Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

All the Rest of Classical Physics

Bruce Rosenblum, Fred Kuttner

Published Jun 29, 2006• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Six years after Kelvin made this claim, he hedged: “Physics is essentially complete: There are just two dark clouds on the horizon.” He picked the right clouds: One hid relativity; the other, quantum mechanics. But before we look behind those clouds, we tell a bit more of the nineteenth-century physics we today call “classical.” We will describe the phenomenon of “interference,” which demonstrates something to be a widely extended wave. We will need the concept of electric field. Light is a rapidly varying electric field, and it is with light that the quantum enigma first arose. We will also talk of energy and its “conservation,” its unchanging totality. And we will briefly tell of Einstein’s theory of relativity. Its well-confirmed but hard-to-believe predictions are good psychological practice for the “impossible-to-believe” implications of quantum theory. There’s somewhat more in this chapter than you actually need to know in order to understand the quantum enigma. But it’s good background.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780195175592.003.0005

Related papers

Leaving The Realm Of The Visualizable: Waves, Quanta, And The Rise Of Quantum Theory

Robert L. Nadeau, Menas C. Kafatos

Abstract Toward the end of the nineteenth century Lord Kelvin, one of the best known and most respected physicists at that time, commented that “only two small clouds” remained on the horizon of knowledge in physics. In other words, there were, in Kelvin’s view, only two sources of confusion in our otherwise complete understanding of material reality. The two clouds were the results of the Michelson-Morley experiment, which failed to detect the existence of a hypothetical substance called the ether, and the inability of electromagnetic theory to predict the distribution of radiant energy at different frequencies emitted by an idealized “radiator” called the black body. These problems seemed so small that some established physicists were encouraging those contemplating graduate study in physics to select other fields of scientific study where there was more opportunity to make original contributions to knowledge. What Lord Kelvin could not have anticipated was that efforts to resolve these two anomalies would lead to relativity theory and quantum theory, or to what came to be called the new physics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 2, 1999•0 citations

The Copenhagen Conspiracy

David K. Ferry

At the close of the nineteenth century, we stood on the threshold of one of the greatest periods of science, in which the entire world and understanding of science would be shaken to the core and greatly modified. This explosion of knowledge led ultimately to that same information revolution that we live in today. Planck and Einstein showed that light was not continuous but made of small corpuscles that today we call photons. Einstein changed the understanding of mechanics with his theory of relativity: airplanes became conceivable; radio and television blossomed; and the microelectronics industry, which drives most of modern technology, came into being. New areas of science were greatly expanded and developed, and one of these was quantum mechanics, which is the story to be told here. Yet, the development of quantum mechanics and the leadership of Niels Bohr have distorted the understanding of quantum mechanics in a strange way. There are some who would say that Bohr set back the real understanding of quantum mechanics by half a century. I believe they underestimate his role, and it may be something more like a full century. Whether we call it the Copenhagen interpretation, or the Copenhagen orthodoxy, it is the how for the continuing mysticism provided by Mach that is still remaining in quantum mechanics. It is not the why. Why it perseveres and why it was forced on the field in the first place is an important perception to be studied. In this book, I want to trace the development of quantum mechanics and try to uncover the why.

•Jan 2, 2019•5 citations

Quantum Foundations and the Building Blocks of Matter

To trace the evolution of the universe, it is necessary to understand at least the basic ideas behind quantum physics. Science up until the beginning of the 20 th century could be traced back to its ancient Greek origins beginning perhaps in the sixth century B.C. Its evolution became what is known as the classical view of the world and in particular of physics. The beginning of the 20 th century brought with it two great revolutions in physics both due to Albert Einstein. The first was special relativity to be followed later by general relativity or the theory of gravity; the second was quantum mechanics initiated by Einstein’s discovery of the photoelectric effect, which showed that the energy of the electrons emitted by some materials when light is shown on them depends on the frequency of light not on its intensity. The attempt to reconcile quantum mechanics with concepts brought over from classical mechanics has led to an enormous literature on the foundations of quantum mechanics and much confusion especially among non-physicists and students of physics. Part of this is due to the historical approach to teaching the subject coupled with the understandable struggle to carry over the basic concepts of particle and wave from classical physics.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 12, 2018•0 citations

The peace before the quantum

Andrew Whitaker

Classical physics Quantum theory was produced roughly between 1900 and 1925; it changed our view of the Universe in a revolutionary way. Such is the central preoccupation of this book. Relativity was another revolutionary theory produced between 1905 and 1916; it is less central here. The clear implication of these statements is that, prior to 1900, there was an established body of theory that was widely successful and was thought to provide final answers to fundamental physical questions. This body of theory is known as classical physics . The above is a simplified account of the development of physics over the last few hundred years. There is a good deal of truth in it. By 1900, Newton's Laws of mechanics had been established for over 200 years; they had been overwhelmingly successful in describing a huge range of phenomena, both terrestrial and in the solar system. They were held to be among the greatest human achievements, indeed the very greatest strictly scientific achievement, and practically a direct revelation of divine intent, and by 1900 it seemed unthinkable that they could be challenged. The same could not quite be said of electromagnetism, an area of physics that encompasses electricity, magnetism and, as will be seen later in this chapter, optics. By 1900, what we now take to be the complete and final theory of classical electromagnetism , that of James Clerk Maxwell, was over 30 years old, and the discovery of radio waves by Heinrich Hertz which was acknowledged to confirm the theory, more than ten years old.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 29, 2006•0 citations

