Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Lecture notes in computer science

Witness-Authenticated Key Exchange, Revisited: Extensions to Groups, Improved Models, Simpler Constructions

Matteo Campanelli, Rosario Gennaro, Kelsey Melissaris, Luca Nizzardo

Published Nov 30, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We study witness-authenticated key exchange (WAKE), in which parties authenticate through knowledge of a witness to any NP statement. WAKE achieves generic authenticated key exchange in the absence of trusted parties; WAKE is most suitable when a certificate authority is either unavailable or undesirable, as in highly decentralized networks. In practice WAKE approximates witness encryption, its elusive non-interactive analogue, at the cost of minimal interaction. This work is the first to propose, model and build witness-authenticated key exchange amongst groups of more than two parties, as well as the first to provide practical and provably secure constructions in the two-party case for general NP statements. Specifically our contributions are: both game-based and universally composable (Canetti, FOCS ’01) definitions for WAKE along with equivalence conditions between the two definitions, a highly general compiler that introduces witness-authentication to any key exchange protocol along with, as a direct consequence, a three-round group WAKE protocol from DDH and signatures of knowledge (SOK), and an optimized two-round group WAKE construction from DDH and SOK along with experimental benchmarks to demonstrate concrete practicality. Additionally, we study the specialized two-party case and provide a critique of prior work on this topic (Ngo et al., Financial Crypto ’21) by pinpointing nontrivial weaknesses in the model, constructions and security proofs seen therein. We rectify those limitations with this work, significantly diverging in our techniques, design and approach.

DOI
10.1007/978-3-031-47754-6_7

Related papers

Strongly Secure Authenticated Key Exchange in the Standard Model

Zheng Yang

Nowadays many crucial network applications rely on the existence of a confidential channel established by authenticated key exchange (AKE) protocols over public networks.With the rapid development of cyber technology, novel attacks to cryptosystem emerge in an endless stream.This has also led to the development of AKE solutions to provide increasingly stronger security guarantees.In this thesis we focus on provision of practical constructions for AKE protocols which are provably secure in a strong sense without resorting to random oracles.We first we present three new efficient compilers to generically turn passively secure key exchange protocols (KE) into authenticated key exchange protocols (AKE) where security also holds in the presence of active adversaries.Our compilers are not only a useful tool for the design of new AKE systems with many additional security properties in a modular and less error-prone fashion, but they also help to relax the assumptions on existing, practical key exchange mechanisms which are not known to be provably secure AKE protocols.Security of our compilers is shown in a strong modified CK model where the adversary is allowed to reveal either long-term secret key or state information of the protocol participants.On the second, we study the open problem on constructing eCK secure two party AKE protocol without random oracles and NAXOS trick.A generic construction satisfying those requirements is given based on well-known cryptographic primitives following the guideline of efficiency.Then a concrete protocol is proposed which is the first eCK secure protocol in the standard model under both standard assumptions and post-specified peer setting (i.e.without knowing any cryptographic information about its communication peer).Both proposed schemes can be more efficiently implemented with secure device than previous works which are eCK secure in the standard model, where the secure device might be normally used to store the long-term private key and to implement codes of protocol which need to be resilience of state leakage.Finally, we generalize our one-round two party AKE construction to group case that yields an efficient tripartite AKE protocol based on bilinear maps and a candidate group AKE protocol (with more than three members) based on multilinear maps.Up to now they are the first solutions which can be proved secure in the g-eCK model without random oracles.Meanwhile we make first step to show how to simplify the security proof for one-round group AKE under g-eCK model.i

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Compiled Constructions towards Post-Quantum Group Key Exchange: A Design from Kyber

José Ignacio Escribano Pablos, María Isabel González Vasco, Misael Enrique Marriaga +1 more

A group authenticated key exchange (GAKE) protocol allows a set of parties belonging to a certain designated group to agree upon a common secret key through an insecure communication network. In the last few years, many new cryptographic tools have been specifically designed to thwart attacks from adversaries which may have access to (different kinds of) quantum computation resources. However, few constructions for group key exchange have been put forward. Here, we propose a four-round GAKE which can be proven secure under widely accepted assumptions in the Quantum Random Oracle Model. Specifically, we integrate several primitives from the so-called Kyber suite of post-quantum tools in a (slightly modified) compiler from Abdalla et al. (TCC 2007). More precisely, taking as a starting point an IND-CPA encryption scheme from the Kyber portfolio, we derive, using results from Hövelmanns et al. (PKC 2020), a two-party key exchange protocol and an IND-CCA encryption scheme and prove them fit as building blocks for our compiled construction. The resulting GAKE protocol is secure under the Module-LWE assumption, and furthermore achieves authentication without the use of (expensive) post-quantum signatures.

