Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum 2.0 Conference and Exhibition

Bell State Statistics with Post-Selection Loophole

S. Andrew Lanham, Brian R. La Cour

Published Jan 1, 2024• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We demonstrate a classical post-selection-induced violation of a Bell-type inequality using the setup of Q. Zhang et al., Phys. Rev. A 77, 062316 (2008). The results demonstrate how post-selection alone can cause Bell inequality violations.
DOI
10.1364/quantum.2024.qtu3a.2

Related papers

Violating Bell’s Inequality with Single-Photon Entangled States using Self-Referential Measurements

Daniel Kun, Teodor Strömberg, Borivoje Dakić +2 more

We violate a CHSH inequality using two copies of single-photon entangled states, simultaneously verifying their entangled nature without the need for post-selection or local oscillators.

Quantum 2.0 Conference and Exhibition•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Bell's Theorem refuted with a Kolmogorovian counterexample

Johannes F. Geurdes

The statistics behind Bell's inequality is demonstrated to allow a Kolmogorovian (i.e. classical) model of probabilities that recovers the quantum covariance.

arXiv:0705.3378•May 23, 2007•3 citations

Computational Perspectives on Bell Inequalities and Many-body Quantum Correlations

Matty J. Hoban

The predictions of quantum mechanics cannot be resolved with a completely classical view of the world. In particular, the statistics of space-like separated \nmeasurements on entangled quantum systems violate a Bell inequality [Bell1964]. \nWe put forward a computational perspective on a broad class of Bell tests that study correlators, or the statistics of joint measurement outcomes. We associate \nparticular maps, or functions to particular theories. The violation of a Bell \ninequality then implies the ability to perform some functions, or computations \nthat classical, or more generally, local hidden variable (LHV) theories cannot. \nWe derive an in�finite class of Bell inequalities that establish a link to so-called "non-local games" [Cleve2004]. We then make the connection between \nRaussendorf and Briegel's formulation of Measurement-based Quantum Computing (MBQC) [Raussendorf2001], and these non-local games. Not only can we show that a quantum violation implies a computational advantage in this model, \nwe show that adaptive measurements are required to perform all quantum computations. \nFinally, we explore post-selection of data in Bell tests from both a practical and \nconceptual point-of-view, with particular consideration to so-called "loopholes". \nLoopholes allow LHV theories to simulate quantum correlations through post-selection. \nWe give a computational description of how loopholes can emerge in diff�erent post-selection scenarios. This motivates us to �find a form of post-selection \nthat does not lead to loopholes. Central again to this discussion is the \ndescription of LHV theories in terms of computations. \nInterestingly, quantum correlators can be made more "non-classical" with this \nloophole-free post-selection. This method of post-selection also can simulate \ninformation processing tasks, such as MBQC, that have time-like separated components. \nThis opens up new avenues for the study of time-like tasks studied \nwithin the space-like separated scenario of the Bell test.

•Apr 26, 2012•0 citations

Experimental post-selection loophole-free time-bin and energy-time nonlocality with integrated photonics

Francesco B. L. Santagiustina, Costantino Agnesi, Alvaro Alarcón +4 more

Time-bin (TB) and energy-time (ET) entanglements are crucial resources for long-distance quantum information processing. However, their standard implementations suffer from the so-called post-selection loophole that allows for classical simulation and thus prevents quantum advantage. The post-selection loophole has been addressed in proof-of-principle experiments. An open problem though is to close it in real-life applications based on integrated technologies. This is especially important since, so far, all integrated sources of TB and ET entanglements suffer from the post-selection loophole. Here, we report post-selection loophole-free certification of TB or ET entanglement in integrated technologies, by implementing in a silicon nitride chip the “hug” scheme [ Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 , 040401 ( 2009 ) PRLTAO 0031-9007 10.1103/PhysRevLett.102.040401 ] and certifying genuine TB entanglement through the violation of a Bell inequality.

