Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Open Journal of Philosophy

Reconciling Quantum Paradoxes through Metaphysical Lenses: Mulla Sadra’s Philosophy and Presentist-Fragmentalism

Hassan Hummadi Mohammed

Published Jan 1, 2025• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

This article explores the potential for reconciling the fundamental paradoxes of quantum mechanics—the measurement problem, entanglement, and Schrödinger’s Cat—with advanced metaphysical frameworks from both classical Islamic philosophy and contemporary Western thought. It specifically examines the compatibility and explanatory power of Mulla Sadra’s transcendent philosophy, particularly his doctrines of Essential Movement, Existential Gradation, and the Primacy of Existence, alongside the modern philosophical interpretation of Presentist-Fragmentalism. By offering conceptual mappings and interpretations, this paper argues that these metaphysical perspectives can provide a more intuitive and coherent understanding of quantum phenomena, moving beyond the limitations of classical intuition and certain prevalent quantum interpretations.

DOI
10.4236/ojpp.2025.153042

Related papers

Quantum Mechanics in Islamic and Sufi Mystics: Scientific Analogies of Light, Immediateness and Unity

This article aims to explore the striking conceptual parallels that exist between the fundamental principles of modern quantum mechanics and the deep ontological concepts of Islamic and Sufi metaphysics.The research focuses on such fundamental concepts of modern physics as the propagation of light by quanta, superposition, the uncertainty principle, quantum entanglement, the holographic principle and the quantum vacuum.These concepts are analyzed in a comparative manner with expressions such as the verse of the Light (24:35) in the Holy Quran, the creation command "Kun fayaqun" (Be and be) (36:82) and "Every moment He is in a new matter" (55:29), as well as with complex Sufi concepts such as Ibn al-Arabi's "wahdati-wujud" (unity of being), "nafs ar-Rahman" (breath of the Most Gracious), "aʿyān as-sabītā" (fixed truths) and "tajalli" (manifestation).The article also interprets the "light-image-mirror" model in Suhrawardi's Ishraq philosophy and Imam Ghazzali's "Mishkat al-Anwar" (The Lamp of Lights), quantum phenomena such as photons, the measurement problem and the collapse of the wave function in an analogous framework.The study aims to build a heuristic bridge between these two different languages, by bringing together the cognitive maps presented by mystical texts and the mathematical models of quantum theory, rather than directly claiming identity.This approach, on the one hand, increases the potential of theological cognition to establish a dialogue with modern science and on the other hand, creates a conceptual basis for rereading and deeply understanding topics such as quantum information, holography and "continuous creation" (creatio continua) in the context of Islamic cosmology.This article, deepening the general framework formed in the author's research over the years, especially focusing on Islamic and Sufi mysticism, proposes a new synthesis in the field of science and philosophy of religion.

Islamic history and literature.•Sep 15, 2025•1 citation

Resolving Paradoxes Through Presentist Fragmentalism: Eight Key Thought Experiments

Merriam, Paul, Mohammed A. Z. Habeeb

Einstein's special and general relativity emerged from his systematic analysis of three seminal thought experiments: chasing a light beam, the train-platform scenario, and the equivalence principle. Following this tradition of using Gedankenexperiments as core theoretical tools, we examine eight fundamental thought experiments through the lens of Presentist Fragmentalism - a framework positing that reality consists of fragments with independent A-series temporal flows connected by B-series relations. Our analysis spans both relativistic scenarios (Einstein's train) and quantum phenomena (EPR correlations, delayed choice eraser, Schrodinger’s Cat), demonstrating how this interpretation naturally resolves apparent paradoxes without sacrificing causality or introducing faster-than-light signaling. The framework's success in systematically resolving these diverse thought experiments, while preserving both relativistic and quantum principles, suggests it captures fundamental features of physical reality. Just as Einstein's resolution of three key paradoxes led to relativity, we argue that the consistent resolution of these eight Gedankenexperiments provides compelling support for Presentist Fragmentalism as a unified framework for understanding quantum and relativistic phenomena.