Mathematics•Oct 21, 2020•12 citations

Realistic, strong and provable key exchange security

Luke Garratt

Authenticated key exchange protocols are ubiquitous in modern-day life. They are used to secure numerous types of data exchange, ranging from online banking to instant messaging conversations. In this thesis, we extend the state of the art for authenticated key exchange security, following the three themes of realistic, strong and provable. First, we tackle the theme of provable security. We develop generic techniques, applicable to a wide range of security models, to assist in proofs of security of cryptographic schemes. Specifically, a "game hopping" proof is a powerful technique to prove strong statements about the security of a protocol. However, the proof technique often involves esoteric and repetitive steps. We demystify the methodology and prove generic theorems to reduce the length and complexity of a wide class of game hopping proofs. Next, we use this new framework to analyse strong and previously unstudied formal security guarantees of authenticated key exchange protocols. These protocols are able to achieve strong security guarantees because they share and update state across sessions. Using our framework, we are able to push the state of the art by defying the folklore of what was previously thought provable of authenticated key exchange protocols. Specifically, it was previously thought that no protocol can achieve a security guarantee about communication with a peer if the peer was already fully compromised. We show that this is not true by formally defining a new concept, which we name post-compromise security. We capture an intuitive "self-healing" property of protocols. We then construct and formally prove protocols can achieve this strong security notion. Finally, we leverage all of this work to analyse realistic protocols. Signal, which is used to encrypt messages in WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger and Google Allo amongst others, is one such protocol we consider. Despite being used by billions of people, Signal was completely unstudied in the academic literature prior to this work. Two reasons for this were that Signal had no documentation at the time and it did not fit into existing models: it shares state across sessions and has over ten different types of key, most of which continually update. Despite its complexity, we are able to use the other work in this thesis to give the first ever analysis and proof of security of Signal. Overall, this thesis aims to bridge the gap between theory and practice in the current state of the art of authenticated key exchange protocols.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

One-round Protocols for Two-Party Authenticated Key Exchange

Ik-Rae Jeong, Donghoon Lee

Abstract. Cryptographic protocol design in a two-party setting has often ignored the possibility of simultaneous message transmission by each of the two parties (i.e., using a duplex channel). In particular, most protocols for two-party key exchange have been designed assuming that parties alternate sending their messages (i.e., assuming a bidirectional half-duplex channel). However, by taking advantage of the communication characteristics of the network it may be possible to design protocols with improved latency. This is the focus of the present work. We present a number of provably-secure protocols for two-party authenticated key exchange (AKE) which require only a single round. Our first protocol provides key independence only, and is analyzed in the random oracle model. This scheme matches the most efficient AKE protocols among those found in the literature. Our second scheme additionally provides forward secrecy, and is also analyzed in the random oracle model. Our final protocol provides the same strong security guarantees, but is proven secure in the standard model. This scheme is only slightly less efficient (from a computational perspective) than the previous ones. These last two schemes are the first provably-secure one-round protocols for authenticated 2-party key exchange which provide forward secrecy.

Jeongbo gwahaghoe nonmunji. si'seu'tem mich i'lon•Jan 1, 2006•1 citation

A Security Weakness in a Generic Construction of a Group Key Exchange Protocol.

Junghyun Nam

Protocols for group key exchange are cryptographic algorithms that allow a group of parties communicating over a public network to come up with a common secret key. One of the interesting results of research on group key exchange is the protocol compiler presented by Abdalla et al. in TCC ’07. Abdalla et al.’s compiler shows how one can transform any authenticated 2-party key exchange protocol into an authenticated group key exchange protocol with 2 more rounds of communication. This compiler certainly is elegant in its genericness, sym-metricity, simplicity and efficiency. However, the situation completely changes when it comes to security. In this work, we reveal a major security weakness in Abdalla et al.’s compiler and show how to address it. The security weakness uncovered here implies that Abdalla et al.’s proof of security for their compiler is invalid.

•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Group key exchange protocols withstanding ephemeral-key reveals.

