Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entropy

Elementary Observations: Building Blocks of Physical Information Gain

Gerhard Müller

Published Jul 23, 2024• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper, we are concerned with the process of experimental information gain. Building on previous work, we show that this is a discontinuous process in which the initiating quantum-mechanical matter-instrument interactions are being turned into macroscopically observable events (EOs). In the course of time, such EOs evolve into spatio-temporal patterns of EOs, which allow conceivable alternatives of physical explanation to be distinguished. Focusing on the specific case of photon detection, we show that during their lifetimes, EOs proceed through the four phases of initiation, detection, erasure and reset. Once generated, the observational value of EOs can be measured in units of the Planck quantum of physical action h=4.136×10-15eVs. Once terminated, each unit of entropy of size kB=8.617×10-5eV/K, which had been created in the instrument during the observational phase, needs to be removed from the instrument to ready it for a new round of photon detection. This withdrawal of entropy takes place at an energetic cost of at least two units of the Landauer minimum energy bound of ELa=ln⁡2kBTD for each unit of entropy of size kB.

DOI
10.3390/e26080619

Related papers

Events as Elements of Physical Observation: Experimental Evidence

Gerhard Müller

It is argued that all physical knowledge ultimately stems from observation and that the simplest possible observation is that an event has happened at a certain space-time location X→=x→,t. Considering historic experiments, which have been groundbreaking in the evolution of our modern ideas of matter on the atomic, nuclear, and elementary particle scales, it is shown that such experiments produce as outputs streams of macroscopically observable events which accumulate in the course of time into spatio-temporal patterns of events whose forms allow decisions to be taken concerning conceivable alternatives of explanation. Working towards elucidating the physical and informational characteristics of those elementary observations, we show that these represent hugely amplified images of the initiating micro-events and that the resulting macro-images have a cognitive value of 1 bit and a physical value of Wobs=Eobsτobs≫h. In this latter equation, Eobs stands for the energy spent in turning the initiating micro-events into macroscopically observable events, τobs for the lifetimes during which the generated events remain macroscopically observable, and h for Planck's constant. The relative value Gobs=Wobs/h finally represents a measure of amplification that was gained in the observation process.

Entropy•Mar 13, 2024•8 citations

Photon Detection as a Process of Information Gain

Gerhard Müller

Making use of the equivalence between information and entropy, we have shown in a recent paper that particles moving with a kinetic energy ε carry potential information i p o t ( ε , T ) = 1 ln ( 2 ) ε k B T relative to a heat reservoir of temperature T . In this paper we build on this result and consider in more detail the process of information gain in photon detection. Considering photons of energy E p h and a photo-ionization detector operated at a temperature T D , we evaluate the signal-to-noise ratio S N ( E p h , T D ) for different detector designs and detector operation conditions and show that the information gain realized upon detection, i r e a l ( E p h , T D ) , always remains smaller than the potential information i p o t ( E p h , T D ) carried with the photons themselves, i.e.,: i r e a l ( E p h , T D ) = 1 ln ( 2 ) ln ( S N ( E p h , T D ) ) ≤ i p o t ( E p h , T D ) = 1 ln ( 2 ) E p h k B T D . This result is shown to be generally valid for all kinds of technical photon detectors, which shows that i p o t ( E p h , T D ) can indeed be regarded as an intrinsic information content that is carried with the photons themselves. Overall, our results suggest that photon detectors perform as thermodynamic engines that incompletely convert potential information into realized information with an efficiency that is limited by the second law of thermodynamics and the Landauer energy bounds on information gain and information erasure.

Entropy•Mar 30, 2020•11 citations

The Wave–Particle Dualism of Photons as Seen from an Informational Point of View

Gerhard Müller

This paper deals with J. A. Wheeler’s proposal that each piece of reality owes its existence to observation—an approach to physics, which implies that all physical entities at their bottom are informational in character. Focusing on the double-slit experiment with photons, which is the key evidence for the wave–particle dualism of photons, this paper follows Wheeler’s observational approach and interprets this experiment as a question posed to nature. Considering how the enquiry regarding the wave–particle duality of photons is answered by nature, it is shown that experimental questions are being answered by nature in the form of spatiotemporal patterns of elementary observations (EOs) which are binary pieces of information, produced by the dissipation of energy. Working through this line of thought, Wheeler’s statements of “binary information gain”, “observer participance” and the “impossibility of continuum idealizations of physical laws” are elucidated and connections to the Landauer Principle are made.

