Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Philosophies

The Hidden Clash: Spacetime Outlook and Quantum-State Reductions

Rafael Andrés Alemañ Berenguer

Published May 30, 2024• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is generally assumed that compatibility with special relativity is guaranteed by the invariance of the fundamental equations of quantum physics under Lorentz transformations and the impossibility of transferring energy or information faster than the speed of light. Despite this, various contradictions persist, which make us suspect the solidity of that compatibility. This paper focuses on collapse theories—although they are not the only way of interpreting quantum theory—in order to examine what seems to be insurmountable difficulties we encounter when trying to construct a space–time picture of such typically quantum processes as state vector reduction or the non-separability of entangled systems. The inescapable nature of such difficulties suggests the need to go further in the search for new formulations that surpass our current conceptions of matter and space–time.

DOI
10.3390/philosophies9030079

Related papers

Simplifying the equations of relativistic quantum mechanics

Luis Grave de Peralta

I n the early 20th century, the groundbreaking theories of quantum mechanics and special relativity emerged at roughly the same time.At first, both theories appeared to be entirely incompatible with each other.While the quantum equations written out by Erwin Schrödinger and Wolfgang Pauli dealt with the behaviours of electrons, atoms, and molecules moving at speeds encountered in classical physics, the rules of special relativity first imagined by Albert Einstein described the behaviour of matter moving at close to the speed of light.Initially, this apparent clash of theories presented a crisis in physics.However, in the late 1920s, further theoretical work carried out by physicists including Paul Dirac, Oskar Klein, and Walter Gordon culminated in a new set of equations, which proved definitively that quantum mechanics and special relativity are compatible with each other after all. An educational challengeYet with this groundbreaking discovery came an entirely new problem.In adding a new layer of complexity to the equations of non-relativistic quantum mechanics, the more complete theories of relativistic

Research Features•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

Lorentz Transformation in Quantum Mechanics

Marcello Baldo

The compatibility of special relativity and Quantum Mechanics has been questioned by several authors. The origin of this tension can be traced back mainly to the introduction of the measurement processes and the corresponding wave function reduction, which play a crucial role in Quantum Mechanics. We approach this problem with the help of a recent proposal for a model of Quantum Mechanics, where the measurement is explicitly described as a specific stochastic process. This implements ordinary Quantum Mechanics, where measurement and reduction are treated as phenomenological events of unknown origin without any physical justification. To state clearly the question in general, we first discuss and establish the effect of a Lorentz transformation on a generic wave function in space-time. Alongside the analysis we formulate the relativistic version of the model. We then consider few thought experiments in order to analyze to what extent Quantum Mechanics follows relativistic invariance and find the specific critical points where non invariance possibly occurs. The analysis can shade light to the interpretation of the existing experimental observations.

quant-pharXiv:2511.11342•Nov 17, 2025•1 citation

Quantum Mechanics versus Special Relativity: A forgotten conflict

Rafael Andrés Alemañ Berenguer

Despite the widespread assumptions on the compatibility between non-relativistic quantum mechanics and special relativity, there still remains a considerable amount of unresolved problems to which few authors explicitly pay attention. Most of them involve the aim of coherently achieving a relativistic description of quantum collapses and quantum entanglements. These processes seem to challenge our present picture of the physical world in terms of space-time structures.

•Nov 1, 2008•1 citation

Collapse Spacetime Model: Foundations and Postulates

Chretien Versteegh

General relativity and quantum mechanics rely on fundamentally incompatible conceptions of spacetime: the former treats spacetime as a smooth, dynamical entity, while the latter presupposes a fixed background on which quantum states evolve. This work introduces the Collapse Spacetime Model (CSM), a foundational framework in which spacetime itself is not fundamental but emerges from discrete ontological transition events (OTEs)—objective, irreversible acts of actualization that generate localized spacetime structure. Within CSM, quantum state reduction is reinterpreted as one particular manifestation of a more general ontological transition, rather than as an anomaly within unitary dynamics. A central refinement, the Multiplicity of Spacetime Hypothesis (MSH), proposes that physical systems construct their own partial spacetimes, with the classical spacetime continuum arising from stable intersections among these locally generated structures. Constants such as the speed of light are interpreted as invariant structural ratios of spacetime co-generation, rather than as fundamental properties of matter or signals. The model aligns conceptually with causal set theory, emergent network geometry, and collapse-based approaches, while offering a unified ontological account of spacetime emergence, time’s passage, and the relational origin of geometry. CSM reframes physical reality as a becoming universe, providing a coherent foundation for quantum gravity, cosmology, and the philosophy of time, while deliberately postponing detailed dynamical and mathematical formalization to future work.

•Jul 5, 2025•0 citations

The Observer Omission in Einstein’s Rail-Car Experiment

Wolfgang Baer

Einstein special relativity theory provides an ontological interpretation of the Lorentz transformations and Maxwell’s Eqs. that predicts the physical retardation of clock rates and shrinkage of measuring rods. A logical explanation for these effects is demonstrated by comparing the measurements of common phenomena made by an observer in moving train versus those obtained by a stationary observer at rest on the embankment. Though the mathematical treatment properly accounts for observations made by coordinate systems built upon the constant speed of light assumption, I will show that these coordinate frames analysis cannot be transferred to actual physical situations without encountering contradictions with the original experiment assumptions. The ontological view of physical reality implied by these assumptions, which underlying special relativity and much of conventional physics, is therefore in question. By eliminating these assumptions an alternative interpretation of experimental evidence is provided. Specifically, the careful construction of clock rates, rod lengths, and time offsets required to explain the constant speed of light reported by all observers is not necessary if the speed of light is observer dependent. I will argue that light propagates in the space attached to the material from which observer’s are built. The speed of light in this material is a property of the gravitational potential the material is subject to. The space supplied by the material of each observer is more accurately described as possessing a constant speed-of-now, which determines the rate of activity of all processes the observer carries out. This ontological interpretation of special relativity is compatible with quantum theory since it treats observables, including the observation of empty space, as the internal observer dependent phenomena resulting from measurements rather than a ubiquitous a priori container in which all things happen.

