Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Spatially resolving classical and quantum entanglement with structured photons

Cade Peters, Pedro Ornelas, Isaac M. Nape, Andrew Forbes

Published Nov 3, 2023• 13 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Nonseparability in classical and quantum states of light gives rise to the notions of classical (local) and quantum (nonlocal) entanglement, usually defined as global features of the fields and states. Here we use concurrence as a measure of this nonseparability and show that it can be spatially resolved, revealing regions of maximum nonseparability and regions with no nonseparability. We use the topical examples of vectorial structured light and its quantum analog, a hybrid spatial mode and polarization entangled states, to test the approach on both local and nonlocal forms of entanglement. Our work has wide reaching implications, for instance, in understanding the spatial dependence of coherence and polarization in vectorial light, as well as in quantum entangled states for imaging, where spatial correlations are vital.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.108.053502

Related papers

Free-space local nonseparability dynamics of vector modes

Xiaobo Hu, Benjamin Perez-García, Valeria Rodríguez-Fajardo +3 more

One of the most prominent features of quantum entanglement is its invariability under local unitary transformations, which implies that the degree of entanglement or nonseparability remains constant during free-space propagation, true for both quantum and classically entangled modes. Here we demonstrate an exception to this rule using a carefully engineered vectorial light field, and we study its nonseparability dynamics upon free-space propagation. We show that the local nonseparability between the spatial and polarization degrees of freedom dramatically decays to zero while preserving the purity of the state and hence the global nonseparability. We show this by numerical simulations and corroborate it experimentally. Our results evince novel properties of classically entangled modes and point to the need for new measures of nonseparability for such vectorial fields, while paving the way for novel applications for customized structured light.

arXiv:2009.13687•Photonics Research•Jan 29, 2021•36 citations

Basis-independent tomography and nonseparability witnesses of pure complex vectorial light fields by Stokes projections

Adam Selyem, Carmelo Rosales‐Guzmán, Sarah Croke +2 more

Complex vectorial light fields, nonseparable in their polarization and spatial degree of freedom, are of relevance in a wide variety of research areas encompassing microscopy, metrology, communication, and topological studies. Controversially, they have been suggested as analogs to quantum entanglement, raising fundamental questions on the relation between nonseparability in classical systems, and entanglement in quantum systems. We perform basis-independent tomography of arbitrary pure vectorial light fields using spatially resolved Stokes projections. Moreover, we propose and demonstrate that concurrence, as a nonseparability witness for any pure vectorial light field, can be extracted from global Stokes projections, without assessing the spatial degree of freedom.

arXiv:1902.07988•Physical Review A•Dec 23, 2019•85 citations

Time-varying classical local entanglement of ultrafast vector light pulses

Zhangyu Zhou, Shuoshuo Zhang, Jielei Ni +5 more

As structured optical fields with spatially inhomogeneous polarization distributions, vector beams have attracted widespread attention for their great applications across multiple fields. The coupling between spatial modes and polarization states in vector beams results in nonseparability analogous to quantum entangled states, referred to as classical entanglement. This concept has garnered considerable scholarly interest, due to its capacity to facilitate quantum-inspired approaches for the characterization of vector optical fields, leading to noteworthy applications such as metrological sensing, communication encryption, and quantum computing. However, most investigations concerning classical entanglement have focused on vector optical fields within the spatial domain, while the classical entanglement characteristics of ultrafast vector beam pulses in the temporal domain remain to be revealed. Here, we investigate the classical local entanglement of ultrafast vector beam pulses in the temporal domain. Through theoretical interpretation and experimental verification, time-varying nonseparability has been demonstrated throughout the pulse duration. The dynamic evolution of spatially vectorial polarization states on femtosecond timescales was measured. The temporal evolution of the classical entanglement and the associated density matrix were analyzed using quantum state tomography. This research provides, to our knowledge, novel perspectives for investigating quantum-classical optical analogies in the temporal domain, advancing deeper fundamental understanding of entanglement.

