Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physica Scripta

Comment on ‘Solving a singular integral equation for the one-dimensional Coulomb problem’ (2023 Physica Scripta 98 085219)

Yu-Peng Zhang, Qihao Zeng, Dong Sun, O. Olendski

Published Jan 28, 2024• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract It is shown by Olendski that the derivation of the momentum waveform of the quasi-one-dimensional hydrogen atom recently performed by Shutovskyi et al (2023 Phys. Scr. 98 085 219) contains the same error as in the previous effort by Saha et al (2017 Eur. J. Phys. 38 025 103). The error was also identified by Olendski (2017 Eur. J. Phys. 38 038 001; 2019 Eur. J. Phys. 40 025 402). To exemplify the faulty nature of Shutovski et al formula, the standard deviations of position and momentum that enter the Heisenberg uncertainty relation were calculated. It produced different results in the position and wave vector spaces, whereas the use of the correct expression yields the same value by either method.

DOI
10.1088/1402-4896/ad0c8e

Related papers

Comment on 'Fisher information for quasi-one-dimensional hydrogen atom'

O. Olendski

A further argument is provided in the discussion on the correct form of the bound-state momentum wave function of the quasi-one-dimensional hydrogen atom; namely, considering its behavior at the large quantum indices, it is reconfirmed that the complex expression from Olendski (2017) {\it Eur. J. Phys.} {\bf 38} 038001 is a correct one. Groundlessness of other interpretations is also highlighted.

arXiv:1703.10042•Mar 26, 2017•1 citation

Comment on ‘On the realisation of quantum Fisher information’

O. Olendski

Abstract It is shown that calculation of the momentum Fisher information of the quasi-one-dimensional hydrogen atom recently presented by Saha et al (2017 Eur. J. Phys. 38 025103 ) is wrong. A correct derivation is provided and its didactical advantages and scientific significances are highlighted.

arXiv:1703.03405•European Journal of Physics•Mar 8, 2017•3 citations

Fisher information for quasi-one-dimensional hydrogen atom

Saha, Aparna, B. Talukdar, Supriya Chatterjee

The coordinate-space wave function $ψ(x)$ of quasi-one-dimensional atoms is defined in the $x\geq 0$ region only. This poses a typical problem to write a physically acceptable momentum-space wave function $ϕ(p)$ from the Fourier transform of $ψ(x)$. We resolve the problem with special attention to the behavior of real and imaginary parts of the complex-valued function $ϕ(p)$ as a function of $p$ and confirm that $ϕ_i(p)$ (the imaginary part of $ϕ(p)$) represents the correct momentum-space wave function. We make use of the results for $ψ(x)$ and $ϕ_i(p)$ to express the position- and momentum-space Fisher information in terms of the principal quantum number and energy eigen value of the system and provide some useful checks on the result presented with particular attention on the information theoretic uncertainty relation.

arXiv:1703.03578•Mar 10, 2017•3 citations

On the application of the Heisenberg uncertainty relations to the hydrogen atom

Karen F Pagnoni, Alexys Bruno‐Alfonso, Roger A. Lewis

Abstract The Heisenberg uncertainty relations are cornerstones of quantum theory. Yet care is required in applying them. While they determine the lowest energy level in some systems, such as the isotropic three-dimensional harmonic oscillator, they fail to do so in other systems, notably, the hydrogen atom. This failure has been overlooked in many textbooks and pedagogic articles. The failure arises due to the singularity of the Coulomb potential. To elucidate the point, we present four subfamilies of position probability distributions. By delineating the limitations in applying position-momentum uncertainty to the hydrogen atom, we hope to improve the teaching and learning of modern physics.

European Journal of Physics•Jun 2, 2025•0 citations

Comment on ‘Little-known non-orthogonality of hydrogenic radial wavefunctions: an ℓ -dependent operator perspective’

Gregory L. Bason, Bruce Cameron Reed

Abstract Following the recent discussion of Mankame (2026 Eur. J. Phys. 47 025405), we consider the orthogonality of the radial parts of the hydrogen atom wavefunctions, R n , ℓ ( r ) . As Mankame showed, these functions are not in general orthogonal. By this we mean that the overlap integral of the product of two of them weighted by the square of the radial coordinate may be non-zero if the two angular momentum quantum numbers differ. Orthogonality does hold in the case where the two angular momentum quantum numbers are the same, providing that the principal quantum numbers differ. Here we offer an alternate proof of this result, describe some analytic examples to complement Mankame’s numerical ones, and point out some further references on this issue.

