Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Spin echoes and thermodynamics

John S. Waugh

Published Aug 27, 1992• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract The spin echo [1] is still striking to those who see it for the first time, as it probably was to Hahn. A nuclear magnetization, having disappeared in a free induction decay (FID), spontaneously reappears as a giant fluctuation. While the phenomenon is easily understood from a mechanical point of view, it seems to verge on a violation of the second law of thermodynamics. It is this problem, about which Hahn [2] and others [3] have written, that we approach here again from what is at least partly a fresh perspective. Our point of view will be that echoesdo violate the second law. After having defended this case we will discuss briefly how the problem can be avoided by appropriate statement of purely macroscopic thermodynamic principles.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780198539629.003.0006

Related papers

More on the demons of thermodynamics

J. Jeener

In her article “The demons haunting thermodynamics” (Physics Today, November 2021, page 44), Katie Robertson concludes the introductory historical summary by saying that modern developments in quantum foundations have banished the demons “once and for all.” Unfortunately, no explanation or reference is given for that optimistic but controversial conclusion.Robertson presents Erwin Hahn’s 1950 spin-echo experiments11. E. L. Hahn, Phys. Rev. 80, 580 (1950). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.80.580 as the realization of Josef Loschmidt’s vision of reversing momentum. But Hahn clearly described his spin-echo experiments as the effect of traditional spin dynamics for noninteracting spins in a spatially inhomogeneous magnetic field. Although the detailed explanation involves many particular subtleties of NMR dynamics in liquids, Hahn’s interpretation does not imply any violation of the “second law”; it uses only the mild assumption that the spin observables are at thermal equilibrium before each start signal. Robertson’s misunderstanding clearly appears when she writes that “atomic spins that have dephased and become disordered are taken back to their earlier state by an RF pulse” and, a few lines later, “it turns out that the spin-echo experiment is a special case; most systems approach equilibrium instead of retracing their steps back to nonequilibrium states.” The spins have not become disordered: The phase of each spin remains directly related to the magnetic field at the spin’s location, and that relationship explains the echo.Two illuminating articles by Won-Kyu Rhim, Alexander Pines, and John Waugh describe spin-echo experiments in which the irreversible time evolution of a coupled nuclear spin system in solids is apparently “reversed” for a limited duration.22. W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. Lett. 25, 218 (1970); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.25.218W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. B 3, 684 (1971). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.3.684 As the authors explain, the results arise from uniform spin manipulation and are still consistent with the laws of thermodynamics.Another aspect of Robertson’s article that disturbed me is the lack of discussion of the relations between the actual experiments performed on large (macroscopic) systems and the microscopic-scale models used in attempts to make predictions about those results.Consider a mixture of oxygen and hydrogen at atmospheric pressure and room temperature. Standard thermodynamics and statistical mechanics will lead to excellent predictions of the equation of state, specific heat, and the like. But the standard models ignore the possibility of the chemical reaction producing water. Improved models are needed if one is to allow for, say, a slow, isothermal catalytic reaction or—much more complicated—an explosion in an isolated system at constant volume. Spin systems offer a rich variety of experimental possibilities for external manipulation and observation, but the corresponding models are related to the real experimental situations by complicated transformations and approximations that must be chosen according to the situation under study.Robertson invokes two models in the context of Maxwell’s demon. One is a biological machine using a ratchet-style mechanism. But in the cited article, the abstract carefully indicates that the evolution does not violate the second law because the microscopic mechanism is coupled to the exterior of the system.33. V. Serreli et al., Nature 445, 523 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature05452 In the demon-style experiment of Robertson’s figure 3, a complete realistic discussion of an actual implementation of the experiment leads to the similar conclusion that the second law is not violated.My conclusion is that demons and the related controversies are features of models and that the interpretation of actual experiments should be subjected to critical examination, preferably by those who performed the experiment and have a complete knowledge of all details.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. E. L. Hahn, Phys. Rev. 80, 580 (1950). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.80.580, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. Lett. 25, 218 (1970); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.25.218, Google ScholarCrossref, ISIW.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. B 3, 684 (1971). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.3.684, , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. V. Serreli et al., Nature 445, 523 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature05452, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2023 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Mar 1, 2023•1 citation