•Dec 28, 2017•0 citations

Can quantum theory and special relativity peacefully coexist?

M. P. Seevinck

This white paper aims to identify an open problem in 'Quantum Physics and the Nature of Reality' --namely whether quantum theory and special relativity are formally compatible--, to indicate what the underlying issues are, and put forward ideas about how the problem might be addressed.

arXiv:1010.3714•Oct 18, 2010•21 citations
It is generally assumed that compatibility with special relativity is guaranteed by the invariance of the fundamental equations of quantum physics under Lorentz transformations and the impossibility of transferring energy or information faster than the speed of light. Despite this, various contradictions persist, which make us suspect the solidity of that compatibility. This paper focuses on collapse theories—although they are not the only way of interpreting quantum theory—in order to examine what seems to be insurmountable difficulties we encounter when trying to construct a space–time picture of such typically quantum processes as state vector reduction or the non-separability of entangled systems. The inescapable nature of such difficulties suggests the need to go further in the search for new formulations that surpass our current conceptions of matter and space–time.
I n the early 20th century, the groundbreaking theories of quantum mechanics and special relativity emerged at roughly the same time.At first, both theories appeared to be entirely incompatible with each other.While the quantum equations written out by Erwin Schrödinger and Wolfgang Pauli dealt with the behaviours of electrons, atoms, and molecules moving at speeds encountered in classical physics, the rules of special relativity first imagined by Albert Einstein described the behaviour of matter moving at close to the speed of light.Initially, this apparent clash of theories presented a crisis in physics.However, in the late 1920s, further theoretical work carried out by physicists including Paul Dirac, Oskar Klein, and Walter Gordon culminated in a new set of equations, which proved definitively that quantum mechanics and special relativity are compatible with each other after all. An educational challengeYet with this groundbreaking discovery came an entirely new problem.In adding a new layer of complexity to the equations of non-relativistic quantum mechanics, the more complete theories of relativistic
The compatibility of special relativity and Quantum Mechanics has been questioned by several authors. The origin of this tension can be traced back mainly to the introduction of the measurement processes and the corresponding wave function reduction, which play a crucial role in Quantum Mechanics. We approach this problem with the help of a recent proposal for a model of Quantum Mechanics, where the measurement is explicitly described as a specific stochastic process. This implements ordinary Quantum Mechanics, where measurement and reduction are treated as phenomenological events of unknown origin without any physical justification. To state clearly the question in general, we first discuss and establish the effect of a Lorentz transformation on a generic wave function in space-time. Alongside the analysis we formulate the relativistic version of the model. We then consider few thought experiments in order to analyze to what extent Quantum Mechanics follows relativistic invariance and find the specific critical points where non invariance possibly occurs. The analysis can shade light to the interpretation of the existing experimental observations.
General relativity and quantum mechanics rely on fundamentally incompatible conceptions of spacetime: the former treats spacetime as a smooth, dynamical entity, while the latter presupposes a fixed background on which quantum states evolve. This work introduces the Collapse Spacetime Model (CSM), a foundational framework in which spacetime itself is not fundamental but emerges from discrete ontological transition events (OTEs)—objective, irreversible acts of actualization that generate localized spacetime structure. Within CSM, quantum state reduction is reinterpreted as one particular manifestation of a more general ontological transition, rather than as an anomaly within unitary dynamics. A central refinement, the Multiplicity of Spacetime Hypothesis (MSH), proposes that physical systems construct their own partial spacetimes, with the classical spacetime continuum arising from stable intersections among these locally generated structures. Constants such as the speed of light are interpreted as invariant structural ratios of spacetime co-generation, rather than as fundamental properties of matter or signals. The model aligns conceptually with causal set theory, emergent network geometry, and collapse-based approaches, while offering a unified ontological account of spacetime emergence, time’s passage, and the relational origin of geometry. CSM reframes physical reality as a becoming universe, providing a coherent foundation for quantum gravity, cosmology, and the philosophy of time, while deliberately postponing detailed dynamical and mathematical formalization to future work.
Einstein special relativity theory provides an ontological interpretation of the Lorentz transformations and Maxwell’s Eqs. that predicts the physical retardation of clock rates and shrinkage of measuring rods. A logical explanation for these effects is demonstrated by comparing the measurements of common phenomena made by an observer in moving train versus those obtained by a stationary observer at rest on the embankment. Though the mathematical treatment properly accounts for observations made by coordinate systems built upon the constant speed of light assumption, I will show that these coordinate frames analysis cannot be transferred to actual physical situations without encountering contradictions with the original experiment assumptions. The ontological view of physical reality implied by these assumptions, which underlying special relativity and much of conventional physics, is therefore in question. By eliminating these assumptions an alternative interpretation of experimental evidence is provided. Specifically, the careful construction of clock rates, rod lengths, and time offsets required to explain the constant speed of light reported by all observers is not necessary if the speed of light is observer dependent. I will argue that light propagates in the space attached to the material from which observer’s are built. The speed of light in this material is a property of the gravitational potential the material is subject to. The space supplied by the material of each observer is more accurately described as possessing a constant speed-of-now, which determines the rate of activity of all processes the observer carries out. This ontological interpretation of special relativity is compatible with quantum theory since it treats observables, including the observation of empty space, as the internal observer dependent phenomena resulting from measurements rather than a ubiquitous a priori container in which all things happen.