Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Modern Physics

Surprising New Bohr Models for H 2 and H 2 +

Auguste Meessen

Published Jan 1, 2024• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Niels Bohr constructed the first version of quantum mechanics. It has been called “old quantum mechanics” with a connotation of being obsolete. It is logically consistent, however, and deserves the name of simple quantum mechanics (SQM). It differs only from the semiclassical approximation by assuming that the average position and average velocity of an electron can be sharply defined on closed orbits. This assumption does not contradict Heisenberg’s uncertainty relations, since the quantization rule means that the electron can be anywhere on this orbit when it allows for stationary waves. This approach was remarkably efficient for one electron in hydrogen atoms and even for the electron pair in hydrogen molecules. However, dissociation of H2 and determination of the orbit of the single electron in H 2 + led to problems that remained unsolved for more than 100 years. Their solution, presented here, yields more physical insight and reveals, for instance, that mutual polarization of two hydrogen atoms can yield a metastable state.

DOI
10.4236/jmp.2024.158053

Related papers

Niels Bohr’s First 1913 Paper: Still Relevant, Still Exciting, Still Puzzling

Kenneth W. Ford

Many teachers like to introduce the Bohr atom toward the end of an introductory physics course. This is an excellent idea, given the historic importance of Bohr’s 1913 work, which provided the bridge from Planck’s quantized interaction of matter and radiation (1900) to the full theory of quantum mechanics (1925-28). Unfortunately, the version of the Bohr atom that appears in many textbooks and is no doubt often presented to students is more wrong than right and may leave both teachers and students wondering why, more than a hundred years later, it is still being taught. This “pedagogic” version postulates that an electron in a stationary state moves in a circular orbit with an angular momentum that is an integral multiple of h/2π (L = nh/2π = nħ)—ħ for the lowest-energy state, 2ħ for the next state, and so on. This picture of the hydrogen atom is wrong in two senses. First it doesn’t conform to our present understanding of the hydrogen atom. This, in itself, is not a reason to scrap it, for the historical development of quantum physics is certainly of interest. But second, it doesn’t conform to the essence of what Bohr actually did. That is a reason not to teach about circular orbits and L = nħ.

The Physics Teacher•Oct 19, 2018•9 citations

Bohr’s molecular model and the melding of classical and quantum mechanics

Petar Grujić

Anatoly Svidzinsky, Marlan Scully, and Dudley Herschbach have illustrated well how the molecular theory might have looked had quantum mechanics not been invented. It’s worth noting that Niels Bohr was not alone in his attempts to extend semiclassical mechanics to systems more complex than the hydrogen atom. From 1913 to 1925, many semiclassical models of two-electron systems were proposed.As we see from the authors’ figure 3a, Bohr assumed that electrons in hydrogen molecules move around the molecular axis out of phase. It is a remarkable fact that Werner Heisenberg put forward in 1922 a two-electron atomic model that had electrons moving similarly out of phase and that ascribed a fractional quantum number (½) to the bending mode of the configuration.11. G. Tanner, K. Richter, J.-M. Rost, Rev. Mod. Phys. 72, 497 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.72.497 Although Heisenberg’s model predicted the ground-state helium level, which was in excellent agreement with the spectroscopic data, Bohr opposed the model, since a noninteger quantum number was considered sacrilege. For the same reason, Bohr never published his own results. However, the asynchronous two-electron atomic model turned out to be the fertile one, though the corresponding classical configurations can have very complex structure.22. P. Grujic, N. Simonovic, J. Phys. B 28, 1159 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1088/0953-4075/28/7/011REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. G. Tanner, K. Richter, J.-M. Rost, Rev. Mod. Phys. 72, 497 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.72.497, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. P. Grujic, N. Simonovic, J. Phys. B 28, 1159 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1088/0953-4075/28/7/011, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2014 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Aug 1, 2014•1 citation