Consistent thermodynamics for spin echoes

Charis Anastopoulos, Ntina Savvidou

Spin-echo experiments are often said to constitute an instant of antithermodynamic behavior in a concrete physical system that violates the second law of thermodynamics. We argue that a proper thermodynamic treatment of the effect should take into account the correlations between the spin and the translational degrees of freedom of the molecules. To this end, we construct an entropy functional using Boltzmann macrostates that incorporate both spin and translational degrees of freedom. With this definition there is nothing special in the thermodynamics of spin echoes: dephasing corresponds to Hamiltonian evolution and leaves the entropy unchanged; dissipation increases the entropy. In particular, there is no phase of entropy decrease in the echo. We also discuss the definition of macrostates from the underlying quantum theory and we show that the decay of net magnetization provides a faithful measure of entropy change.

arXiv:1009.0940•Physical Review E•Feb 28, 2011•7 citations

Long-Time Behavior of Spin Echo

Boris V. Fine

It is predicted that (i) spin echoes have two kinds of generic long-time decays: either simple exponential, or a superposition of a monotonic and an oscillatory exponential decays; and (ii) the long-time behavior of spin echo and the long-time behavior of the corresponding homogeneous free induction decay are characterized by the same time constants. This prediction extends to various echo problems both within and beyond nuclear magnetic resonance. Experimental confirmation of this prediction would also support the notion of the eigenvalues of time evolution operators in large quantum systems.

arXiv:cond-mat/0411345•Physical Review Letters•Jun 20, 2005•31 citations

Solid-State NMR Free Induction Decay, Simulated by the System of Classical Magnetic Moments and Quantum Correlations

A. A. Lundin, V. E. Zobov

Abstract In the past decade, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) has been actively used to study the basic principles of quantum computers. It is assumed that quantum correlations play a significant role in their performance. They exist at both low and high temperatures. At the same time, the time correlation functions of nuclear spin systems of solids determine the observed signals in traditional NMR implementations. The separation of such signals into quantum and classical components has not previously been carried out and will be performed in this study for the most important of the correlational functions observed in magnetic resonance: the free induction decay (FID).

Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry B•Sep 1, 2021•7 citations

Quantum beat echoes

T. Hashi, Yukio Fukuda, M Tanigawa

Abstract The spin echo [1 ] discovered by Erwin Hahn in 1950 is one of the most sophisticated phenomena in physics. It demonstrates the fact that the decay of coherence due to the inhomogeneous broadening can be recovered by an ingenious ‘effective time reversal’ technique. Since then, the research on coherent transients has been developed in the field of pulsed magnetic resonance [2]. The advent of the laser stimulated the studies in the optical region. Optical analogues of most of the coherent transients in magnetic resonance have been realized [ 3] except for those in solids, whose mechanisms are based on the spin temperature hypothesis [4] . Thus coherent interactions between radiation and atoms have been extensively studied and the techniques developed have been effectively used in a variety of fields. In the studies of so-called two-level problems the coherence is generated by a direct excitation of the relevant transitions by radiofrequency (r.f.), microwave, or laser fields.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Aug 27, 1992•0 citations

