context in which the property is measured. It is, perhaps, the most fundamental feature of quantum mechanics. The many states with different spin that particle physics provides are the ideal setting for testing contextuality. We verify that the polarization states of single spin-1 massive particles produced at colliders are contextual. We test W + gauge bosons produced in top-quark decays, J / ψ and K * ( 892 ) 0 mesons in B -meson decays and ϕ mesons in χ c 0 and χ c 1 charmonium decays by reinterpreting the data and the analyses of the ATLAS, LHCb, Belle II and BESIII experimental collaborations, respectively. The polarization states of these four particles show contextuality with a significance larger than 5 σ . We also discuss the presence of quantum contextuality in spin states of bipartite systems formed by spin- 1 / 2 particles. We test Λ and Σ baryons reinterpreting two BESIII data analyses, and pairs of top quarks utilizing a recent analysis of the CMS Collaboration. Quantum contextuality is present with a significance exceeding 5 σ also in these cases. In addition, we study the feasibility of testing quantum contextuality by means of Z boson production in association with the Higgs boson, Z and W bosons pairs created in Higgs boson decays and with pairs of τ leptons. For the latter, we use Monte Carlo simulations that mimic the settings of SuperKEKB and of future lepton colliders. Experiments at high energies, though not designed for the purpose, perform surprisingly well in testing for quantum contextuality.
There exist quantum phenomena that cannot be explained by noncontextual hidden-variable theories, yet the majority of them requires measurements that are performed on a single quantum system at a time. This fact constrains the phenomenon of contextuality to the microscopic domain. It is therefore natural to ask if quantum contextuality can be observed in measurements on collections of particles. Since particles in nature are identical, one can expect that such contextuality would be linked to bosonic and fermionic properties. Analysis of quantum contextuality in such scenarios would broaden our understanding of nonclassical effects in composite systems and perhaps would give us a hint on how to observe quantum phenomena in the macroscopic world. In this work I propose a generalization of quantum contextuality to the case of many identical particles. I show that a type of contextuality exhibited by a collection of particles (state dependent, state independent, or noncontextual) depends on their type and their number. I also discuss further properties of this generalization and identify major open questions.
Recent research on quantum contextuality has been strongly centered on device-independent frameworks, such as the many graph approaches to contextuality and the celebrated sheaf-theoretical approach. Contextuality is described in these frameworks as a property of data only, making it possible to characterize and quantify the phenomena regardless of the reasons why it occurs. In this paper we look beyond the data and focus on possible explanations for this experimental fact. We show that a classical system generating contextual data can easily be found if the following conditions are satisfied (1) We only have access to a specific collection of epistemic measurements (which, all things considered, is basically Bohr's view on quantum measurements) and (2) There is a limitation on which of these measurements can be jointly performed. The way we see it, this example indicates that contextuality may be a consequence of the type of measurement taken into account, instead of an intrinsic feature of the system upon which these measurements are performed; if this is correct, the widespread idea that quantum contextuality is a non-classical feature can be avoided.