Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Coshare Science

Quantum spin liquids and the phases of the cuprates

Subir Sachdev A

Published Jan 31, 2024• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Soon after the discovery of high temperature superconductivity in the cuprates, Anderson proposed a connection to quantum spin liquids. But observations since then have shown that the low temperature phase diagram is dominated by conventional states, with a competition between superconductivity and charge-ordered states which break translational symmetry. We employ the "pseudogap metal" phase, found at intermediate temperatures and low hole doping, as the parent to the phases found at lower temperatures. We argue that the pseudogap is associated with a spin liquid, and that a particular spin liquid has the needed confining instabilities to resolve a number of open puzzles on the cuprate phase diagram.

DOI
10.61109/cs.202401.127

Related papers

Lectures on insulating and conducting quantum spin liquids

Subir Sachdev A

Two of the iconic phases of the hole-doped cuprate materials are the intermediate temperature pseudogap metal and the lower temperature $d$-wave superconductor. Following the suggestion of P. W. Anderson, there were early theories of these phases as doped quantum spin liquids. However, these theories have had difficulties with two prominent observations: (i) angle-dependent magnetoresistance measurements (ADMR) in the pseudogap metal, including observation of the Yamaji effect, present convincing evidence of small hole pockets which can tunnel coherently between square lattice layers (Fang et al., Nature Physics 18, 558 (2022); Chan et al., Nature Physics 21, 1753 (2025)) and (ii) the velocities of the nodal Bogoliubov quasiparticles in the $d$-wave superconductor are highly anisotropic, with $v_F \gg v_Δ$ (Chiao et al., Phys. Rev. B 62, 3554 (2000)). These notes review how the fractionalized Fermi Liquid (FL*) state, which dopes quantum spin liquids with gauge-neutral electron-like quasiparticles, resolves both difficulties. Theories of insulating quantum spin liquids employing fractionalization of the electron spin into bosonic or fermionic partons are discussed. Doping the bosonic parton theory leads to a holon metal theory: while not appropriate for the cuprate pseudogap, this theory is argued to apply to ultracold atom experiments on the Lieb lattice. Doping the fermionic parton theory leads to a $d$-wave superconductor with nearly isotropic quasiparticle velocities. The construction of the FL* state in a single band Hubbard-type model is described using a quantum dimer model, followed by a more realistic description using the Ancilla Layer Model (ALM), which is then used to obtain the theory of the pseudogap and the $d$-wave superconductor. The ALM also leads to a wavefunction for the FL* state of the Hubbard model, which agrees with ultracold atom observations.

arXiv:2512.23962•Dec 30, 2025•7 citations

A model of d -wave superconductivity, antiferromagnetism, and charge order on the square lattice

Maine Christos, Zhu-Xi Luo, Henry Shackleton +3 more

We describe the confining instabilities of a proposed quantum spin liquid underlying the pseudogap metal state of the hole-doped cuprates. The spin liquid can be described by a SU(2) gauge theory of N f = 2 massless Dirac fermions carrying fundamental gauge charges—this is the low-energy theory of a mean-field state of fermionic spinons moving on the square lattice with π -flux per plaquette in the ℤ 2 center of SU(2). This theory has an emergent SO(5) f global symmetry and is presumed to confine at low energies to the Néel state. At nonzero doping (or smaller Hubbard repulsion U at half-filling), we argue that confinement occurs via the Higgs condensation of bosonic chargons carrying fundamental SU(2) gauge charges also moving in π ℤ 2 -flux. At half-filling, the low-energy theory of the Higgs sector has N b = 2 relativistic bosons with a possible emergent SO(5) b global symmetry describing rotations between a d -wave superconductor, period-2 charge stripes, and the time-reversal breaking “ d -density wave” state. We propose a conformal SU(2) gauge theory with N f = 2 fundamental fermions, N b = 2 fundamental bosons, and a SO(5) f ×SO(5) b global symmetry, which describes a deconfined quantum critical point between a confining state which breaks SO(5) f and a confining state which breaks SO(5) b . The pattern of symmetry breaking within both SO(5)s is determined by terms likely irrelevant at the critical point, which can be chosen to obtain a transition between Néel order and d -wave superconductivity. A similar theory applies at nonzero doping and large U , with longer-range couplings of the chargons leading to charge order with longer periods.

arXiv:2302.07885•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•May 16, 2023•40 citations

