Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A

Computerized simulation of 2-dimensional phase contrast images using spiral phase plates in neutron interferometry

W. Treimer, Frank Haußer, Martin Suda

Published Aug 17, 2024• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract We present calculations of interferograms (interference patterns) of one or multiple spiral phase plates that would be observed with a perfect crystal neutron interferometer of Mach–Zehnder type. A spiral phase plate (SPP) in one of the two coherent beam paths produces a twist in the phase front and thus a vortex beam with intrinsic angular momentum, which in the case of neutrons should be observed as a characteristic interference pattern that appears complementary to each other in both detectors behind the interferometer. Adding additional SPPs in one beam path of the interferometer yield interference patterns similar to that of a single SPP but only due to the cumulative step height. All simulated interferograms have been calculated on the basis of dynamical neutron diffraction without any assumption of a neutron orbital angular momentum and show very convincing agreement with experimental results from the literature, see e.g. (C. W. Clark, R. Barankov, M. G. Huber, M. Arif, D. G. Cory, and D. A. Pushin, “Controlling neutron orbital angular momentum,” Nature, vol. 525, pp. 504–506, 2015). In particular, this clarifies, that the cited experiments do not give evidence of the quantization of interactions caused by a twist of the phase front of a neutron wave in the interferometer and thus no evidence for the effect of a neutron orbital angular momentum.

DOI
10.1515/zna-2024-0142

Related papers

On the neutron orbital angular momentum: Has it actually been demonstrated?

W. Treimer, Frank Haußer, Suda, Martin

In a Nature LETTER [1], a control of neutron angular momentum was apparently demonstrated using a neutron crystal interferometer. In the meantime, a number of highly interesting articles have been published dealing with the n-OAM and neutron interferometry, citing [1]. We show that the interpretation of [1] having detected a n-OAM is incorrect for several serious reasons and point out inconsistencies. Based only on the theory of dynamical neutron diffraction, we calculate all the interferograms and show perfect agreement with those given in [1]. There was no need to assume an additional n-OAM because no additional effect was observed that could not be explained by standard theory.

arXiv:2309.03594•Sep 7, 2023•1 citation

Intrinsic Orbital Angular Momentum States of Neutrons

R. L. Cappelletti, Terrence Jach, John Vinson

It has been shown that single-particle wave functions, of both photons and electrons, can be created with a phase vortex, i.e., an intrinsic orbital angular momentum (OAM). A recent experiment has claimed similar success using neutrons [C. W. Clark et al., Nature, 525, 504 (2015)NATUAS0028-083610.1038/nature15265]. We show that their results are insufficient to unambiguously demonstrate OAM, and they can be fully explained as phase contrast interference patterns. Furthermore, given the small transverse coherence length of the neutrons in the original experiment, the probability that any neutron was placed in an OAM state is vanishingly small. We highlight the importance of the relative size of the coherence length, which presents a unique challenge for neutron experiments compared to electron or photon work, and we suggest improvements for the creation of neutron OAM states.

Physical Review Letters•Mar 2, 2018•35 citations

The Effects of Dynamical Diffraction on the Measurement of Gravitationally Induced Quantum Phase Shifts by Neutron Interferometry

Kenneth C. Littrell, Brendan E. Allman, Olexei I. Motrunich +1 more

The proper analysis of experiments to measure the quantum-mechanical phase shift due to potential gradients such as gravity across a perfect-silicon-crystal Mach–Zehnder interferometer for neutrons is complicated by the highly dispersive nature of the dynamical diffraction process describing the propagation of neutrons through a perfect crystal. Through dynamical diffraction, a coherent monochromatic incident beam of neutrons that does not exactly satisfy the Bragg condition is split into two currents within each crystal so that there are 16 possible coherent interfering trajectories by which the neutron can traverse the interferometer. In this work, previous calculations of the effects of dynamical diffraction on gravitationally induced phase-shift measurements are extended to include effects in all exit beams and internal effects within the subbeams for both symmetric and skew-symmetric interferometers. For the interferometers used in a recent experiment in which the gravitationally induced phase shift of the neutron is measured with a statistical uncertainty of the order of 1 part in 1000, it is found that these effects predict an increase of a few percent in the magnitude of the phase shift. Additionally, some consequences on the phase and contrast of restricting the beams within and after the interferometer are discussed. Agreement of this theory with experiment and the general applicability of the model is discussed.