Photonics Research•Oct 1, 2025•1 citation

Free-space local nonseparability dynamics of parabolic vector modes

Carmelo Rosales‐Guzmán, Xiaobo Hu, Valeria Rodríguez-Fajardo +3 more

It is well known that entanglement is invariant to local unitary transformations, this implies the degree of entanglement or non-separability remains constant during free-space propagation, which is true for both quantum and classically-entangled modes. Here we demonstrate an exception to this rule using a carefully engineered vectorial light field, and study its non-separability dynamics upon free-space propagation. We show that the local non-separability between the spatial and polarisation degrees of freedom dramatically decays to zero, while preserving the purity of the state and hence the global non-separability. We show this by numerical simulations and corroborate it experimentally. Our results evince novel properties of classically-entangled modes, point to the need for new measures of non-separability for such vectorial fields, while paving the way to novel applications for customised structured light.

Laser Beam Shaping•Jul 30, 2021•1 citation

Tomography of structured light beams: exploring analogies with quantum measurement theory

Sarah Croke, Harry Jimbrown, Mustafa A. Al Khafaji +3 more

There is a fruitful interplay in the literature between quantum information theory and the study of vector beams, inspired by the mathematical structure shared by quantum entanglement and classical beams of light. As an example, measures of entanglement, notably concurrence, are widely used as measures of the quality of a vector beam. In addition, there is a close analogy, previously exploited in the literature, between polarimetry and qubit state tomography, which become identical tasks in the single photon limit. In this talk I will discuss the use of so-called POVM measurements in spatially-resolved polarimetry to characterise structured light beams.

Complex Light and Optical Forces•Mar 4, 2021•0 citations

Quantum correlations in separable multi-mode states and in classically entangled light

N Korolkova, Gerd Leuchs

In this review we discuss intriguing properties of apparently classical optical fields, that go beyond purely classical context and allow us to speak about quantum characteristics of such fields and about their applications in quantum technologies. We briefly define the genuinely quantum concepts of entanglement and steering. We then move to the boarder line between classical and quantum world introducing quantum discord, a more general concept of quantum coherence, and finally a controversial notion of classical entanglement. To unveil the quantum aspects of often classically perceived systems, we focus more in detail on quantum discordant correlations between the light modes and on nonseparability properties of optical vector fields leading to entanglement between different degrees of freedom of a single beam. To illustrate the aptitude of different types of correlated systems to act as quantum or quantum-like resource, entanglement activation from discord, high-precision measurements with classical entanglement and quantum information tasks using intra-system correlations are discussed. The common themes behind the versatile quantum properties of seemingly classical light are coherence, polarization and inter and intra-mode quantum correlations.

