Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Shadow of a Laser Beam and the Interaction of Light with Matter

W. Tiefenbrunner

Published Aug 13, 2025• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The Boltzmann factor not only characterises the relationship between particle energies and their respective populations as a function of temperature, but also indicates that absorption and emission processes involving photons of different colours (i.e., frequencies) are, in general, mutually independent [29]. However, this stands in contrast to experiments in the field of nonlinear optics, such as the one by Abrahao et al. (2024) [1]. The authors of that publication show that green laser light (532 nm wavelength) enhances the absorption of blue laser light (450 nm) in a ruby crystal, and explain this phenomenon using a hierarchical orbital model.In the context of an alternative interpretation of quantum mechanics [28] (as opposed to the Copenhagen interpretation), based on the works of A. Einstein (1916) [9] and H. De Raedt et al. (2005) [5], a different possible explanation emerges, which is outlined here. Based on this model and the findings of Abrahao et al. (2024), modified interference experiments are proposed. These may help clarify whether particles—such as photons—interfere with themselves [8, 13, 14, 15], or whether quantum mechanics is merely an ensemble theory, without descriptive power concerning individual events [12].

DOI
10.20944/preprints202508.0965.v1

Related papers

The Monochromatic Resonator and the Interaction Between Light and Matter Under the Assumption That Photons Follow Classical Trajectories

W. Tiefenbrunner

According to R. Feynman 1963-1965 [10], the interference pattern that appears on the observation screen in the double-slit experiment with light cannot be explained by classical physics. The detection probability is supposed to result from the superposition of all paths that the photon can take from the source to the detector, the light quantum is self-interfering. However, Jin et al. 2010 [11] showed that this is not necessarily the case. In their computer simulation, they assumed that the trajectory of a photon corresponds to that of a classical particle. Thus, the interference only occurs at the detector with the participation of several photons. Not every photon causes a detection.Tiefenbrunner 2024 [17] investigated the detector further and recognized that particle interference under this and some other conditions presupposes a monochromatic resonator (all permissible energy levels are integer (ℕ0) multiples of a basal energy unit ε, where ε is also referred to as the ‘colour’ of the resonator). A monochromatic two-state system, e.g. a molecule that can only exist in two energetic states (ground and excited) and can only absorb one quantum (with respect to one ‘colour’), is, however, not sufficient for this. This prompted an evaluation of the significance of the monochromatic resonator for the Boltzmann-factor and Planck's radiation law. It turns out that the Boltzmann-factor and thus also the radiation law require resonators and hence are incompatible with two-state systems. The radiation law is derived using a kinetic model for the interaction of light with matter and without a priori use of the Boltzmann-factor, whereby it is also assumed that photons follow classical trajectories.

•Feb 20, 2025•3 citations

Quantum mechanics of the atom-radiation interaction

R. Loudon

Abstract The calculations of the preceding chapter display some of the inadequacies of the Einstein theory of interaction of light with atoms. The theory itself gives no prescription for computing the values of the A and B coefficients appropriate to a given atomic transition. For this one must look to the quantum-mechanical theory of transition probabilities. As light beams are generated by emission from atoms and measurements on light beams ultimately depend on the absorption of light by atoms, it is essential to cover the theory of the atomic interaction processes, even though the main interest of the book is the quantum nature of the light itself. More seriously, the Einstein theory is applicable only for broad-band illumination of the atom, where the energy in the incident light is distributed smoothly across the frequencies within the linewidth of the atomic transition. By contrast, many experiments with laser sources use light beams whose frequency distributions are much narrower than atomic transition linewidths.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 7, 2000•1 citation

Introduction

Guang S. He

Abstract Laser radiation is an intense coherent light field that is characterized by its high monochromatic brightness and high photon degeneracy. Thus, it is capable of generating various stimulated scattering effects and a series of multiphoton excitation-induced opto-physical and opto-chemical effects. There are two parallel theoretical regimes. The first regime is the semiclassical theory that treats light as a classical electromagnetic field described by Maxwell’s equations. The second regime is the quantum electrodynamic theory, which treats light as an assembly of photons obeying Bose–Einstein statistics. Both regimes can be complementarily adopted to describe the interaction of light radiation with matter.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 25, 2022•0 citations

