Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Qeios

A Common Origin for the Sagnac Effect and Einstein’s Train-Embankment Thought Experiment

Stefano Quattrini

Published May 5, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Sagnac effect and the Einstein Train-Embankment thought experiment deal with the simultaneous emission of light and its non-simultaneous absorption. The original Einstein’s thought experiment arrangement is slightly modified, also for pedagogical purposes, becoming a rectilinear version of Sagnac’s interferometer. It is shown that at the base of the effect lies the solution of the famous Achilles and the tortoise paradox, a problem of pursuit. An account is given of the failure of simultaneity at a distance, forming the basis of what Einstein called the relativity of simultaneity. The effect experienced by the moving observer, which relies also on time dilation, is also discussed.

DOI
10.32388/wtulik

Related papers

Twin-Like Experiment Without Acceleration Shows that “Everything is Measured Relatively” Does not Mean, “Everything is Relative”

Holger Kubel

With Einstein’s interpretation, “everything is relative”, the so-called twin experiment discloses what is called a paradox, when the travelling twin returns and they compare watches (and aging). Some assign the solution to acceleration, which they claim should be taken into account so that the paradox evaporates. However, it’s easy to construct an experiment in which any acceleration lays outside the considered part of the experiment, so that within the measured part we have only constant velocities. We can then have one observer at rest, and two travelers who run through the travelling twin’s route, but without acceleration. Within a hypothetical absolute underlying medium, particles oscillate slower for an observer who moves through the Aether than they do for an observer at rest. An acceleration free experiment can be made in which all three agree on that. The conflict appears if the traveling ‘twins’ measure how fast the first observers clock runs, based on their respective lines of simultaneity, because then the travelling ‘twins’ then insist that A’s particles oscillate slower than their own. Even without the physical experiment, the thought experiment itself discloses that the twin-paradox is a product of the “everything is relative” interpretation.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Lightning strokes that are measured as simultaneous from the railway embankment, are also measured as simultaneous from the moving train

Dionysios G. Raftopoulos

In this paper, we examine the thought (gedanken) experiment referred to by the title, by utilizing the two principles (hypotheses) of the Theory of Special Relativity and adhering to Heisenberg’s and the School of Copenhagen’s philosophical line. In other words, we introduce to the theater of events the Observer who measures them in both Space and Time and request that the propositions of Physical Science are derived from those very measurements. By doing so, we arrive to the conclusion that events measured as simultaneous from one system of reference, are also measured as simultaneous from any other system of reference moving in a linear uniform translatory motion relative to it, contrary to Einstein’s thesis. Resume Dans ce traite, nous examinons l’experience de pensee (Gedankenexperiment) evoquee par le titre, en utilisant les deux principes (hypotheses) de la Theorie de la Relativite Restreinte et suivant la ligne philosophique de Heisenberg et de l'Ecole de Copenhague. En d'autres termes, nous introduisons dans le theâtre des evenements l'Observateur qui les mesure a la fois dans l'espace et le temps, en exigeant que les propositions de la science physique soient derivees de ces memes mesures. Ce faisant, nous arrivons a la conclusion que les evenements consideres comme simultanes par la mesure selon un premier systeme de reference, sont egalement mesures comme simultanes selon tout autre systeme de reference, se deplacant dans un mouvement lineaire de translation uniforme par rapport au premier, contrairement a la these d'Einstein.

