This chapter introduces the general concept of symmetry in both classical and quantum physics. The part devoted to classical physics stresses the importance of conservation laws and the role of Noether’s theorem for their understanding. A fairly general discussion of Noether’s theorem is offered, including ambiguities in the definition of the Noether current, possible existence of generalized, tensor conservation laws, and the inverse of Noether’s theorem. The Hamiltonian formalism is then used to motivate the transition from classical to quantum physics, and the definition of symmetry in the latter. In anticipation of the discussion of spontaneous symmetry breaking in the following chapter, the text here emphasizes the difference between implementing symmetry in terms of transformations on the algebra of physical observables, and in terms of unitary mappings on the Hilbert space of states.
This chapter introduces the general concept of symmetry in both classical and quantum physics. The part devoted to classical physics stresses the importance of conservation laws and the role of Noether’s theorem for their understanding. A fairly general discussion of Noether’s theorem is offered, including ambiguities in the definition of the Noether current, possible existence of generalized, tensor conservation laws, and the inverse of Noether’s theorem. The Hamiltonian formalism is then used to motivate the transition from classical to quantum physics, and the definition of symmetry in the latter. In anticipation of the discussion of spontaneous symmetry breaking in the following chapter, the text here emphasizes the difference between implementing symmetry in terms of transformations on the algebra of physical observables, and in terms of unitary mappings on the Hilbert space of states.
The previously developed 'continuous temporal development and Noether's theorem' approach to the association of symmetries and conservations of the laws of nature, part of the foundation of any (classical or quantum) Lagrangian theory, is generalised significantly. Within this framework a strong result is obtained for the inverse Noether's theorem, associating symmetries with given conservations. A general symmetry-conservation formalism is proposed, into which both the previously developed 'linear temporal development and conserved eigenheit' approach, part of the foundation of any quantum theory and also applicable to certain classical ones, and the 'continuous temporal...' approach, as different as they are, fit nicely.
This chapter is concerned with a discussion of symmetries in quantum many-body systems. After a general introduction to symmetries, invariances and conservation laws (Sec. 2.1), we consider a number of standard symmetry transformations: geometric space transformations (e.g. parity or space rotation), time translation, Galilean transformation, time-reversal and U(1) transformation (Sec. 2.2). In Sec. 2.3, we briefly review Noether’s theorem in classical field theory and show how the invariance of a quantum system in a symmetry transformation implies a set of relations, known as Ward identities, which must be satisfied by the Green functions or the 1PI/2PI vertices.
Symmetries are defined in histories-based generalized quantum mechanics paying special attention to the class of history theories admitting quasitemporal structure (a generalization of the concept of `temporal sequences' of `events' using partial semigroups) and logic structure for `single time histories'. Symmetries are classified into orthochronous (those preserving the `temporal order' of `events') and non-orthochronous. A straightforward criterion for physical equivalence of histories is formulated in terms of orthochronous symmetries; this criterion covers various notions of physical equivalence considered by Gell-Mann and Hartle as special cases. In familiar situations, a reciprocal relationship between traditional symmetries (Wigner symmetries in quantum mechanics and Borel-measurable transformations of phase space in classical mechanics) and symmetries defined in this work is established. In a restricted class of theories, a definition of conservation law is given in the history language which agrees with the standard ones in familiar situations; in a smaller subclass of theories, a Noether type theorem (implying a connection between continuous symmetries of dynamics and conservation laws) is proved.
A symmetry transformation can be represented on the Hilbert space of physical states by an operator that is either linear and unitary, or anti-linear and anti-unitary. —Eugene P. Wigner A.1 Continuous, Dynamical, and Discrete Symmetries The role of symmetry in natural laws has been underscored by many, notably by Eugene P. Wigner [1]. Symmetry plays a huge role in our understanding of the laws of nature. Plato (427–327 BCE) recognized that the only regular solids, whose faces are polygons having identical faces meeting at identical solid angles, are the (i) tetrahedron, (ii) cube, (iii) octahedron, (iv) dodecahedron, and (v) icosahedron. Their symmetry properties are celebrated in Euler's theorem where V is the number of vertices, E the number of edges, and F the number of faces. In 1905, Einstein recognized the symmetry in Maxwell's laws of electrodynamics and formulated the special theory of relativity. This symmetry resulted from the mind-boggling invariance of the speed of light in all inertial frames of reference. It required for its account a non-Euclidean four-dimensional (flat) space–time continuum [Chapter 13 of Reference 2]. Maxwell's theory of electrodynamics engendered an unimaginable constancy of the speed of light in all inertial frames of reference, regardless of their mutual motion. Einstein harbored length-contraction and time-dilation to account for the invariance of the speed of light, which is a fundamental symmetry principle. About ten years later, Einstein interpreted gravity in terms of an equivalence principle , inspired yet again by symmetry. A few years later, in 1918, Emmy Noether established that each conservation law is in essence an equivalent expression of an underlying symmetry . Rudimentary introduction to some of these ideas is now found even in undergraduate texts, such as Reference [2]. In this chapter, we discuss the role of symmetry in atomic structure and dynamics. The hallmark of quantum theory is the recognition of employing operators to represent dynamical variables of classical mechanics. The simplest symmetry operation is translation through an infinitesimal displacement in homogeneous space.
This chapter examines the assumptions behind Noether’s theorem connecting symmetries and conservation laws, taking an algebraic approach to compare classical and quantum versions of this theorem. In both classical and quantum mechanics, observables are naturally elements of a Jordan algebra, while generators of one-parameter groups of transformations are naturally elements of a Lie algebra. Noether’s theorem holds whenever we can map observables to generators in such a way that each observable generates a one-parameter group that preserves itself. In ordinary complex quantum mechanics, this mapping is multiplication by the square root of ?1. In the more general framework of unital JB-algebras, Alfsen and Shultz call such a mapping a ‘dynamical correspondence’ and show its presence allows us to identify the unital JB-algebra with the self-adjoint part of a complex C*-algebra. However, to prove their result, they impose a second, more obscure, condition on the dynamical correspondence. This expresses a relation between quantum and statistical mechanics, closely connected to the principle that ‘inverse temperature is imaginary time’.
Symmetries are defined in histories-based theories paying special attention to the class of history theories admitting quasitemporal structure (a generalization of the concept of `temporal sequences' of `events' using partial semigroups) and logic structure for `single-time histories'. Symmetries are classified into orthochronous (those preserving the `temporal order' of `events') and nonorthochronous. A straightforward criterion for physical equivalence of histories is formulated in terms of orthochronous symmetries; this criterion covers various notions of physical equivalence of histories considered by Gell-Mann and Hartle as special cases. In familiar situations, a reciprocal relationship between traditional symmetries (Wigner symmetries in quantum mechanics and Borel-measurable transformations of phase space in classical mechanics) and symmetries defined in this work is established. In a restricted class of theories, a definition of conservation law is given in the history language which agrees with the standard ones in familiar situations; in a smaller subclass of theories, a Noether type theorem (implying a connection between continuous symmetries of dynamics and conservation laws) is proved. The formalism evolved is applied to histories (of particles, fields or more general objects) in general curved spacetimes. Sharpening the definition of symmetry so as to include a continuity requirement, it is shown that a symmetry in our formalism implies a conformal isometry of the spacetime metric.