María Isabel González Vasco, Ángel Luis Pérez del Pozo, Adriana Suárez Corona

When a group key exchange protocol is executed, the session key is typically extracted from two types of secrets: long-term keys (for authentication) and freshly generated (often random) values. The leakage of this latter so-called ephemeral keys has been extensively analysed in the 2-party case, yet very few works are concerned with it in the group setting. The authors provide a generic group key exchange construction that is strongly secure, meaning that the attacker is allowed to learn both long-term and ephemeral keys (but not both from the same participant, as this would trivially disclose the session key). Their design can be seen as a compiler, in the sense that it builds on a 2-party key exchange protocol which is strongly secure and transforms it into a strongly secure group key exchange protocol by adding only one extra round of communication. When applied to an existing 2-party protocol from Bergsma et al., the result is a 2-round group key exchange protocol which is strongly secure in the standard model, thus yielding the first construction with this property.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations
We study witness-authenticated key exchange (WAKE), in which parties authenticate through knowledge of a witness to any NP statement. WAKE achieves generic authenticated key exchange in the absence of trusted parties; WAKE is most suitable when a certificate authority is either unavailable or undesirable, as in highly decentralized networks. In practice WAKE approximates witness encryption, its elusive non-interactive analogue, at the cost of minimal interaction. This work is the first to propose, model and build witness-authenticated key exchange amongst groups of more than two parties, as well as the first to provide practical and provably secure constructions in the two-party case for general NP statements. Specifically our contributions are: both game-based and universally composable (Canetti, FOCS ’01) definitions for WAKE along with equivalence conditions between the two definitions, a highly general compiler that introduces witness-authentication to any key exchange protocol along with, as a direct consequence, a three-round group WAKE protocol from DDH and signatures of knowledge (SOK), and an optimized two-round group WAKE construction from DDH and SOK along with experimental benchmarks to demonstrate concrete practicality. Additionally, we study the specialized two-party case and provide a critique of prior work on this topic (Ngo et al., Financial Crypto ’21) by pinpointing nontrivial weaknesses in the model, constructions and security proofs seen therein. We rectify those limitations with this work, significantly diverging in our techniques, design and approach.
Nowadays many crucial network applications rely on the existence of a confidential channel established by authenticated key exchange (AKE) protocols over public networks.With the rapid development of cyber technology, novel attacks to cryptosystem emerge in an endless stream.This has also led to the development of AKE solutions to provide increasingly stronger security guarantees.In this thesis we focus on provision of practical constructions for AKE protocols which are provably secure in a strong sense without resorting to random oracles.We first we present three new efficient compilers to generically turn passively secure key exchange protocols (KE) into authenticated key exchange protocols (AKE) where security also holds in the presence of active adversaries.Our compilers are not only a useful tool for the design of new AKE systems with many additional security properties in a modular and less error-prone fashion, but they also help to relax the assumptions on existing, practical key exchange mechanisms which are not known to be provably secure AKE protocols.Security of our compilers is shown in a strong modified CK model where the adversary is allowed to reveal either long-term secret key or state information of the protocol participants.On the second, we study the open problem on constructing eCK secure two party AKE protocol without random oracles and NAXOS trick.A generic construction satisfying those requirements is given based on well-known cryptographic primitives following the guideline of efficiency.Then a concrete protocol is proposed which is the first eCK secure protocol in the standard model under both standard assumptions and post-specified peer setting (i.e.without knowing any cryptographic information about its communication peer).Both proposed schemes can be more efficiently implemented with secure device than previous works which are eCK secure in the standard model, where the secure device might be normally used to store the long-term private key and to implement codes of protocol which need to be resilience of state leakage.Finally, we generalize our one-round two party AKE construction to group case that yields an efficient tripartite AKE protocol based on bilinear maps and a candidate group AKE protocol (with more than three members) based on multilinear maps.Up to now they are the first solutions which can be proved secure in the g-eCK model without random oracles.Meanwhile we make first step to show how to simplify the security proof for one-round group AKE under g-eCK model.i
A group authenticated key exchange (GAKE) protocol allows a set of parties belonging to a certain designated group to agree upon a common secret key through an insecure communication network. In the last few years, many new cryptographic tools have been specifically designed to thwart attacks from adversaries which may have access to (different kinds of) quantum computation resources. However, few constructions for group key exchange have been put forward. Here, we propose a four-round GAKE which can be proven secure under widely accepted assumptions in the Quantum Random Oracle Model. Specifically, we integrate several primitives from the so-called Kyber suite of post-quantum tools in a (slightly modified) compiler from Abdalla et al. (TCC 2007). More precisely, taking as a starting point an IND-CPA encryption scheme from the Kyber portfolio, we derive, using results from Hövelmanns et al. (PKC 2020), a two-party key exchange protocol and an IND-CCA encryption scheme and prove them fit as building blocks for our compiled construction. The resulting GAKE protocol is secure under the Module-LWE assumption, and furthermore achieves authentication without the use of (expensive) post-quantum signatures.
