Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Open Journal of the Communications Society

An In-Depth Comparative Study of Quantum-Classical Encoding Methods for Network Intrusion Detection

Adam Kadi, Aymene Selamnia, Zakaria Abou El Houda, Hajar Moudoud, Bouziane Brik, Lyes Khoukhi

Published Jan 1, 2025• 32 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In today's rapidly evolving cyber landscape, the growing sophistication of attacks, including the rise of zero-day exploits, poses critical challenges for network intrusion detection. Traditional Intrusion Detection Systems (IDSs) often struggle with the complexity and high dimensionality of modern cyber threats. Quantum Machine Learning (QML) seamlessly integrates the computational power of quantum computing with the adaptability of machine learning, offering an innovative approach to solving intricate and highdimensional challenges. A key factor in QML's performance is the method used to encode classical data into quantum states, as it defines how data is represented and processed in quantum circuits. QML offers promising advances for IDS, particularly through hybrid quantum-classical models. This study presents an in-depth comparative analysis of quantum-classical data encoding techniques for QML-based IDS. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to comprehensively evaluate the performance impact of different quantum encoding methods and provide a thorough evaluation of their impacts on the overall model performances. To achieve this, we first present a comprehensive evaluation of quantum and classical data encoding techniques, focusing on four key encoding techniques namely, Amplitude Embedding, Angle Embedding, Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial (IQP) Encoding, and Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) Embedding. Then, we develop a hybrid quantum-classical QML model to analyze how each encoding affects classification performance for malicious traffic. Finally, we conduct extensive experiments using two well-known, real-world network attack datasets to assess the accuracy and efficiency of each encoding approach. Our obtained results show notable differences in classification accuracy, underscoring the importance of encoding choice in optimizing QML-based IDS. This study aims to advance the application of quantum methodologies in network security by identifying effective encoding strategies for intrusion detection.

DOI
10.1109/ojcoms.2025.3537957

Related papers

Hybrid Quantum Machine Learning for Intrusion Detection: A Comparative Study of QNN and QSVM Models

Raid Anis Kerkatou, Hacene Belhadef, Aicha Eutamene +1 more

Intrusion Detection Systems (IDSs) are a cornerstone of modern cybersecurity; however, their performance is increasingly constrained by high-dimensional network traffic and the scalability limitations of classical machine learning approaches. Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has recently emerged as a promising paradigm by leveraging quantum feature spaces and hybrid quantum–classical optimization. In this work, we present a unified and reproducible benchmarking framework for QML-based intrusion detection under realistic Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) constraints. The proposed framework integrates hybrid Quantum Neural Networks (QNNs) and Quantum Support Vector Machines (QSVMs) within a consistent experimental pipeline, enabling a systematic comparison of quantum models, embedding strategies, and dimensionality reduction techniques. Experiments are conducted on the NSL-KDD benchmark dataset for both binary (normal versus attack) and multiclass intrusion detection tasks. Multiple quantum embedding strategies, including angle, amplitude, and Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial (IQP) embeddings, are evaluated in conjunction with PCA-based dimensionality reduction to analyze trade-offs between expressivity, circuit complexity, and computational cost. The proposed models are benchmarked against strong classical baselines under identical preprocessing and evaluation conditions. The results demonstrate that QNN- and QSVM-based IDS models achieve competitive and, in several scenarios, superior performance compared to classical approaches, particularly in multiclass settings characterized by nonlinear and imbalanced data distributions. In addition, we provide an in-depth analysis of scalability limitations, training complexity, and NISQ feasibility, highlighting practical considerations for real-world deployment. To ensure full reproducibility, all implementation details, datasets, and experimental configurations are publicly available at: https://github.com/raidanis/QML-IDS-NSLKDD. These findings position hybrid QML as a promising complementary paradigm for next-generation intrusion detection systems, particularly in low-dimensional and high-complexity feature spaces.

IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2026•5 citations

Benchmarking quantum machine learning methods for intrusion detection on noisy quantum computers

Franco Cirillo, Christian Esposito, Jung Taek Seo

Intrusion detection systems (IDS) are essential for identifying cyber threats in complex digital environments. Machine learning (ML) is widely used to improve IDS by detecting anomalies, but classical ML methods often struggle with high-dimensional data and evolving threats. Quantum machine learning (QML) has been proposed as a potential paradigm to overcome some of these limitations, but is constrained by noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) challenges, affecting quality. This study systematically evaluates three QML models, Pegasos Quantum Support Vector Classifier (QSVC), Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC), and a Hybrid Quantum–Classical Neural Network (HQNN), for network anomaly detection. The models were optimized and tested on the ToN_IoT and NSL-KDD datasets using IBM quantum simulators under both ideal and noisy conditions. Performance was analyzed through the F1-score distribution as a function of circuit complexity, revealing how entanglement and noise affect robustness across different backends. Comparisons with classical models contextualize the current maturity of QML for cybersecurity, while computational time was used as an indicator of model complexity to explore accuracy–efficiency trade-offs. Among all configurations, Pegasos-QSVC achieved the best results, with 94.60% accuracy and an F1-score of 94.13%. The findings provide practical guidelines for designing noise-resilient QML models and highlight their potential for reliable intrusion detection under realistic quantum conditions.

Quantum Machine Intelligence•Mar 11, 2026•8 citations

Exploring and Evaluating the Application of Quantum Computing Techniques in Enhancing the Performance of Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS)

David Laud Amenyo Fiase, KWADWO OPOKU ATTAH, Nathaniel Nelson +1 more

As cyber-physical systems and digital infrastructures grow in scale and complexity, conventional threat-detection techniques face increasing challenges in processing high-dimensional data, modeling nonlinear relationships, and responding to rapidly evolving attack surfaces. This work explores the potential of quantum computing techniques to enhance threat detection through quantum machine learning, quantum optimization, and quantum-inspired analytics focuses on IDS. We examine how quantum systems can encode complex feature spaces, accelerate search and classification tasks, and improve the detection of subtle anomalies and advanced persistent threats. Key use cases include intrusion detection, malware classification, behavioral analytics, and risk modeling. The study evaluates hybrid quantum classical architectures and discusses current hardware constraints, algorithmic maturity, and implementation considerations. While large-scale, fault-tolerant quantum systems remain under development, our findings indicate that near-term quantum approaches particularly variational models and amplitudeencoding schemes show promise for improving detection accuracy and computational efficiency in specific problem classes. This research highlights both the opportunities and the practical limitations of integrating quantum computing into cybersecurity workflows and outlines future directions for realizing robust, scalable quantum-enabled threat-detection systems

International Journal for Research in Applied Science and Engineering Technology•Feb 20, 2026•0 citations

LIGHTWEIGHT COMPARATIVE EVALUATION OF QUANTUM AND HYBRID QUANTUM-CLASSICAL MACHINE LEARNING MODELS FOR INTRUSION DETECTION

Genadiy Gospodinov, Tamara Ristovska, Tito Titov +3 more

Quantum machine learning (QML) has recently emerged as a promising research direction at the intersection of artificial intelligence, quantum computing, and cybersecurity. Among its potential applications, intrusion detection remains particularly relevant due to the growing complexity of cyber threats and the increasing need for adaptive and efficient detection mechanisms. This paper explores the applicability of lightweight quantum and hybrid quantum-classical machine learning approaches for intrusion detection in resource-constrained experimental settings. The study is designed as a comparative analysis of selected models, including variational and kernel-based quantum techniques, alongside a conventional classical baseline, in order to evaluate their practical potential for cybersecurity tasks.The experimental framework relies on a reduced and preprocessed cybersecurity dataset and is implemented in a simulated quantum environment using accessible open-source tools. The comparison considers standard performance indicators such as classification effectiveness and computational efficiency, while also reflecting on broader dimensions of model suitability for security-oriented applications. In addition to the technical evaluation, the paper addresses several ethical considerations associated with the use of QML in cybersecurity, including limited transparency, risks related to biased or imbalanced training data, and the operational implications of incorrect classifications in intrusion detection scenarios.Rather than claiming immediate quantum advantage, the study aims to provide a realistic and methodologically grounded perspective on the current role of QML in cybersecurity research. The expected contribution is twofold - first, to outline a feasible experimental approach for evaluating QML methods in intrusion detection and second, to highlight the importance of combining performance-oriented assessment with ethical and interpretability-related considerations when examining emerging intelligent security solutions.