Entropy•Oct 3, 2025•1 citation

Information Without a Bit: A Process–Event Ontology of Quantum Theory and the Limits of Realization

Jadran Damjanović

This work develops a process–event ontological framework for quantum theory, with particular emphasis on information, collapse, and the energetic cost of realization. The central claim is that quantum mechanics formally describes physical processes—coherent, continuous, and reversible in principle—while information, records, and outcomes arise only at the level of events, through irreversible physical realization. Within this framework, collapse is redefined not as a dynamical anomaly, but as the physical realization of a process into an event. Information is not treated as a primary entity or carrier, but as a stabilized physical imprint of events, necessarily involving energy dissipation. The framework reinterprets Landauer’s principle as a cost of record stabilization rather than bit erasure, clarifies the ontological status of qubits as energetically maintained process states, and resolves standard measurement paradoxes without modifying the formalism of quantum mechanics. This work operates at a meta-level: it does not propose new dynamics or interpretations, but explicitly delineates the boundary between quantum processes and realized events.

•Jan 10, 2026•0 citations

The Fundamental Equation: Energy as the Physical Manifestation of Distinction-Making

Thomas E. Claiborne

Every physical process, measurement, or information exchange requires distinguishing between different states. We propose that this distinction-making constitutes the fundamental activity un- derlying all physical phenomena, with energy representing the quantitative measure of distinction- making processes manifesting in spacetime. From information-theoretic variational principles, we derive the relationship E = κD connecting energy to distinction magnitude D, where κ exhibits scale-dependent manifestations interpolating between Landauer’s principle (κthermal = kB T ln 2) and Planck-scale limits (κP = ℏc/lp). This framework provides a process ontology resolving longstand- ing puzzles: the measurement problem in quantum mechanics, the physical efficacy of information, and the hard problem of consciousness. We propose experimental protocols testing the linear rela- tionship across quantum, biological, and neural systems, with specific predictions for consciousness emergence at exactly three levels of recursive distinction-making depth.

•Jun 9, 2025•0 citations

The entropic cost of quantum generalized measurements

Luca Mancino, Marco Sbroscia, Emanuele Roccia +5 more

Abstract Landauer’s principle introduces a symmetry between computational and physical processes: erasure of information, a logically irreversible operation, must be underlain by an irreversible transformation dissipating energy. Monitoring micro- and nano-systems needs to enter into the energetic balance of their control; hence, finding the ultimate limits is instrumental to the development of future thermal machines operating at the quantum level. We report on the experimental investigation of a lower bound to the irreversible entropy associated to generalized quantum measurements on a quantum bit. We adopted a quantum photonics gate to implement a device interpolating from the weakly disturbing to the fully invasive and maximally informative regime. Our experiment prompted us to introduce a bound taking into account both the classical result of the measurement and the outcoming quantum state; unlike previous investigation, our entropic bound is based uniquely on measurable quantities. Our results highlight what insights the information-theoretic approach provides on building blocks of quantum information processors.

