Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Quantum nonlocality of density operators and their corresponding density matrices

K. F. Hu, Zhihua Guo, Huaixin Cao, L. Lu

Published Oct 28, 2024• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Quantum nonlocality represents correlations between subsystems of a composite quantum system, usually including Bell nonlocality, steerability, and entanglement. According to the hypothesis of quantum mechanics, states of a quantum system Q described by a d -dimensional Hilbert space are denoted by density operators acting on . Under a basis e for the Hilbert space , every abstract density operator ρ of the system AB corresponds to a density matrix ρ e , which is a state of the complex Hilbert space . In this work, we discuss the consistency of quantum nonlocality of density operators ρ and their corresponding density matrices ρ e under the chosen basis e . It is proved that only when a basis e is a product one, a density operator ρ is entangled (respectively, Bell nonlocal, steerable) if and only if its density matrix ρ e is entangled (respectively, Bell nonlocal, steerable).

DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/ad8bee

Related papers

Bell nonlocality measure of density matrix based on trace distance

Yuxuan Fu, Liting Li

Abstract Quantum information technology exhibits advantages in terms of algorithm efficiency, communication security, and other aspects compared to classical information technology, partially due to quantum nonlocality, which is a characteristic that distinguishes quantum mechanics from classical mechanics. Compared to quantum entanglement and quantum steering, Bell nonlocality exhibits stronger quantum properties in a certain sense. However, research on efficient estimation of Bell nonlocality of general quantum states remains rare. This work proposes a generalized Bell nonlocality measure of density matrices. Our method generalizes the fundamental matrix for classical correlation and applies it to experimental scenarios of various dimensions. We prove that this measure of Bell nonlocality is well-defined. We also propose a relaxation algorithm for numerically estimating this measure. Applying the see-saw method, the algorithm obtains an upper bound on this measure. Numerical experiments show the effectiveness of our method in low dimensions and suggest that it could be used in high dimensions.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Feb 1, 2025•0 citations

Exploring High-dimensional Hilbert spaces by Quantum Optics

Andrea Chiuri, Paolo Mataloni

In the case of mixed states ρAB of the composite system A ⊗ B, the previous relation generalizes to ρAB = ∑ k pkρ A k ⊗ρk , where pk are probabilities and ρk ’s (ρk ’s) are generic density matrix of the system A (B). The entanglement derives from “subtle” nonlocal correlations between the parts of a quantum system and combines three basic structural elements of quantum theory: the superposition principle, the quantum non-separability property and the exponential scaling of the state space with the number of partitions. This unique resource can be used to perform computational and cryptographic tasks otherwise impossible with classical systems. An entangled state shared by two or more separated parties is a valuable resource for fundamental quantum protocols, such as quantum teleportation [2], quantum computing [3] and quantum cryptography. By using entangled states we can deeply investigate the nonlocal properties of the quantum world. In fact, an entangled system exhibits correlations between two (or more) parties, which cannot be reproduced by a classical theory or, in general, by a Local Hidden Variables Theory (LHVT). Quantum optics represents an excellent experimental test bench for various novel concepts introduced within the framework of quantum information theory. Quantum states of photons, generally produced by a probabilistic process, namely spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC), may be easily and accurately manipulated using linear and nonlinear optical devices and measured by efficient single-photon detectors. Photonic qubits represent the typical carrier of quantum information and can be distributed over long distances, either in free-space or in low-loss optical fibers. Two-particle experiments correspond to operate with qubits belonging to a (2 × 2) Hilbert space. Many quantum information tasks and fundamental tests of quantum mechanics, such as the simulation of properties of quantum systems, the realization of quantum algorithms of increasing complexity and the investigation of the quantum world at a mesoscopic level, deal with a large number of qubits. In order to take full advantage of the possibilities offered by quantum mechanics, more qubits must be added to a quantum state. Two approaches may be followed to increase the number of qubits. The first one consists of increasing the number of entangled particles. In this way, multi-qubit entangled states are created by distributing the qubits between the particles so that each particle carries one qubit. A second strategy consists of encoding more than one qubit in each particle, by exploiting different degrees of freedom (DOFs) of the photon such as the polarization, the path, the emission time, the orbital angular momentum. This has been used to create two-photon fourand six-qubit states and up to five-photon ten-qubit graph states. The entanglement of two particles in different DOFs corresponds to socalled hyperentanglement. It is worth noting that multi-qubit hyperentanglement allows to achieve higher