The classical physics pathway

P. van der Straten, Harold J. Metcalf

Introduction While it might appear that the nineteenth-century physics presented in this chapter has no place in a topic as quantum mechanically oriented as atomic physics, this is simply not the case. The purpose of this first chapter is to try to convince the readers that the material learned in their early years of studying physics is not disjoint from modern topics, but in fact can provide a foundation for their further understanding. Other examples will occur later. The reader may be a bit surprised to see that the results of the classical description turn out to be so close to the quantum mechanical results. Where there are significant disagreements between classical and quantum descriptions, it is necessary to explain why these occur. The correspondence principle requires that in the limit of large quantum numbers the complete quantum mechanical description must agree with the classical one. It is always better to need fewer of these explanations and to be able to treat physics as a coherent whole instead of a collection of topics. The consequences of classical physics are intuitively familiar, and this is often most helpful in gaining deeper understanding. In fact, the approach taken in very many of the chapters in this book is to start with a purely classical description of a topic, and then transport it directly into the Schrödinger equation. Radiation from an accelerated charge, as treated here in the harmonic case, provides an ideal setting for such pedagogy. Even though classical mechanics is used in place of quantum mechanics, for the case of harmonic motion, the results are quite compatible. The early history of atomic physics contains many topics that are well worth reading about, especially the experimental facilities. For example, there were no electric motors, wire was not readily available, and making even a crude vacuum was an experimental tour de force. Very many textbooks have discussions of these topics, and so they will not be presented here. But the reader is warned that certain oft-repeated modern descriptions are simply wrong. Perhaps the most important notion to be gained from this chapter is that the classical description of a harmonically bound electron provides quite accurate results about the interaction between atoms and light. Of course, the utility of this description is limited because the classical harmonic oscillator has no internal structure, is infinitely deep, and has a continuous energy spectrum.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 31, 2015•0 citations

