Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Imagination and Real Quantization

Stanislav Ordin

Published Oct 24, 2024• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This chapter shows that the use of mathematical imaginaries, complex numbers, and even more so quaternions in quantum theory to increase the dimension of solutions of one-dimensional equations is, in principle, incorrect. As a result, Einstein’s condition was violated: SOME equations of classical physics can be rewritten in operator form. The use of correct multidimensional models makes it possible, using the example of the harmonic oscillator, to obtain the Planck-Einstein quantization for da Broglie waves.

DOI
10.1201/9781003570615-18

Related papers

Imagination and real quantization

Stanislav Ordin

The paper shows that the use of mathematical imaginaries, complex numbers, and even more so quaternions in the Quantum Theory to increase the dimension of solutions of one-dimensional equations is, in principle, incorrect. As a result, Einstein's condition was violated: SOME equations of Classical Physics can be rewritten in operator form. The use of correct multidimensional models makes it possible, using the example of the Harmonic Oscillator, to obtain the Planck-Einstein Quantization for da Broglie waves.

International Journal of Physics and Applications•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

QUANTIZATION

In the introductory chapter we discussed some simple applications of Schrödinger’s wave mechanics, one example being the harmonic oscillator. We shall now make a fresh start and approach the world of quantum mechanics along a rather different route by taking classical analytical mechanics as our point of departure. We shall see how classical mechanics may be formulated in a way that makes the transition to quantum mechanics look like a simple generalization. This route is not the one taken by history, as we have seen in the introductory chapter. The revolutionary changes in the description of physical systems brought about by quantum mechanics were not due to formal generalizations of classical mechanics. The driving force was the increasing number of experimental observations, which could not be explained within the classical physics of the nineteenth century. In the present chapter we shall use the harmonic oscillator to illustrate the quantization procedure. The reason for this is two-fold; the harmonic oscillator plays a very important role in quantum physics, and it is also one of the few physical systems which may be treated exactly. The harmonic oscillator forms the basis for understanding a wide range of different phenomena, such as absorption and emission of radiation, vibrations in molecules, specific heat of solids or collective oscillations in nuclei.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•May 1, 1991•0 citations

Historical Development

P. J. E. Peebles

This chapter presents the origins of quantum mechanics. The story of how people hit on the highly non-intuitive world picture of quantum mechanics, in which the physical state of a system is represented by an element in an abstract linear space and its observable properties by operators in the space, is fascinating and exceedingly complicated. The much greater change from the classical world picture of Newtonian mechanics and general relativity to the quantum world picture came in many steps taken by many people, often against the better judgment of participants. There are three major elements in the story. The first is the experimental evidence that the energy of an isolated system can only assume special discrete or quantized values. The second is the idea that the energy is proportional to the frequency of a wave function associated with the system. The third is the connection between the de Broglie relation and energy quantization through the mathematical result that a wave equation with fixed boundary conditions allows only discrete quantized values of the frequency of oscillation of the wave function (as in the fundamental and harmonics of the vibration of a violin string).

Princeton University Press eBooks•May 14, 2019•0 citations

Quadratic and linear potentials

Keith Hannabuss

Abstract Although the classical examples of harmonic oscillators such as springs or the simple pendulum are of limited use in the submicroscopic world of quantum mechanics, there are plenty of other applications that make the oscillator worth studying. Atoms in a crystal, for instance, oscillate about their mean positions and it is their vibrations that carry sound and heat through the material. Indeed, we know from classical theory that by using normal coordinates we may regard any system performing small oscillations about a point of stable equilibrium as a collection of harmonic oscillators. This extends even to the normal modes of vibration of a string or of the electromagnetic field. The harmonic oscillator thus provides the key to understanding how wave phenomena such as light can be quantized, and lies at the heart of Einstein’s idea of the photon and of Planck’s quantum.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 20, 1997•0 citations

General Description and Quantization of EM Fields

Z. Ficek, Mohamed Ridza Wahiddin

We will begin our journey through the background of quantum optics with an elementary, but quantitative, classical theory of radiative fields.Wewill first briefly outline the electromagnetic (EM) theory of radiation, and describe how the EM radiation may be understood as a wavewhich can be represented by a set of harmonic oscillators. We shall describe how the free or non-interacting EM field may be understood as a collection of harmonic oscillators which is quantized in the standard manner, and whose energy cannot be zero as a consequence of the basic non-commutability of the canonical field variables. This chapter discusses the properties of plane EM waves and normalization of the EM field in one dimension. This is followed by a description of the Hamiltonian and the amplitudes of the EM field in terms of the annihilation and creation operators. Based on this chapter, it is possible to considerably simplify the formulation of the physical basis for the mathematical description of the major problems of quantum optics.

•Apr 19, 2016•0 citations

Continuous Spectra

Tilak Sinha

In this chapter we take up systems whose state spaces form a continuum. These are, naturally, infinite dimensional vector spaces (often called Hilbert spaces). Unfortunately, we could not do any better than treating such systems by formal analogy with their finite dimensional counterparts. A rigorous treatment would require a background in functional analysis and is beyond the scope of the present work. Thus, we essentially lay out a dictionary for translating the mathematical ingredients and formulae, from discrete to continuum descriptions, motivated by plausibility arguments. In particular, we argue why states are now described by complex square integrable functions (called wave functions) and observables by Hermitian differential operators. We then move on to show how to quantize quantum systems with classical analogues, which comprise the bulk of real life physical systems. Here, we explicitly show how the most nontrivial component of the quantization, i.e., the description of the representation of the momentum operator (in position space) can be deduced from both, the de Broglie hypothesis, and the canonical commutation relation. The “particle in a box” problem is treated as an illustration. The parity operator, Ehrenfest's theorem and continuity conditions have been relegated to the problem section.