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Nonlocality of orthogonal product basis quantum states

Zhichao Zhang, Fei Gao, Guojing Tian +2 more

In this paper, we mainly study the local indistinguishability of mutually orthogonal product basis quantum states in the high-dimensional quantum systems. In the Hilbert space of $3\ensuremath{\bigotimes}3$, Walgate and Hardy [Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 147901 (2002)] presented a very simple proof for nonlocality of nine orthogonal product basis quantum states which are given by Bennett et al. [Phys. Rev. A 59, 1070 (1999)]. In the quantum system of $d\ensuremath{\bigotimes}d$, where $d$ is odd, we construct ${d}^{2}$ orthogonal product basis quantum states and prove these states are locally indistinguishable. Then we are able to construct some locally indistinguishable product basis quantum states in the multipartite systems. All these results reveal the phenomenon of ``nonlocality without entanglement.''

Physical Review A•Aug 13, 2014•101 citations

Revealing hidden quantum steerability using local filtering operations

Tanumoy Pramanik, Young‐Wook Cho, Sang-Wook Han +3 more

Nonlocal quantum correlation is at the heart of the bizarre nature of quantum physics. While there are various classes of nonlocal quantum correlation, steerability of a quantum state by local measurements provides unique operational features. Here, we theoretically and experimentally investigate the ``hidden'' property of quantum steerability. In particular, we find that there are initially unsteerable states which can reveal the steerability by using local filters on individual quantum systems. It is remarkable that a certain set of local filters is more effective in revealing steerability than Bell nonlocality whereas there exists another set of filters that is more effective in revealing Bell nonlocality than steerability. This result suggests the structural difference between entanglement and steerability. Finally, we present a counterintuitive result that mixed states originating from nonmaximally pure entangled states can have hidden steerability while the mixed state from a maximally pure entangled state fails to show steerability.

arXiv:1707.08285•Physical Review A•Mar 1, 2019•40 citations

Quantum Entanglement as Shared Informational Identity A Postulational, Operator-Based, and Thermodynamic Framework for Nonlocal Correlations, Measurement, and Collapse

Ali Caner Yücel

Quantum entanglement produces correlations that violate classical locality constraints while remaining fully consistent with relativistic no-signaling. Although standard quantum mechanics predicts these correlations with extraordinary empirical success, the ontological meaning of entangled states and the physical status of wave-function collapse remain deeply debated. This paper develops a speculative but structured informational interpretation in which entangled subsystems are modeled as multiple local realizations of a single shared informational identity within an underlying finite-capacity substrate. The framework is articulated through explicit postulates, density-matrix analysis, entanglement entropy, a toy realization scheme, and an informational identity operator acting on composite states. Within this view, nonlocal correlations arise not from superluminal causal influence but from ontological non-separability at the informational level. Measurement is interpreted as informational resolution: a reduction of degeneracy in the local realization of a shared informational structure. The irreversible stabilization of outcomes is then linked to thermodynamic cost through Landauer-type reasoning. The proposal is not advanced as a replacement for quantum mechanics, nor as a fully worked-out hidden-variable theory, but as an ontological scaffold intended to unify entanglement, collapse, and thermodynamic irreversibility within an informational perspective. Compatibility with Bell inequalities, decoherence, basis selection, and no-signaling is discussed in detail, together with limitations and possible routes toward future formalization and empirical relevance.

