Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Proceedings on Privacy Enhancing Technologies

Efficiently Compiling Secure Computation Protocols From Passive to Active Security: Beyond Arithmetic Circuits

Marina Blanton, Dennis Murphy, Chen Yuan

Published Oct 22, 2023• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

This work studies compilation of honest-majority semi-honest secure multi-party protocols secure up to additive attacks to maliciously secure computation with abort. Prior work concentrated on arithmetic circuits composed of addition and multiplication gates, while many practical protocols rely on additional types of elementary operations or gates to achieve good performance. In this work we revisit the notion of security up to additive attacks in the presence of additional gates such as random element generation and opening. This requires re-evaluation of functions that can be securely evaluated, extending the notion of protocols secure up to additive attacks, and re-visiting the notion of delayed verification that points to weaknesses in its prior use and designing a mitigation strategy. We transform the computation using dual execution to achieve security in the malicious model with abort and experimentally evaluate the difference in performance of semi-honest and malicious protocols to demonstrate the low cost.

DOI
10.56553/popets-2024-0006

Related papers

Two-Thirds Honest-Majority MPC for Malicious Adversaries at Almost the Cost of Semi-Honest

Jun Furukawa, Yehuda Lindell

Secure multiparty computation (MPC) enables a set of parties to securely carry out a joint computation of their private inputs without revealing anything but the output. Protocols for semi-honest adversaries guarantee security as long as the corrupted parties run the specified protocol and ensure that nothing is leaked in the transcript. In contrast, protocols for malicious adversaries guarantee security in the presence of arbitrary adversaries who can run any attack strategy. Security for malicious adversaries is typically what is needed in practice (and is always preferred), but comes at a significant cost. In this paper, we present the first protocol for a two-thirds honest majority that achieves security in the presence of malicious adversariesat essentially the exact same cost as the best known protocols for semi-honest adversaries. Our construction is not a general transformation and thus it is possible that better semi-honest protocols will be constructed which do not support our transformation. Nevertheless, for the current state-of-the-art for many parties (based on Shamir sharing), our protocol invokes the best semi-honest multiplication protocol exactly once per multiplication gate (plus some additional local computation that is negligible to the overall cost). Concretely, the best version of our protocol requires each party to send on average of just 2 2/3 elements per multiplication gate (when the number of multiplication gates is at least the number of parties). This is four times faster than the previous-best protocol of Barak et al. (ACM CCS 2018) for small fields, and twice as fast as the previous-best protocol of Chida et al. (CRYPTO 2018) for large fields.

ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security (CCS)•Nov 6, 2019•34 citations

A Framework for Constructing Fast MPC over Arithmetic Circuits with Malicious Adversaries and an Honest-Majority

Yehuda Lindell, Ariel Nof

Protocols for secure multiparty computation enable a set of parties to compute a function of their inputs without revealing anything but the output. The security properties of the protocol must be preserved in the presence of adversarial behavior. The two classic adversary models considered are semi-honest (where the adversary follows the protocol specification but tries to learn more than allowed by examining the protocol transcript) and malicious (where the adversary may follow any arbitrary attack strategy). Protocols for semi-honest adversaries are often far more efficient, but in many cases the security guarantees are not strong enough.

ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security (CCS)•Oct 27, 2017•96 citations

Secure Arithmetic Computation with No Honest Majority.

