Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Graphical approach to Bell's inequalities

Krzysztof Rębilas

Published Feb 20, 2025• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Following an approach proposed by Eberhard, a graphical representation of entangled particles is used to provide insight into the meaning and direct experimental consequences of local realism. The most famous Bell-type theorems, like the original inequality developed by Bell, as well as the ones presented by Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt, Clauser and Horn, Eberhard, d'Espagnat, and Maccone, are then derived by means of the graphical method. The universality and efficiency of the presented method in achieving different Bell's inequalities follow from making local realism explicitly a starting point in our general reasoning. The pedagogical and illustrative nature of the approach makes it easy to see directly how all the miscellaneous inequalities are actually rooted in the local realist view on microscopic particles.

DOI
10.1119/5.0250670

Related papers

Synthetic approach to Bell's inequalities and a fundamental Bell-type theorem

Krzysztof Rębilas

A fundamental Bell-type inequality is derived by referring solely to laws of logic, tertium non datur and the transitivity axiom, that are used to express the local realism assumption. The general form of the achieved inequality makes it a root of other more specific Bell-type theorems involving additional mathematical formalism and experimental conditions. Its universality is demonstrated explicitly by showing that the most famous theorems provided by Bell, Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt (CHSH), Clauser and Horne (CH), Eberhard, d'Espagnat and Maccone are direct corollaries of the general inequality. The method to retrieve Bell's inequalities of different kinds, as being based on a single scheme of reasoning, unifies diversity of proofs presented in the literature. Additionally, some of the known inequalities can be easily achieved in a more general form compared to their original versions and still suitable, or possibly even more convenient, for experimental investigations. By extracting local realism in the form of an explicit logical propositions and making it a cornerstone of a systematic reasoning leading to the universal Bell's inequality, the paper offers a synthetic perspective on Bell-type theorems and their logical basis.

Physics Letters A•Jun 14, 2024•0 citations

Bell Inequalities

Reinhold A. Bertlmann, Nicolai Friis

Abstract This chapter presents a detailed discussion of Bell inequalities and their experimental tests. Starting from the Aharonov-Bohm version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox, we review EPR’s criteria for realism and completeness and Bell’s locality condition, before deriving the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality. This is followed by an exposition on Bell’s original inequality and other Bell inequalities by Wigner, as well as Clauser and Horne. We then discuss the milestones in the experimental violation of Bell inequalities, from the experiment of Freedman and Clauser in the 1970s, to the efforts of Aspect et al. in the 1980s, the experiments by the teams of Zeilinger and Gisin in the 1990s, and culminating the loophole-free tests in 2015. Finally we turn to a brief discussion of the interpretations of quantum mechanics, focusing on contrasting the realist views held by, e.g., Einstein and Bell, and the informational views with proponents such as Brukner and Zeilinger

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 7, 2023•1 citation

Experimental Entangled Entanglement

Philip John Walther, Kevin J. Resch, Časlav Brukner +1 more

All previous tests of local realism have studied correlations between single-particle measurements. In the present experiment, we have performed a Bell experiment on three particles in which one of the measurements corresponds to a projection onto a maximally entangled state. We show theoretically and experimentally that correlations between these entangled measurements and single-particle measurements are too strong for any local-realistic theory and are experimentally exploited to violate a Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt-Bell inequality by more than 5 standard deviations. We refer to this possibility as "entangled entanglement."

arXiv:quant-ph/0508183•Physical Review Letters•Jul 11, 2006•49 citations

Bayesian Analysis of Bell Inequalities

Asher Peres

Statistical tests are needed to determine experimentally whether a hypothetical theory based on local realism can be an acceptable alternative to quantum mechanics. It is impossible to rule out local realism by a single test, as often claimed erroneously. The “strength” of a particular Bell inequality is measured by the number of trials that are needed to invalidate local realism at a given confidence level. Various versions of Bell's inequality are compared from this point of view. It is shown that Mermin's inequality for Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states requires fewer tests than the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality or than its chained variants applied to a singlet state, and also than Hardy's proof of nonlocality.

arXiv:quant-ph/9905084•Fortschritte der Physik•May 1, 2000•28 citations

The 1960s

Andrew Charles Whitaker

During the 1960s, Bell produced his seminal work on the foundations of quantum theory, first showing that, contrary to von Neumann’s argument, hidden variable theories were allowed but then that they had to be non-local. Thus, he showed that quantum theory did not respect local causality, and he outlined experiments that could be used to test whether the assumption of local realism was true in quantum theory: Bell’s theorem, or Bell’s inequality, or Bell’s inequalities. His work was followed up by John Clauser, Abner Shimony, Michael Horne, and Richard Holt, who produced the CHSH inequality. Bell had moved to CERN, where he worked on the theory of neutrino experiments, and on nuclear and elementary particle physics, making crucial suggestions concerning the use of gauge theory for each type of physical force and also producing the Adler–Bell–Jackiw anomaly, or the ABJ anomaly.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 16, 2016•0 citations

Reconciling Local Realism with Quantum Mechanics: The Generalized BCHSH Inequalities

Claudio Garola, Sandro Sozzo

Most physicists uphold that the tests of the Bell-Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt (BCHSH) inequalities confirm quantum mechanics (QM) and refute local realism. Some scholars, however, criticize this conviction, yet maintaining that QM conflicts with local realism. At variance with both viewpoints one of the authors has recently worked out an extended semantic realism (ESR) model which shows that, if quantum probabilities are interpreted as conditional rather than absolute probabilities, a picture of the microworld can be constructed that is simultaneously consistent with local realism and QM. We show here that the BCHSH inequalities must be replaced, within the ESR model, by more general inequalities. These depend on parameters (detection probabilities) which may be such that the inequalities are never violated by quantum expectation values. The condition that no violation occurs implies the existence of upper bounds on detection probabilities, which makes the ESR model falsifiable. These results admit an intuitive explanation in terms of unfair sampling but basically differ from the seemingly similar results obtained by other approaches in which the efficiency problem is discussed in order to vindicate some kind of local realism.