•Mar 6, 2026•0 citations

Quantum channels transforming Bell local states as unsteerable states

Shu Xiao, Li‐Hua Bai, Zhihua Guo +1 more

Motivated by the contributions [Sci. Rep. 6, 39063 (2016)] and [Phys. Rev. A 98, 052114 (2018)], we aim to establish a new method for theoretically checking Bell nonlocality of a bipartite state of systems for any finite dimensional Hilbert spaces and , provided that the operator space has an orthonormal basis consisting of the identity operator and Hermitian unitary operators. Our main result induces a quantum channel transforming a Bell local state as an unsteerable state from A to B whenever the parameters T and satisfy the condition . Thus, when and the image is steerable from Ato B, the original state must be Bell nonlocal. Our result not only reveals a deep connection between EPR steerability and Bell nonlocality but also provides a feasible approach to theoretically prove difficultly verified Bell nonlocality by translating it into easily verified steerability.

Quantum Engineering•Jul 6, 2021•1 citation
Abstract Quantum nonlocality represents correlations between subsystems of a composite quantum system, usually including Bell nonlocality, steerability, and entanglement. According to the hypothesis of quantum mechanics, states of a quantum system Q described by a d -dimensional Hilbert space are denoted by density operators acting on . Under a basis e for the Hilbert space , every abstract density operator ρ of the system AB corresponds to a density matrix ρ e , which is a state of the complex Hilbert space . In this work, we discuss the consistency of quantum nonlocality of density operators ρ and their corresponding density matrices ρ e under the chosen basis e . It is proved that only when a basis e is a product one, a density operator ρ is entangled (respectively, Bell nonlocal, steerable) if and only if its density matrix ρ e is entangled (respectively, Bell nonlocal, steerable).
Abstract Quantum information technology exhibits advantages in terms of algorithm efficiency, communication security, and other aspects compared to classical information technology, partially due to quantum nonlocality, which is a characteristic that distinguishes quantum mechanics from classical mechanics. Compared to quantum entanglement and quantum steering, Bell nonlocality exhibits stronger quantum properties in a certain sense. However, research on efficient estimation of Bell nonlocality of general quantum states remains rare. This work proposes a generalized Bell nonlocality measure of density matrices. Our method generalizes the fundamental matrix for classical correlation and applies it to experimental scenarios of various dimensions. We prove that this measure of Bell nonlocality is well-defined. We also propose a relaxation algorithm for numerically estimating this measure. Applying the see-saw method, the algorithm obtains an upper bound on this measure. Numerical experiments show the effectiveness of our method in low dimensions and suggest that it could be used in high dimensions.
In the case of mixed states ρAB of the composite system A ⊗ B, the previous relation generalizes to ρAB = ∑ k pkρ A k ⊗ρk , where pk are probabilities and ρk ’s (ρk ’s) are generic density matrix of the system A (B). The entanglement derives from “subtle” nonlocal correlations between the parts of a quantum system and combines three basic structural elements of quantum theory: the superposition principle, the quantum non-separability property and the exponential scaling of the state space with the number of partitions. This unique resource can be used to perform computational and cryptographic tasks otherwise impossible with classical systems. An entangled state shared by two or more separated parties is a valuable resource for fundamental quantum protocols, such as quantum teleportation [2], quantum computing [3] and quantum cryptography. By using entangled states we can deeply investigate the nonlocal properties of the quantum world. In fact, an entangled system exhibits correlations between two (or more) parties, which cannot be reproduced by a classical theory or, in general, by a Local Hidden Variables Theory (LHVT). Quantum optics represents an excellent experimental test bench for various novel concepts introduced within the framework of quantum information theory. Quantum states of photons, generally produced by a probabilistic process, namely spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC), may be easily and accurately manipulated using linear and nonlinear optical devices and measured by efficient single-photon detectors. Photonic qubits represent the typical carrier of quantum information and can be distributed over long distances, either in free-space or in low-loss optical fibers. Two-particle experiments correspond to operate with qubits belonging to a (2 × 2) Hilbert space. Many quantum information tasks and fundamental tests of quantum mechanics, such as the simulation of properties of quantum systems, the realization of quantum algorithms of increasing complexity and the investigation of the quantum world at a mesoscopic level, deal with a large number of qubits. In order to take full advantage of the possibilities offered by quantum mechanics, more qubits