Oscillatory free-induction decay

Axel Schenzle, N. C. Wong, Richard G. Brewer

Large-amplitude oscillations are predicted in the free-induction decay (FID) of atomic or spin two-level quantum systems that are coherently prepared by a resonant electromagnetic field in the form of a square amplitude pulse of duration $T$. The effect should be detectable in nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) or in optical resonance experiments when the transition line shape is inhomogeneously broadened (${T}_{2}^{*}\ensuremath{\ll}{T}_{2}$) and the applied field is intense enough that the pulse area $\ensuremath{\chi}T\ensuremath{\ge}2\ensuremath{\pi}$, where $\ensuremath{\chi}$ is the Rabi frequency. Physically, the effect is due to Rabi oscillations which are generated in the preparative stage and are then reproduced because of atomic memory in the radiative period which follows. The atomic polarization derived from the Bloch equations assumes the form of an integral over the inhomogeneous line shape, and can be evaluated numerically for arbitrary linewidth $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ or analytically when $\ensuremath{\sigma}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. The characteristics of the oscillation are unusual since the oscillation frequency, which is of order $\ensuremath{\chi}$, increases with time while the oscillation envelope vanishes identically for times $t\ensuremath{\ge}2T$. Coherent emission is therefore confined to one pulse width $T$ immediately following the pulse. Previous NMR and infrared FID experiments with small-area pulses ($\ensuremath{\chi}T\ensuremath{\le}4\ensuremath{\pi}$), interpreted erroneously in terms of an edge echo effect, support the oscillatory FID behavior described here. For the case $\ensuremath{\chi}T>4\ensuremath{\pi}$, an experimental test would be even more decisive, as the oscillations are more pronounced.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1980•58 citations
Abstract The spin echo [1] is still striking to those who see it for the first time, as it probably was to Hahn. A nuclear magnetization, having disappeared in a free induction decay (FID), spontaneously reappears as a giant fluctuation. While the phenomenon is easily understood from a mechanical point of view, it seems to verge on a violation of the second law of thermodynamics. It is this problem, about which Hahn [2] and others [3] have written, that we approach here again from what is at least partly a fresh perspective. Our point of view will be that echoesdo violate the second law. After having defended this case we will discuss briefly how the problem can be avoided by appropriate statement of purely macroscopic thermodynamic principles.
In her article “The demons haunting thermodynamics” (Physics Today, November 2021, page 44), Katie Robertson concludes the introductory historical summary by saying that modern developments in quantum foundations have banished the demons “once and for all.” Unfortunately, no explanation or reference is given for that optimistic but controversial conclusion.Robertson presents Erwin Hahn’s 1950 spin-echo experiments11. E. L. Hahn, Phys. Rev. 80, 580 (1950). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.80.580 as the realization of Josef Loschmidt’s vision of reversing momentum. But Hahn clearly described his spin-echo experiments as the effect of traditional spin dynamics for noninteracting spins in a spatially inhomogeneous magnetic field. Although the detailed explanation involves many particular subtleties of NMR dynamics in liquids, Hahn’s interpretation does not imply any violation of the “second law”; it uses only the mild assumption that the spin observables are at thermal equilibrium before each start signal. Robertson’s misunderstanding clearly appears when she writes that “atomic spins that have dephased and become disordered are taken back to their earlier state by an RF pulse” and, a few lines later, “it turns out that the spin-echo experiment is a special case; most systems approach equilibrium instead of retracing their steps back to nonequilibrium states.” The spins have not become disordered: The phase of each spin remains directly related to the magnetic field at the spin’s location, and that relationship explains the echo.Two illuminating articles by Won-Kyu Rhim, Alexander Pines, and John Waugh describe spin-echo experiments in which the irreversible time evolution of a coupled nuclear spin system in solids is apparently “reversed” for a limited duration.22. W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. Lett. 25, 218 (1970); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.25.218W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. B 3, 684 (1971). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.3.684 As the authors explain, the results arise from uniform spin manipulation and are still consistent with the laws of thermodynamics.Another aspect of Robertson’s article that disturbed me is the lack of discussion of the relations between the actual experiments performed on large (macroscopic) systems and the microscopic-scale models used in attempts to make predictions about those results.Consider a mixture of oxygen and hydrogen at atmospheric pressure and room temperature. Standard thermodynamics and statistical mechanics will lead to excellent predictions of the equation of state, specific heat, and the like. But the standard models ignore the possibility of the chemical reaction producing water. Improved models are needed if one is to allow for, say, a slow, isothermal catalytic reaction or—much more complicated—an explosion in an isolated system at constant volume. Spin systems offer a rich variety of experimental possibilities for external manipulation and observation, but the corresponding models are related to the real experimental situations by complicated transformations and approximations that must be chosen according to the situation under study.Robertson invokes two models in the context of Maxwell’s demon. One is a biological machine using a ratchet-style mechanism. But in the cited article, the abstract carefully indicates that the evolution does not violate the second law because the microscopic mechanism is coupled to the exterior of the system.33. V. Serreli et al., Nature 445, 523 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature05452 In the demon-style experiment of Robertson’s figure 3, a complete realistic discussion of an actual implementation of the experiment leads to the similar conclusion that the second law is not violated.My conclusion is that demons and the related controversies are features of models and that the interpretation of actual experiments should be subjected to critical examination, preferably by those who performed the experiment and have a complete knowledge of all details.