The Light Quantum as Replicator: Phase Copying by Photon-pair Interaction Mediated by Matter

W. Tiefenbrunner

The selection equation (replicator equation) has been independently discovered not only in various fields of biology (population genetics, ecology, prebiotic evolution, and sociobiology), but also in laser theory, where it accounts for the emergence of coherent light. Selection theory (replicator dynamics) is an ensemble theory, i. e., it describes the entire system rather than individual events, neglecting details in favor of a statistical view. However, the underlying processes at the individual level are well known in biology. For light quanta, this is not the case, because quantum theory says nothing about individual events. In the Copenhagen interpretation even the existence of causality on "quantum level" is denied. A large number of recent publications, however, makes this interpretation seem questionable.In the present paper, therefore, an attempt is made to describe the basic interactions between light and matter, as far as they are relevant for the emergence of coherent light in the laser (a photon pair interaction mediated by matter is postulated), and to apply replicator dynamics on this basis. Starting point are papers of A. Einstein about the interaction of light and matter as well as the photoelectric effect. Both theories are slightly modified. Furthermore, the double-slit experiment is investigated and finally the emergence of coherent light by density-dependent selection of photons of different phase in a laser-like model. The relationship between “mean fitness”, information content of the photon ensemble and the amplitude of the light is also analyzed.

•Feb 9, 2023•4 citations

On New Phenomena of Photon from Modified Double Slit Experiment

Haisheng Liu, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Gregg S. Jaeger +2 more

A modified double slit experiment of light was implemented. In the experiment, a spatial shape filter is used to manipulate the shape of cross section of laser beam. When this modified laser beam was shined on the double slit, the intensity distribution of laser beam on double slit is asymmetrical. In this way, the laser light was directed to pass through only one or two slits of double slit in different sections. So the which‐way information is predetermined before the photons pass through the slits. At the same time, the visible interference pattern can be observed on a monitor screen after the double slit. A couple of new phenomena had been observed from this experiment. The results of this experiment raise questions about Wave‐Particle Duality model of quantum theory, which is the foundation for the Copenhagen explanation that is generally regarded as the principal interpretation of quantum theory. As the observed properties from this experiment cannot be fully explained using the quantum theory, especially the Copenhagen explanation, a new model of photon is proposed. The new model for photon should be also applicable to all other micro entities, according to L. de Broglie assumption.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Laser Beams

