Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Lbe For Quantum Mechanics

Sauro Succi

Published Jun 28, 2001• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract The lattice Boltzmann concepts and applications described so far refer to classical (non-quantum) physics. Whether this limitation is strictly scientific or purely contingental in character, it is difficult to say. However, it appears plausible to speculate that at least part of the LBE assets should be exportable to the quantum world. In principle, this does not even require much of a conceptual jump, since it has been known for a long time that quantum mechanics can be formulated in a fluid dynamic language. This analogy is precisely the stepping stone for this final chapter: stay with us, LBE goes quantum mechanical! Intriguing analogies between quantum mechanics and fluid mechanics have been pointed out since the earliest days of quantum theory [212]. The orthodox tenet is that these analogies are purely formal in character and do not bear upon the basic physics of quantum phenomena. A less orthodox, albeit not minor, stream of thought insists instead that quantum mechanics and notably its philosophical hard-core, Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, are nothing but a mirror of our ignorance of the underlying (hidden) microscopic physical level. This leads to the puzzling theory of ‘hidden variables’ which can be traced back to Einstein and subsequently to D. Bohm and others [213]. It is not our intention here to enter this fascinating and still open subject [214]. We turn to a practical question instead: what can the analogy do for us in terms of numerical modeling of evolutionary quantum mechanical phenomena? The question is legitimate because, regardless of its philosophical implications, the fluid analogy certainly provides an intuitive and sound basis to develop numerical methods for time-dependent quantum mechanics. In particular, it appears reasonable to ask whether the advantages brought about by LBE in fluid dynamics can (by means of the fluid analogy) be exported to the context of quantum mechanics. Before we put forward our discrete kinetic theory version of the analogy, it is useful to provide a cursory survey of the main ideas behind the analogy itself. To this end, a short recap of basic notions of quantum mechanics is in order.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780198503989.003.0013

Related papers

Quantum Lattice Boltzmann (QLB)

Sauro Succi

Abstract The Lattice Boltzmann concepts and applications described so far refer to classical, i.e., non-quantum physics. However, the LB formalism is not restricted to classical Newtonian mechanics and indeed an LB formulation of quantum mechanics, going by the name of quantum LB (QLB) has been in existence for more than two decades. Even though it would far-fetched to say that QLB represents a mainstream, in the recent years it has captured some revived interest, mostly on account of recent developments in quantum-computing research. This chapter provides an account of the QLB formulation: stay tuned, LBE goes quantum!

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 19, 2018•0 citations

Quantum basics

Phuong Mai Dinh, Jesús Navarro, E. Suraud

Quantum fluids are fluids, indeed. We have seen in the previous chapter what it means from a classical physics point of view. But quantum fluids are by definition ruled by quantum physics, as well. The goal of this chapter is to introduce some key concepts of quantum physics necessary to understand what makes a fluid a quantum one or rather what quantum property makes an ensemble of particles a quantum fluid. We are here precisely at the edge of our basic intuition of quantum physics. Indeed, one usually associates the notion of quantum object to a microscopic nature and it may thus a priori seem paradoxical to link the word quantum to a macroscopic object, such as the notion of fluid. Thinking it over a bit deeper, quantum physics is certainly present at all scales and we are confronted with quantum mechanics through the many electronic devices which have invaded our everyday life. And it actually turns out that, as we will see later on, most of these quantum devices are directly connected to the notion of quantum fluids, the case of electron fluids being certainly the most common one in such devices. Quantum physics has for sure deeply modified our everyday life. But it has also changed our perception of the world, and as we shall see in this chapter, it is precisely this new vision of the world which allows us to understand the concept of quantum fluids underlying so many physical systems.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 2, 2024•0 citations

Should Philosophers Take Lessons from Quantum Theory?

Christopher Norris

This essay examines some of the arguments in David Deutsch's book The Fabric of Reality , chief among them its case for the so-called many-universe interpretation of quantum mechanics (QM), presented as the only physically and logically consistent solution to the QM paradoxes of wave/particle dualism, remote simultaneous interaction, the observer-induced 'collapse of the wave-packet', etc. The hypothesis assumes that all possible outcomes are realized in every such momentary 'collapse', since the observer splits off into so many parallel, coexisting, but epistemically non-interaccessible 'worlds' whose subsequent branchings constitute the lifeline-or experiential world-series- for each of those proliferating centres of consciousness. Although Deutsch concedes that his 'multiverse' theory is counter-intuitive, he none the less takes it to be borne out beyond question by the sheer observational/predictive success of QM and the conceptual dilemmas that supposedly arise with alternative (single-universe) accounts. Moreover, he claims the theory resolves a range of longstanding philosophical problems, notably those of mind/body dualism, the various traditional paradoxes of time, and the freewill/determinism issue. The essay suggests on the contrary, that Deutsch unwittingly transposes into the framework of presentday quantum debate speculative themes from the history of rationalist metaphysics, often with bizarre or philosophically dubious results, and that he rules out at least one promising rival account, namely Bohm's 'hidden variables' theory. It goes on to consider reasons for resistance to that theory among proponents of the 'orthodox' (Copenhagen) doctrine, and for the strong anti-realist, at times even irrationalist bias that has characterized much of this discussion since Bohr's debates with Einstein about quantum non-locality, observer-intervention, and the limits of precise measurement. Finally, the contrast is pointed out between Deutsch's ontologically extravagant use of the many-worlds hypothesis (akin to certain ideas advanced by speculative metaphysicians from Leibniz down) and those realist modes of counterfactual reasoning- e.g. in Kripke and the early Putnam- which deploy similar arguments to very different causal-explanatory ends.

