Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Quantization

N M J Woodhouse

Published Mar 26, 1992• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract The problem with prequantization is that the Hilbert space it constructs is too large to represent the phase space of a physically reasonable quantum system. In the first example in §8.4 (a cotangent bundle), the Hilbert space contained wave functions that depended on momentum as well as position; and in the third (a Coadjoint orbit), the group representation was reducible. We have already touched on a possible solution: we should admit only sections of B that are parallel along a polarization. We shall now look in detail at how this works. It should be stressed, however, that the physical justification is not based on general mathematical results (such as the Borel-Weil theorem), but on the way in which the construction works in particular examples. It generalizes and unifies a number of quantization techniques that, in the past, have not appeared to have any obvious connection with each other and that have sometimes seemed overspecialized with applications only to particular physical systems. Also it should be noted that not all syrnplectic manifolds admit polarizations (Gotay 1987).

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780198536734.003.0009

Related papers

An Introduction To Geometric Prequantization

Geraci, Joseph

Classical mechanics has a natural mathematical setting in symplectic geometry and it may be asked if the same is true for quantum mechanics. More precisely, is it possible to capture certain quantum idiosyncrasies within the symplectic framework of classical mechanics? Beginning with Dirac, the idea of quantizing a classical system involved associating the phase space variables with Hermitian operators which act on some Hilbert space, as well as associating the Poisson bracket on the phase space with the commutator for the operators. Mathematically the phase space is associated with some symplectic manifold $M$ and the non-degenerate 2-form $ω$, which comes with $M$. Geometric prequantization is a process by which one does this in a mathematically "rigorous" manner and we shall attempt to just introduce the methods here. We do this by exploring this contruction for ($\mathbb{R}^{2n}, \sum_{i=1}^n dp_i \wedge dq_i$) which avoids using complex line bundles in any non-trivial way. One should note however that the Hilbert space one obtains is in fact too "big", in the sense that it has too many functions in order to correspond with actual physically significant Hilbert spaces. Geometric quantization remedies this situation but it should be noted that not all manifolds are prequantizable. We shall not discuss either of these issues however.

arXiv:0911.0964•Nov 5, 2009•4 citations

Operators and Bases

David K. Ferry

In the past few chapters, people have developed the Schrödinger equation and applied it to the solution of a number of quantum mechanical problems, mainly to develop experience with the results of simple and common systems. The results from the examples can be summarized relatively simply. In general, quantization enters the problem through the non-commuting nature of conjugate operators such as position and momentum. It should not be surprising that the set of all possible solutions to a given problem formulation, for example, the set of all sines and cosines for the rectangular barriers, can be shown to form a complete set, and thus can serve as a basis for a many-dimensional linear-vector-space representation of the problem. In treating conjugate operators, such as position and momentum, it was not generally possible to write the Hamiltonian as a function of only position or of only momentum. In general, the Hamiltonian contains both position and momentum.

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 6, 2020•0 citations

Complex Polarizations

N M J Woodhouse

Abstract Real polarizations play an important part in linking classical and quantum mechanics. We shall see that picking a polarization in a classical phase space amounts to choosing a representation in the underlying quantum theory-’representation’ in the sense of a position or momentum space representation. We shall also come across complex representations, which in many ways are easier to handle. An obvious example is the Fock space treatment of the harmonic oscillator, in which the quantum Hilbert space is realized as a space of holomorphic functions Complex representations arise from complex polarizations, which are natural generalizations of real polarizations: one simply relaxes the condition that the Hamiltonian vector fields spanning P should be real.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 26, 1992•0 citations

Prequantization

N M J Woodhouse

Abstract These are Dirac’s quantum conditions (Dirac 1925): they imply that the quantum operators form a Hilbert space representation of the classical observables. In his terms, the Poisson bracket is the classical analogue of the quantum commentator. The quantum conditions do not determine the underlying quantum system uniquely. Nor is every representation of the classical observables a physically reasonable quantization.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 26, 1992•0 citations

The geometry of real reducible polarizations in quantum mechanics

Carlos Prieto, Raffaele F. Vitolo

Abstract The formulation of geometric quantization contains several axioms and assumptions. We show that for real polarizations we can generalize the standard geometric quantization procedure by introducing an arbitrary connection on the polarization bundle. The existence of reducible quantum structures leads to considering the class of Liouville symplectic manifolds. Our main application of this modified geometric quantization scheme is to quantum mechanics on Riemannian manifolds. With this method we obtain an energy operator without the scalar curvature term that appears in the standard formulation, thus agreeing with the usual expression found in the physics literature.

arXiv:1608.00031•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 11, 2017•2 citations

Ordering problem in quantum mechanics: Prime quantization and a physical interpretation

S. Ali, H. D. Doebner

A method for quantizing a classical system, based upon the notion of localization on phase space, is developed. This method, to which is given the name prime quantization, is based upon the mathematical theory of positive-operator-valued measures and their relationship to reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces, and to a notion of generalized kinematical variables related to phase space. For a system with ${\mathrm{openR}}^{n}$ as its configuration space, it has the advantage of being able to connect the well-known problem of ordering in quantum mechanics to the choice of a measuring apparatus in a joint measurement of position and momentum (within the limits of the uncertainty principle). Moreover, for such a system, a choice of ordering in the present context also turns out to be a choice of polarization in the method of geometric quantization.

Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1990•24 citations
Abstract The problem with prequantization is that the Hilbert space it constructs is too large to represent the phase space of a physically reasonable quantum system. In the first example in §8.4 (a cotangent bundle), the Hilbert space contained wave functions that depended on momentum as well as position; and in the third (a Coadjoint orbit), the group representation was reducible. We have already touched on a possible solution: we should admit only sections of B that are parallel along a polarization. We shall now look in detail at how this works. It should be stressed, however, that the physical justification is not based on general mathematical results (such as the Borel-Weil theorem), but on the way in which the construction works in particular examples. It generalizes and unifies a number of quantization techniques that, in the past, have not appeared to have any obvious connection with each other and that have sometimes seemed overspecialized with applications only to particular physical systems. Also it should be noted that not all syrnplectic manifolds admit polarizations (Gotay 1987).
Classical mechanics has a natural mathematical setting in symplectic geometry and it may be asked if the same is true for quantum mechanics. More precisely, is it possible to capture certain quantum idiosyncrasies within the symplectic framework of classical mechanics? Beginning with Dirac, the idea of quantizing a classical system involved associating the phase space variables with Hermitian operators which act on some Hilbert space, as well as associating the Poisson bracket on the phase space with the commutator for the operators. Mathematically the phase space is associated with some symplectic manifold MMM and the non-degenerate 2-form ωωω, which comes with MMM. Geometric prequantization is a process by which one does this in a mathematically "rigorous" manner and we shall attempt to just introduce the methods here. We do this by exploring this contruction for (R2n,∑i=1ndpi∧dqi\mathbb{R}^{2n}, \sum_{i=1}^n dp_i \wedge dq_iR2n,∑i=1n​dpi​∧dqi​) which avoids using complex line bundles in any non-trivial way. One should note however that the Hilbert space one obtains is in fact too "big", in the sense that it has too many functions in order to correspond with actual physically significant Hilbert spaces. Geometric quantization remedies this situation but it should be noted that not all manifolds are prequantizable. We shall not discuss either of these issues however.
In the past few chapters, people have developed the Schrödinger equation and applied it to the solution of a number of quantum mechanical problems, mainly to develop experience with the results of simple and common systems. The results from the examples can be summarized relatively simply. In general, quantization enters the problem through the non-commuting nature of conjugate operators such as position and momentum. It should not be surprising that the set of all possible solutions to a given problem formulation, for example, the set of all sines and cosines for the rectangular barriers, can be shown to form a complete set, and thus can serve as a basis for a many-dimensional linear-vector-space representation of the problem. In treating conjugate operators, such as position and momentum, it was not generally possible to write the Hamiltonian as a function of only position or of only momentum. In general, the Hamiltonian contains both position and momentum.
Abstract Real polarizations play an important part in linking classical and quantum mechanics. We shall see that picking a polarization in a classical phase space amounts to choosing a representation in the underlying quantum theory-’representation’ in the sense of a position or momentum space representation. We shall also come across complex representations, which in many ways are easier to handle. An obvious example is the Fock space treatment of the harmonic oscillator, in which the quantum Hilbert space is realized as a space of holomorphic functions Complex representations arise from complex polarizations, which are natural generalizations of real polarizations: one simply relaxes the condition that the Hamiltonian vector fields spanning P should be real.
Abstract The formulation of geometric quantization contains several axioms and assumptions. We show that for real polarizations we can generalize the standard geometric quantization procedure by introducing an arbitrary connection on the polarization bundle. The existence of reducible quantum structures leads to considering the class of Liouville symplectic manifolds. Our main application of this modified geometric quantization scheme is to quantum mechanics on Riemannian manifolds. With this method we obtain an energy operator without the scalar curvature term that appears in the standard formulation, thus agreeing with the usual expression found in the physics literature.
A method for quantizing a classical system, based upon the notion of localization on phase space, is developed. This method, to which is given the name prime quantization, is based upon the mathematical theory of positive-operator-valued measures and their relationship to reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces, and to a notion of generalized kinematical variables related to phase space. For a system with openRn{\mathrm{openR}}^{n}openRn as its configuration space, it has the advantage of being able to connect the well-known problem of ordering in quantum mechanics to the choice of a measuring apparatus in a joint measurement of position and momentum (within the limits of the uncertainty principle). Moreover, for such a system, a choice of ordering in the present context also turns out to be a choice of polarization in the method of geometric quantization.