Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Proof of the incompleteness of wave quantum mechanics

Субхон Джомирзоев

Published Dec 25, 2024• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The first paragraph shows the incompleteness of the formulas proposed by de Broglie for the corpuscular-wave duality (CWD) of a nonrelativistic electron (NE) and in the second paragraph the full CWD of a NE is shown and the deducibility of corpuscular and wave quantities from more general quantities is indicated.
DOI
10.24108/preprints-3113318

Related papers

Proof of the incompleteness of wave quantum mechanics. Second part.

Субхон Джомирзоев

As a result of identifying the corpuscular-wave quantities (CWQ) of a non-relativistic electron (NE) as quantities associated with the equation of motion of wave quantum mechanics (WQM),it was discovered that WQM in reality is corpuscular-wave mechanics (CWM)and the fundamental differences between WQM and classical Newtonian mechanics (CNM) were established, and also, the possibility of creating analogies of WQM and CNM is indicated.

•Dec 27, 2024•0 citations

Schrödinger’s wave quantum mechanics is actually the corpuscular-wave mechanics of a non-relativistic electron.

Субхон Джомирзоев

The hundred and fifty years ago, I.Newton, in his corpuscular classic mechanics (CCM), introduced mass as an initial quantity, and, an its basis, defined other corpuscular quantities of CCM. And a hundred years ago, the corpuscular-wave properties of microparticles testified to the inherent corpuscular-wave quantities (CWQ), which as the initial value had the product of mass and wavelength. Accordingly, just as Newton’s CCM was based on corpuscular quantities, corpuscular-wave mechanics (CWM) should have been based on CWQ in the same way. But a hundred years ago, Plank’s and Einstein, to describe the corpuscular-wave properties of the photon, used hybrid of corpuscular quantities Newton’s CCM and wave quantities of wave optics, which a priori, by their definition, were insufficient to describe the CWQ of the photon. Subsequently, de Broglie and Schrödinger applied the method of Planck and Einstein to the case of a non-relativistic electron (NE), and obtained wave quantum mechanics (WQM). But the WQM he obtained turned out to be a real puzzle, and now, a hundred years later, l was able to discover that in reality WQM is an incomplete version of the CWM NE. The campaign managed to find out that Newton’s CCM arises in the form of a special case of the CWM macroscopic body. In this regard, now, l seem to be a Tajikistan physicist who discovered CWQ and CWM physics.

•Feb 7, 2025•0 citations

How to Complete the Quantum-Mechanical Description?

T. F. Kamalov

If the statement by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen on incompleteness of Quantum-Mechanical description of nature is correct, then we can regard Quantum Mechanics as a Method of Indirect Computation. The problem is, whether the theory is incomplete or the nature itself does not allow complete description? And if the first option is correct, how is it possible to complete the Quantum-Mechanical description? Here we try to complement de-Broglie's idea on wave-pilot the stochastic gravitation gives origin to. We assume that de-Broglie's wave-pilots are gravitational stochastic ones, and we shall regard micro-objects as test classical particles being subject to the influence of de-Broglie's waves stochastic gravitation.

arXiv:quant-ph/0212139•Dec 24, 2002•2 citations

Matter Waves Proposed by de Broglie (1923)

S. Brandt

Abstract We have seen that it took about two decades to fully realize that light or, generally, electromagnetic radiation has both wave and particle properties. The final proof came with the discovery of the Compton effect (Episode 31). Even Compton himself needed years before he saw that the particle picture of radiation was unavoidable in view of the experimental evidence. Still in the year of Compton’s publications, Louis de Broglie [1] on purely theoretical grounds proposed that the particle–wave duality not only holds for radiation but also for material particles, i.e., for particles with a rest mass such as the electron.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 22, 1992•0 citations

Electrons and Quanta1

Clinton J. Davisson

The experiments by the author and L. H. Germer, by G. P. Thomson and by others from which the wave properties of electrons are adduced are briefly described. The agreement between the results of these experiments and the prediction of L. de Broglie is pointed out. The wave and corpuscular properties of electrons are compared with the similar properties of light quanta.