•Feb 5, 2025•0 citations

WITHDRAWN

Tenzin C. Trepp

Modern quantum mechanics, despite its relativistic extensions, provides intriguing support for a present-centered view of time. This paper argues that quantum phenomena – indeterminacy, wavefunction collapse, the Born rule, and temporal asymmetries in measurement – challenge the static block universe of eternalism and instead elevate the present moment to ontological prominence. Remaining largely interpretation-neutral, we draw on a range of perspectives (from Einstein’s relativity to collapse models, and thinkers like Heisenberg, Rovelli, Maudlin and others) to show that quantum theory operationally distinguishes past, present, and future in a way classical physics did not. We examine how the measurement problem and the randomness of quantum outcomes resist a fully eternalist description, highlight how quantum mechanics introduces an arrow of time at a fundamental level, and consider proposals (e.g. GRW theory, delayed-choice experiments) that make a global present – or something akin to it – conceptually necessary. Classical philosophers and physicists from Einstein to Schrödinger are discussed alongside contemporary voices. While stopping short of endorsing any single ontology outright, we contend that the empirical success of quantum theory re-opens the case for presentism or related “A-theoretic” models of time. In closing, we introduce Existential Realism as a novel metaphysical framework aligning with these insights – one which preserves the special status of the present while accommodating the reality of past and future in a more dynamic ontology. The result is a rigorous yet accessible interdisciplinary inquiry: quantum physics, we conclude, prefers the present, suggesting time’s passage and the now are more than mere illusions.

•Aug 12, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Philosophy

Christopher C. Gerry, Kimberley M. Bruno

Standard quantum theory is highly successful in all its applications, from photons and atoms, to semiconductors, superconductors, quarks, and so on. Yet the need to understand what the theory is really trying to tell us about the nature of the world beyond specific predictions forces us into the realm of philosophy, or, as some have dubbed it, quantum metaphysics: the study of the interpretation of quantum mechanics. There is a wide range of opinions regarding the philosophical foundations of quantum mechanics. This chapter focuses on two of the most prominent interpretations: the Copenhagen interpretation, and one alternative interpretation that has been gaining some support in recent years, the many-worlds interpretation (MWI), also known as the many universes interpretation. The central issues of contention are: firstly, that the measurement of some attribute of a quantum system generally involves the probabilistic collapse, or reduction, of the state vector where the probabilistic nature of the process is inherent—that is, not reducible to a more fundamental, deterministic explanation; and, secondly, the problem of bringing a measurement to a completion—a problem generally known as the measurement paradox.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 21, 2013•0 citations

Beyond Schrödinger’s Cat

Javed, Mohammad

This paper proposes Javed’s Bread Collapse Model (JBCM) as a conceptual replacement for Schrödinger’s Cat in discussions of quantum observation and perceived reality. It argues that the traditional cat paradox relies on artificial isolation, binary outcomes, and observer-only collapse, which together limit its philosophical and experiential relevance. Integrating insights from quantum mechanics, relativity, the placebo effect, and metaphysical philosophy, the paper contends that collapse does not occur through observation alone. Instead, it emerges from a structured interaction between intention (niyyah), belief (yaqeen), and Divine will (Allah’s hukm). Within this framework, measurement is treated as an intervention rather than a direct revelation of objective reality. Using bread as a real-world microcosm, JBCM demonstrates how physical outcomes may be empirically valid while causal understanding can remain misaligned. The model introduces the concept of an “error shift,” in which effects are correctly observed but incorrectly attributed to material causes alone, thereby obscuring the true source of manifestation. This work is presented as a theoretical and philosophical contribution to discussions in quantum interpretation, philosophy of science, and metaphysical epistemology. It does not claim experimental validation or propose a physical replacement within formal quantum theory, but instead offers a coherent interpretive framework that re-examines collapse, causality, and observer participation beyond purely materialist models.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

WITHDRAWN

Tenzin C. Trepp

Modern quantum mechanics, despite its relativistic extensions, provides intriguing support for a present-centered view of time. This paper argues that quantum phenomena – indeterminacy, wavefunction collapse, the Born rule, and temporal asymmetries in measurement – challenge the static block universe of eternalism and instead elevate the present moment to ontological prominence. Remaining largely interpretation-neutral, we draw on a range of perspectives (from Einstein’s relativity to collapse models, and thinkers like Heisenberg, Rovelli, Maudlin and others) to show that quantum theory operationally distinguishes past, present, and future in a way classical physics did not. We examine how the measurement problem and the randomness of quantum outcomes resist a fully eternalist description, highlight how quantum mechanics introduces an arrow of time at a fundamental level, and consider proposals (e.g. GRW theory, delayed-choice experiments) that make a global present – or something akin to it – conceptually necessary. Classical philosophers and physicists from Einstein to Schrödinger are discussed alongside contemporary voices. While stopping short of endorsing any single ontology outright, we contend that the empirical success of quantum theory re-opens the case for presentism or related “A-theoretic” models of time. In closing, we introduce Existential Realism as a novel metaphysical framework aligning with these insights – one which preserves the special status of the present while accommodating the reality of past and future in a more dynamic ontology. The result is a rigorous yet accessible interdisciplinary inquiry: quantum physics, we conclude, prefers the present, suggesting time’s passage and the now are more than mere illusions.[1] [1] https://quoteinvestigator.com/2024/03/18/stubborn-illusion/#:~:text=%3E%20On%20Michele%20Besso%20%281873,245