Rise and premature fall of the old quantum theory

Manfred Bucher

The old quantum theory of Bohr and Sommerfeld was abandonned for the wrong reason. Its contradictions were caused not by the orbit concept but by a mental barrier—the inconceivability that an electron might collide with the atomic nucleus. Removing that barrier resolves the theory’s main failures—incorrect orbital momenta, He atom, H + 2 molecule ion. The inclusion of electron oscillations through the nucleus—a concept called “Coulomb oscillator”—renders the old quantum theory consistent with quantum mechanics (although devoid of wave character). The triple success of the Bohr-Sommerfeld model is its correct description of the H atom (and one-electron ions) concerning (1) the energy levels Enl, (2) the orbital angular momenta Lnl—if corrected as L 2 = l(l + 1)~ 2 and with the Coulomb oscillator included—and (3) the orbits’ space quantization—with (Lnl)z = ml~. These achievements are succinctly represented by the principal, angular and magnetic quantum numbers (n, l, ml) and visualized by orbital ellipse geometry—major axis, vertex curvature, and tilt angle, respectively. Orbit geometry also accounts for the average orbit size. Moreover, the Coulomb oscillator provides a natural explanation of (isotropic) hyperfine interaction. The shortcomings of the old quantum theory lie in its neglect of three properties of particles—their spin, their wave nature and their quantum statistics. These deficiencies notwithstanding, the visual appeal of the Bohr-Sommerfeld model remains a pedagogical asset to complement the abstract character of quantum mechanics.

•Jan 1, 2008•7 citations

The Hydrogen-Like Atom

Uri Peskin

The mere existence of stable atoms, and their arrangement into many-atom nanoscale structures, can only be explained by the laws of quantum mechanics. Indeed, the accumulated evidence regarding the internal structure of atoms motivated the formulation of quantum mechanics at the early twentieth century. Here we focus on single-electron (hydrogen-like) atoms. The dominance of the Coulomb central potential between the electron and nucleus, translates into a simple Schrödinger equation for their relative position distribution. Solving rigorously this equation reveals quantized energy levels, which explains the emission spectra of hydrogen-like atoms (Rydberg formula). The corresponding stationary probability density distributions for the electron around the nucleus are reminiscent of the Bohr model, where classical trajectories (orbits) are replaced by single-electron wave functions (orbitals). The degeneracies of different orbitals, associated with three quantum numbers, will later turn out to be critical for understanding many-electron atoms and the periodic table of the elements.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 11, 2023•0 citations

Time-independent quantum mechanics

ROBERT K. NESBET

In 1926, Schrödinger [365] recognized that the variational theory of elliptical differential equations with fixed boundary conditions could produce a discrete eigenvalue spectrum in agreement with the energy levels of Bohr's model of the hydrogen atom. This conceptually startling amalgam of classical ideas of particle and field turned out to be correct. Within a few years, the new wave mechanics almost completely replaced the ad hoc quantization of classical mechanics that characterized the “old” quantum theory initiated by Bohr. Although the matrix mechanics of Heisenberg was soon shown to be logically equivalent, the variational wave theory became the standard basis of methodology in the physics of electrons.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 14, 2002•0 citations