Acta Crystallographica Section A Foundations of Crystallography•Sep 1, 1998•12 citations

Neutron interferometers and apparatus

Helmut Rauch, Samuel A. Werner

Abstract Among the various areas of neutron optical research, neutron interferometry has provided some of the most challenging and spectacular developments. In most cases, separated coherent beams are used which are produced either by wavefront division (Young’s type) or by amplitude division (Mach− Zehnder type). These beams are subsequently coherently superposed after passing through regions of space where the neutron wavefunction is modified in phase and amplitude by various interactions: nuclear, magnetic, electromagnetic, gravitational, or by geometry and topology (as in Aharonov−Bohm-type experiments). Various types of neutron interferometers that have been tested are shown in Fig. 2.1. The first neutron interferometer was based upon wavefront division and biprism deflection, but it had several constraints for interferometric applications mainly due to the small beam separation (100 μm) (Maier-Leibnitz and Springer 1962). Nevertheless, this method gained further interest for diffraction experiments from macroscopic objects and for the detection of weak interaction effects where the long flight paths (10 m) enhance the sensitivity for the measurements of these effects (Gähler et al. 1980; Klein et al. 1981a). The perfect-crystal interferometer (Rauch et al. 1974) provides widely separated coherent beams and has become a standard method for advanced neutron optical investigations. The development of diffraction and phase grating interferometers extended the Mach-Zehnder interferometer method to very slow neutrons (loffe et al. 1985; Gruber et al. 1989). The superposition of spin-up and spin-down states in the longitudinal direction provides the basis for Larmor and Ramsey interferometry, where no lateral beam splitting is necessary. The well-known spin-echo systems (Mezei 1972) and zero-field spin-echo systems (Gähler and Golub 1987; Dubbers et al. 1989) are examples of such interferometers, which also play an important role in atom interferometry (Bord é 1989; Kasevich and Chu 1991; Riehle et al. 1991).

Oxford University Press eBooks•Aug 10, 2000•0 citations

Quantum Measurements in Neutron Interferometry

H. Rauch

The perfect crystal neutron interferometer has been used continuously for test measurements on quantum mechanics. Semitransparent and chopper type beam attenuators were inserted into the coherent beams to observe the influence of stochastic and deterministic absorption on the interference pattern. Polarized neutrons were used to perform the quantum mechanical spin-superposition experiment on a macroscopic scale. These experiments were continued with two resonance coils in the beams, in which the coherence persisted, even if an energy exchange occurred with certainty between the neutron and the resonator system. A quantum beat effect was observed when slightly different resonance frequencies were applied to both beams. In this case, an extremely high energy sensitivity of 2.7 × 10 -l9 eV was achieved. Neutron spectroscopy is thus able to cover time domains from microscopic to macroscopic scales. Phase echo systems, experiments with chopped beams and multiplate interferometry are discussed as examples of forthcoming experiments. All the results obtained until now are in agreement with the formalism of quantum mechanics and stimulate discussion about the interpretation of this basic theory.

