Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Putting it to the test

Jim Baggott

Published Apr 16, 1992• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Work on hidden variable solutions to the conceptual problems of quantum theory did not exactly stop after the publication of von Neumann’s ‘impossibility proof, but then it hardly represented an expanding field of scientific activity. About 20 years elapsed before David Bohm, a young American physicist, began to take more than a passing interest in the subject. His first, all-important contributions to the debate over the interpretation of quantum theory were made in 1951.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780198555766.003.0004

Related papers

Von Neumann, Bell and Bohm

Jeremy Bernstein

This article discusses von Neumann's "proof" that hidden variable theories are impossible.

arXiv:1102.2222•Feb 10, 2011•2 citations

The Epistemological Development of Quantum Measurement Theory——From the Standard Interpretation to Hidden Variable Theory

Hongfang Li

The problem of quantum measurement is an important epistemological problem in philosophical researches of quantum mechanics.Aim at von Neumann's wave packet collapse hypothesis and Bohr's quantum-classical dichotomy,physicists had put forward some alternative solutions that are different from the standard interpretation since 1950s.As historical outcomes in endless flow of development of scientific theory,these alternative solutions indicate that the development of scientific theory always tends to aspects of consistency,apprehensible and testability.

Ziran bianzhengfa yanjiu•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

The hidden-variables controversy in quantum physics

Trevor Pinch

The author discusses the work of Bohm in the 1950s on the hidden variables approach to quantum theory, and the subsequent debate and controversy that it produced.

Physics Education•Jan 1, 1979•8 citations

Conclusion

Vladimir B. Braginsky, Farid Ya Khalili, Kip S. Thorne

The background for this book was a shift of interest among experimental physicists that began approximately 20 years ago. The shift was from quantum measurements on large ensembles of microscopic quantum objects, to experiments of very high precision on single, macroscopic objects. This shift was accompanied by developments in the “culture” of such measurements and the invention and elaboration of new experimental methods. In parallel with these experimental developments, there was a noticeable increase of theoretical interest in the foundations and interpretation of quantum theory, and even in attempts to revise its foundational principles. Although these efforts have not produced any significant changes in the fundamental structure of quantum theory, they have revealed a rather large number of “blank spots” and unsolved problems, to which the founders of quantum physics had paid no attention. A reasonable number of the blank spots have been filled in during the past decade.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 24, 1992•0 citations

The Theorem of John S. Bell

Jim Baggott, John L. Heilbron

Abstract In 1957, Bohm and Yakir Aharonov alighted on experiments on correlated photons performed some years earlier. Although the experimenters had not looked for EPR-type correlations, Bohm and Aharonov found no contradictions with quantum theory, concluding that entanglement is a real property of matter. Inspired by Bohm, in 1964 John Bell first dispatched von Neumann’s impossibility proof, readmitting the possibility of local hidden variables, and showed how experiment could decide if they existed. Many physicists later misunderstood this as a challenge to Copenhagen. But, as Bohm and Aharonov explained: ‘ . . . there is no inconsistency in the quantum-mechanical conclusion that such correlations exist, but there is, in [Bohr’s] point of view, no way even to raise the question of what is their origin’. If the particles cannot be considered as separable, Einstein’s gaping explanatory hole returns. Interested experimenters had first to disinter the question, which Bell had buried in an obscure journal.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 25, 2024•1 citation

The Early History of David Bohm’s Quantum Mechanics Through the Perspective of Ludwik Fleck’s Thought-Collectives

Christian Forstner

Minerva•Jun 1, 2008•25 citations
Abstract Work on hidden variable solutions to the conceptual problems of quantum theory did not exactly stop after the publication of von Neumann’s ‘impossibility proof, but then it hardly represented an expanding field of scientific activity. About 20 years elapsed before David Bohm, a young American physicist, began to take more than a passing interest in the subject. His first, all-important contributions to the debate over the interpretation of quantum theory were made in 1951.
The problem of quantum measurement is an important epistemological problem in philosophical researches of quantum mechanics.Aim at von Neumann's wave packet collapse hypothesis and Bohr's quantum-classical dichotomy,physicists had put forward some alternative solutions that are different from the standard interpretation since 1950s.As historical outcomes in endless flow of development of scientific theory,these alternative solutions indicate that the development of scientific theory always tends to aspects of consistency,apprehensible and testability.
The background for this book was a shift of interest among experimental physicists that began approximately 20 years ago. The shift was from quantum measurements on large ensembles of microscopic quantum objects, to experiments of very high precision on single, macroscopic objects. This shift was accompanied by developments in the “culture” of such measurements and the invention and elaboration of new experimental methods. In parallel with these experimental developments, there was a noticeable increase of theoretical interest in the foundations and interpretation of quantum theory, and even in attempts to revise its foundational principles. Although these efforts have not produced any significant changes in the fundamental structure of quantum theory, they have revealed a rather large number of “blank spots” and unsolved problems, to which the founders of quantum physics had paid no attention. A reasonable number of the blank spots have been filled in during the past decade.
Abstract In 1957, Bohm and Yakir Aharonov alighted on experiments on correlated photons performed some years earlier. Although the experimenters had not looked for EPR-type correlations, Bohm and Aharonov found no contradictions with quantum theory, concluding that entanglement is a real property of matter. Inspired by Bohm, in 1964 John Bell first dispatched von Neumann’s impossibility proof, readmitting the possibility of local hidden variables, and showed how experiment could decide if they existed. Many physicists later misunderstood this as a challenge to Copenhagen. But, as Bohm and Aharonov explained: ‘ . . . there is no inconsistency in the quantum-mechanical conclusion that such correlations exist, but there is, in [Bohr’s] point of view, no way even to raise the question of what is their origin’. If the particles cannot be considered as separable, Einstein’s gaping explanatory hole returns. Interested experimenters had first to disinter the question, which Bell had buried in an obscure journal.