Bell System Technical Journal•Apr 1, 1929•5 citations

Inadequacies in De Broglie's Theory: rectifications, verifications, and applications

Himanshu Chauhan, Ravindra Kumar Sinha

The proposed paper calls attention towards the unobserved mathematical and conceptual inadequacies persisting in the wave-particle duality and matter wave’s concepts, given by Louis de Broglie. Matter wave’s frequency and phase velocity expressions, shown to be inappropriate, are the consequences of these inadequate concepts. The rectifications in these concepts are presented through the corrected implementation of analogy between light waves and matter waves and thus modified frequency and phase velocity expressions are introduced. The proposed expressions are free from all the inadequacies and negations, contrary to that confronted by de Broglie’s proposed expressions. Mathematical proofs for the proposed modified frequency and phase velocity expression are also presented. A novel General Quantum Mechanical Wave Equation is proposed involving the modified phase velocity expression, which itself can precisely derive out Schrodinger’s and Dirac’s Equation.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Oct 1, 2013•0 citations
The hundred and fifty years ago, I.Newton, in his corpuscular classic mechanics (CCM), introduced mass as an initial quantity, and, an its basis, defined other corpuscular quantities of CCM. And a hundred years ago, the corpuscular-wave properties of microparticles testified to the inherent corpuscular-wave quantities (CWQ), which as the initial value had the product of mass and wavelength. Accordingly, just as Newton’s CCM was based on corpuscular quantities, corpuscular-wave mechanics (CWM) should have been based on CWQ in the same way. But a hundred years ago, Plank’s and Einstein, to describe the corpuscular-wave properties of the photon, used hybrid of corpuscular quantities Newton’s CCM and wave quantities of wave optics, which a priori, by their definition, were insufficient to describe the CWQ of the photon. Subsequently, de Broglie and Schrödinger applied the method of Planck and Einstein to the case of a non-relativistic electron (NE), and obtained wave quantum mechanics (WQM). But the WQM he obtained turned out to be a real puzzle, and now, a hundred years later, l was able to discover that in reality WQM is an incomplete version of the CWM NE. The campaign managed to find out that Newton’s CCM arises in the form of a special case of the CWM macroscopic body. In this regard, now, l seem to be a Tajikistan physicist who discovered CWQ and CWM physics.
If the statement by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen on incompleteness of Quantum-Mechanical description of nature is correct, then we can regard Quantum Mechanics as a Method of Indirect Computation. The problem is, whether the theory is incomplete or the nature itself does not allow complete description? And if the first option is correct, how is it possible to complete the Quantum-Mechanical description? Here we try to complement de-Broglie's idea on wave-pilot the stochastic gravitation gives origin to. We assume that de-Broglie's wave-pilots are gravitational stochastic ones, and we shall regard micro-objects as test classical particles being subject to the influence of de-Broglie's waves stochastic gravitation.
Abstract We have seen that it took about two decades to fully realize that light or, generally, electromagnetic radiation has both wave and particle properties. The final proof came with the discovery of the Compton effect (Episode 31). Even Compton himself needed years before he saw that the particle picture of radiation was unavoidable in view of the experimental evidence. Still in the year of Compton’s publications, Louis de Broglie [1] on purely theoretical grounds proposed that the particle–wave duality not only holds for radiation but also for material particles, i.e., for particles with a rest mass such as the electron.
The proposed paper calls attention towards the unobserved mathematical and conceptual inadequacies persisting in the wave-particle duality and matter wave’s concepts, given by Louis de Broglie. Matter wave’s frequency and phase velocity expressions, shown to be inappropriate, are the consequences of these inadequate concepts. The rectifications in these concepts are presented through the corrected implementation of analogy between light waves and matter waves and thus modified frequency and phase velocity expressions are introduced. The proposed expressions are free from all the inadequacies and negations, contrary to that confronted by de Broglie’s proposed expressions. Mathematical proofs for the proposed modified frequency and phase velocity expression are also presented. A novel General Quantum Mechanical Wave Equation is proposed involving the modified phase velocity expression, which itself can precisely derive out Schrodinger’s and Dirac’s Equation.