Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics & Optics Sciences

Cartesian Approach to Developing the Foundations of Quantum Physics

Altayev Namaz Karabalievich

Published Oct 13, 2023• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In 1900, Planck presented an equation that became fundamental to quantum physics and paved the way for interpreting the nature of radiation. However, in a 1911 article where he attempted to theoretically justify this equation, some errors might have been introduced. In this paper, Planck proposed that the central concept in quantum physics is the quantum of action, which diminished the significance of the energy quantum. Many researchers argue that this approach was flawed, as it contradicted the foundational ideas he introduced in 1900, termed the “quantum hypothesis.”

DOI
10.47363/jpsos/2023(5)207

Related papers

Disclosure of the True Essence of Quantum Theory on the Basis of Scientific Philosophy

Altayev Namaz Karabalievich

It is well known that in 1900, after Planck obtained the basic equation of quantum theory, there came a moment when it became necessary to obtain a theoretical justification of this equation. In 1911, based on the possibility of Gibbs' canonical distribution function (CDF), he solved this problem partially: he obtained a justification for the second multiplier of his equation. Then on the basis of the analysis of these results he stated that henceforth in the role of the basic concept of quantum theory there is a necessity to accept the possibility of the concept of the quantum of action. However, Poincaré at the same congress criticized these new ideas. For he recognized the value of the idea of the quantum of action in solving only frequent problems. Therefore, he further, in his article entitled "On the Theory of Quanta", made the following conclusion: in his opinion, the main essence of quantum theory is connected with the concept of the quantum of energy [1]. Thus, he wanted to say that in the future the main results of Planck's quantum theory have the possibility to substantiate only if the possibility of the concept of energy quantum is taken as more general. In this paper an attempt is made to prove that it is really so.

Journal of Physics & Optics Sciences•Jun 30, 2024•1 citation

Introduction to Quantum Mechanics

Arjun Sharma

This chapter starts with the historical development of quantum mechanics and explanations of key concepts behind fundamental discoveries such as Planck's hypothesis, the photoelectric effect, Bohr's atomic model, Compton scattering, the de Broglie hypothesis, the Pauli exclusion principle, the Schrödinger equation, Heisenberg quantum mechanics and the uncertainty principle, the Born interpretation of wave function, the Davisson and Germer experiment, and Dirac relativistic quantum mechanics, which made important contributions to the foundation of modern quantum mechanics. Concepts like the particle properties of radiation, the wave properties of matter, quantized energy and momentum, and the idea that one can no longer know exactly where a single particle like an electron is at any instant of time are brought out clearly through this chapter. A list of important quantum mechanical parameters along with solved examples and unsolved exercises on the key concepts are included towards the end.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 18, 2021•9 citations

Planck’s Relation

Energy is proportional to frequency. With this single, austere relation Max Planck introduced the quantum of action and opened the door to a new physics. The constant of proportionality, h, is now known as Planck’s constant; the equation E = hv asserts that electromagnetic energy can be absorbed or emitted only in discrete packets whose size is fixed by the frequency of the radiation. First proposed in December 1900 as a formal device to save the theory of black-body radiation, the relation became the foundation of quantum theory. Few equations of comparable brevity have so thoroughly overturned the classical picture of nature.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 26, 2026•0 citations

Theoretically Proving the Quantization Hypothesis

James Deng

A century ago, the energy quantization hypothesis required to derive Planck's formula has been proposed as the foundations of the quantum theory. So far, this quantization hypothesis still lacks complete theoretical proof and interpretation, even no answer for why the quantization occurs. Here Planck's quantization hypothesis has been proved completely in pure theoretical methods, and accompanied by a full interpretation of the related physical laws. A new physical and mathematical expression of Planck's law has been achieved. From now on, the energy quantum presumption is no longer the premise hypothesis of quantum theory, but the credible conclusion.

•Jul 11, 2022•0 citations

An Examination Of The Philosophical Foundations Of Quantum Theory

Cranston, Julius Byron, Jr.

Beginning in 1900 with 1-iax Planck's hypothesis of quanta, physics has been embarked on a course which has raised serious questions about the true nature of physical reality, about the foundational assumptions and structures of science, and about the relationships between physical reality and physical theory. In particular, attempts to give a physical interpretation to quantum theory seem to result in "pictures" of nature which are paradoxical. A subatomic entity is described by the theory as exhibiting the properties and behavior of both particle-like phenomena and wave­like phenomena. Since it seems unreasonable that a single entity could be both a point-like mass and a wave spread out through a region of space, quantum theory would seem to be less than satisfactory or less than complete at the interpretational level. The purpose of this dissertation is to investigate the underlying causes of this paradox. The dissertation proceeds by reviewing the development of quantum theory and the emergence of the paradox. Next, the prob­lem of physical interpretation is examined and several of the more significant existing interpretations are discussed and analyzed. Finally, the foundations of science and the general structure of scientific theory are examined in a search for the origins of the paradox. As a result of these investigations and analyses, it is con­cluded that the paradoxical nature of the physical interpretation of quantum theory is the consequence of certain paradigms and preconceptualizations about physical reality which have been incorporated into the theory at the foundational level. These fundamental assU14p­tions produce, within quantum theory, a forced marriage of the plenum and atomic views of physical reality. They also produce an ambiguity with respect to the nature of causality which is charaeteristic of the theory. These problems are reflected in the mathematical formalisms and physical concepts of the theory as well as in its meta­physical foundations. Lastly, methods of resoling the paradox are discussed. It is argued that a successful solution is possible, but that it would involve the creation of a new metaphor-an extension of the present language--which would lead science to a deeper, subquantum level in terms of which the present paradox would vanish.