Chapman & Hall/CRC eBooks•Jun 18, 2021•0 citations
This chapter shows that the use of mathematical imaginaries, complex numbers, and even more so quaternions in quantum theory to increase the dimension of solutions of one-dimensional equations is, in principle, incorrect. As a result, Einstein’s condition was violated: SOME equations of classical physics can be rewritten in operator form. The use of correct multidimensional models makes it possible, using the example of the harmonic oscillator, to obtain the Planck-Einstein quantization for da Broglie waves.
The paper shows that the use of mathematical imaginaries, complex numbers, and even more so quaternions in the Quantum Theory to increase the dimension of solutions of one-dimensional equations is, in principle, incorrect. As a result, Einstein's condition was violated: SOME equations of Classical Physics can be rewritten in operator form. The use of correct multidimensional models makes it possible, using the example of the Harmonic Oscillator, to obtain the Planck-Einstein Quantization for da Broglie waves.
In the introductory chapter we discussed some simple applications of Schrödinger’s wave mechanics, one example being the harmonic oscillator. We shall now make a fresh start and approach the world of quantum mechanics along a rather different route by taking classical analytical mechanics as our point of departure. We shall see how classical mechanics may be formulated in a way that makes the transition to quantum mechanics look like a simple generalization. This route is not the one taken by history, as we have seen in the introductory chapter. The revolutionary changes in the description of physical systems brought about by quantum mechanics were not due to formal generalizations of classical mechanics. The driving force was the increasing number of experimental observations, which could not be explained within the classical physics of the nineteenth century. In the present chapter we shall use the harmonic oscillator to illustrate the quantization procedure. The reason for this is two-fold; the harmonic oscillator plays a very important role in quantum physics, and it is also one of the few physical systems which may be treated exactly. The harmonic oscillator forms the basis for understanding a wide range of different phenomena, such as absorption and emission of radiation, vibrations in molecules, specific heat of solids or collective oscillations in nuclei.
This chapter presents the origins of quantum mechanics. The story of how people hit on the highly non-intuitive world picture of quantum mechanics, in which the physical state of a system is represented by an element in an abstract linear space and its observable properties by operators in the space, is fascinating and exceedingly complicated. The much greater change from the classical world picture of Newtonian mechanics and general relativity to the quantum world picture came in many steps taken by many people, often against the better judgment of participants. There are three major elements in the story. The first is the experimental evidence that the energy of an isolated system can only assume special discrete or quantized values. The second is the idea that the energy is proportional to the frequency of a wave function associated with the system. The third is the connection between the de Broglie relation and energy quantization through the mathematical result that a wave equation with fixed boundary conditions allows only discrete quantized values of the frequency of oscillation of the wave function (as in the fundamental and harmonics of the vibration of a violin string).
Abstract Although the classical examples of harmonic oscillators such as springs or the simple pendulum are of limited use in the submicroscopic world of quantum mechanics, there are plenty of other applications that make the oscillator worth studying. Atoms in a crystal, for instance, oscillate about their mean positions and it is their vibrations that carry sound and heat through the material. Indeed, we know from classical theory that by using normal coordinates we may regard any system performing small oscillations about a point of stable equilibrium as a collection of harmonic oscillators. This extends even to the normal modes of vibration of a string or of the electromagnetic field. The harmonic oscillator thus provides the key to understanding how wave phenomena such as light can be quantized, and lies at the heart of Einstein’s idea of the photon and of Planck’s quantum.
We will begin our journey through the background of quantum optics with an elementary, but quantitative, classical theory of radiative fields.Wewill first briefly outline the electromagnetic (EM) theory of radiation, and describe how the EM radiation may be understood as a wavewhich can be represented by a set of harmonic oscillators. We shall describe how the free or non-interacting EM field may be understood as a collection of harmonic oscillators which is quantized in the standard manner, and whose energy cannot be zero as a consequence of the basic non-commutability of the canonical field variables. This chapter discusses the properties of plane EM waves and normalization of the EM field in one dimension. This is followed by a description of the Hamiltonian and the amplitudes of the EM field in terms of the annihilation and creation operators. Based on this chapter, it is possible to considerably simplify the formulation of the physical basis for the mathematical description of the major problems of quantum optics.
In this chapter we take up systems whose state spaces form a continuum. These are, naturally, infinite dimensional vector spaces (often called Hilbert spaces). Unfortunately, we could not do any better than treating such systems by formal analogy with their finite dimensional counterparts. A rigorous treatment would require a background in functional analysis and is beyond the scope of the present work. Thus, we essentially lay out a dictionary for translating the mathematical ingredients and formulae, from discrete to continuum descriptions, motivated by plausibility arguments. In particular, we argue why states are now described by complex square integrable functions (called wave functions) and observables by Hermitian differential operators. We then move on to show how to quantize quantum systems with classical analogues, which comprise the bulk of real life physical systems. Here, we explicitly show how the most nontrivial component of the quantization, i.e., the description of the representation of the momentum operator (in position space) can be deduced from both, the de Broglie hypothesis, and the canonical commutation relation. The “particle in a box” problem is treated as an illustration. The parity operator, Ehrenfest's theorem and continuity conditions have been relegated to the problem section.