Rise and fall of the old quantum theory

Manfred Bucher

The old quantum theory of Bohr and Sommerfeld was abandonned for the wrong reason. Its contradictions were caused not by the orbit concept but by a mental barrier--the inconceivability that an electron might collide with the atomic nucleus. Removing that barrier resolves the theory's main failures--incorrect orbital momenta, He atom, H2+ molecule ion. The inclusion of electron oscillations through the nucleus--a concept called "Coulomb oscillator"--renders the old quantum theory consistent with quantum mechanics (although devoid of wave character). The triple success of the Bohr-Sommerfeld model is its correct description of the H atom (and one-electron ions) concerning (1) the energy levels Enl, (2) the orbital angular momenta Lnl--if corrected as Lnl^2 = l(l+1) hbar^2 and with the Coulomb oscillator included--and (3) the orbits' space quantization--with (Lnl)z = ml hbar. These achievements are succinctly represented by the principal, angular and magnetic quantum numbers (n, l, ml) and visualized by orbital ellipse geometry--major axis, vertex curvature, and tilt angle, respectively. Orbit geometry also accounts for the average orbit size. Moreover, the Coulomb oscillator provides a natural explanation of (isotropic) hyperfine interaction. The shortcomings of the old quantum theory lie in its neglect of three properties of particles--their spin, their wave nature and their quantum statistics. These deficiencies notwithstanding, the visual appeal of the Bohr-Sommerfeld model remains a pedagogical asset to complement the abstract character of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:0802.1366•Feb 11, 2008•14 citations
Niels Bohr constructed the first version of quantum mechanics. It has been called “old quantum mechanics” with a connotation of being obsolete. It is logically consistent, however, and deserves the name of simple quantum mechanics (SQM). It differs only from the semiclassical approximation by assuming that the average position and average velocity of an electron can be sharply defined on closed orbits. This assumption does not contradict Heisenberg’s uncertainty relations, since the quantization rule means that the electron can be anywhere on this orbit when it allows for stationary waves. This approach was remarkably efficient for one electron in hydrogen atoms and even for the electron pair in hydrogen molecules. However, dissociation of H2 and determination of the orbit of the single electron in H 2 + led to problems that remained unsolved for more than 100 years. Their solution, presented here, yields more physical insight and reveals, for instance, that mutual polarization of two hydrogen atoms can yield a metastable state.
Many teachers like to introduce the Bohr atom toward the end of an introductory physics course. This is an excellent idea, given the historic importance of Bohr’s 1913 work, which provided the bridge from Planck’s quantized interaction of matter and radiation (1900) to the full theory of quantum mechanics (1925-28). Unfortunately, the version of the Bohr atom that appears in many textbooks and is no doubt often presented to students is more wrong than right and may leave both teachers and students wondering why, more than a hundred years later, it is still being taught. This “pedagogic” version postulates that an electron in a stationary state moves in a circular orbit with an angular momentum that is an integral multiple of h/2π (L = nh/2π = nħ)—ħ for the lowest-energy state, 2ħ for the next state, and so on. This picture of the hydrogen atom is wrong in two senses. First it doesn’t conform to our present understanding of the hydrogen atom. This, in itself, is not a reason to scrap it, for the historical development of quantum physics is certainly of interest. But second, it doesn’t conform to the essence of what Bohr actually did. That is a reason not to teach about circular orbits and L = nħ.
Anatoly Svidzinsky, Marlan Scully, and Dudley Herschbach have illustrated well how the molecular theory might have looked had quantum mechanics not been invented. It’s worth noting that Niels Bohr was not alone in his attempts to extend semiclassical mechanics to systems more complex than the hydrogen atom. From 1913 to 1925, many semiclassical models of two-electron systems were proposed.As we see from the authors’ figure 3a, Bohr assumed that electrons in hydrogen molecules move around the molecular axis out of phase. It is a remarkable fact that Werner Heisenberg put forward in 1922 a two-electron atomic model that had electrons moving similarly out of phase and that ascribed a fractional quantum number (½) to the bending mode of the configuration.11. G. Tanner, K. Richter, J.-M. Rost, Rev. Mod. Phys. 72, 497 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.72.497 Although Heisenberg’s model predicted the ground-state helium level, which was in excellent agreement with the spectroscopic data, Bohr opposed the model, since a noninteger quantum number was considered sacrilege. For the same reason, Bohr never published his own results. However, the asynchronous two-electron atomic model turned out to be the fertile one, though the corresponding classical configurations can have very complex structure.22. P. Grujic, N. Simonovic, J. Phys. B 28, 1159 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1088/0953-4075/28/7/011REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. G. Tanner, K. Richter, J.-M. Rost, Rev. Mod. Phys. 72, 497 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.72.497, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. P. Grujic, N. Simonovic, J. Phys. B 28, 1159 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1088/0953-4075/28/7/011, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2014 American Institute of Physics.
