Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Linear Algebra and its Applications

Quantum subspace controllability implying full controllability

Francesca Albertini, Domenico D’Alessandro

Published Nov 7, 2024• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In the analysis of controllability of finite dimensional quantum systems, subspace controllability refers to the situation where the underlying Hilbert space splits into the direct sum of invariant subspaces, and, on each of such invariant subspaces, it is possible to generate any arbitrary unitary operation using appropriate control functions. This is a typical situation in the presence of symmetries for the dynamics. We investigate whether and when if subspace controllability is verified, the addition of an extra Hamiltonian to the dynamics implies full controllability of the system. Under the natural (and necessary) condition that the new Hamiltonian connects all the invariant subspaces, we show that this is always the case, except for a very specific case we shall describe. Even in this specific case, a weaker notion of controllability, controllability of the state ( Pure State Controllability ) is verified.

DOI
10.1016/j.laa.2024.11.002

Related papers

Subspace Controllability and Clebsch–Gordan Decomposition of Symmetric Quantum Networks

Domenico D’Alessandro

Abstract. This paper describes a framework for the controllability analysis of networks of [Formula: see text] quantum systems of an arbitrary dimension [Formula: see text] , qudits, with dynamics determined by Hamiltonians that are invariant under the permutation group [Formula: see text]. Because of the symmetry, the underlying Hilbert space, [Formula: see text], splits into invariant subspaces for the Lie algebra of [Formula: see text]-invariant elements in [Formula: see text], denoted here by [Formula: see text]. The dynamical Lie algebra [Formula: see text], which determines the controllability properties of the system, is a Lie subalgebra of such a Lie algebra [Formula: see text]. If [Formula: see text] acts as [Formula: see text] on each of the invariant subspaces [Formula: see text], the system is called subspace controllable. The described approach is based on recognizing that such a splitting of the Hilbert space [Formula: see text] coincides with the Clebsch–Gordan splitting of [Formula: see text] into irreducible representations of [Formula: see text]. In this view, [Formula: see text] is the direct sum of certain [Formula: see text] for some [Formula: see text]’s we shall specify and its center, which is the Abelian (Lie) algebra generated by the Casimir operators. Most of the results presented are for general [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text], but the paper provides a complete treatment and proof of subspace controllability for the new case of a system with [Formula: see text], [Formula: see text], that is, three qutrits. The results are motivated by recent great interest in symmetric quantum states and systems (see, e.g., [K. Eckert et al., Ann. Phys., 299 (2001), pp. 88–127], [A. W. Harrow, “The Church of the Symmetric Subspace,” https://arxiv.org/abs/1308.6595 , 2013], [P. Migdal, J. Rodriguez-Laguna, and M. Lewenstein, Phys. Rev. A, 88 (2013), 021335]) both at the theoretical and experimental levels and by recent proposals in geometric quantum machine learning [M. Cerezo et al., Nature Comput. Sci., 2 (2022), pp. 567–576], [Q. T. Nguyen et al., PRX Quant., 5 (2024), 020328] to exploit symmetries in the data and in quantum circuits to improve the performance of learning protocols.

arXiv:2307.12908•SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization•Dec 13, 2024•3 citations

Subspace Controllability of Quantum Ising Spin Networks with a Central Spin

Francesca Albertini, Domenico D’Alessandro

We consider a class of spin networks where each spin in a certain set interacts via Ising coupling with a single central spin. This is a common situation for instance in NV centers in diamonds. Due to the permutation symmetries of the network, the system is not globally controllable but it displays invariant subspaces of the underlying Hilbert space. The system is said to be subspace controllable if it is controllable on each of these subspaces. We characterize the given invariant subspaces and the dynamical Lie algebra of this class of systems and prove subspace controllability.

European Control Conference (ECC)•Jun 1, 2019•0 citations

Controllable Subspaces of Open Quantum Dynamical Systems

Ming Zhang, Hong‐Yi Dai, Gong Er-Ling +2 more

This paper discusses the concept of controllable subspace for open quantum dynamical systems.It is constructively demonstrated that combining structural features of decoherence-free subspaces with the ability to perform open-loop coherent control on open quantum systems will allow decoherence-free subspaces to be controllable.This is in contrast to the observation that open quantum dynamical systems are not open-loop controllable.To a certain extent, this paper gives an alternative control theoretical interpretation on why decoherence-free subspaces can be useful for quantum computation.