Advanced series in applied physics•Jan 1, 1997•3 citations

Low-contrast and low-counting-rate measurements in neutron interferometry

H. Rauch, Johann Summhammer, Michael Zawisky +1 more

Here we discuss the limits of the recognizability of neutron interference patterns either observed in low-contrast measurements or when collecting very few neutrons only. Low contrast can be caused by a strong beam attenuation or by a large phase shift applied to one beam path. Stochastic and deterministic cases have different influences on the interference pattern, which can be interpreted as a different wavelike or particlelike behavior of the system. Measurements of interference patterns with very few neutrons only are related to the phase--particle-number uncertainty relation, which is discussed on the basis of stochastic and quantum theory arguments. Analogies between coherent-state behavior known in atomic physics and the behavior of neutrons in an interferometer are discussed also.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1990•68 citations
Abstract We present calculations of interferograms (interference patterns) of one or multiple spiral phase plates that would be observed with a perfect crystal neutron interferometer of Mach–Zehnder type. A spiral phase plate (SPP) in one of the two coherent beam paths produces a twist in the phase front and thus a vortex beam with intrinsic angular momentum, which in the case of neutrons should be observed as a characteristic interference pattern that appears complementary to each other in both detectors behind the interferometer. Adding additional SPPs in one beam path of the interferometer yield interference patterns similar to that of a single SPP but only due to the cumulative step height. All simulated interferograms have been calculated on the basis of dynamical neutron diffraction without any assumption of a neutron orbital angular momentum and show very convincing agreement with experimental results from the literature, see e.g. (C. W. Clark, R. Barankov, M. G. Huber, M. Arif, D. G. Cory, and D. A. Pushin, “Controlling neutron orbital angular momentum,” Nature, vol. 525, pp. 504–506, 2015). In particular, this clarifies, that the cited experiments do not give evidence of the quantization of interactions caused by a twist of the phase front of a neutron wave in the interferometer and thus no evidence for the effect of a neutron orbital angular momentum.
In a Nature LETTER [1], a control of neutron angular momentum was apparently demonstrated using a neutron crystal interferometer. In the meantime, a number of highly interesting articles have been published dealing with the n-OAM and neutron interferometry, citing [1]. We show that the interpretation of [1] having detected a n-OAM is incorrect for several serious reasons and point out inconsistencies. Based only on the theory of dynamical neutron diffraction, we calculate all the interferograms and show perfect agreement with those given in [1]. There was no need to assume an additional n-OAM because no additional effect was observed that could not be explained by standard theory.
It has been shown that single-particle wave functions, of both photons and electrons, can be created with a phase vortex, i.e., an intrinsic orbital angular momentum (OAM). A recent experiment has claimed similar success using neutrons [C. W. Clark et al., Nature, 525, 504 (2015)NATUAS0028-083610.1038/nature15265]. We show that their results are insufficient to unambiguously demonstrate OAM, and they can be fully explained as phase contrast interference patterns. Furthermore, given the small transverse coherence length of the neutrons in the original experiment, the probability that any neutron was placed in an OAM state is vanishingly small. We highlight the importance of the relative size of the coherence length, which presents a unique challenge for neutron experiments compared to electron or photon work, and we suggest improvements for the creation of neutron OAM states.
The proper analysis of experiments to measure the quantum-mechanical phase shift due to potential gradients such as gravity across a perfect-silicon-crystal Mach–Zehnder interferometer for neutrons is complicated by the highly dispersive nature of the dynamical diffraction process describing the propagation of neutrons through a perfect crystal. Through dynamical diffraction, a coherent monochromatic incident beam of neutrons that does not exactly satisfy the Bragg condition is split into two currents within each crystal so that there are 16 possible coherent interfering trajectories by which the neutron can traverse the interferometer. In this work, previous calculations of the effects of dynamical diffraction on gravitationally induced phase-shift measurements are extended to include effects in all exit beams and internal effects within the subbeams for both symmetric and skew-symmetric interferometers. For the interferometers used in a recent experiment in which the gravitationally induced phase shift of the neutron is measured with a statistical uncertainty of the order of 1 part in 1000, it is found that these effects predict an increase of a few percent in the magnitude of the phase shift. Additionally, some consequences on the phase and contrast of restricting the beams within and after the interferometer are discussed. Agreement of this theory with experiment and the general applicability of the model is discussed.
Abstract Among the various areas of neutron optical research, neutron interferometry has provided some of the most challenging and spectacular developments. In most cases, separated coherent beams are used which are produced either by wavefront division (Young’s type) or by amplitude division (Mach− Zehnder type). These beams are subsequently coherently superposed after passing through regions of space where the neutron wavefunction is modified in phase and amplitude by various interactions: nuclear, magnetic, electromagnetic, gravitational, or by geometry and topology (as in Aharonov−Bohm-type experiments). Various types of neutron interferometers that have been tested are shown in Fig. 2.1. The first neutron interferometer was based upon wavefront division and biprism deflection, but it had several constraints for interferometric applications mainly due to the small beam separation (100 μm) (Maier-Leibnitz and Springer 1962). Nevertheless, this method gained further interest for diffraction experiments from macroscopic objects and for the detection of weak interaction effects where the long flight paths (10 m) enhance the sensitivity for the measurements of these effects (Gähler et al. 1980; Klein et al. 1981a). The perfect-crystal interferometer (Rauch et al. 1974) provides widely separated coherent beams and has become a standard method for advanced neutron optical investigations. The development of diffraction and phase grating interferometers extended the Mach-Zehnder interferometer method to very slow neutrons (loffe et al. 1985; Gruber et al. 1989). The superposition of spin-up and spin-down states in the longitudinal direction provides the basis for Larmor and Ramsey interferometry, where no lateral beam splitting is necessary. The well-known spin-echo systems (Mezei 1972) and zero-field spin-echo systems (Gähler and Golub 1987; Dubbers et al. 1989) are examples of such interferometers, which also play an important role in atom interferometry (Bord é 1989; Kasevich and Chu 1991; Riehle et al. 1991).
The perfect crystal neutron interferometer has been used continuously for test measurements on quantum mechanics. Semitransparent and chopper type beam attenuators were inserted into the coherent beams to observe the influence of stochastic and deterministic absorption on the interference pattern. Polarized neutrons were used to perform the quantum mechanical spin-superposition experiment on a macroscopic scale. These experiments were continued with two resonance coils in the beams, in which the coherence persisted, even if an energy exchange occurred with certainty between the neutron and the resonator system. A quantum beat effect was observed when slightly different resonance frequencies were applied to both beams. In this case, an extremely high energy sensitivity of 2.7 × 10 -l9 eV was achieved. Neutron spectroscopy is thus able to cover time domains from microscopic to macroscopic scales. Phase echo systems, experiments with chopped beams and multiplate interferometry are discussed as examples of forthcoming experiments. All the results obtained until now are in agreement with the formalism of quantum mechanics and stimulate discussion about the interpretation of this basic theory.
Here we discuss the limits of the recognizability of neutron interference patterns either observed in low-contrast measurements or when collecting very few neutrons only. Low contrast can be caused by a strong beam attenuation or by a large phase shift applied to one beam path. Stochastic and deterministic cases have different influences on the interference pattern, which can be interpreted as a different wavelike or particlelike behavior of the system. Measurements of interference patterns with very few neutrons only are related to the phase--particle-number uncertainty relation, which is discussed on the basis of stochastic and quantum theory arguments. Analogies between coherent-state behavior known in atomic physics and the behavior of neutrons in an interferometer are discussed also.