Helmut Satz

In atoms, the electron orbits around the nucleus are quantized, occur for discrete energies. Transitions between energy levels require absorption or emission of photons. In the case of an unusual occupation of excited levels, individual photons can trigger a coherent transition of all such levels to the ground state, thus leading to a beam of coherent photons, a laser beam.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 14, 2020•0 citations
The Boltzmann factor not only characterises the relationship between particle energies and their respective populations as a function of temperature, but also indicates that absorption and emission processes involving photons of different colours (i.e., frequencies) are, in general, mutually independent [29]. However, this stands in contrast to experiments in the field of nonlinear optics, such as the one by Abrahao et al. (2024) [1]. The authors of that publication show that green laser light (532 nm wavelength) enhances the absorption of blue laser light (450 nm) in a ruby crystal, and explain this phenomenon using a hierarchical orbital model.In the context of an alternative interpretation of quantum mechanics [28] (as opposed to the Copenhagen interpretation), based on the works of A. Einstein (1916) [9] and H. De Raedt et al. (2005) [5], a different possible explanation emerges, which is outlined here. Based on this model and the findings of Abrahao et al. (2024), modified interference experiments are proposed. These may help clarify whether particles—such as photons—interfere with themselves [8, 13, 14, 15], or whether quantum mechanics is merely an ensemble theory, without descriptive power concerning individual events [12].
According to R. Feynman 1963-1965 [10], the interference pattern that appears on the observation screen in the double-slit experiment with light cannot be explained by classical physics. The detection probability is supposed to result from the superposition of all paths that the photon can take from the source to the detector, the light quantum is self-interfering. However, Jin et al. 2010 [11] showed that this is not necessarily the case. In their computer simulation, they assumed that the trajectory of a photon corresponds to that of a classical particle. Thus, the interference only occurs at the detector with the participation of several photons. Not every photon causes a detection.Tiefenbrunner 2024 [17] investigated the detector further and recognized that particle interference under this and some other conditions presupposes a monochromatic resonator (all permissible energy levels are integer (ℕ0) multiples of a basal energy unit ε, where ε is also referred to as the ‘colour’ of the resonator). A monochromatic two-state system, e.g. a molecule that can only exist in two energetic states (ground and excited) and can only absorb one quantum (with respect to one ‘colour’), is, however, not sufficient for this. This prompted an evaluation of the significance of the monochromatic resonator for the Boltzmann-factor and Planck's radiation law. It turns out that the Boltzmann-factor and thus also the radiation law require resonators and hence are incompatible with two-state systems. The radiation law is derived using a kinetic model for the interaction of light with matter and without a priori use of the Boltzmann-factor, whereby it is also assumed that photons follow classical trajectories.
Abstract The calculations of the preceding chapter display some of the inadequacies of the Einstein theory of interaction of light with atoms. The theory itself gives no prescription for computing the values of the A and B coefficients appropriate to a given atomic transition. For this one must look to the quantum-mechanical theory of transition probabilities. As light beams are generated by emission from atoms and measurements on light beams ultimately depend on the absorption of light by atoms, it is essential to cover the theory of the atomic interaction processes, even though the main interest of the book is the quantum nature of the light itself. More seriously, the Einstein theory is applicable only for broad-band illumination of the atom, where the energy in the incident light is distributed smoothly across the frequencies within the linewidth of the atomic transition. By contrast, many experiments with laser sources use light beams whose frequency distributions are much narrower than atomic transition linewidths.
Abstract Laser radiation is an intense coherent light field that is characterized by its high monochromatic brightness and high photon degeneracy. Thus, it is capable of generating various stimulated scattering effects and a series of multiphoton excitation-induced opto-physical and opto-chemical effects. There are two parallel theoretical regimes. The first regime is the semiclassical theory that treats light as a classical electromagnetic field described by Maxwell’s equations. The second regime is the quantum electrodynamic theory, which treats light as an assembly of photons obeying Bose–Einstein statistics. Both regimes can be complementarily adopted to describe the interaction of light radiation with matter.
The selection equation (replicator equation) has been independently discovered not only in various fields of biology (population genetics, ecology, prebiotic evolution, and sociobiology), but also in laser theory, where it accounts for the emergence of coherent light. Selection theory (replicator dynamics) is an ensemble theory, i. e., it describes the entire system rather than individual events, neglecting details in favor of a statistical view. However, the underlying processes at the individual level are well known in biology. For light quanta, this is not the case, because quantum theory says nothing about individual events. In the Copenhagen interpretation even the existence of causality on "quantum level" is denied. A large number of recent publications, however, makes this interpretation seem questionable.In the present paper, therefore, an attempt is made to describe the basic interactions between light and matter, as far as they are relevant for the emergence of coherent light in the laser (a photon pair interaction mediated by matter is postulated), and to apply replicator dynamics on this basis. Starting point are papers of A. Einstein about the interaction of light and matter as well as the photoelectric effect. Both theories are slightly modified. Furthermore, the double-slit experiment is investigated and finally the emergence of coherent light by density-dependent selection of photons of different phase in a laser-like model. The relationship between “mean fitness”, information content of the photon ensemble and the amplitude of the light is also analyzed.
A modified double slit experiment of light was implemented. In the experiment, a spatial shape filter is used to manipulate the shape of cross section of laser beam. When this modified laser beam was shined on the double slit, the intensity distribution of laser beam on double slit is asymmetrical. In this way, the laser light was directed to pass through only one or two slits of double slit in different sections. So the which‐way information is predetermined before the photons pass through the slits. At the same time, the visible interference pattern can be observed on a monitor screen after the double slit. A couple of new phenomena had been observed from this experiment. The results of this experiment raise questions about Wave‐Particle Duality model of quantum theory, which is the foundation for the Copenhagen explanation that is generally regarded as the principal interpretation of quantum theory. As the observed properties from this experiment cannot be fully explained using the quantum theory, especially the Copenhagen explanation, a new model of photon is proposed. The new model for photon should be also applicable to all other micro entities, according to L. de Broglie assumption.