Proceedings of the International Conference on Secure Systems Design and Technology Development•Sep 17, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Machine Learning for Network Intrusion Detection Systems, a Systematic Literature Review

Otavio Kiyatake Nicesio, Adriano Galindo Leal, Vagner Luiz Gava

Quantum computing presents potential advantages over classical computing in terms of computational complexity. Therefore, it is expected for quantum machine learning applications to have improvements in capacity and learning efficiency over classical machine learning methods. This paper aims to present a Systematic Literature Review of articles published between 2017 and 2022, identifying, analyzing, and comparing different proposals of quantum machine learning applications for network intrusion detection systems (IDS). This study focused on identifying papers that implemented quantum machine learning algorithms in the context of intrusion detection systems. The main algorithms found were variational hybrid quantum-classical, with models based on quantum support vector machines and quantum neural networks. Benefits compared to classical models were observed and described, such as reduced training time and improved classification accuracy for attacking traffic.

IEEE International Conference on AI in Cybersecurity (ICAIC)•Feb 7, 2023•33 citations

Quantum Machine Learning in Cybersecurity: A Hybrid Framework for Advanced Threat Detection and Classification

Nandala Narayanamma, Karnam Madhavi

With an increasing sophistication and prevalence of cyber attacks, basic machine learning techniques have been shown to lack basic capabilities for network attack detection in complex, high-dimensional attacks. In this paper, the authors present and thoroughly test a hybrid Quantum Machine Learning (QML) approach to facilitate the detection and classification of advanced cybersecurity threats. The QETC framework uses quantum feature mapping and data encoding with entanglement to increase the representational power of high dimensional data over classical methods. Systematic evaluation was performed on the NSL-KDD and CICIDS-2017 benchmark intrusion detection datasets with a simulated quantum backend with 8 qubits. Experimental results show that the QETC model obtains classification accuracy of 96.3% and 97.1% on the NSL-KDD and CICIDS-2017 datasets, respectively, which is statistically significant, with a margin of 2.8 and 3.4 percentage points over the best-performing classical baseline models. Interestingly, the quantum model outperformed by a large margin the detection capabilities for both rare and zeroday attack classes with an F1-score improvement up to 8.2 percentage points in the minority attack classes. This result in this paper demonstrates significant empirical evidence that quantum-classical hybrid architectures are a promising and viable path forward for next-generation cybersecurity applications.