must be added to a quantum state. Two approaches may be followed to increase the number of qubits. The first one consists of increasing the number of entangled particles. In this way, multi-qubit entangled states are created by distributing the qubits between the particles so that each particle carries one qubit. A second strategy consists of encoding more than one qubit in each particle, by exploiting different degrees of freedom (DOFs) of the photon such as the polarization, the path, the emission time, the orbital angular momentum. This has been used to create two-photon fourand six-qubit states and up to five-photon ten-qubit graph states. The entanglement of two particles in different DOFs corresponds to socalled hyperentanglement. It is worth noting that multi-qubit hyperentanglement allows to achieve higher
In this paper, we mainly study the local indistinguishability of mutually orthogonal product basis quantum states in the high-dimensional quantum systems. In the Hilbert space of $3\ensuremath{\bigotimes}3$, Walgate and Hardy [Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 147901 (2002)] presented a very simple proof for nonlocality of nine orthogonal product basis quantum states which are given by Bennett et al. [Phys. Rev. A 59, 1070 (1999)]. In the quantum system of $d\ensuremath{\bigotimes}d$, where ddd is odd, we construct d2{d}^{2}d2 orthogonal product basis quantum states and prove these states are locally indistinguishable. Then we are able to construct some locally indistinguishable product basis quantum states in the multipartite systems. All these results reveal the phenomenon of ``nonlocality without entanglement.''
Nonlocal quantum correlation is at the heart of the bizarre nature of quantum physics. While there are various classes of nonlocal quantum correlation, steerability of a quantum state by local measurements provides unique operational features. Here, we theoretically and experimentally investigate the ``hidden'' property of quantum steerability. In particular, we find that there are initially unsteerable states which can reveal the steerability by using local filters on individual quantum systems. It is remarkable that a certain set of local filters is more effective in revealing steerability than Bell nonlocality whereas there exists another set of filters that is more effective in revealing Bell nonlocality than steerability. This result suggests the structural difference between entanglement and steerability. Finally, we present a counterintuitive result that mixed states originating from nonmaximally pure entangled states can have hidden steerability while the mixed state from a maximally pure entangled state fails to show steerability.
Quantum entanglement produces correlations that violate classical locality constraints while remaining fully consistent with relativistic no-signaling. Although standard quantum mechanics predicts these correlations with extraordinary empirical success, the ontological meaning of entangled states and the physical status of wave-function collapse remain deeply debated. This paper develops a speculative but structured informational interpretation in which entangled subsystems are modeled as multiple local realizations of a single shared informational identity within an underlying finite-capacity substrate. The framework is articulated through explicit postulates, density-matrix analysis, entanglement entropy, a toy realization scheme, and an informational identity operator acting on composite states. Within this view, nonlocal correlations arise not from superluminal causal influence but from ontological non-separability at the informational level. Measurement is interpreted as informational resolution: a reduction of degeneracy in the local realization of a shared informational structure. The irreversible stabilization of outcomes is then linked to thermodynamic cost through Landauer-type reasoning. The proposal is not advanced as a replacement for quantum mechanics, nor as a fully worked-out hidden-variable theory, but as an ontological scaffold intended to unify entanglement, collapse, and thermodynamic irreversibility within an informational perspective. Compatibility with Bell inequalities, decoherence, basis selection, and no-signaling is discussed in detail, together with limitations and possible routes toward future formalization and empirical relevance.
Motivated by the contributions [Sci. Rep. 6, 39063 (2016)] and [Phys. Rev. A 98, 052114 (2018)], we aim to establish a new method for theoretically checking Bell nonlocality of a bipartite state of systems for any finite dimensional Hilbert spaces and , provided that the operator space has an orthonormal basis consisting of the identity operator and Hermitian unitary operators. Our main result induces a quantum channel transforming a Bell local state as an unsteerable state from A to B whenever the parameters T and satisfy the condition . Thus, when and the image is steerable from Ato B, the original state must be Bell nonlocal. Our result not only reveals a deep connection between EPR steerability and Bell nonlocality but also provides a feasible approach to theoretically prove difficultly verified Bell nonlocality by translating it into easily verified steerability.