Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Heisenberg's Principle of Uncertainty

Hans Werner Arnold

Published Sep 16, 2024• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Heisenberg's Principle of Uncertainty may defy our intuition as we see no obvious reason why we can not exactly measure the momentary position and speed of an object like a racing car. If any difficulty exists to determine both exactly, we may attribute this difficulty to our own inability to measure both exactly. An example may be the Hubble Constant H0, which relates the recession speed v of cosmic objects, such as galaxies, to their distance x from us by Hubble's Law v=H0*x. In this case, the speed of v can be easily determined fairly exactly, but not of x. Heisenberg's Principle states that such inability is a fundamental law of Physics, not of our own inability to measure.Although this law may not very well concur with our intuition, it is possible to illustrate and even simulate it with a simple geometrical model. This paper presents such a model and explains its geometrical, dynamic and mathematical properties as those stated by Heisenberg's Principle of Uncertainty. It also shows that its physical reality is observable in some every day processes.It is the sole purpose of this model to illustrate Heisenberg's Principle of Uncertainty. It should enhance the understanding of this principle.

DOI
10.31219/osf.io/nm289

Related papers

An uncertain world!

Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

Abstract One of the foundational principles of quantum mechanics is Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation. According to this relation, no one can measure both the position of a particle and how fast it is moving simultaneously no matter how precise the measuring instruments. Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation and the associated Bohr’s principle of complementarity are explained using simple examples. The idea that measurement disturbs the system is a source of the uncertainty. The philosophical question whether the uncertainty represents only our inability to measure the properties precisely or it has much deeper consequences related to the question of reality is also discussed.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

Anti Heisenberg—Refutation Of Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Relation

Ilija Barukčić, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Gregg S. Jaeger +2 more

The quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum plays an important role in many treatments on the (philosophical, physical and other) implications of quantum mechanics. Roughly speaking, the more precisely the momentum (position) of a (quantum mechanical) object is given, the less precisely can one say what its position (momentum) is. This quantum mechanical measurement problem is not just an interpretational difficulty, it raises broader issues as well. The measurement (of a property) of a (quantum mechanical) object determines the existence of the measured. In brief, the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle challenges some fundamental principles of Science and especially the principle of causality. In particular, an independently existing (external) objective reality is denied. As we shall see, that the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum is based on the assumption that 1⩽0, which is a logical contradiction.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Anti Heisenberg—Refutation Of Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Relation

Ilija Barukčić

The quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum plays an important role in many treatments on the (philosophical, physical and other) implications of quantum mechanics. Roughly speaking, the more precisely the momentum (position) of a (quantum mechanical) object is given, the less precisely can one say what its position (momentum) is. This quantum mechanical measurement problem is not just an interpretational difficulty, it raises broader issues as well. The measurement (of a property) of a (quantum mechanical) object determines the existence of the measured. In brief, the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle challenges some fundamental principles of Science and especially the principle of causality. In particular, an independently existing (external) objective reality is denied. As we shall see, that the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum is based on the assumption that 1⩽0, which is a logical contradiction.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•31 citations

Geschwindigkeits- und Abstand- Abschätzung nach dem Prinzip der Heisenbergschen Unbestimmtheits- Relation.

Georg Gati

Did you know that every road user—anyone who steps out onto the street—employs an analogue to the Nobel Prize-winning Heisenberg uncertainty principle when estimating speed and distance? Estimating speed and distance is an integral part of our lives, and this process occurs within us subconsciously, following the logic of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. While this claim may come as a surprise, we shall soon see that the estimation of speed and distance can, in fact, be modeled precisely using this very principle. The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is a fundamental concept in quantum physics, stating that two complementary properties—specifically the position and momentum of a particle—cannot both be determined with arbitrary precision simultaneously. The world-famous equation is expressed as follows: Δx * Δp = h constant (h where the constant is related to the Planck constant). This implies that it is fundamentally impossible to measure both the position and the momentum of a particle with infinite precision at the same time. Since momentum (p) depends on velocity—defined as p = m * v (mass multiplied by velocity)—these characteristic uncertainties are just significant in everyday life in fact, our very lives depend on our ability to estimate these factors accurately! Furthermore: Every single person on Earth encounters this phenomenon the moment they step out onto the street! So, what are the underlying principles that govern how we estimate distance and speed? This immediately raises the question: what method do we use to estimate distance and speed? We can state in advance that, when estimating speed at greater distances, we have only one option: perceiving the change in the parallax angle.

•Nov 7, 2026•0 citations

The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

Kok Choy LOH

The Heisenberg equation may not be as well-known as Einstein’s e=mc^2. But the Heisenberg equation’s implications that there is an irreducible uncertainty with regard to the position of an object are no less intriguing than the implications of Einstein’s relativity equation that time slows to a stop when the relative velocity of an object approaches the speed of light. Using elementary mathematics and science, this paper begins by examining the physics of motion of an everyday object such as a tennis ball. The paper shows that the same physics that applies to everyday objects in fact also applies when it comes to subatomic particles, such as an electron in motion. And by taking gradual incremental steps in developing the mathematics of the underlying physics, the paper leads to the conclusion that the universe is inherently uncertain, that it is impossible to know the exact position of any object.

•Sep 29, 2023•0 citations

The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

Kok Choy LOH

The Heisenberg equation may not be as well-known as Einstein’s e=mc^2. But the Heisenberg equation’s implications that there is an irreducible uncertainty with regard to the position of an object are no less intriguing than the implications of Einstein’s relativity equation that time slows to a stop when the relative velocity of an object approaches the speed of light. Using elementary mathematics and science, this paper begins by examining the physics of motion of an everyday object such as a tennis ball. The paper shows that the same physics that applies to everyday objects in fact also applies when it comes to subatomic particles, such as an electron in motion. And by taking gradual incremental steps in developing the mathematics of the underlying physics, the paper leads to the conclusion that the universe is inherently uncertain, that it is impossible to know the exact position of any object.