Quantum Confinement Transition and Cuprate Criticality

T. Senthil, Matthew P. A. Fisher

Theoretical attempts to explain the origin of high temperature superconductivity are challenged by the complexity of the normal state, which exhibits three regimes with increasing hole doping: a pseudo-gap regime when underdoped, strange power laws near optimal doping and more conventional metallic behavior when heavily overdoped. We suggest that the origin of this behavior is linked to a zero temperature quantum phase transition separating the overdoped Fermi liquid from a spin-charge separated underdoped phase. Central to our analysis is a new $Z_2$ gauge theory formulation, which supports topological vortex excitations - dubbed visons. The visons are gapped in the underdoped phase, splitting the electron's charge and Fermi statistics into two separate excitations. Superconductivity occurs when the resulting charge $e$ boson condenses. The visons are condensed in the overdoped phase, thereby confining the charge and statistics of the electron leading to a Fermi liquid phase. Right at the quantum confinement transition the visons are in a critical state, leading to power law behavior for both charge and spin.

arXiv:cond-mat/9912380•Dec 21, 1999•17 citations

From high temperature superconductivity to quantum spin liquid: progress in strong correlation physics

Patrick A. Lee

This review gives a rather general discussion of high temperature superconductors as an example of a strongly correlated material. The argument is made that in view of the many examples of unconventional superconductors discovered in the past twenty years, we should no longer be surprised that superconductivity emerges as a highly competitive ground state in systems where Coulomb repulsion plays a dominant role. The physics of the cuprates is discussed, emphasizing the unusual pseudogap phase in the underdoped region. It is argued that the resonating valence bond picture, as formulated using gauge theory with fermionic and bosonic matter fields, gives an adequate physical understanding, even though many details are beyond the powers of current calculational tools. The recent discovery of quantum oscillations in a high magnetic field is discussed in this context. Meanwhile, the problem of the quantum spin liquid (a spin system with antiferromagnetic coupling which refuses to order even at zero temperature) is a somewhat simpler version of the high T c problem where significant progress has been made recently. It is understood that the existence of matter fields can lead to deconfinement of the U (1) gauge theory in 2 + 1 dimensions, and novel new particles (called fractionalized particles), such as fermionic spinons which carry spin and no charge, and gapless gauge bosons can emerge to create a new critical state at low energies. We even have a couple of real materials where such a scenario may be realized experimentally. The paper ends with answers to questions such as: What limits T c if pairing is driven by an electronic energy scale? Why is the high T c problem hard? Why is there no consensus? And why is the high T c problem important?

arXiv:0708.2115•Reports on Progress in Physics•Dec 17, 2007•260 citations

A Critique of Two Metals

R. B. Laughlin

I argue that the conflict between the fermi-liquid and non-fermi-liquid metallic states viewed by Anderson as the central intellectual issue of cuprate superconductivity, and which motivates the recent criticism by Baskaran and Anderson [cond-mat/9706076] of the work of Zhang [cond-mat/9610140], is a fundamentally wrong concept. All experimental evidence points to adiabatic continuability of the strange metal into a conventional one, and thus to one metallic phase rather than two, and all attempts to account theoretically for the existence of a luttinger-liquid at zero temperature in spatial dimension greater than 1 have failed. I discuss the underlying reasons for this failure and then argue that the true higher-dimensional generalization of the luttinger-liquid behavior is a propensity of the system to order. I speculate about how the conflict between antiferromagnetism and superconductivity, the two principal kinds of order in this problem, might result in both the observed zero-temperature phase diagram of the cuprates and the luttinger-liquid phenomenology, i.e. the breakup of the electron into spinons and holons in certain regimes of doping and energy. The key idea is a quantum critical point regulating a first-order transition between these phases and toward which one is first attracted under renormalization before bifurcating between the two phases.

arXiv:cond-mat/9709195•Sep 17, 1997•21 citations

Slave particle study of the strongly correlated electrons

Seyyed Mir Abolhassan Vaezi

Until three decades ago, our understanding of the condensed matter systems were based on two frameworks developed by Russian physicist Lev Landau: his theory of phase transition, and Fermi liquids. The Landau theory of phase transition and the Fermi liquid theory together, can successfully explain a wide range of phenomena from ferromagnetism and antiferromagnetism to the conventional superconductivity. However, in the last thirty years, many experiments including the fractional quantum Hall effect (QHE) have revolutionized our view of nature. For a system of electrons that is subject to a very strong interactions and/or strong correlations between electrons, these two frameworks may break down. There many phases of matter, e.g. spin liquids, that do not break any classical symmetry, but are separated by phase transition. These states has the so called topological order. Also, many of these states do not follow predictions of the Fermi liquid theory and have many exotic behaviors. A rather powerful technique to handle with these issues is the slave particle method. In the first part of this thesis, using a more general slave particle method we study the strongly correlated Hubbard model, whose ground state may represent a Fermi liquid state at two spatial dimensions. We study the phase diagram of this model and show that the gapped spin liquid can be realized on the both honeycomb and square lattices, within mean-field. We also investigate the effective low energy theory of these states. Some of them are subject to compact gauge fluctuations. We study instanton effect in them and show that instanton proliferation can destabilize some of them. Another interesting problem in which we are interested in is the copper based high temperature superconductors (HTSC). The parent state of cuprates materials (undoped case) is a Mott insulator whose ground state is proposed to be a spin liquid. Upon doping, many exotic phases appear, from high temperature superconductivity to the pseudogap phase with disjoint Fermi segments (Fermi arcs) instead of a closed Fermi surface, or the strange metal phase where the Fermi liquid theory breaks down and exhibits very unusual transport properties. The isotope effect in these materials is also very different from that of conventional superconductors. In the second part of this thesis we study the above mentioned problem in detail and explain them by appealing to the slave particle method.