arXiv:1702.07164•npj Quantum Information•Mar 7, 2018•26 citations
In this paper, we are concerned with the process of experimental information gain. Building on previous work, we show that this is a discontinuous process in which the initiating quantum-mechanical matter-instrument interactions are being turned into macroscopically observable events (EOs). In the course of time, such EOs evolve into spatio-temporal patterns of EOs, which allow conceivable alternatives of physical explanation to be distinguished. Focusing on the specific case of photon detection, we show that during their lifetimes, EOs proceed through the four phases of initiation, detection, erasure and reset. Once generated, the observational value of EOs can be measured in units of the Planck quantum of physical action h=4.136×10-15eVs. Once terminated, each unit of entropy of size kB=8.617×10-5eV/K, which had been created in the instrument during the observational phase, needs to be removed from the instrument to ready it for a new round of photon detection. This withdrawal of entropy takes place at an energetic cost of at least two units of the Landauer minimum energy bound of ELa=ln⁡2kBTD for each unit of entropy of size kB.
It is argued that all physical knowledge ultimately stems from observation and that the simplest possible observation is that an event has happened at a certain space-time location X→=x→,t. Considering historic experiments, which have been groundbreaking in the evolution of our modern ideas of matter on the atomic, nuclear, and elementary particle scales, it is shown that such experiments produce as outputs streams of macroscopically observable events which accumulate in the course of time into spatio-temporal patterns of events whose forms allow decisions to be taken concerning conceivable alternatives of explanation. Working towards elucidating the physical and informational characteristics of those elementary observations, we show that these represent hugely amplified images of the initiating micro-events and that the resulting macro-images have a cognitive value of 1 bit and a physical value of Wobs=Eobsτobs≫h. In this latter equation, Eobs stands for the energy spent in turning the initiating micro-events into macroscopically observable events, τobs for the lifetimes during which the generated events remain macroscopically observable, and h for Planck's constant. The relative value Gobs=Wobs/h finally represents a measure of amplification that was gained in the observation process.
Making use of the equivalence between information and entropy, we have shown in a recent paper that particles moving with a kinetic energy ε carry potential information i p o t ( ε , T ) = 1 ln ( 2 ) ε k B T relative to a heat reservoir of temperature T . In this paper we build on this result and consider in more detail the process of information gain in photon detection. Considering photons of energy E p h and a photo-ionization detector operated at a temperature T D , we evaluate the signal-to-noise ratio S N ( E p h , T D ) for different detector designs and detector operation conditions and show that the information gain realized upon detection, i r e a l ( E p h , T D ) , always remains smaller than the potential information i p o t ( E p h , T D ) carried with the photons themselves, i.e.,: i r e a l ( E p h , T D ) = 1 ln ( 2 ) ln ( S N ( E p h , T D ) ) ≤ i p o t ( E p h , T D ) = 1 ln ( 2 ) E p h k B T D . This result is shown to be generally valid for all kinds of technical photon detectors, which shows that i p o t ( E p h , T D ) can indeed be regarded as an intrinsic information content that is carried with the photons themselves. Overall, our results suggest that photon detectors perform as thermodynamic engines that incompletely convert potential information into realized information with an efficiency that is limited by the second law of thermodynamics and the Landauer energy bounds on information gain and information erasure.
This paper deals with J. A. Wheeler’s proposal that each piece of reality owes its existence to observation—an approach to physics, which implies that all physical entities at their bottom are informational in character. Focusing on the double-slit experiment with photons, which is the key evidence for the wave–particle dualism of photons, this paper follows Wheeler’s observational approach and interprets this experiment as a question posed to nature. Considering how the enquiry regarding the wave–particle duality of photons is answered by nature, it is shown that experimental questions are being answered by nature in the form of spatiotemporal patterns of elementary observations (EOs) which are binary pieces of information, produced by the dissipation of energy. Working through this line of thought, Wheeler’s statements of “binary information gain”, “observer participance” and the “impossibility of continuum idealizations of physical laws” are elucidated and connections to the Landauer Principle are made.
This work develops a process–event ontological framework for quantum theory, with particular emphasis on information, collapse, and the energetic cost of realization. The central claim is that quantum mechanics formally describes physical processes—coherent, continuous, and reversible in principle—while information, records, and outcomes arise only at the level of events, through irreversible physical realization. Within this framework, collapse is redefined not as a dynamical anomaly, but as the physical realization of a process into an event. Information is not treated as a primary entity or carrier, but as a stabilized physical imprint of events, necessarily involving energy dissipation. The framework reinterprets Landauer’s principle as a cost of record stabilization rather than bit erasure, clarifies the ontological status of qubits as energetically maintained process states, and resolves standard measurement paradoxes without modifying the formalism of quantum mechanics. This work operates at a meta-level: it does not propose new dynamics or interpretations, but explicitly delineates the boundary between quantum processes and realized events.
Every physical process, measurement, or information exchange requires distinguishing between different states. We propose that this distinction-making constitutes the fundamental activity un- derlying all physical phenomena, with energy representing the quantitative measure of distinction- making processes manifesting in spacetime. From information-theoretic variational principles, we derive the relationship E = κD connecting energy to distinction magnitude D, where κ exhibits scale-dependent manifestations interpolating between Landauer’s principle (κthermal = kB T ln 2) and Planck-scale limits (κP = ℏc/lp). This framework provides a process ontology resolving longstand- ing puzzles: the measurement problem in quantum mechanics, the physical efficacy of information, and the hard problem of consciousness. We propose experimental protocols testing the linear rela- tionship across quantum, biological, and neural systems, with specific predictions for consciousness emergence at exactly three levels of recursive distinction-making depth.
Abstract Landauer’s principle introduces a symmetry between computational and physical processes: erasure of information, a logically irreversible operation, must be underlain by an irreversible transformation dissipating energy. Monitoring micro- and nano-systems needs to enter into the energetic balance of their control; hence, finding the ultimate limits is instrumental to the development of future thermal machines operating at the quantum level. We report on the experimental investigation of a lower bound to the irreversible entropy associated to generalized quantum measurements on a quantum bit. We adopted a quantum photonics gate to implement a device interpolating from the weakly disturbing to the fully invasive and maximally informative regime. Our experiment prompted us to introduce a bound taking into account both the classical result of the measurement and the outcoming quantum state; unlike previous investigation, our entropic bound is based uniquely on measurable quantities. Our results highlight what insights the information-theoretic approach provides on building blocks of quantum information processors.