•Aug 3, 2025•1 citation
This article explores the potential for reconciling the fundamental paradoxes of quantum mechanics—the measurement problem, entanglement, and Schrödinger’s Cat—with advanced metaphysical frameworks from both classical Islamic philosophy and contemporary Western thought. It specifically examines the compatibility and explanatory power of Mulla Sadra’s transcendent philosophy, particularly his doctrines of Essential Movement, Existential Gradation, and the Primacy of Existence, alongside the modern philosophical interpretation of Presentist-Fragmentalism. By offering conceptual mappings and interpretations, this paper argues that these metaphysical perspectives can provide a more intuitive and coherent understanding of quantum phenomena, moving beyond the limitations of classical intuition and certain prevalent quantum interpretations.
This article aims to explore the striking conceptual parallels that exist between the fundamental principles of modern quantum mechanics and the deep ontological concepts of Islamic and Sufi metaphysics.The research focuses on such fundamental concepts of modern physics as the propagation of light by quanta, superposition, the uncertainty principle, quantum entanglement, the holographic principle and the quantum vacuum.These concepts are analyzed in a comparative manner with expressions such as the verse of the Light (24:35) in the Holy Quran, the creation command "Kun fayaqun" (Be and be) (36:82) and "Every moment He is in a new matter" (55:29), as well as with complex Sufi concepts such as Ibn al-Arabi's "wahdati-wujud" (unity of being), "nafs ar-Rahman" (breath of the Most Gracious), "aʿyān as-sabītā" (fixed truths) and "tajalli" (manifestation).The article also interprets the "light-image-mirror" model in Suhrawardi's Ishraq philosophy and Imam Ghazzali's "Mishkat al-Anwar" (The Lamp of Lights), quantum phenomena such as photons, the measurement problem and the collapse of the wave function in an analogous framework.The study aims to build a heuristic bridge between these two different languages, by bringing together the cognitive maps presented by mystical texts and the mathematical models of quantum theory, rather than directly claiming identity.This approach, on the one hand, increases the potential of theological cognition to establish a dialogue with modern science and on the other hand, creates a conceptual basis for rereading and deeply understanding topics such as quantum information, holography and "continuous creation" (creatio continua) in the context of Islamic cosmology.This article, deepening the general framework formed in the author's research over the years, especially focusing on Islamic and Sufi mysticism, proposes a new synthesis in the field of science and philosophy of religion.
Einstein's special and general relativity emerged from his systematic analysis of three seminal thought experiments: chasing a light beam, the train-platform scenario, and the equivalence principle. Following this tradition of using Gedankenexperiments as core theoretical tools, we examine eight fundamental thought experiments through the lens of Presentist Fragmentalism - a framework positing that reality consists of fragments with independent A-series temporal flows connected by B-series relations. Our analysis spans both relativistic scenarios (Einstein's train) and quantum phenomena (EPR correlations, delayed choice eraser, Schrodinger’s Cat), demonstrating how this interpretation naturally resolves apparent paradoxes without sacrificing causality or introducing faster-than-light signaling. The framework's success in systematically resolving these diverse thought experiments, while preserving both relativistic and quantum principles, suggests it captures fundamental features of physical reality. Just as Einstein's resolution of three key paradoxes led to relativity, we argue that the consistent resolution of these eight Gedankenexperiments provides compelling support for Presentist Fragmentalism as a unified framework for understanding quantum and relativistic phenomena.
Modern quantum mechanics, despite its relativistic extensions, provides intriguing support for a present-centered view of time. This paper argues that quantum phenomena – indeterminacy, wavefunction collapse, the Born rule, and temporal asymmetries in measurement – challenge the static block universe of eternalism and instead elevate the present moment to ontological prominence. Remaining largely interpretation-neutral, we draw on a range of perspectives (from Einstein’s relativity to collapse models, and thinkers like Heisenberg, Rovelli, Maudlin and others) to show that quantum theory operationally distinguishes past, present, and future in a way classical physics did not. We examine how the measurement problem and the randomness of quantum outcomes resist a fully eternalist description, highlight how quantum mechanics introduces an arrow of time at a fundamental level, and consider proposals (e.g. GRW theory, delayed-choice experiments) that make a global present – or something akin to it – conceptually necessary. Classical philosophers and physicists from Einstein to Schrödinger are discussed alongside contemporary voices. While stopping short of endorsing any single ontology outright, we contend that the empirical success of quantum theory re-opens the case for presentism or related “A-theoretic” models of time. In closing, we introduce Existential Realism as a novel metaphysical framework aligning with these insights – one which preserves the special status of the present while accommodating the reality of past and future in a more dynamic ontology. The result is a rigorous yet accessible interdisciplinary inquiry: quantum physics, we conclude, prefers the present, suggesting time’s passage and the now are more than mere illusions.