•Aug 1, 2026•0 citations
In today's rapidly evolving cyber landscape, the growing sophistication of attacks, including the rise of zero-day exploits, poses critical challenges for network intrusion detection. Traditional Intrusion Detection Systems (IDSs) often struggle with the complexity and high dimensionality of modern cyber threats. Quantum Machine Learning (QML) seamlessly integrates the computational power of quantum computing with the adaptability of machine learning, offering an innovative approach to solving intricate and highdimensional challenges. A key factor in QML's performance is the method used to encode classical data into quantum states, as it defines how data is represented and processed in quantum circuits. QML offers promising advances for IDS, particularly through hybrid quantum-classical models. This study presents an in-depth comparative analysis of quantum-classical data encoding techniques for QML-based IDS. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to comprehensively evaluate the performance impact of different quantum encoding methods and provide a thorough evaluation of their impacts on the overall model performances. To achieve this, we first present a comprehensive evaluation of quantum and classical data encoding techniques, focusing on four key encoding techniques namely, Amplitude Embedding, Angle Embedding, Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial (IQP) Encoding, and Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) Embedding. Then, we develop a hybrid quantum-classical QML model to analyze how each encoding affects classification performance for malicious traffic. Finally, we conduct extensive experiments using two well-known, real-world network attack datasets to assess the accuracy and efficiency of each encoding approach. Our obtained results show notable differences in classification accuracy, underscoring the importance of encoding choice in optimizing QML-based IDS. This study aims to advance the application of quantum methodologies in network security by identifying effective encoding strategies for intrusion detection.
Intrusion Detection Systems (IDSs) are a cornerstone of modern cybersecurity; however, their performance is increasingly constrained by high-dimensional network traffic and the scalability limitations of classical machine learning approaches. Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has recently emerged as a promising paradigm by leveraging quantum feature spaces and hybrid quantum–classical optimization. In this work, we present a unified and reproducible benchmarking framework for QML-based intrusion detection under realistic Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) constraints. The proposed framework integrates hybrid Quantum Neural Networks (QNNs) and Quantum Support Vector Machines (QSVMs) within a consistent experimental pipeline, enabling a systematic comparison of quantum models, embedding strategies, and dimensionality reduction techniques. Experiments are conducted on the NSL-KDD benchmark dataset for both binary (normal versus attack) and multiclass intrusion detection tasks. Multiple quantum embedding strategies, including angle, amplitude, and Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial (IQP) embeddings, are evaluated in conjunction with PCA-based dimensionality reduction to analyze trade-offs between expressivity, circuit complexity, and computational cost. The proposed models are benchmarked against strong classical baselines under identical preprocessing and evaluation conditions. The results demonstrate that QNN- and QSVM-based IDS models achieve competitive and, in several scenarios, superior performance compared to classical approaches, particularly in multiclass settings characterized by nonlinear and imbalanced data distributions. In addition, we provide an in-depth analysis of scalability limitations, training complexity, and NISQ feasibility, highlighting practical considerations for real-world deployment. To ensure full reproducibility, all implementation details, datasets, and experimental configurations are publicly available at: https://github.com/raidanis/QML-IDS-NSLKDD. These findings position hybrid QML as a promising complementary paradigm for next-generation intrusion detection systems, particularly in low-dimensional and high-complexity feature spaces.
Intrusion detection systems (IDS) are essential for identifying cyber threats in complex digital environments. Machine learning (ML) is widely used to improve IDS by detecting anomalies, but classical ML methods often struggle with high-dimensional data and evolving threats. Quantum machine learning (QML) has been proposed as a potential paradigm to overcome some of these limitations, but is constrained by noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) challenges, affecting quality. This study systematically evaluates three QML models, Pegasos Quantum Support Vector Classifier (QSVC), Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC), and a Hybrid Quantum–Classical Neural Network (HQNN), for network anomaly detection. The models were optimized and tested on the ToN_IoT and NSL-KDD datasets using IBM quantum simulators under both ideal and noisy conditions. Performance was analyzed through the F1-score distribution as a function of circuit complexity, revealing how entanglement and noise affect robustness across different backends. Comparisons with classical models contextualize the current maturity of QML for cybersecurity, while computational time was used as an indicator of model complexity to explore accuracy–efficiency trade-offs. Among all configurations, Pegasos-QSVC achieved the best results, with 94.60% accuracy and an F1-score of 94.13%. The findings provide practical guidelines for designing noise-resilient QML models and highlight their potential for reliable intrusion detection under realistic quantum conditions.