Physics Essays•Dec 1, 2012•0 citations

The Observer Omission in Einstein’s Rail-Car Experiment

Wolfgang Baer

Einstein special relativity theory provides an ontological interpretation of the Lorentz transformations and Maxwell’s Eqs. that predicts the physical retardation of clock rates and shrinkage of measuring rods. A logical explanation for these effects is demonstrated by comparing the measurements of common phenomena made by an observer in moving train versus those obtained by a stationary observer at rest on the embankment. Though the mathematical treatment properly accounts for observations made by coordinate systems built upon the constant speed of light assumption, I will show that these coordinate frames analysis cannot be transferred to actual physical situations without encountering contradictions with the original experiment assumptions. The ontological view of physical reality implied by these assumptions, which underlying special relativity and much of conventional physics, is therefore in question. By eliminating these assumptions an alternative interpretation of experimental evidence is provided. Specifically, the careful construction of clock rates, rod lengths, and time offsets required to explain the constant speed of light reported by all observers is not necessary if the speed of light is observer dependent. I will argue that light propagates in the space attached to the material from which observer’s are built. The speed of light in this material is a property of the gravitational potential the material is subject to. The space supplied by the material of each observer is more accurately described as possessing a constant speed-of-now, which determines the rate of activity of all processes the observer carries out. This ontological interpretation of special relativity is compatible with quantum theory since it treats observables, including the observation of empty space, as the internal observer dependent phenomena resulting from measurements rather than a ubiquitous a priori container in which all things happen.

•Dec 28, 2017•0 citations

A Non-Relativistic Explanation of the Sagnac Effect

Olivier Serret

More than a century ago, M. Sagnac realized an experiment with light rays, whose results according to him invalidated the theory of Relativity and validated the hypothesis of the Aether. This hypothesis of the ether was not retained by the scientific community, and relativistic explanations were given to the results of the Sagnac experiment. But these relativistic explanations remain open to criticism because they are various and because the prediction may differ depending on whether the observer’s frame of reference is at rest or in motion. The neo-Newtonian mechanics proposes a new explanation which leads to demonstrate the formula with P the light path. In order to verify this new interpretation, it is proposed to do again the Sagnac experiment with a slightly different light path, a square-shaped path. The results should be at least 30% lower than those predicted by the theory of Relativity. In which case, the relativistic explanation would be questioned.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

The Sagnac-Wang Interferometers and Absolute vs. Relative Simultaneity

Justo Pastor Lambare

Gianfranco Spavieri, George T. Gillies & Espen Gaarder Haug (The Sagnac effect and the role of simultaneity in relativity theory, Journal of Modern Optics (2021)), claim that the Sagnac effect reveals the theory of relativity is incorrect and inconsistent. We prove that when standard relativity is appropriately interpreted, it is observationally correct and logically sound.

Qeios•Jan 16, 2024•0 citations

The Sagnac effect and the role of simultaneity in relativity theory

Gianfranco Spavieri, G. T. Gillies, Espen Gaarder Haug

We thoroughly examine the role of absolute and relative simultaneity in the interpretation of the Sagnac effect, using an approach that allows for determining the local speed along the light path. If the local speed of light is assumed to be c over the whole closed contour, there is no agreement with the observed result. There is agreement if the local speed is c along an open section of the contour only. Thus a rigorous and coherent interpretation of the Sagnac effect favours absolute over relative simultaneity. The implications for the Lorentz transformations and synchronization by means of the Global Positioning System are considered.