Inquiry•Oct 1, 1999•2 citations

Investigating the Numerical Applicability of Analogies between Quantum Mechanics and Fluid Mechanics

Anton Scotte, Emil Zeidlitz

Investigating the Numerical Applicability of Analogies between Quantum Mechanics and Fluid Mechanics

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Brownian motion

A. O. Caldeira

In the two preceding chapters of this book we have analyzed many interesting physical phenomena in magnetic and superconducting systems which could adequately be described by phenomenological dynamical equations in terms of collective classical variables. One unavoidable consequence of this approach is that, as we are always dealing with variables that describe only part of the whole system, the interaction with the remaining degrees of freedom shows up through the presence of non-conservative terms which describe the relaxation of those variables to equilibrium. Those phenomenological equations are able to describe a very rich diversity of physical phenomena, in particular, those which can be studied in the context of quantum mechanics. Since these are genuine dynamical equations, there is no reason why they should be restricted to classical physics. However, as we do not yet know how to treat dissipative effects in quantum mechanics, we have deliberately neglected those terms when trying to describe quantum mechanical effects of our collective variables.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 20, 2014•0 citations

Apparent Retrocausation as a Consequence of Orthodox Quantum Mechanics Refined to Accommodate the Principle of Sufficient Reason

Henry Pierce Stapp

The principle of sufficient reason asserts that anything that happens does so for a reason: no definite state of affairs can come into being unless there is a sufficient reason why that particular thing should happen. This principle is usually attributed to Leibniz, although the first recorded Western philosopher to use it was Anaximander of Miletus. The demand that nature be rational, in the sense that it be compatible with the principle of sufficient reason, conflicts with a basic feature of contemporary orthodox physical theory, namely the notion that nature's response to the probing action of an observer is determined by pure chance, and hence on the basis of absolutely no reason at all. This appeal to pure chance can be deemed to have no rational fundamental place in reason-based Western science. It is argued here, on the basis of the other basic principles of quantum physics, that in a world that conforms to the principle of sufficient reason, the usual quantum statistical rules will naturally emerge at the pragmatic level, in cases where the reason behind Nature's choice of response is unknown, but that the usual statistics can become biased in an empirically manifest and apparently retrocausal way when the reason for the choice is empirically identifiable. It is shown here that if the statistical laws of quantum mechanics were to be biased in a certain plausible way then the basically forward-in-time unfolding of empirical reality described by orthodox quantum mechanics would generate the appearance of backward-time-causation of the kind that have been reported in the scientific literature.