Authenticated key exchange protocols are ubiquitous in modern-day life. They are used to secure numerous types of data exchange, ranging from online banking to instant messaging conversations. In this thesis, we extend the state of the art for authenticated key exchange security, following the three themes of realistic, strong and provable. First, we tackle the theme of provable security. We develop generic techniques, applicable to a wide range of security models, to assist in proofs of security of cryptographic schemes. Specifically, a "game hopping" proof is a powerful technique to prove strong statements about the security of a protocol. However, the proof technique often involves esoteric and repetitive steps. We demystify the methodology and prove generic theorems to reduce the length and complexity of a wide class of game hopping proofs. Next, we use this new framework to analyse strong and previously unstudied formal security guarantees of authenticated key exchange protocols. These protocols are able to achieve strong security guarantees because they share and update state across sessions. Using our framework, we are able to push the state of the art by defying the folklore of what was previously thought provable of authenticated key exchange protocols. Specifically, it was previously thought that no protocol can achieve a security guarantee about communication with a peer if the peer was already fully compromised. We show that this is not true by formally defining a new concept, which we name post-compromise security. We capture an intuitive "self-healing" property of protocols. We then construct and formally prove protocols can achieve this strong security notion. Finally, we leverage all of this work to analyse realistic protocols. Signal, which is used to encrypt messages in WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger and Google Allo amongst others, is one such protocol we consider. Despite being used by billions of people, Signal was completely unstudied in the academic literature prior to this work. Two reasons for this were that Signal had no documentation at the time and it did not fit into existing models: it shares state across sessions and has over ten different types of key, most of which continually update. Despite its complexity, we are able to use the other work in this thesis to give the first ever analysis and proof of security of Signal. Overall, this thesis aims to bridge the gap between theory and practice in the current state of the art of authenticated key exchange protocols.
Abstract. Cryptographic protocol design in a two-party setting has often ignored the possibility of simultaneous message transmission by each of the two parties (i.e., using a duplex channel). In particular, most protocols for two-party key exchange have been designed assuming that parties alternate sending their messages (i.e., assuming a bidirectional half-duplex channel). However, by taking advantage of the communication characteristics of the network it may be possible to design protocols with improved latency. This is the focus of the present work. We present a number of provably-secure protocols for two-party authenticated key exchange (AKE) which require only a single round. Our first protocol provides key independence only, and is analyzed in the random oracle model. This scheme matches the most efficient AKE protocols among those found in the literature. Our second scheme additionally provides forward secrecy, and is also analyzed in the random oracle model. Our final protocol provides the same strong security guarantees, but is proven secure in the standard model. This scheme is only slightly less efficient (from a computational perspective) than the previous ones. These last two schemes are the first provably-secure one-round protocols for authenticated 2-party key exchange which provide forward secrecy.
Protocols for group key exchange are cryptographic algorithms that allow a group of parties communicating over a public network to come up with a common secret key. One of the interesting results of research on group key exchange is the protocol compiler presented by Abdalla et al. in TCC ’07. Abdalla et al.’s compiler shows how one can transform any authenticated 2-party key exchange protocol into an authenticated group key exchange protocol with 2 more rounds of communication. This compiler certainly is elegant in its genericness, sym-metricity, simplicity and efficiency. However, the situation completely changes when it comes to security. In this work, we reveal a major security weakness in Abdalla et al.’s compiler and show how to address it. The security weakness uncovered here implies that Abdalla et al.’s proof of security for their compiler is invalid.
When a group key exchange protocol is executed, the session key is typically extracted from two types of secrets: long-term keys (for authentication) and freshly generated (often random) values. The leakage of this latter so-called ephemeral keys has been extensively analysed in the 2-party case, yet very few works are concerned with it in the group setting. The authors provide a generic group key exchange construction that is strongly secure, meaning that the attacker is allowed to learn both long-term and ephemeral keys (but not both from the same participant, as this would trivially disclose the session key). Their design can be seen as a compiler, in the sense that it builds on a 2-party key exchange protocol which is strongly secure and transforms it into a strongly secure group key exchange protocol by adding only one extra round of communication. When applied to an existing 2-party protocol from Bergsma et al., the result is a 2-round group key exchange protocol which is strongly secure in the standard model, thus yielding the first construction with this property.