As cyber-physical systems and digital infrastructures grow in scale and complexity, conventional threat-detection techniques face increasing challenges in processing high-dimensional data, modeling nonlinear relationships, and responding to rapidly evolving attack surfaces. This work explores the potential of quantum computing techniques to enhance threat detection through quantum machine learning, quantum optimization, and quantum-inspired analytics focuses on IDS. We examine how quantum systems can encode complex feature spaces, accelerate search and classification tasks, and improve the detection of subtle anomalies and advanced persistent threats. Key use cases include intrusion detection, malware classification, behavioral analytics, and risk modeling. The study evaluates hybrid quantum classical architectures and discusses current hardware constraints, algorithmic maturity, and implementation considerations. While large-scale, fault-tolerant quantum systems remain under development, our findings indicate that near-term quantum approaches particularly variational models and amplitudeencoding schemes show promise for improving detection accuracy and computational efficiency in specific problem classes. This research highlights both the opportunities and the practical limitations of integrating quantum computing into cybersecurity workflows and outlines future directions for realizing robust, scalable quantum-enabled threat-detection systems
Quantum machine learning (QML) has recently emerged as a promising research direction at the intersection of artificial intelligence, quantum computing, and cybersecurity. Among its potential applications, intrusion detection remains particularly relevant due to the growing complexity of cyber threats and the increasing need for adaptive and efficient detection mechanisms. This paper explores the applicability of lightweight quantum and hybrid quantum-classical machine learning approaches for intrusion detection in resource-constrained experimental settings. The study is designed as a comparative analysis of selected models, including variational and kernel-based quantum techniques, alongside a conventional classical baseline, in order to evaluate their practical potential for cybersecurity tasks.The experimental framework relies on a reduced and preprocessed cybersecurity dataset and is implemented in a simulated quantum environment using accessible open-source tools. The comparison considers standard performance indicators such as classification effectiveness and computational efficiency, while also reflecting on broader dimensions of model suitability for security-oriented applications. In addition to the technical evaluation, the paper addresses several ethical considerations associated with the use of QML in cybersecurity, including limited transparency, risks related to biased or imbalanced training data, and the operational implications of incorrect classifications in intrusion detection scenarios.Rather than claiming immediate quantum advantage, the study aims to provide a realistic and methodologically grounded perspective on the current role of QML in cybersecurity research. The expected contribution is twofold - first, to outline a feasible experimental approach for evaluating QML methods in intrusion detection and second, to highlight the importance of combining performance-oriented assessment with ethical and interpretability-related considerations when examining emerging intelligent security solutions.
Quantum computing presents potential advantages over classical computing in terms of computational complexity. Therefore, it is expected for quantum machine learning applications to have improvements in capacity and learning efficiency over classical machine learning methods. This paper aims to present a Systematic Literature Review of articles published between 2017 and 2022, identifying, analyzing, and comparing different proposals of quantum machine learning applications for network intrusion detection systems (IDS). This study focused on identifying papers that implemented quantum machine learning algorithms in the context of intrusion detection systems. The main algorithms found were variational hybrid quantum-classical, with models based on quantum support vector machines and quantum neural networks. Benefits compared to classical models were observed and described, such as reduced training time and improved classification accuracy for attacking traffic.
With an increasing sophistication and prevalence of cyber attacks, basic machine learning techniques have been shown to lack basic capabilities for network attack detection in complex, high-dimensional attacks. In this paper, the authors present and thoroughly test a hybrid Quantum Machine Learning (QML) approach to facilitate the detection and classification of advanced cybersecurity threats. The QETC framework uses quantum feature mapping and data encoding with entanglement to increase the representational power of high dimensional data over classical methods. Systematic evaluation was performed on the NSL-KDD and CICIDS-2017 benchmark intrusion detection datasets with a simulated quantum backend with 8 qubits. Experimental results show that the QETC model obtains classification accuracy of 96.3% and 97.1% on the NSL-KDD and CICIDS-2017 datasets, respectively, which is statistically significant, with a margin of 2.8 and 3.4 percentage points over the best-performing classical baseline models. Interestingly, the quantum model outperformed by a large margin the detection capabilities for both rare and zeroday attack classes with an F1-score improvement up to 8.2 percentage points in the minority attack classes. This result in this paper demonstrates significant empirical evidence that quantum-classical hybrid architectures are a promising and viable path forward for next-generation cybersecurity applications.