Journal of Modern Optics•Feb 20, 2021•37 citations
The Sagnac effect and the Einstein Train-Embankment thought experiment deal with the simultaneous emission of light and its non-simultaneous absorption. The original Einstein’s thought experiment arrangement is slightly modified, also for pedagogical purposes, becoming a rectilinear version of Sagnac’s interferometer. It is shown that at the base of the effect lies the solution of the famous Achilles and the tortoise paradox, a problem of pursuit. An account is given of the failure of simultaneity at a distance, forming the basis of what Einstein called the relativity of simultaneity. The effect experienced by the moving observer, which relies also on time dilation, is also discussed.
With Einstein’s interpretation, “everything is relative”, the so-called twin experiment discloses what is called a paradox, when the travelling twin returns and they compare watches (and aging). Some assign the solution to acceleration, which they claim should be taken into account so that the paradox evaporates. However, it’s easy to construct an experiment in which any acceleration lays outside the considered part of the experiment, so that within the measured part we have only constant velocities. We can then have one observer at rest, and two travelers who run through the travelling twin’s route, but without acceleration. Within a hypothetical absolute underlying medium, particles oscillate slower for an observer who moves through the Aether than they do for an observer at rest. An acceleration free experiment can be made in which all three agree on that. The conflict appears if the traveling ‘twins’ measure how fast the first observers clock runs, based on their respective lines of simultaneity, because then the travelling ‘twins’ then insist that A’s particles oscillate slower than their own. Even without the physical experiment, the thought experiment itself discloses that the twin-paradox is a product of the “everything is relative” interpretation.
In this paper, we examine the thought (gedanken) experiment referred to by the title, by utilizing the two principles (hypotheses) of the Theory of Special Relativity and adhering to Heisenberg’s and the School of Copenhagen’s philosophical line. In other words, we introduce to the theater of events the Observer who measures them in both Space and Time and request that the propositions of Physical Science are derived from those very measurements. By doing so, we arrive to the conclusion that events measured as simultaneous from one system of reference, are also measured as simultaneous from any other system of reference moving in a linear uniform translatory motion relative to it, contrary to Einstein’s thesis. Resume Dans ce traite, nous examinons l’experience de pensee (Gedankenexperiment) evoquee par le titre, en utilisant les deux principes (hypotheses) de la Theorie de la Relativite Restreinte et suivant la ligne philosophique de Heisenberg et de l'Ecole de Copenhague. En d'autres termes, nous introduisons dans le theâtre des evenements l'Observateur qui les mesure a la fois dans l'espace et le temps, en exigeant que les propositions de la science physique soient derivees de ces memes mesures. Ce faisant, nous arrivons a la conclusion que les evenements consideres comme simultanes par la mesure selon un premier systeme de reference, sont egalement mesures comme simultanes selon tout autre systeme de reference, se deplacant dans un mouvement lineaire de translation uniforme par rapport au premier, contrairement a la these d'Einstein.
Einstein special relativity theory provides an ontological interpretation of the Lorentz transformations and Maxwell’s Eqs. that predicts the physical retardation of clock rates and shrinkage of measuring rods. A logical explanation for these effects is demonstrated by comparing the measurements of common phenomena made by an observer in moving train versus those obtained by a stationary observer at rest on the embankment. Though the mathematical treatment properly accounts for observations made by coordinate systems built upon the constant speed of light assumption, I will show that these coordinate frames analysis cannot be transferred to actual physical situations without encountering contradictions with the original experiment assumptions. The ontological view of physical reality implied by these assumptions, which underlying special relativity and much of conventional physics, is therefore in question. By eliminating these assumptions an alternative interpretation of experimental evidence is provided. Specifically, the careful construction of clock rates, rod lengths, and time offsets required to explain the constant speed of light reported by all observers is not necessary if the speed of light is observer dependent. I will argue that light propagates in the space attached to the material from which observer’s are built. The speed of light in this material is a property of the gravitational potential the material is subject to. The space supplied by the material of each observer is more accurately described as possessing a constant speed-of-now, which determines the rate of activity of all processes the observer carries out. This ontological interpretation of special relativity is compatible with quantum theory since it treats observables, including the observation of empty space, as the internal observer dependent phenomena resulting from measurements rather than a ubiquitous a priori container in which all things happen.
More than a century ago, M. Sagnac realized an experiment with light rays, whose results according to him invalidated the theory of Relativity and validated the hypothesis of the Aether. This hypothesis of the ether was not retained by the scientific community, and relativistic explanations were given to the results of the Sagnac experiment. But these relativistic explanations remain open to criticism because they are various and because the prediction may differ depending on whether the observer’s frame of reference is at rest or in motion. The neo-Newtonian mechanics proposes a new explanation which leads to demonstrate the formula with P the light path. In order to verify this new interpretation, it is proposed to do again the Sagnac experiment with a slightly different light path, a square-shaped path. The results should be at least 30% lower than those predicted by the theory of Relativity. In which case, the relativistic explanation would be questioned.
We thoroughly examine the role of absolute and relative simultaneity in the interpretation of the Sagnac effect, using an approach that allows for determining the local speed along the light path. If the local speed of light is assumed to be c over the whole closed contour, there is no agreement with the observed result. There is agreement if the local speed is c along an open section of the contour only. Thus a rigorous and coherent interpretation of the Sagnac effect favours absolute over relative simultaneity. The implications for the Lorentz transformations and synchronization by means of the Global Positioning System are considered.