Standard quantum theory is highly successful in all its applications, from photons and atoms, to semiconductors, superconductors, quarks, and so on. Yet the need to understand what the theory is really trying to tell us about the nature of the world beyond specific predictions forces us into the realm of philosophy, or, as some have dubbed it, quantum metaphysics: the study of the interpretation of quantum mechanics. There is a wide range of opinions regarding the philosophical foundations of quantum mechanics. This chapter focuses on two of the most prominent interpretations: the Copenhagen interpretation, and one alternative interpretation that has been gaining some support in recent years, the many-worlds interpretation (MWI), also known as the many universes interpretation. The central issues of contention are: firstly, that the measurement of some attribute of a quantum system generally involves the probabilistic collapse, or reduction, of the state vector where the probabilistic nature of the process is inherent—that is, not reducible to a more fundamental, deterministic explanation; and, secondly, the problem of bringing a measurement to a completion—a problem generally known as the measurement paradox.
This paper proposes Javed’s Bread Collapse Model (JBCM) as a conceptual replacement for Schrödinger’s Cat in discussions of quantum observation and perceived reality. It argues that the traditional cat paradox relies on artificial isolation, binary outcomes, and observer-only collapse, which together limit its philosophical and experiential relevance. Integrating insights from quantum mechanics, relativity, the placebo effect, and metaphysical philosophy, the paper contends that collapse does not occur through observation alone. Instead, it emerges from a structured interaction between intention (niyyah), belief (yaqeen), and Divine will (Allah’s hukm). Within this framework, measurement is treated as an intervention rather than a direct revelation of objective reality. Using bread as a real-world microcosm, JBCM demonstrates how physical outcomes may be empirically valid while causal understanding can remain misaligned. The model introduces the concept of an “error shift,” in which effects are correctly observed but incorrectly attributed to material causes alone, thereby obscuring the true source of manifestation. This work is presented as a theoretical and philosophical contribution to discussions in quantum interpretation, philosophy of science, and metaphysical epistemology. It does not claim experimental validation or propose a physical replacement within formal quantum theory, but instead offers a coherent interpretive framework that re-examines collapse, causality, and observer participation beyond purely materialist models.
Modern quantum mechanics, despite its relativistic extensions, provides intriguing support for a present-centered view of time. This paper argues that quantum phenomena – indeterminacy, wavefunction collapse, the Born rule, and temporal asymmetries in measurement – challenge the static block universe of eternalism and instead elevate the present moment to ontological prominence. Remaining largely interpretation-neutral, we draw on a range of perspectives (from Einstein’s relativity to collapse models, and thinkers like Heisenberg, Rovelli, Maudlin and others) to show that quantum theory operationally distinguishes past, present, and future in a way classical physics did not. We examine how the measurement problem and the randomness of quantum outcomes resist a fully eternalist description, highlight how quantum mechanics introduces an arrow of time at a fundamental level, and consider proposals (e.g. GRW theory, delayed-choice experiments) that make a global present – or something akin to it – conceptually necessary. Classical philosophers and physicists from Einstein to Schrödinger are discussed alongside contemporary voices. While stopping short of endorsing any single ontology outright, we contend that the empirical success of quantum theory re-opens the case for presentism or related “A-theoretic” models of time. In closing, we introduce Existential Realism as a novel metaphysical framework aligning with these insights – one which preserves the special status of the present while accommodating the reality of past and future in a more dynamic ontology. The result is a rigorous yet accessible interdisciplinary inquiry: quantum physics, we conclude, prefers the present, suggesting time’s passage and the now are more than mere illusions.[1] [1] https://quoteinvestigator.com/2024/03/18/stubborn-illusion/#:~:text=%3E%20On%20Michele%20Besso%20%281873,245