arXiv:1111.6584•Nov 28, 2011•0 citations
Abstract The lattice Boltzmann concepts and applications described so far refer to classical (non-quantum) physics. Whether this limitation is strictly scientific or purely contingental in character, it is difficult to say. However, it appears plausible to speculate that at least part of the LBE assets should be exportable to the quantum world. In principle, this does not even require much of a conceptual jump, since it has been known for a long time that quantum mechanics can be formulated in a fluid dynamic language. This analogy is precisely the stepping stone for this final chapter: stay with us, LBE goes quantum mechanical! Intriguing analogies between quantum mechanics and fluid mechanics have been pointed out since the earliest days of quantum theory [212]. The orthodox tenet is that these analogies are purely formal in character and do not bear upon the basic physics of quantum phenomena. A less orthodox, albeit not minor, stream of thought insists instead that quantum mechanics and notably its philosophical hard-core, Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, are nothing but a mirror of our ignorance of the underlying (hidden) microscopic physical level. This leads to the puzzling theory of ‘hidden variables’ which can be traced back to Einstein and subsequently to D. Bohm and others [213]. It is not our intention here to enter this fascinating and still open subject [214]. We turn to a practical question instead: what can the analogy do for us in terms of numerical modeling of evolutionary quantum mechanical phenomena? The question is legitimate because, regardless of its philosophical implications, the fluid analogy certainly provides an intuitive and sound basis to develop numerical methods for time-dependent quantum mechanics. In particular, it appears reasonable to ask whether the advantages brought about by LBE in fluid dynamics can (by means of the fluid analogy) be exported to the context of quantum mechanics. Before we put forward our discrete kinetic theory version of the analogy, it is useful to provide a cursory survey of the main ideas behind the analogy itself. To this end, a short recap of basic notions of quantum mechanics is in order.
Abstract The Lattice Boltzmann concepts and applications described so far refer to classical, i.e., non-quantum physics. However, the LB formalism is not restricted to classical Newtonian mechanics and indeed an LB formulation of quantum mechanics, going by the name of quantum LB (QLB) has been in existence for more than two decades. Even though it would far-fetched to say that QLB represents a mainstream, in the recent years it has captured some revived interest, mostly on account of recent developments in quantum-computing research. This chapter provides an account of the QLB formulation: stay tuned, LBE goes quantum!
Quantum fluids are fluids, indeed. We have seen in the previous chapter what it means from a classical physics point of view. But quantum fluids are by definition ruled by quantum physics, as well. The goal of this chapter is to introduce some key concepts of quantum physics necessary to understand what makes a fluid a quantum one or rather what quantum property makes an ensemble of particles a quantum fluid. We are here precisely at the edge of our basic intuition of quantum physics. Indeed, one usually associates the notion of quantum object to a microscopic nature and it may thus a priori seem paradoxical to link the word quantum to a macroscopic object, such as the notion of fluid. Thinking it over a bit deeper, quantum physics is certainly present at all scales and we are confronted with quantum mechanics through the many electronic devices which have invaded our everyday life. And it actually turns out that, as we will see later on, most of these quantum devices are directly connected to the notion of quantum fluids, the case of electron fluids being certainly the most common one in such devices. Quantum physics has for sure deeply modified our everyday life. But it has also changed our perception of the world, and as we shall see in this chapter, it is precisely this new vision of the world which allows us to understand the concept of quantum fluids underlying so many physical systems.
This essay examines some of the arguments in David Deutsch's book The Fabric of Reality , chief among them its case for the so-called many-universe interpretation of quantum mechanics (QM), presented as the only physically and logically consistent solution to the QM paradoxes of wave/particle dualism, remote simultaneous interaction, the observer-induced 'collapse of the wave-packet', etc. The hypothesis assumes that all possible outcomes are realized in every such momentary 'collapse', since the observer splits off into so many parallel, coexisting, but epistemically non-interaccessible 'worlds' whose subsequent branchings constitute the lifeline-or experiential world-series- for each of those proliferating centres of consciousness. Although Deutsch concedes that his 'multiverse' theory is counter-intuitive, he none the less takes it to be borne out beyond question by the sheer observational/predictive success of QM and the conceptual dilemmas that supposedly arise with alternative (single-universe) accounts. Moreover, he claims the theory resolves a range of longstanding philosophical problems, notably those of mind/body dualism, the various traditional paradoxes of time, and the freewill/determinism issue. The essay suggests on the contrary, that Deutsch unwittingly transposes into the framework of presentday quantum debate speculative themes from the history of rationalist metaphysics, often with bizarre or philosophically dubious results, and that he rules out at least one promising rival account, namely Bohm's 'hidden variables' theory. It goes on to consider reasons for resistance to that theory among proponents of the 'orthodox' (Copenhagen) doctrine, and for the strong anti-realist, at times even irrationalist bias that has characterized much of this discussion since Bohr's debates with Einstein about quantum non-locality, observer-intervention, and the limits of precise measurement. Finally, the contrast is pointed out between Deutsch's ontologically extravagant use of the many-worlds hypothesis (akin to certain ideas advanced by speculative metaphysicians from Leibniz down) and those realist modes of counterfactual reasoning- e.g. in Kripke and the early Putnam- which deploy similar arguments to very different causal-explanatory ends.
In the two preceding chapters of this book we have analyzed many interesting physical phenomena in magnetic and superconducting systems which could adequately be described by phenomenological dynamical equations in terms of collective classical variables. One unavoidable consequence of this approach is that, as we are always dealing with variables that describe only part of the whole system, the interaction with the remaining degrees of freedom shows up through the presence of non-conservative terms which describe the relaxation of those variables to equilibrium. Those phenomenological equations are able to describe a very rich diversity of physical phenomena, in particular, those which can be studied in the context of quantum mechanics. Since these are genuine dynamical equations, there is no reason why they should be restricted to classical physics. However, as we do not yet know how to treat dissipative effects in quantum mechanics, we have deliberately neglected those terms when trying to describe quantum mechanical effects of our collective variables.
The principle of sufficient reason asserts that anything that happens does so for a reason: no definite state of affairs can come into being unless there is a sufficient reason why that particular thing should happen. This principle is usually attributed to Leibniz, although the first recorded Western philosopher to use it was Anaximander of Miletus. The demand that nature be rational, in the sense that it be compatible with the principle of sufficient reason, conflicts with a basic feature of contemporary orthodox physical theory, namely the notion that nature's response to the probing action of an observer is determined by pure chance, and hence on the basis of absolutely no reason at all. This appeal to pure chance can be deemed to have no rational fundamental place in reason-based Western science. It is argued here, on the basis of the other basic principles of quantum physics, that in a world that conforms to the principle of sufficient reason, the usual quantum statistical rules will naturally emerge at the pragmatic level, in cases where the reason behind Nature's choice of response is unknown, but that the usual statistics can become biased in an empirically manifest and apparently retrocausal way when the reason for the choice is empirically identifiable. It is shown here that if the statistical laws of quantum mechanics were to be biased in a certain plausible way then the basically forward-in-time unfolding of empirical reality described by orthodox quantum mechanics would generate the appearance of backward-time-causation of the kind that have been reported in the scientific literature.