Yuval Ishai, Manoj Prabhakaran, Amit Sahai

We study the complexity of securely evaluating arithmetic circuits over finite rings. This question is motivated by natural secure computation tasks. Focusing mainly on the case of two-party protocols with security against malicious parties, our main goals are to: (1) only make black-box calls to the ring operations and standard cryptographic primitives, and (2) minimize the number of such black-box calls as well as the communication overhead. We present several solutions which differ in their efficiency, generality, and underlying intractability assumptions. These include: • An unconditionally secure protocol in the OT-hybrid model which makes a black-box use of an arbitrary ring R, but where the number of ring operations grows linearly with (an upper bound on) log |R|. • Computationally secure protocols in the OT-hybrid model which make a black-box use of an underlying ring, and in which the number of ring operations does not grow with the ring size. The protocols rely on variants of previous intractability assumptions related to linear codes. In the most efficient instance of these protocols, applied to a suitable class of fields, the (amortized) communication cost is a constant number of field elements per multiplication gate and the computational cost is dominated by O(log k) field operations per gate, where k is a security parameter. These results extend a previous approach of Naor and Pinkas for secure polynomial evaluation (SIAM J. Comput., 35(5), 2006). • A protocol for the rings Zm = Z/mZ which only makes a black-box use of a homomorphic encryption scheme. When m is prime, the (amortized) number of calls to the encryption scheme for each gate of the circuit is constant. All of our protocols are in fact UC-secure in the OT-hybrid model and can be generalized to multiparty computation with an arbitrary number of malicious parties.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Dishonest Majority Passive-to-Active Compiler Over Rings for MPC With Constant Online Communication

Jiandong Zhang, Han Jiang, Chenkai Zeng +5 more

Secure multiparty computation (MPC) over Z2kis more efficient than computations over fields, and studying MPC protocols under malicious security has practical application value. Malicious security with a dishonest majority over rings remains challenging. The most popular approach is SPDZ2k, however, this is a specific protocol that does not support the transformation of any existing semi-honest MPC protocols into malicious security protocols. The zero knowledge proof (ZKP)-based compiler satisfies this requirement. Existing state-of-the-art protocols have logarithmic online communication overhead in terms of the circuit size |C|, and their direct application to rings is nontrivial as they were originally designed for finite fields. In this work, we investigate the communication overhead to develop malicious security protocols. We bridge the gap between malicious security with abort and semi-honest security, by constructing a “GMW-style” verification protocol to achieve malicious security in a dishonest majority setting. This approach incurs a constant online communication overhead by enhancing the machinery of zero-knowledge fully linear interactive oracle proof (zk-FLIOP). Additionally, we extend the zk-FLIOP to work over any ring by invoking reverse multiplication friendly embeddings (RMFEs). Our results show that the online communication complexity of the verification process depends on only the security parameter, the number of parties, and the ring size. Furthermore, for small-scale circuits over Z2, we designed a distributed lookup table argument where both the total communication complexity and the computational cost are independent of the circuit size but of the input wires.

IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security•Jan 1, 2026•1 citation

Quid-Pro-Quo-tocols: Strengthening Semi-honest Protocols with Dual Execution

Yan Huang, Jonathan Katz, David Evans

Known protocols for secure two-party computation that are designed to provide full security against malicious behavior are significantly less efficient than protocols intended only to thwart semi-honest adversaries. We present a concrete design and implementation of protocols achieving security guarantees that are much stronger than are possible with semi-honest protocols, at minimal extra cost. Specifically, we consider protocols in which a malicious adversary may learn a single (arbitrary) bit of additional information about the honest party's input. Correctness of the honest party's output is still guaranteed. Adapting prior work of Mohassel and Franklin, the basic idea in our protocols is to conduct two separate runs of a (specific) semi-honest, garbled-circuit protocol, with the parties swapping roles, followed by an inexpensive secure equality test. We provide a rigorous definition and prove that this protocol leaks no more than one additional bit against a malicious adversary. In addition, we propose some heuristic enhancements to reduce the overall information a cheating adversary learns. Our experiments show that protocols meeting this security level can be implemented at cost very close to that of protocols that only achieve semi-honest security. Our results indicate that this model enables the large-scale, practical applications possible within the semi-honest security model, while providing dramatically stronger security guarantees.

IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy (S&P)•May 1, 2012•103 citations

ECHO: Efficient Covertly-Secure Three-party Computation with Applications to Private Machine Learning

Yufei Duan, Yun Li, Zhicong Huang +3 more

Secure three-party computation with an honest majority is among the most efficient secure computation settings and is widely used in practice. However, achieving malicious security incurs significant overhead, often an order of magnitude higher than semi-honest protocols. Covert security provides a security–efficiency trade-off by detecting malicious behavior with a certain probability (e.g., 50%), deterring rational adversaries. Existing covert protocols mainly target two-party or dishonest-majority settings, with little work on efficient honest-majority three-party solutions. We present ECHO, a family of concretely efficient protocols for covertly secure honest-majority three-party computation. We explore the design space of cheating detection and identification, and develop optimized protocols for both arithmetic and Boolean circuits, targeting different performance goals such as low latency and reduced communication. For arithmetic circuits over rings, our asymmetric-MAC-based protocol achieves an online phase only 1.26× slower than the semi-honest baseline and over 5.59× faster than MAC-based maliciously secure protocol. For Boolean circuits, our method improves over the best malicious protocol by 5×. We also applied ECHO on practical PPML tasks. ECHO approaches semi-honest performance while providing up to 8× speedup over malicious security.

IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
This work studies compilation of honest-majority semi-honest secure multi-party protocols secure up to additive attacks to maliciously secure computation with abort. Prior work concentrated on arithmetic circuits composed of addition and multiplication gates, while many practical protocols rely on additional types of elementary operations or gates to achieve good performance. In this work we revisit the notion of security up to additive attacks in the presence of additional gates such as random element generation and opening. This requires re-evaluation of functions that can be securely evaluated, extending the notion of protocols secure up to additive attacks, and re-visiting the notion of delayed verification that points to weaknesses in its prior use and designing a mitigation strategy. We transform the computation using dual execution to achieve security in the malicious model with abort and experimentally evaluate the difference in performance of semi-honest and malicious protocols to demonstrate the low cost.
Secure multiparty computation (MPC) enables a set of parties to securely carry out a joint computation of their private inputs without revealing anything but the output. Protocols for semi-honest adversaries guarantee security as long as the corrupted parties run the specified protocol and ensure that nothing is leaked in the transcript. In contrast, protocols for malicious adversaries guarantee security in the presence of arbitrary adversaries who can run any attack strategy. Security for malicious adversaries is typically what is needed in practice (and is always preferred), but comes at a significant cost. In this paper, we present the first protocol for a two-thirds honest majority that achieves security in the presence of malicious adversariesat essentially the exact same cost as the best known protocols for semi-honest adversaries. Our construction is not a general transformation and thus it is possible that better semi-honest protocols will be constructed which do not support our transformation. Nevertheless, for the current state-of-the-art for many parties (based on Shamir sharing), our protocol invokes the best semi-honest multiplication protocol exactly once per multiplication gate (plus some additional local computation that is negligible to the overall cost). Concretely, the best version of our protocol requires each party to send on average of just 2 2/3 elements per multiplication gate (when the number of multiplication gates is at least the number of parties). This is four times faster than the previous-best protocol of Barak et al. (ACM CCS 2018) for small fields, and twice as fast as the previous-best protocol of Chida et al. (CRYPTO 2018) for large fields.
Protocols for secure multiparty computation enable a set of parties to compute a function of their inputs without revealing anything but the output. The security properties of the protocol must be preserved in the presence of adversarial behavior. The two classic adversary models considered are semi-honest (where the adversary follows the protocol specification but tries to learn more than allowed by examining the protocol transcript) and malicious (where the adversary may follow any arbitrary attack strategy). Protocols for semi-honest adversaries are often far more efficient, but in many cases the security guarantees are not strong enough.