The old quantum theory of Bohr and Sommerfeld was abandonned for the wrong reason. Its contradictions were caused not by the orbit concept but by a mental barrier—the inconceivability that an electron might collide with the atomic nucleus. Removing that barrier resolves the theory’s main failures—incorrect orbital momenta, He atom, H + 2 molecule ion. The inclusion of electron oscillations through the nucleus—a concept called “Coulomb oscillator”—renders the old quantum theory consistent with quantum mechanics (although devoid of wave character). The triple success of the Bohr-Sommerfeld model is its correct description of the H atom (and one-electron ions) concerning (1) the energy levels Enl, (2) the orbital angular momenta Lnl—if corrected as L 2 = l(l + 1)~ 2 and with the Coulomb oscillator included—and (3) the orbits’ space quantization—with (Lnl)z = ml~. These achievements are succinctly represented by the principal, angular and magnetic quantum numbers (n, l, ml) and visualized by orbital ellipse geometry—major axis, vertex curvature, and tilt angle, respectively. Orbit geometry also accounts for the average orbit size. Moreover, the Coulomb oscillator provides a natural explanation of (isotropic) hyperfine interaction. The shortcomings of the old quantum theory lie in its neglect of three properties of particles—their spin, their wave nature and their quantum statistics. These deficiencies notwithstanding, the visual appeal of the Bohr-Sommerfeld model remains a pedagogical asset to complement the abstract character of quantum mechanics.
The mere existence of stable atoms, and their arrangement into many-atom nanoscale structures, can only be explained by the laws of quantum mechanics. Indeed, the accumulated evidence regarding the internal structure of atoms motivated the formulation of quantum mechanics at the early twentieth century. Here we focus on single-electron (hydrogen-like) atoms. The dominance of the Coulomb central potential between the electron and nucleus, translates into a simple Schrödinger equation for their relative position distribution. Solving rigorously this equation reveals quantized energy levels, which explains the emission spectra of hydrogen-like atoms (Rydberg formula). The corresponding stationary probability density distributions for the electron around the nucleus are reminiscent of the Bohr model, where classical trajectories (orbits) are replaced by single-electron wave functions (orbitals). The degeneracies of different orbitals, associated with three quantum numbers, will later turn out to be critical for understanding many-electron atoms and the periodic table of the elements.
In 1926, Schrödinger [365] recognized that the variational theory of elliptical differential equations with fixed boundary conditions could produce a discrete eigenvalue spectrum in agreement with the energy levels of Bohr's model of the hydrogen atom. This conceptually startling amalgam of classical ideas of particle and field turned out to be correct. Within a few years, the new wave mechanics almost completely replaced the ad hoc quantization of classical mechanics that characterized the “old” quantum theory initiated by Bohr. Although the matrix mechanics of Heisenberg was soon shown to be logically equivalent, the variational wave theory became the standard basis of methodology in the physics of electrons.
The old quantum theory of Bohr and Sommerfeld was abandonned for the wrong reason. Its contradictions were caused not by the orbit concept but by a mental barrier--the inconceivability that an electron might collide with the atomic nucleus. Removing that barrier resolves the theory's main failures--incorrect orbital momenta, He atom, H2+ molecule ion. The inclusion of electron oscillations through the nucleus--a concept called "Coulomb oscillator"--renders the old quantum theory consistent with quantum mechanics (although devoid of wave character). The triple success of the Bohr-Sommerfeld model is its correct description of the H atom (and one-electron ions) concerning (1) the energy levels Enl, (2) the orbital angular momenta Lnl--if corrected as Lnl^2 = l(l+1) hbar^2 and with the Coulomb oscillator included--and (3) the orbits' space quantization--with (Lnl)z = ml hbar. These achievements are succinctly represented by the principal, angular and magnetic quantum numbers (n, l, ml) and visualized by orbital ellipse geometry--major axis, vertex curvature, and tilt angle, respectively. Orbit geometry also accounts for the average orbit size. Moreover, the Coulomb oscillator provides a natural explanation of (isotropic) hyperfine interaction. The shortcomings of the old quantum theory lie in its neglect of three properties of particles--their spin, their wave nature and their quantum statistics. These deficiencies notwithstanding, the visual appeal of the Bohr-Sommerfeld model remains a pedagogical asset to complement the abstract character of quantum mechanics.