Historical Outline

David Hodgson

By the end of the nineteenth century, tremendous advances had been made in the understanding of the physical world; and classical physics as developed up to that time provided powerful and coherent models for a wide range of phenomena. In order to suggest the range and power of classical physics, this chapter starts by reviewing briefly some areas of classical physics, and pointing out certain assumptions about the world and about measurement which underlie and are reflected in classical physics. It then outlines, as an extension of classical physics and as part of pre-quantum physics, aspects of the theory of relativity. The remainder of the chapter explains why the reasonable and common-sense views of classical physics had to be discarded; and gives some understanding of the historical development of quantum physics and of the refutations of common-sense views involved.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 4, 1993•0 citations
Abstract Six years after Kelvin made this claim, he hedged: “Physics is essentially complete: There are just two dark clouds on the horizon.” He picked the right clouds: One hid relativity; the other, quantum mechanics. But before we look behind those clouds, we tell a bit more of the nineteenth-century physics we today call “classical.” We will describe the phenomenon of “interference,” which demonstrates something to be a widely extended wave. We will need the concept of electric field. Light is a rapidly varying electric field, and it is with light that the quantum enigma first arose. We will also talk of energy and its “conservation,” its unchanging totality. And we will briefly tell of Einstein’s theory of relativity. Its well-confirmed but hard-to-believe predictions are good psychological practice for the “impossible-to-believe” implications of quantum theory. There’s somewhat more in this chapter than you actually need to know in order to understand the quantum enigma. But it’s good background.
Abstract Toward the end of the nineteenth century Lord Kelvin, one of the best known and most respected physicists at that time, commented that “only two small clouds” remained on the horizon of knowledge in physics. In other words, there were, in Kelvin’s view, only two sources of confusion in our otherwise complete understanding of material reality. The two clouds were the results of the Michelson-Morley experiment, which failed to detect the existence of a hypothetical substance called the ether, and the inability of electromagnetic theory to predict the distribution of radiant energy at different frequencies emitted by an idealized “radiator” called the black body. These problems seemed so small that some established physicists were encouraging those contemplating graduate study in physics to select other fields of scientific study where there was more opportunity to make original contributions to knowledge. What Lord Kelvin could not have anticipated was that efforts to resolve these two anomalies would lead to relativity theory and quantum theory, or to what came to be called the new physics.
At the close of the nineteenth century, we stood on the threshold of one of the greatest periods of science, in which the entire world and understanding of science would be shaken to the core and greatly modified. This explosion of knowledge led ultimately to that same information revolution that we live in today. Planck and Einstein showed that light was not continuous but made of small corpuscles that today we call photons. Einstein changed the understanding of mechanics with his theory of relativity: airplanes became conceivable; radio and television blossomed; and the microelectronics industry, which drives most of modern technology, came into being. New areas of science were greatly expanded and developed, and one of these was quantum mechanics, which is the story to be told here. Yet, the development of quantum mechanics and the leadership of Niels Bohr have distorted the understanding of quantum mechanics in a strange way. There are some who would say that Bohr set back the real understanding of quantum mechanics by half a century. I believe they underestimate his role, and it may be something more like a full century. Whether we call it the Copenhagen interpretation, or the Copenhagen orthodoxy, it is the how for the continuing mysticism provided by Mach that is still remaining in quantum mechanics. It is not the why. Why it perseveres and why it was forced on the field in the first place is an important perception to be studied. In this book, I want to trace the development of quantum mechanics and try to uncover the why.
To trace the evolution of the universe, it is necessary to understand at least the basic ideas behind quantum physics. Science up until the beginning of the 20 th century could be traced back to its ancient Greek origins beginning perhaps in the sixth century B.C. Its evolution became what is known as the classical view of the world and in particular of physics. The beginning of the 20 th century brought with it two great revolutions in physics both due to Albert Einstein. The first was special relativity to be followed later by general relativity or the theory of gravity; the second was quantum mechanics initiated by Einstein’s discovery of the photoelectric effect, which showed that the energy of the electrons emitted by some materials when light is shown on them depends on the frequency of light not on its intensity. The attempt to reconcile quantum mechanics with concepts brought over from classical mechanics has led to an enormous literature on the foundations of quantum mechanics and much confusion especially among non-physicists and students of physics. Part of this is due to the historical approach to teaching the subject coupled with the understandable struggle to carry over the basic concepts of particle and wave from classical physics.
Classical physics Quantum theory was produced roughly between 1900 and 1925; it changed our view of the Universe in a revolutionary way. Such is the central preoccupation of this book. Relativity was another revolutionary theory produced between 1905 and 1916; it is less central here. The clear implication of these statements is that, prior to 1900, there was an established body of theory that was widely successful and was thought to provide final answers to fundamental physical questions. This body of theory is known as classical physics . The above is a simplified account of the development of physics over the last few hundred years. There is a good deal of truth in it. By 1900, Newton's Laws of mechanics had been established for over 200 years; they had been overwhelmingly successful in describing a huge range of phenomena, both terrestrial and in the solar system. They were held to be among the greatest human achievements, indeed the very greatest strictly scientific achievement, and practically a direct revelation of divine intent, and by 1900 it seemed unthinkable that they could be challenged. The same could not quite be said of electromagnetism, an area of physics that encompasses electricity, magnetism and, as will be seen later in this chapter, optics. By 1900, what we now take to be the complete and final theory of classical electromagnetism , that of James Clerk Maxwell, was over 30 years old, and the discovery of radio waves by Heinrich Hertz which was acknowledged to confirm the theory, more than ten years old.
Introduction While it might appear that the nineteenth-century physics presented in this chapter has no place in a topic as quantum mechanically oriented as atomic physics, this is simply not the case. The purpose of this first chapter is to try to convince the readers that the material learned in their early years of studying physics is not disjoint from modern topics, but in fact can provide a foundation for their further understanding. Other examples will occur later. The reader may be a bit surprised to see that the results of the classical description turn out to be so close to the quantum mechanical results. Where there are significant disagreements between classical and quantum descriptions, it is necessary to explain why these occur. The correspondence principle requires that in the limit of large quantum numbers the complete quantum mechanical description must agree with the classical one. It is always better to need fewer of these explanations and to be able to treat physics as a coherent whole instead of a collection of topics. The consequences of classical physics are intuitively familiar, and this is often most helpful in gaining deeper understanding. In fact, the approach taken in very many of the chapters in this book is to start with a purely classical description of a topic, and then transport it directly into the Schrödinger equation. Radiation from an accelerated charge, as treated here in the harmonic case, provides an ideal setting for such pedagogy. Even though classical mechanics is used in place of quantum mechanics, for the case of harmonic motion, the results are quite compatible. The early history of atomic physics contains many topics that are well worth reading about, especially the experimental facilities. For example, there were no electric motors, wire was not readily available, and making even a crude vacuum was an experimental tour de force. Very many textbooks have discussions of these topics, and so they will not be presented here. But the reader is warned that certain oft-repeated modern descriptions are simply wrong. Perhaps the most important notion to be gained from this chapter is that the classical description of a harmonically bound electron provides quite accurate results about the interaction between atoms and light. Of course, the utility of this description is limited because the classical harmonic oscillator has no internal structure, is infinitely deep, and has a continuous energy spectrum.
By the end of the nineteenth century, tremendous advances had been made in the understanding of the physical world; and classical physics as developed up to that time provided powerful and coherent models for a wide range of phenomena. In order to suggest the range and power of classical physics, this chapter starts by reviewing briefly some areas of classical physics, and pointing out certain assumptions about the world and about measurement which underlie and are reflected in classical physics. It then outlines, as an extension of classical physics and as part of pre-quantum physics, aspects of the theory of relativity. The remainder of the chapter explains why the reasonable and common-sense views of classical physics had to be discarded; and gives some understanding of the historical development of quantum physics and of the refutations of common-sense views involved.