We study the complexity of securely evaluating arithmetic circuits over finite rings. This question is motivated by natural secure computation tasks. Focusing mainly on the case of two-party protocols with security against malicious parties, our main goals are to: (1) only make black-box calls to the ring operations and standard cryptographic primitives, and (2) minimize the number of such black-box calls as well as the communication overhead. We present several solutions which differ in their efficiency, generality, and underlying intractability assumptions. These include: • An unconditionally secure protocol in the OT-hybrid model which makes a black-box use of an arbitrary ring R, but where the number of ring operations grows linearly with (an upper bound on) log |R|. • Computationally secure protocols in the OT-hybrid model which make a black-box use of an underlying ring, and in which the number of ring operations does not grow with the ring size. The protocols rely on variants of previous intractability assumptions related to linear codes. In the most efficient instance of these protocols, applied to a suitable class of fields, the (amortized) communication cost is a constant number of field elements per multiplication gate and the computational cost is dominated by O(log k) field operations per gate, where k is a security parameter. These results extend a previous approach of Naor and Pinkas for secure polynomial evaluation (SIAM J. Comput., 35(5), 2006). • A protocol for the rings Zm = Z/mZ which only makes a black-box use of a homomorphic encryption scheme. When m is prime, the (amortized) number of calls to the encryption scheme for each gate of the circuit is constant. All of our protocols are in fact UC-secure in the OT-hybrid model and can be generalized to multiparty computation with an arbitrary number of malicious parties.
Secure multiparty computation (MPC) over Z2kis more efficient than computations over fields, and studying MPC protocols under malicious security has practical application value. Malicious security with a dishonest majority over rings remains challenging. The most popular approach is SPDZ2k, however, this is a specific protocol that does not support the transformation of any existing semi-honest MPC protocols into malicious security protocols. The zero knowledge proof (ZKP)-based compiler satisfies this requirement. Existing state-of-the-art protocols have logarithmic online communication overhead in terms of the circuit size |C|, and their direct application to rings is nontrivial as they were originally designed for finite fields. In this work, we investigate the communication overhead to develop malicious security protocols. We bridge the gap between malicious security with abort and semi-honest security, by constructing a “GMW-style” verification protocol to achieve malicious security in a dishonest majority setting. This approach incurs a constant online communication overhead by enhancing the machinery of zero-knowledge fully linear interactive oracle proof (zk-FLIOP). Additionally, we extend the zk-FLIOP to work over any ring by invoking reverse multiplication friendly embeddings (RMFEs). Our results show that the online communication complexity of the verification process depends on only the security parameter, the number of parties, and the ring size. Furthermore, for small-scale circuits over Z2, we designed a distributed lookup table argument where both the total communication complexity and the computational cost are independent of the circuit size but of the input wires.
Known protocols for secure two-party computation that are designed to provide full security against malicious behavior are significantly less efficient than protocols intended only to thwart semi-honest adversaries. We present a concrete design and implementation of protocols achieving security guarantees that are much stronger than are possible with semi-honest protocols, at minimal extra cost. Specifically, we consider protocols in which a malicious adversary may learn a single (arbitrary) bit of additional information about the honest party's input. Correctness of the honest party's output is still guaranteed. Adapting prior work of Mohassel and Franklin, the basic idea in our protocols is to conduct two separate runs of a (specific) semi-honest, garbled-circuit protocol, with the parties swapping roles, followed by an inexpensive secure equality test. We provide a rigorous definition and prove that this protocol leaks no more than one additional bit against a malicious adversary. In addition, we propose some heuristic enhancements to reduce the overall information a cheating adversary learns. Our experiments show that protocols meeting this security level can be implemented at cost very close to that of protocols that only achieve semi-honest security. Our results indicate that this model enables the large-scale, practical applications possible within the semi-honest security model, while providing dramatically stronger security guarantees.
Secure three-party computation with an honest majority is among the most efficient secure computation settings and is widely used in practice. However, achieving malicious security incurs significant overhead, often an order of magnitude higher than semi-honest protocols. Covert security provides a security–efficiency trade-off by detecting malicious behavior with a certain probability (e.g., 50%), deterring rational adversaries. Existing covert protocols mainly target two-party or dishonest-majority settings, with little work on efficient honest-majority three-party solutions. We present ECHO, a family of concretely efficient protocols for covertly secure honest-majority three-party computation. We explore the design space of cheating detection and identification, and develop optimized protocols for both arithmetic and Boolean circuits, targeting different performance goals such as low latency and reduced communication. For arithmetic circuits over rings, our asymmetric-MAC-based protocol achieves an online phase only 1.26× slower than the semi-honest baseline and over 5.59× faster than MAC-based maliciously secure protocol. For Boolean circuits, our method improves over the best malicious protocol by 5×. We also applied ECHO on practical PPML tasks. ECHO approaches semi-honest performance while providing up to 8× speedup over malicious security.