Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science

Wavefunction Mereology

Isaac Wilhelm

Published Feb 25, 2025• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

I propose and defend an analysis of the parthood relation among quantum wavefunctions. Roughly put, according to the analysis, one wavefunction is part of another just in case the latter can be projected onto the former. This analysis brings mereology into closer contact with contemporary physics, implies many standard mereological principles, challenges some traditional mereological presuppositions, and supports compelling answers to long-standing questions about parthood.

DOI
10.1086/735531

Related papers

The One Magic Wave: Quantum Monism Meets Wavefunction Realism

Claudio Calosi

The paper provides a systematic assessment of wavefunction mereological priority monism, the combination of priority mereological monism and wavefunction realism. Such a combination has been recently discussed and defended both in philosophy of physics and metaphysics. I argue that such a combination threatens to undermine the master arguments in favour of its components. Furthermore, wavefunction mereological priority monism entails controversial consequences for both mereology and location. In the light of the above, I explore different ways to resist the arguments and different combinations of monism and realism about the wavefunction.

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Apr 21, 2022•8 citations

Vector Mereology

Phil Pickering, Sam Baron, John Tanner

This paper outlines a notion of parthood for vectors, which has come to the fore in discussions of quantum mechanics. We show that existing accounts fail to generalise in a way that preserves transitivity. We thus present a new more general account that preserves transitivity and is applicable to quantum systems but may have applicability beyond quantum mechanics, including classical vector quantities and waves.

•Jan 15, 2026•0 citations

Is Mereology Empirical? Composition for Fermions.

Adam Caulton

How best to think about quantum systems under permutation invariance is a question that has received a great deal of attention in the literature.But very little attention has been paid to taking seriously the proposal that permutation invariance reflects a representational redundancy in the formalism.Under such a proposal, it is far from obvious how a constituent quantum system is represented.Consequently, it is also far from obvious how quantum systems compose to form assemblies, i.e. what is the formal structure of their relations of parthood, overlap and fusion.In this paper, I explore one proposal for the case of fermions and their assemblies.According to this proposal, fermionic assemblies which are not entangled-in some heterodox, but natural sense of 'entangled'-provide a prima facie counterexample to classical mereology.This result is puzzling; but, I argue, no more intolerable than any other available interpretative option.

arXiv:1409.0245•BRILL eBooks•Nov 21, 2015•11 citations

The Wave Function: Essays on the Metaphysics of Quantum Mechanics

Alyssa Ney, David Z. Albert

This is a new volume of original essays on the metaphysics of quantum mechanics. The essays address questions such as: What fundamental metaphysics is best motivated by quantum mechanics? What is the ontological status of the wave function? Does quantum mechanics support the existence of any other fundamental entities, e.g. particles? What is the nature of the fundamental space (or space-time manifold) of quantum mechanics? What is the relationship between the fundamental ontology of quantum mechanics and ordinary, macroscopic objects like tables, chairs, and persons? This collection includes a comprehensive introduction with a history of quantum mechanics and the debate over its metaphysical interpretation focusing especially on the main realist alternatives.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 8, 2013•352 citations

Wave Function Realism

David Z. Albert

I rehearse some of the reasons for treating the quantum mechanical wave function as a concrete physical object—and some of the consequences of treating it that way—with particular attention to questions of the metaphysical status of space and the origins of geometrical appearances.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 8, 2013•156 citations

On the emergence of preferred structures in quantum theory

Antoine Soulas, Guilherme Franzmann, Andrea Di Biagio

We assess the possibilities offered by Hilbert space fundamentalism, an attitude towards quantum physics according to which all physical structures (e.g. subsystems, locality, spacetime, preferred observables) should emerge from minimal quantum ingredients (typically a Hilbert space, Hamiltonian, and state). As a case study, we first mainly focus on the specific question of whether the Hamiltonian can uniquely determine a tensor product structure, a crucial challenge in the growing field of quantum mereology. The present paper reviews, clarifies, and critically examines two apparently conflicting theorems by Cotler et al. and Stoica. We resolve the tension, show how the former has been widely misinterpreted and why the latter is correct only in some weaker version. We then propose a correct mathematical way to address the general problem of preferred structures in quantum theory, relative to the characterization of emergent objects by unitary-invariant properties. Finally, we apply this formalism in the particular case we started with, and show that a Hamiltonian and a state are enough structure to uniquely select a preferred tensor product structure.

quant-pharXiv:2512.07468•Dec 9, 2025•10 citations
I propose and defend an analysis of the parthood relation among quantum wavefunctions. Roughly put, according to the analysis, one wavefunction is part of another just in case the latter can be projected onto the former. This analysis brings mereology into closer contact with contemporary physics, implies many standard mereological principles, challenges some traditional mereological presuppositions, and supports compelling answers to long-standing questions about parthood.
The paper provides a systematic assessment of wavefunction mereological priority monism, the combination of priority mereological monism and wavefunction realism. Such a combination has been recently discussed and defended both in philosophy of physics and metaphysics. I argue that such a combination threatens to undermine the master arguments in favour of its components. Furthermore, wavefunction mereological priority monism entails controversial consequences for both mereology and location. In the light of the above, I explore different ways to resist the arguments and different combinations of monism and realism about the wavefunction.
How best to think about quantum systems under permutation invariance is a question that has received a great deal of attention in the literature.But very little attention has been paid to taking seriously the proposal that permutation invariance reflects a representational redundancy in the formalism.Under such a proposal, it is far from obvious how a constituent quantum system is represented.Consequently, it is also far from obvious how quantum systems compose to form assemblies, i.e. what is the formal structure of their relations of parthood, overlap and fusion.In this paper, I explore one proposal for the case of fermions and their assemblies.According to this proposal, fermionic assemblies which are not entangled-in some heterodox, but natural sense of 'entangled'-provide a prima facie counterexample to classical mereology.This result is puzzling; but, I argue, no more intolerable than any other available interpretative option.
This is a new volume of original essays on the metaphysics of quantum mechanics. The essays address questions such as: What fundamental metaphysics is best motivated by quantum mechanics? What is the ontological status of the wave function? Does quantum mechanics support the existence of any other fundamental entities, e.g. particles? What is the nature of the fundamental space (or space-time manifold) of quantum mechanics? What is the relationship between the fundamental ontology of quantum mechanics and ordinary, macroscopic objects like tables, chairs, and persons? This collection includes a comprehensive introduction with a history of quantum mechanics and the debate over its metaphysical interpretation focusing especially on the main realist alternatives.
We assess the possibilities offered by Hilbert space fundamentalism, an attitude towards quantum physics according to which all physical structures (e.g. subsystems, locality, spacetime, preferred observables) should emerge from minimal quantum ingredients (typically a Hilbert space, Hamiltonian, and state). As a case study, we first mainly focus on the specific question of whether the Hamiltonian can uniquely determine a tensor product structure, a crucial challenge in the growing field of quantum mereology. The present paper reviews, clarifies, and critically examines two apparently conflicting theorems by Cotler et al. and Stoica. We resolve the tension, show how the former has been widely misinterpreted and why the latter is correct only in some weaker version. We then propose a correct mathematical way to address the general problem of preferred structures in quantum theory, relative to the characterization of emergent objects by unitary-invariant properties. Finally, we apply this formalism in the particular case we started with, and show that a Hamiltonian and a state are enough structure to uniquely select a preferred tensor product structure.