European Journal of Physics•Jul 20, 2026•0 citations

Heisenberg uncertainty relation for position and momentum beyond central potentials

Łukasz Rudnicki

Recently, S\'anchez-Moreno et al. [New J. Phys. 8, 330 (2006)] have shown that the three-dimensional Heisenberg uncertainty relation ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{r}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{p}\ensuremath{\ge}3\ensuremath{\hbar}/2$ might be significantly sharpened if the relevant quantum state describes the particle in a central potential. I extend that result to the case of states which are not the eigenstates of the square of the angular momentum operator. I derive a lower bound for ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{r}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{p}$ which involves the mean value and the variance of the square of the angular momentum operator.

arXiv:1112.5198•Physical Review A•Feb 8, 2012•11 citations
Abstract It is shown by Olendski that the derivation of the momentum waveform of the quasi-one-dimensional hydrogen atom recently performed by Shutovskyi et al (2023 Phys. Scr. 98 085 219) contains the same error as in the previous effort by Saha et al (2017 Eur. J. Phys. 38 025 103). The error was also identified by Olendski (2017 Eur. J. Phys. 38 038 001; 2019 Eur. J. Phys. 40 025 402). To exemplify the faulty nature of Shutovski et al formula, the standard deviations of position and momentum that enter the Heisenberg uncertainty relation were calculated. It produced different results in the position and wave vector spaces, whereas the use of the correct expression yields the same value by either method.
The coordinate-space wave function ψ(x)ψ(x)ψ(x) of quasi-one-dimensional atoms is defined in the x≥0x\geq 0x≥0 region only. This poses a typical problem to write a physically acceptable momentum-space wave function ϕ(p)ϕ(p)ϕ(p) from the Fourier transform of ψ(x)ψ(x)ψ(x). We resolve the problem with special attention to the behavior of real and imaginary parts of the complex-valued function ϕ(p)ϕ(p)ϕ(p) as a function of ppp and confirm that ϕi(p)ϕ_i(p)ϕi​(p) (the imaginary part of ϕ(p)ϕ(p)ϕ(p)) represents the correct momentum-space wave function. We make use of the results for ψ(x)ψ(x)ψ(x) and ϕi(p)ϕ_i(p)ϕi​(p) to express the position- and momentum-space Fisher information in terms of the principal quantum number and energy eigen value of the system and provide some useful checks on the result presented with particular attention on the information theoretic uncertainty relation.
Abstract The Heisenberg uncertainty relations are cornerstones of quantum theory. Yet care is required in applying them. While they determine the lowest energy level in some systems, such as the isotropic three-dimensional harmonic oscillator, they fail to do so in other systems, notably, the hydrogen atom. This failure has been overlooked in many textbooks and pedagogic articles. The failure arises due to the singularity of the Coulomb potential. To elucidate the point, we present four subfamilies of position probability distributions. By delineating the limitations in applying position-momentum uncertainty to the hydrogen atom, we hope to improve the teaching and learning of modern physics.
Abstract Following the recent discussion of Mankame (2026 Eur. J. Phys. 47 025405), we consider the orthogonality of the radial parts of the hydrogen atom wavefunctions, R n , ℓ ( r ) . As Mankame showed, these functions are not in general orthogonal. By this we mean that the overlap integral of the product of two of them weighted by the square of the radial coordinate may be non-zero if the two angular momentum quantum numbers differ. Orthogonality does hold in the case where the two angular momentum quantum numbers are the same, providing that the principal quantum numbers differ. Here we offer an alternate proof of this result, describe some analytic examples to complement Mankame’s numerical ones, and point out some further references on this issue.
Recently, S\'anchez-Moreno et al. [New J. Phys. 8, 330 (2006)] have shown that the three-dimensional Heisenberg uncertainty relation ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{r}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{p}\ensuremath{\ge}3\ensuremath{\hbar}/2$ might be significantly sharpened if the relevant quantum state describes the particle in a central potential. I extend that result to the case of states which are not the eigenstates of the square of the angular momentum operator. I derive a lower bound for ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{r}{\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{p}$ which involves the mean value and the variance of the square of the angular momentum operator.