Communications in Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 2008•5 citations

Quantum control and representation theory

Alberto Ibort, Juan Manuel Pérez-Pardo

A new notion of controllability for quantum systems that takes advantage of the linear superposition of quantum states is introduced. We call such notion von Neumann controllabilty and it is shown that it is strictly weaker than the usual notion of pure state and operator controlability. We provide a simple and effective characterization of it by using tools from the theory of unitary representations of Lie groups. In this sense we are able to approach the problem of control of quantum states from a new perspective, that of the theory of unitary representations of Lie groups. A few examples of physical interest and the particular instances of compact and nilpotent dynamical Lie groups are discussed.

arXiv:1203.2380•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 28, 2009•8 citations

Small Entangled Quantum Worlds with a Simple Structure

E. D. Vol

We introduce the notion of a small quantum world (SQW) , which in our opinion, is very helpful in the situations when an experimenter's tools for preparing quantum states and (or) for measuring the observables of a quantum system under study are restricted due to some kind of reasons. In this case it is advisable to use as original an appropriate subspace of complete Hilbert space of states and respectively to utilize observables acting only in this subspace. If this subspace possesses some additional symmetries, the structure of a pure states set, as a rule, is simpler by far than in general case. Moreover in such SQWs some specific irreducible entangled states may appear. The similar states could be very helpful in various tasks connected with quantum informational applications. In the present paper main ideas outlined above are developed in detail in the simple and instructive case of a two-qubit system in which the accessible space of states possesses the additional symmetry structure of permutation group of three elements.

arXiv:1604.07374•Apr 25, 2016•0 citations

The controllability of infinite quantum systems

Roger W. Brockett, Chitra Rangan, Anthony M. Bloch

Quantum phenomena of interest in connection with computation and communication often deal with transfers between eigenstates. For systems having only a finite number of states, the quantum evolution equation is finite-dimensional and the results on controllability on Lie groups as worked out decades ago provide most of what is needed in so far as controllability of dissipationless systems is concerned. However, for infinite-dimensional evolution of quantum systems, many difficulties, both conceptual and technical, remain. In this paper we organize some recent results from the physics literature in control theoretic terms and emphasize the type of analysis needed to go beyond what basic differential geometry can provide. In particular, we analyze from a controllability point of view the important results of Law and Eberly, and discuss the problem of controllability of quantum systems subject to the constraint that the trajectories must lie in pre-defined subspaces. The study of this problem is motivated by recent work on the design of quantum computers that avoid loss of coherence by operating in decoherence free subspaces.

IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC)•Jul 8, 2004•17 citations
In the analysis of controllability of finite dimensional quantum systems, subspace controllability refers to the situation where the underlying Hilbert space splits into the direct sum of invariant subspaces, and, on each of such invariant subspaces, it is possible to generate any arbitrary unitary operation using appropriate control functions. This is a typical situation in the presence of symmetries for the dynamics. We investigate whether and when if subspace controllability is verified, the addition of an extra Hamiltonian to the dynamics implies full controllability of the system. Under the natural (and necessary) condition that the new Hamiltonian connects all the invariant subspaces, we show that this is always the case, except for a very specific case we shall describe. Even in this specific case, a weaker notion of controllability, controllability of the state ( Pure State Controllability ) is verified.
Abstract. This paper describes a framework for the controllability analysis of networks of [Formula: see text] quantum systems of an arbitrary dimension [Formula: see text] , qudits, with dynamics determined by Hamiltonians that are invariant under the permutation group [Formula: see text]. Because of the symmetry, the underlying Hilbert space, [Formula: see text], splits into invariant subspaces for the Lie algebra of [Formula: see text]-invariant elements in [Formula: see text], denoted here by [Formula: see text]. The dynamical Lie algebra [Formula: see text], which determines the controllability properties of the system, is a Lie subalgebra of such a Lie algebra [Formula: see text]. If [Formula: see text] acts as [Formula: see text] on each of the invariant subspaces [Formula: see text], the system is called subspace controllable. The described approach is based on recognizing that such a splitting of the Hilbert space [Formula: see text] coincides with the Clebsch–Gordan splitting of [Formula: see text] into irreducible representations of [Formula: see text]. In this view, [Formula: see text] is the direct sum of certain [Formula: see text] for some [Formula: see text]’s we shall specify and its center, which is the Abelian (Lie) algebra generated by the Casimir operators. Most of the results presented are for general [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text], but the paper provides a complete treatment and proof of subspace controllability for the new case of a system with [Formula: see text], [Formula: see text], that is, three qutrits. The results are motivated by recent great interest in symmetric quantum states and systems (see, e.g., [K. Eckert et al., Ann. Phys., 299 (2001), pp. 88–127], [A. W. Harrow, “The Church of the Symmetric Subspace,” https://arxiv.org/abs/1308.6595 , 2013], [P. Migdal, J. Rodriguez-Laguna, and M. Lewenstein, Phys. Rev. A, 88 (2013), 021335]) both at the theoretical and experimental levels and by recent proposals in geometric quantum machine learning [M. Cerezo et al., Nature Comput. Sci., 2 (2022), pp. 567–576], [Q. T. Nguyen et al., PRX Quant., 5 (2024), 020328] to exploit symmetries in the data and in quantum circuits to improve the performance of learning protocols.
We consider a class of spin networks where each spin in a certain set interacts via Ising coupling with a single central spin. This is a common situation for instance in NV centers in diamonds. Due to the permutation symmetries of the network, the system is not globally controllable but it displays invariant subspaces of the underlying Hilbert space. The system is said to be subspace controllable if it is controllable on each of these subspaces. We characterize the given invariant subspaces and the dynamical Lie algebra of this class of systems and prove subspace controllability.
This paper discusses the concept of controllable subspace for open quantum dynamical systems.It is constructively demonstrated that combining structural features of decoherence-free subspaces with the ability to perform open-loop coherent control on open quantum systems will allow decoherence-free subspaces to be controllable.This is in contrast to the observation that open quantum dynamical systems are not open-loop controllable.To a certain extent, this paper gives an alternative control theoretical interpretation on why decoherence-free subspaces can be useful for quantum computation.
A new notion of controllability for quantum systems that takes advantage of the linear superposition of quantum states is introduced. We call such notion von Neumann controllabilty and it is shown that it is strictly weaker than the usual notion of pure state and operator controlability. We provide a simple and effective characterization of it by using tools from the theory of unitary representations of Lie groups. In this sense we are able to approach the problem of control of quantum states from a new perspective, that of the theory of unitary representations of Lie groups. A few examples of physical interest and the particular instances of compact and nilpotent dynamical Lie groups are discussed.
We introduce the notion of a small quantum world (SQW) , which in our opinion, is very helpful in the situations when an experimenter's tools for preparing quantum states and (or) for measuring the observables of a quantum system under study are restricted due to some kind of reasons. In this case it is advisable to use as original an appropriate subspace of complete Hilbert space of states and respectively to utilize observables acting only in this subspace. If this subspace possesses some additional symmetries, the structure of a pure states set, as a rule, is simpler by far than in general case. Moreover in such SQWs some specific irreducible entangled states may appear. The similar states could be very helpful in various tasks connected with quantum informational applications. In the present paper main ideas outlined above are developed in detail in the simple and instructive case of a two-qubit system in which the accessible space of states possesses the additional symmetry structure of permutation group of three elements.
Quantum phenomena of interest in connection with computation and communication often deal with transfers between eigenstates. For systems having only a finite number of states, the quantum evolution equation is finite-dimensional and the results on controllability on Lie groups as worked out decades ago provide most of what is needed in so far as controllability of dissipationless systems is concerned. However, for infinite-dimensional evolution of quantum systems, many difficulties, both conceptual and technical, remain. In this paper we organize some recent results from the physics literature in control theoretic terms and emphasize the type of analysis needed to go beyond what basic differential geometry can provide. In particular, we analyze from a controllability point of view the important results of Law and Eberly, and discuss the problem of controllability of quantum systems subject to the constraint that the trajectories must lie in pre-defined subspaces. The study of this problem is motivated by recent work on the design of quantum computers that avoid loss of coherence by operating in decoherence free subspaces.