Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IPI Letters

Beware of New Ideas: Views on the Wave-Particle Duality

Rodney Bartlett

Published Jan 19, 2024• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In an e-mail sent in the year 2000, Josephson offered the admonition: “Beware ye, all those bold of spirit who want to suggest new ideas.” His words apply to his younger self who, in 1962, was “bold of spirit” and “want(ed) to suggest new ideas”. What did he need to beware? Possibly – older scientists with established ways and conservative views … perhaps even his older, settled-into-tradition, self.

DOI
10.59973/ipil.51

Related papers

Scientists update views of light

Gary Anthes

Experiment sheds new light on wave-particle duality.

Communications of the ACM•Sep 28, 2015•1 citation

Bright idea

Gordon D. Love

Some of us have "brainwaves" whereas others have "flashes of inspiration". Is this yet another example of wave–particle duality?

Physics World•Aug 1, 1992•0 citations

Classical apples and quantum potatoes

Jean-Marc Lévy-Leblond

Beware of the ideas hidden behind the words: quantons (quantum things) are neither waves, nor particles. A gastronomical metaphor and a geometrical one are proposed to clarify the relationship between quantum and classical concepts.

European Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1981•12 citations

The Enigma that is Light

Jeremy Dunning-Davies, Richard Lawrence Norman

The presently accepted notion of wave/particle duality, especially when applied to light, is undoubtedly a cause of great unease for many. Here the issue is examined afresh in the light of ideas put forward in recent years, especially by Mayants, while not forgetting the contributions of those great scientists of the past. Explanations and interpretations are then offered to account for seemingly paradoxical effects.

•Jun 1, 2016•0 citations

The scientists and the electron or a tale of duality (with apologies to John Godfrey Saxe)

Janice Kelland

Poem on the wave / particle duality of the electron.

Journal of Chemical Education•Dec 1, 1989•0 citations

The Scientist as Critic

Wolfgang Ernst Friederich Pauli

Abstract The modern version of quantum theory—now known as “quantum mechanics”— was born and grew to maturity in just five years, between 1925 and 1930. More was accomplished during those five years than in the preceding twenty-five years, or, for that matter, in the seventy years that have followed. Progress before 1925 was constantly hampered by conceptual doubts. Paradoxes such as the wave-particle duality—the contradiction between the Einstein particle theory of light and the classical wave theory—were disturbing and limiting. But by 1925 these difficulties had, perhaps from familiarity, become less inhibiting. Theorists stopped worrying about the conceptual strangeness of the quantum realm, and began to make a new physics with the strangeness incorporated in it. Once the conceptual barriers were passed, progress was astonishingly rapid. For those who had the vision, it was as if a great fog had lifted. Suddenly it was possible to see in many directions with a clarity no one could have anticipated.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 15, 2001•0 citations
In an e-mail sent in the year 2000, Josephson offered the admonition: “Beware ye, all those bold of spirit who want to suggest new ideas.” His words apply to his younger self who, in 1962, was “bold of spirit” and “want(ed) to suggest new ideas”. What did he need to beware? Possibly – older scientists with established ways and conservative views … perhaps even his older, settled-into-tradition, self.
Abstract The modern version of quantum theory—now known as “quantum mechanics”— was born and grew to maturity in just five years, between 1925 and 1930. More was accomplished during those five years than in the preceding twenty-five years, or, for that matter, in the seventy years that have followed. Progress before 1925 was constantly hampered by conceptual doubts. Paradoxes such as the wave-particle duality—the contradiction between the Einstein particle theory of light and the classical wave theory—were disturbing and limiting. But by 1925 these difficulties had, perhaps from familiarity, become less inhibiting. Theorists stopped worrying about the conceptual strangeness of the quantum realm, and began to make a new physics with the strangeness incorporated in it. Once the conceptual barriers were passed, progress was astonishingly rapid. For those who had the vision, it was as if a great fog had lifted. Suddenly it was possible to see in many directions with a clarity no one could have anticipated.