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. E. L. Hahn, Phys. Rev. 80, 580 (1950). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.80.580, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. Lett. 25, 218 (1970); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.25.218, Google ScholarCrossref, ISIW.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. B 3, 684 (1971). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.3.684, , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. V. Serreli et al., Nature 445, 523 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature05452, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2023 American Institute of Physics.
Spin-echo experiments are often said to constitute an instant of antithermodynamic behavior in a concrete physical system that violates the second law of thermodynamics. We argue that a proper thermodynamic treatment of the effect should take into account the correlations between the spin and the translational degrees of freedom of the molecules. To this end, we construct an entropy functional using Boltzmann macrostates that incorporate both spin and translational degrees of freedom. With this definition there is nothing special in the thermodynamics of spin echoes: dephasing corresponds to Hamiltonian evolution and leaves the entropy unchanged; dissipation increases the entropy. In particular, there is no phase of entropy decrease in the echo. We also discuss the definition of macrostates from the underlying quantum theory and we show that the decay of net magnetization provides a faithful measure of entropy change.
It is predicted that (i) spin echoes have two kinds of generic long-time decays: either simple exponential, or a superposition of a monotonic and an oscillatory exponential decays; and (ii) the long-time behavior of spin echo and the long-time behavior of the corresponding homogeneous free induction decay are characterized by the same time constants. This prediction extends to various echo problems both within and beyond nuclear magnetic resonance. Experimental confirmation of this prediction would also support the notion of the eigenvalues of time evolution operators in large quantum systems.
Abstract In the past decade, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) has been actively used to study the basic principles of quantum computers. It is assumed that quantum correlations play a significant role in their performance. They exist at both low and high temperatures. At the same time, the time correlation functions of nuclear spin systems of solids determine the observed signals in traditional NMR implementations. The separation of such signals into quantum and classical components has not previously been carried out and will be performed in this study for the most important of the correlational functions observed in magnetic resonance: the free induction decay (FID).
Abstract The spin echo [1 ] discovered by Erwin Hahn in 1950 is one of the most sophisticated phenomena in physics. It demonstrates the fact that the decay of coherence due to the inhomogeneous broadening can be recovered by an ingenious ‘effective time reversal’ technique. Since then, the research on coherent transients has been developed in the field of pulsed magnetic resonance [2]. The advent of the laser stimulated the studies in the optical region. Optical analogues of most of the coherent transients in magnetic resonance have been realized [ 3] except for those in solids, whose mechanisms are based on the spin temperature hypothesis [4] . Thus coherent interactions between radiation and atoms have been extensively studied and the techniques developed have been effectively used in a variety of fields. In the studies of so-called two-level problems the coherence is generated by a direct excitation of the relevant transitions by radiofrequency (r.f.), microwave, or laser fields.
Large-amplitude oscillations are predicted in the free-induction decay (FID) of atomic or spin two-level quantum systems that are coherently prepared by a resonant electromagnetic field in the form of a square amplitude pulse of duration TTT. The effect should be detectable in nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) or in optical resonance experiments when the transition line shape is inhomogeneously broadened (${T}_{2}^{*}\ensuremath{\ll}{T}_{2}$) and the applied field is intense enough that the pulse area $\ensuremath{\chi}T\ensuremath{\ge}2\ensuremath{\pi}$, where $\ensuremath{\chi}$ is the Rabi frequency. Physically, the effect is due to Rabi oscillations which are generated in the preparative stage and are then reproduced because of atomic memory in the radiative period which follows. The atomic polarization derived from the Bloch equations assumes the form of an integral over the inhomogeneous line shape, and can be evaluated numerically for arbitrary linewidth $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ or analytically when $\ensuremath{\sigma}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. The characteristics of the oscillation are unusual since the oscillation frequency, which is of order $\ensuremath{\chi}$, increases with time while the oscillation envelope vanishes identically for times $t\ensuremath{\ge}2T$. Coherent emission is therefore confined to one pulse width TTT immediately following the pulse. Previous NMR and infrared FID experiments with small-area pulses ($\ensuremath{\chi}T\ensuremath{\le}4\ensuremath{\pi}$), interpreted erroneously in terms of an edge echo effect, support the oscillatory FID behavior described here. For the case $\ensuremath{\chi}T>4\ensuremath{\pi}$, an experimental test would be even more decisive, as the oscillations are more pronounced.