•Oct 16, 2023•1 citation
Heisenberg's Principle of Uncertainty may defy our intuition as we see no obvious reason why we can not exactly measure the momentary position and speed of an object like a racing car. If any difficulty exists to determine both exactly, we may attribute this difficulty to our own inability to measure both exactly. An example may be the Hubble Constant H0, which relates the recession speed v of cosmic objects, such as galaxies, to their distance x from us by Hubble's Law v=H0*x. In this case, the speed of v can be easily determined fairly exactly, but not of x. Heisenberg's Principle states that such inability is a fundamental law of Physics, not of our own inability to measure.Although this law may not very well concur with our intuition, it is possible to illustrate and even simulate it with a simple geometrical model. This paper presents such a model and explains its geometrical, dynamic and mathematical properties as those stated by Heisenberg's Principle of Uncertainty. It also shows that its physical reality is observable in some every day processes.It is the sole purpose of this model to illustrate Heisenberg's Principle of Uncertainty. It should enhance the understanding of this principle.
Abstract One of the foundational principles of quantum mechanics is Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation. According to this relation, no one can measure both the position of a particle and how fast it is moving simultaneously no matter how precise the measuring instruments. Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation and the associated Bohr’s principle of complementarity are explained using simple examples. The idea that measurement disturbs the system is a source of the uncertainty. The philosophical question whether the uncertainty represents only our inability to measure the properties precisely or it has much deeper consequences related to the question of reality is also discussed.
The quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum plays an important role in many treatments on the (philosophical, physical and other) implications of quantum mechanics. Roughly speaking, the more precisely the momentum (position) of a (quantum mechanical) object is given, the less precisely can one say what its position (momentum) is. This quantum mechanical measurement problem is not just an interpretational difficulty, it raises broader issues as well. The measurement (of a property) of a (quantum mechanical) object determines the existence of the measured. In brief, the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle challenges some fundamental principles of Science and especially the principle of causality. In particular, an independently existing (external) objective reality is denied. As we shall see, that the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum is based on the assumption that 1⩽0, which is a logical contradiction.
The quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum plays an important role in many treatments on the (philosophical, physical and other) implications of quantum mechanics. Roughly speaking, the more precisely the momentum (position) of a (quantum mechanical) object is given, the less precisely can one say what its position (momentum) is. This quantum mechanical measurement problem is not just an interpretational difficulty, it raises broader issues as well. The measurement (of a property) of a (quantum mechanical) object determines the existence of the measured. In brief, the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle challenges some fundamental principles of Science and especially the principle of causality. In particular, an independently existing (external) objective reality is denied. As we shall see, that the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum is based on the assumption that 1⩽0, which is a logical contradiction.
Did you know that every road user—anyone who steps out onto the street—employs an analogue to the Nobel Prize-winning Heisenberg uncertainty principle when estimating speed and distance? Estimating speed and distance is an integral part of our lives, and this process occurs within us subconsciously, following the logic of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. While this claim may come as a surprise, we shall soon see that the estimation of speed and distance can, in fact, be modeled precisely using this very principle. The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is a fundamental concept in quantum physics, stating that two complementary properties—specifically the position and momentum of a particle—cannot both be determined with arbitrary precision simultaneously. The world-famous equation is expressed as follows: Δx * Δp = h constant (h where the constant is related to the Planck constant). This implies that it is fundamentally impossible to measure both the position and the momentum of a particle with infinite precision at the same time. Since momentum (p) depends on velocity—defined as p = m * v (mass multiplied by velocity)—these characteristic uncertainties are just significant in everyday life in fact, our very lives depend on our ability to estimate these factors accurately! Furthermore: Every single person on Earth encounters this phenomenon the moment they step out onto the street! So, what are the underlying principles that govern how we estimate distance and speed? This immediately raises the question: what method do we use to estimate distance and speed? We can state in advance that, when estimating speed at greater distances, we have only one option: perceiving the change in the parallax angle.
The Heisenberg equation may not be as well-known as Einstein’s e=mc^2. But the Heisenberg equation’s implications that there is an irreducible uncertainty with regard to the position of an object are no less intriguing than the implications of Einstein’s relativity equation that time slows to a stop when the relative velocity of an object approaches the speed of light. Using elementary mathematics and science, this paper begins by examining the physics of motion of an everyday object such as a tennis ball. The paper shows that the same physics that applies to everyday objects in fact also applies when it comes to subatomic particles, such as an electron in motion. And by taking gradual incremental steps in developing the mathematics of the underlying physics, the paper leads to the conclusion that the universe is inherently uncertain, that it is impossible to know the exact position of any object.
The Heisenberg equation may not be as well-known as Einstein’s e=mc^2. But the Heisenberg equation’s implications that there is an irreducible uncertainty with regard to the position of an object are no less intriguing than the implications of Einstein’s relativity equation that time slows to a stop when the relative velocity of an object approaches the speed of light. Using elementary mathematics and science, this paper begins by examining the physics of motion of an everyday object such as a tennis ball. The paper shows that the same physics that applies to everyday objects in fact also applies when it comes to subatomic particles, such as an electron in motion. And by taking gradual incremental steps in developing the mathematics of the underlying physics, the paper leads to the conclusion that the universe is inherently uncertain, that it is impossible to know the exact position of any object.