arXiv:1903.00469•Reports on Progress in Physics•Mar 4, 2019•44 citations
Nonseparability in classical and quantum states of light gives rise to the notions of classical (local) and quantum (nonlocal) entanglement, usually defined as global features of the fields and states. Here we use concurrence as a measure of this nonseparability and show that it can be spatially resolved, revealing regions of maximum nonseparability and regions with no nonseparability. We use the topical examples of vectorial structured light and its quantum analog, a hybrid spatial mode and polarization entangled states, to test the approach on both local and nonlocal forms of entanglement. Our work has wide reaching implications, for instance, in understanding the spatial dependence of coherence and polarization in vectorial light, as well as in quantum entangled states for imaging, where spatial correlations are vital.
One of the most prominent features of quantum entanglement is its invariability under local unitary transformations, which implies that the degree of entanglement or nonseparability remains constant during free-space propagation, true for both quantum and classically entangled modes. Here we demonstrate an exception to this rule using a carefully engineered vectorial light field, and we study its nonseparability dynamics upon free-space propagation. We show that the local nonseparability between the spatial and polarization degrees of freedom dramatically decays to zero while preserving the purity of the state and hence the global nonseparability. We show this by numerical simulations and corroborate it experimentally. Our results evince novel properties of classically entangled modes and point to the need for new measures of nonseparability for such vectorial fields, while paving the way for novel applications for customized structured light.
Complex vectorial light fields, nonseparable in their polarization and spatial degree of freedom, are of relevance in a wide variety of research areas encompassing microscopy, metrology, communication, and topological studies. Controversially, they have been suggested as analogs to quantum entanglement, raising fundamental questions on the relation between nonseparability in classical systems, and entanglement in quantum systems. We perform basis-independent tomography of arbitrary pure vectorial light fields using spatially resolved Stokes projections. Moreover, we propose and demonstrate that concurrence, as a nonseparability witness for any pure vectorial light field, can be extracted from global Stokes projections, without assessing the spatial degree of freedom.
As structured optical fields with spatially inhomogeneous polarization distributions, vector beams have attracted widespread attention for their great applications across multiple fields. The coupling between spatial modes and polarization states in vector beams results in nonseparability analogous to quantum entangled states, referred to as classical entanglement. This concept has garnered considerable scholarly interest, due to its capacity to facilitate quantum-inspired approaches for the characterization of vector optical fields, leading to noteworthy applications such as metrological sensing, communication encryption, and quantum computing. However, most investigations concerning classical entanglement have focused on vector optical fields within the spatial domain, while the classical entanglement characteristics of ultrafast vector beam pulses in the temporal domain remain to be revealed. Here, we investigate the classical local entanglement of ultrafast vector beam pulses in the temporal domain. Through theoretical interpretation and experimental verification, time-varying nonseparability has been demonstrated throughout the pulse duration. The dynamic evolution of spatially vectorial polarization states on femtosecond timescales was measured. The temporal evolution of the classical entanglement and the associated density matrix were analyzed using quantum state tomography. This research provides, to our knowledge, novel perspectives for investigating quantum-classical optical analogies in the temporal domain, advancing deeper fundamental understanding of entanglement.
It is well known that entanglement is invariant to local unitary transformations, this implies the degree of entanglement or non-separability remains constant during free-space propagation, which is true for both quantum and classically-entangled modes. Here we demonstrate an exception to this rule using a carefully engineered vectorial light field, and study its non-separability dynamics upon free-space propagation. We show that the local non-separability between the spatial and polarisation degrees of freedom dramatically decays to zero, while preserving the purity of the state and hence the global non-separability. We show this by numerical simulations and corroborate it experimentally. Our results evince novel properties of classically-entangled modes, point to the need for new measures of non-separability for such vectorial fields, while paving the way to novel applications for customised structured light.
There is a fruitful interplay in the literature between quantum information theory and the study of vector beams, inspired by the mathematical structure shared by quantum entanglement and classical beams of light. As an example, measures of entanglement, notably concurrence, are widely used as measures of the quality of a vector beam. In addition, there is a close analogy, previously exploited in the literature, between polarimetry and qubit state tomography, which become identical tasks in the single photon limit. In this talk I will discuss the use of so-called POVM measurements in spatially-resolved polarimetry to characterise structured light beams.
In this review we discuss intriguing properties of apparently classical optical fields, that go beyond purely classical context and allow us to speak about quantum characteristics of such fields and about their applications in quantum technologies. We briefly define the genuinely quantum concepts of entanglement and steering. We then move to the boarder line between classical and quantum world introducing quantum discord, a more general concept of quantum coherence, and finally a controversial notion of classical entanglement. To unveil the quantum aspects of often classically perceived systems, we focus more in detail on quantum discordant correlations between the light modes and on nonseparability properties of optical vector fields leading to entanglement between different degrees of freedom of a single beam. To illustrate the aptitude of different types of correlated systems to act as quantum or quantum-like resource, entanglement activation from discord, high-precision measurements with classical entanglement and quantum information tasks using intra-system correlations are discussed. The common themes behind the versatile quantum properties of seemingly classical light are coherence, polarization and inter and intra-mode quantum correlations.