•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation
Soon after the discovery of high temperature superconductivity in the cuprates, Anderson proposed a connection to quantum spin liquids. But observations since then have shown that the low temperature phase diagram is dominated by conventional states, with a competition between superconductivity and charge-ordered states which break translational symmetry. We employ the "pseudogap metal" phase, found at intermediate temperatures and low hole doping, as the parent to the phases found at lower temperatures. We argue that the pseudogap is associated with a spin liquid, and that a particular spin liquid has the needed confining instabilities to resolve a number of open puzzles on the cuprate phase diagram.
Two of the iconic phases of the hole-doped cuprate materials are the intermediate temperature pseudogap metal and the lower temperature ddd-wave superconductor. Following the suggestion of P. W. Anderson, there were early theories of these phases as doped quantum spin liquids. However, these theories have had difficulties with two prominent observations: (i) angle-dependent magnetoresistance measurements (ADMR) in the pseudogap metal, including observation of the Yamaji effect, present convincing evidence of small hole pockets which can tunnel coherently between square lattice layers (Fang et al., Nature Physics 18, 558 (2022); Chan et al., Nature Physics 21, 1753 (2025)) and (ii) the velocities of the nodal Bogoliubov quasiparticles in the ddd-wave superconductor are highly anisotropic, with vF≫vΔv_F \gg v_ΔvF​≫vΔ​ (Chiao et al., Phys. Rev. B 62, 3554 (2000)). These notes review how the fractionalized Fermi Liquid (FL*) state, which dopes quantum spin liquids with gauge-neutral electron-like quasiparticles, resolves both difficulties. Theories of insulating quantum spin liquids employing fractionalization of the electron spin into bosonic or fermionic partons are discussed. Doping the bosonic parton theory leads to a holon metal theory: while not appropriate for the cuprate pseudogap, this theory is argued to apply to ultracold atom experiments on the Lieb lattice. Doping the fermionic parton theory leads to a ddd-wave superconductor with nearly isotropic quasiparticle velocities. The construction of the FL* state in a single band Hubbard-type model is described using a quantum dimer model, followed by a more realistic description using the Ancilla Layer Model (ALM), which is then used to obtain the theory of the pseudogap and the ddd-wave superconductor. The ALM also leads to a wavefunction for the FL* state of the Hubbard model, which agrees with ultracold atom observations.
We describe the confining instabilities of a proposed quantum spin liquid underlying the pseudogap metal state of the hole-doped cuprates. The spin liquid can be described by a SU(2) gauge theory of N f = 2 massless Dirac fermions carrying fundamental gauge charges—this is the low-energy theory of a mean-field state of fermionic spinons moving on the square lattice with π -flux per plaquette in the ℤ 2 center of SU(2). This theory has an emergent SO(5) f global symmetry and is presumed to confine at low energies to the Néel state. At nonzero doping (or smaller Hubbard repulsion U at half-filling), we argue that confinement occurs via the Higgs condensation of bosonic chargons carrying fundamental SU(2) gauge charges also moving in π ℤ 2 -flux. At half-filling, the low-energy theory of the Higgs sector has N b = 2 relativistic bosons with a possible emergent SO(5) b global symmetry describing rotations between a d -wave superconductor, period-2 charge stripes, and the time-reversal breaking “ d -density wave” state. We propose a conformal SU(2) gauge theory with N f = 2 fundamental fermions, N b = 2 fundamental bosons, and a SO(5) f ×SO(5) b global symmetry, which describes a deconfined quantum critical point between a confining state which breaks SO(5) f and a confining state which breaks SO(5) b . The pattern of symmetry breaking within both SO(5)s is determined by terms likely irrelevant at the critical point, which can be chosen to obtain a transition between Néel order and d -wave superconductivity. A similar theory applies at nonzero doping and large U , with longer-range couplings of the chargons leading to charge order with longer periods.
Theoretical attempts to explain the origin of high temperature superconductivity are challenged by the complexity of the normal state, which exhibits three regimes with increasing hole doping: a pseudo-gap regime when underdoped, strange power laws near optimal doping and more conventional metallic behavior when heavily overdoped. We suggest that the origin of this behavior is linked to a zero temperature quantum phase transition separating the overdoped Fermi liquid from a spin-charge separated underdoped phase. Central to our analysis is a new Z2Z_2Z2​ gauge theory formulation, which supports topological vortex excitations - dubbed visons. The visons are gapped in the underdoped phase, splitting the electron's charge and Fermi statistics into two separate excitations. Superconductivity occurs when the resulting charge eee boson condenses. The visons are condensed in the overdoped phase, thereby confining the charge and statistics of the electron leading to a Fermi liquid phase. Right at the quantum confinement transition the visons are in a critical state, leading to power law behavior for both charge and spin.