arXiv:2302.06522•Optica•Feb 5, 2024•23 citations

Bell Inequality Violations Without Entanglement? It's Just Postselection

K. B. Wharton, Huw Price

Recently Wang et al. have reported a violation of a Bell inequality without entanglement [arXiv:2507.07756]. We show that their result is an artifact of postselection. It is well known that postselection may yield Bell inequality violations, both in classical toy models and in real experiments with delayed-choice entanglement-swapping. Here we describe a classical analog of Wang et al.'s experiment, and show that it produces essentially the same results as their quantum version. We explain in detail why neither version is a challenge to Local Causality or local realism: the postselection entails a rejection of Bell's assumption of Statistical Independence.

arXiv:2508.13431•Aug 19, 2025•6 citations

Peculiar features of entangled states with postselection

Yakir Aharonov, SHMUEL NUSSINOV, Sandu Popescu +1 more

We consider quantum systems in entangled states post-selected in non-entangled states. Such systems exhibit unusual behavior, in particular when weak measurements are performed at intermediate times.

arXiv:1301.6154•Physical Review A•Jan 28, 2013•13 citations
The predictions of quantum mechanics cannot be resolved with a completely classical view of the world. In particular, the statistics of space-like separated \nmeasurements on entangled quantum systems violate a Bell inequality [Bell1964]. \nWe put forward a computational perspective on a broad class of Bell tests that study correlators, or the statistics of joint measurement outcomes. We associate \nparticular maps, or functions to particular theories. The violation of a Bell \ninequality then implies the ability to perform some functions, or computations \nthat classical, or more generally, local hidden variable (LHV) theories cannot. \nWe derive an in�finite class of Bell inequalities that establish a link to so-called "non-local games" [Cleve2004]. We then make the connection between \nRaussendorf and Briegel's formulation of Measurement-based Quantum Computing (MBQC) [Raussendorf2001], and these non-local games. Not only can we show that a quantum violation implies a computational advantage in this model, \nwe show that adaptive measurements are required to perform all quantum computations. \nFinally, we explore post-selection of data in Bell tests from both a practical and \nconceptual point-of-view, with particular consideration to so-called "loopholes". \nLoopholes allow LHV theories to simulate quantum correlations through post-selection. \nWe give a computational description of how loopholes can emerge in diff�erent post-selection scenarios. This motivates us to �find a form of post-selection \nthat does not lead to loopholes. Central again to this discussion is the \ndescription of LHV theories in terms of computations. \nInterestingly, quantum correlators can be made more "non-classical" with this \nloophole-free post-selection. This method of post-selection also can simulate \ninformation processing tasks, such as MBQC, that have time-like separated components. \nThis opens up new avenues for the study of time-like tasks studied \nwithin the space-like separated scenario of the Bell test.
Time-bin (TB) and energy-time (ET) entanglements are crucial resources for long-distance quantum information processing. However, their standard implementations suffer from the so-called post-selection loophole that allows for classical simulation and thus prevents quantum advantage. The post-selection loophole has been addressed in proof-of-principle experiments. An open problem though is to close it in real-life applications based on integrated technologies. This is especially important since, so far, all integrated sources of TB and ET entanglements suffer from the post-selection loophole. Here, we report post-selection loophole-free certification of TB or ET entanglement in integrated technologies, by implementing in a silicon nitride chip the “hug” scheme [ Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 , 040401 ( 2009 ) PRLTAO 0031-9007 10.1103/PhysRevLett.102.040401 ] and certifying genuine TB entanglement through the violation of a Bell inequality.
Recently Wang et al. have reported a violation of a Bell inequality without entanglement [arXiv:2507.07756]. We show that their result is an artifact of postselection. It is well known that postselection may yield Bell inequality violations, both in classical toy models and in real experiments with delayed-choice entanglement-swapping. Here we describe a classical analog of Wang et al.'s experiment, and show that it produces essentially the same results as their quantum version. We explain in detail why neither version is a challenge to Local Causality or local realism: the postselection entails a rejection of Bell's assumption of Statistical Independence.