•Mar 28, 2007•0 citations
Following an approach proposed by Eberhard, a graphical representation of entangled particles is used to provide insight into the meaning and direct experimental consequences of local realism. The most famous Bell-type theorems, like the original inequality developed by Bell, as well as the ones presented by Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt, Clauser and Horn, Eberhard, d'Espagnat, and Maccone, are then derived by means of the graphical method. The universality and efficiency of the presented method in achieving different Bell's inequalities follow from making local realism explicitly a starting point in our general reasoning. The pedagogical and illustrative nature of the approach makes it easy to see directly how all the miscellaneous inequalities are actually rooted in the local realist view on microscopic particles.
A fundamental Bell-type inequality is derived by referring solely to laws of logic, tertium non datur and the transitivity axiom, that are used to express the local realism assumption. The general form of the achieved inequality makes it a root of other more specific Bell-type theorems involving additional mathematical formalism and experimental conditions. Its universality is demonstrated explicitly by showing that the most famous theorems provided by Bell, Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt (CHSH), Clauser and Horne (CH), Eberhard, d'Espagnat and Maccone are direct corollaries of the general inequality. The method to retrieve Bell's inequalities of different kinds, as being based on a single scheme of reasoning, unifies diversity of proofs presented in the literature. Additionally, some of the known inequalities can be easily achieved in a more general form compared to their original versions and still suitable, or possibly even more convenient, for experimental investigations. By extracting local realism in the form of an explicit logical propositions and making it a cornerstone of a systematic reasoning leading to the universal Bell's inequality, the paper offers a synthetic perspective on Bell-type theorems and their logical basis.
Abstract This chapter presents a detailed discussion of Bell inequalities and their experimental tests. Starting from the Aharonov-Bohm version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox, we review EPR’s criteria for realism and completeness and Bell’s locality condition, before deriving the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality. This is followed by an exposition on Bell’s original inequality and other Bell inequalities by Wigner, as well as Clauser and Horne. We then discuss the milestones in the experimental violation of Bell inequalities, from the experiment of Freedman and Clauser in the 1970s, to the efforts of Aspect et al. in the 1980s, the experiments by the teams of Zeilinger and Gisin in the 1990s, and culminating the loophole-free tests in 2015. Finally we turn to a brief discussion of the interpretations of quantum mechanics, focusing on contrasting the realist views held by, e.g., Einstein and Bell, and the informational views with proponents such as Brukner and Zeilinger
All previous tests of local realism have studied correlations between single-particle measurements. In the present experiment, we have performed a Bell experiment on three particles in which one of the measurements corresponds to a projection onto a maximally entangled state. We show theoretically and experimentally that correlations between these entangled measurements and single-particle measurements are too strong for any local-realistic theory and are experimentally exploited to violate a Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt-Bell inequality by more than 5 standard deviations. We refer to this possibility as "entangled entanglement."
Statistical tests are needed to determine experimentally whether a hypothetical theory based on local realism can be an acceptable alternative to quantum mechanics. It is impossible to rule out local realism by a single test, as often claimed erroneously. The “strength” of a particular Bell inequality is measured by the number of trials that are needed to invalidate local realism at a given confidence level. Various versions of Bell's inequality are compared from this point of view. It is shown that Mermin's inequality for Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states requires fewer tests than the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality or than its chained variants applied to a singlet state, and also than Hardy's proof of nonlocality.
During the 1960s, Bell produced his seminal work on the foundations of quantum theory, first showing that, contrary to von Neumann’s argument, hidden variable theories were allowed but then that they had to be non-local. Thus, he showed that quantum theory did not respect local causality, and he outlined experiments that could be used to test whether the assumption of local realism was true in quantum theory: Bell’s theorem, or Bell’s inequality, or Bell’s inequalities. His work was followed up by John Clauser, Abner Shimony, Michael Horne, and Richard Holt, who produced the CHSH inequality. Bell had moved to CERN, where he worked on the theory of neutrino experiments, and on nuclear and elementary particle physics, making crucial suggestions concerning the use of gauge theory for each type of physical force and also producing the Adler–Bell–Jackiw anomaly, or the ABJ anomaly.
Most physicists uphold that the tests of the Bell-Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt (BCHSH) inequalities confirm quantum mechanics (QM) and refute local realism. Some scholars, however, criticize this conviction, yet maintaining that QM conflicts with local realism. At variance with both viewpoints one of the authors has recently worked out an extended semantic realism (ESR) model which shows that, if quantum probabilities are interpreted as conditional rather than absolute probabilities, a picture of the microworld can be constructed that is simultaneously consistent with local realism and QM. We show here that the BCHSH inequalities must be replaced, within the ESR model, by more general inequalities. These depend on parameters (detection probabilities) which may be such that the inequalities are never violated by quantum expectation values. The condition that no violation occurs implies the existence of upper bounds on detection probabilities, which makes the ESR model falsifiable. These results admit an intuitive explanation in terms of unfair sampling but basically differ from the seemingly similar results obtained by other approaches in which the efficiency problem is discussed in order to vindicate some kind of local realism.