This review gives a rather general discussion of high temperature superconductors as an example of a strongly correlated material. The argument is made that in view of the many examples of unconventional superconductors discovered in the past twenty years, we should no longer be surprised that superconductivity emerges as a highly competitive ground state in systems where Coulomb repulsion plays a dominant role. The physics of the cuprates is discussed, emphasizing the unusual pseudogap phase in the underdoped region. It is argued that the resonating valence bond picture, as formulated using gauge theory with fermionic and bosonic matter fields, gives an adequate physical understanding, even though many details are beyond the powers of current calculational tools. The recent discovery of quantum oscillations in a high magnetic field is discussed in this context. Meanwhile, the problem of the quantum spin liquid (a spin system with antiferromagnetic coupling which refuses to order even at zero temperature) is a somewhat simpler version of the high T c problem where significant progress has been made recently. It is understood that the existence of matter fields can lead to deconfinement of the U (1) gauge theory in 2 + 1 dimensions, and novel new particles (called fractionalized particles), such as fermionic spinons which carry spin and no charge, and gapless gauge bosons can emerge to create a new critical state at low energies. We even have a couple of real materials where such a scenario may be realized experimentally. The paper ends with answers to questions such as: What limits T c if pairing is driven by an electronic energy scale? Why is the high T c problem hard? Why is there no consensus? And why is the high T c problem important?
I argue that the conflict between the fermi-liquid and non-fermi-liquid metallic states viewed by Anderson as the central intellectual issue of cuprate superconductivity, and which motivates the recent criticism by Baskaran and Anderson [cond-mat/9706076] of the work of Zhang [cond-mat/9610140], is a fundamentally wrong concept. All experimental evidence points to adiabatic continuability of the strange metal into a conventional one, and thus to one metallic phase rather than two, and all attempts to account theoretically for the existence of a luttinger-liquid at zero temperature in spatial dimension greater than 1 have failed. I discuss the underlying reasons for this failure and then argue that the true higher-dimensional generalization of the luttinger-liquid behavior is a propensity of the system to order. I speculate about how the conflict between antiferromagnetism and superconductivity, the two principal kinds of order in this problem, might result in both the observed zero-temperature phase diagram of the cuprates and the luttinger-liquid phenomenology, i.e. the breakup of the electron into spinons and holons in certain regimes of doping and energy. The key idea is a quantum critical point regulating a first-order transition between these phases and toward which one is first attracted under renormalization before bifurcating between the two phases.
Until three decades ago, our understanding of the condensed matter systems were based on two frameworks developed by Russian physicist Lev Landau: his theory of phase transition, and Fermi liquids. The Landau theory of phase transition and the Fermi liquid theory together, can successfully explain a wide range of phenomena from ferromagnetism and antiferromagnetism to the conventional superconductivity. However, in the last thirty years, many experiments including the fractional quantum Hall effect (QHE) have revolutionized our view of nature. For a system of electrons that is subject to a very strong interactions and/or strong correlations between electrons, these two frameworks may break down. There many phases of matter, e.g. spin liquids, that do not break any classical symmetry, but are separated by phase transition. These states has the so called topological order. Also, many of these states do not follow predictions of the Fermi liquid theory and have many exotic behaviors. A rather powerful technique to handle with these issues is the slave particle method. In the first part of this thesis, using a more general slave particle method we study the strongly correlated Hubbard model, whose ground state may represent a Fermi liquid state at two spatial dimensions. We study the phase diagram of this model and show that the gapped spin liquid can be realized on the both honeycomb and square lattices, within mean-field. We also investigate the effective low energy theory of these states. Some of them are subject to compact gauge fluctuations. We study instanton effect in them and show that instanton proliferation can destabilize some of them. Another interesting problem in which we are interested in is the copper based high temperature superconductors (HTSC). The parent state of cuprates materials (undoped case) is a Mott insulator whose ground state is proposed to be a spin liquid. Upon doping, many exotic phases appear, from high temperature superconductivity to the pseudogap phase with disjoint Fermi segments (Fermi arcs) instead of a closed Fermi surface, or the strange metal phase where the Fermi liquid theory breaks down and exhibits very unusual transport properties. The isotope effect in these materials is also very different from that of conventional superconductors. In the second part of this thesis we study the above mentioned problem in detail and explain them by appealing to the slave particle method.