•Dec 12, 1975•0 citations

Quantum Theory

A. C. Fischer-Cripps

One of the first inklings of a problem in physics at the end of the 19th century was the nature of the radiation emission spectrum from a black body. This could not be explained in terms of established and irrefutable methods of statistical mechanics. It was Planck’s idea to divide up the energy spectrum of a series of harmonic oscillators each with a different state of energy but whose energy steps depended upon the frequency of the oscillation that marked the beginning of quantum physics. As a result, Planck introduced a fundamental constant of nature, Planck’s constant.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 20, 2019•0 citations
In 1900, Planck presented an equation that became fundamental to quantum physics and paved the way for interpreting the nature of radiation. However, in a 1911 article where he attempted to theoretically justify this equation, some errors might have been introduced. In this paper, Planck proposed that the central concept in quantum physics is the quantum of action, which diminished the significance of the energy quantum. Many researchers argue that this approach was flawed, as it contradicted the foundational ideas he introduced in 1900, termed the “quantum hypothesis.”
It is well known that in 1900, after Planck obtained the basic equation of quantum theory, there came a moment when it became necessary to obtain a theoretical justification of this equation. In 1911, based on the possibility of Gibbs' canonical distribution function (CDF), he solved this problem partially: he obtained a justification for the second multiplier of his equation. Then on the basis of the analysis of these results he stated that henceforth in the role of the basic concept of quantum theory there is a necessity to accept the possibility of the concept of the quantum of action. However, Poincaré at the same congress criticized these new ideas. For he recognized the value of the idea of the quantum of action in solving only frequent problems. Therefore, he further, in his article entitled "On the Theory of Quanta", made the following conclusion: in his opinion, the main essence of quantum theory is connected with the concept of the quantum of energy [1]. Thus, he wanted to say that in the future the main results of Planck's quantum theory have the possibility to substantiate only if the possibility of the concept of energy quantum is taken as more general. In this paper an attempt is made to prove that it is really so.
This chapter starts with the historical development of quantum mechanics and explanations of key concepts behind fundamental discoveries such as Planck's hypothesis, the photoelectric effect, Bohr's atomic model, Compton scattering, the de Broglie hypothesis, the Pauli exclusion principle, the Schrödinger equation, Heisenberg quantum mechanics and the uncertainty principle, the Born interpretation of wave function, the Davisson and Germer experiment, and Dirac relativistic quantum mechanics, which made important contributions to the foundation of modern quantum mechanics. Concepts like the particle properties of radiation, the wave properties of matter, quantized energy and momentum, and the idea that one can no longer know exactly where a single particle like an electron is at any instant of time are brought out clearly through this chapter. A list of important quantum mechanical parameters along with solved examples and unsolved exercises on the key concepts are included towards the end.
Energy is proportional to frequency. With this single, austere relation Max Planck introduced the quantum of action and opened the door to a new physics. The constant of proportionality, h, is now known as Planck’s constant; the equation E = hv asserts that electromagnetic energy can be absorbed or emitted only in discrete packets whose size is fixed by the frequency of the radiation. First proposed in December 1900 as a formal device to save the theory of black-body radiation, the relation became the foundation of quantum theory. Few equations of comparable brevity have so thoroughly overturned the classical picture of nature.
A century ago, the energy quantization hypothesis required to derive Planck's formula has been proposed as the foundations of the quantum theory. So far, this quantization hypothesis still lacks complete theoretical proof and interpretation, even no answer for why the quantization occurs. Here Planck's quantization hypothesis has been proved completely in pure theoretical methods, and accompanied by a full interpretation of the related physical laws. A new physical and mathematical expression of Planck's law has been achieved. From now on, the energy quantum presumption is no longer the premise hypothesis of quantum theory, but the credible conclusion.
Beginning in 1900 with 1-iax Planck's hypothesis of quanta, physics has been embarked on a course which has raised serious questions about the true nature of physical reality, about the foundational assumptions and structures of science, and about the relationships between physical reality and physical theory. In particular, attempts to give a physical interpretation to quantum theory seem to result in "pictures" of nature which are paradoxical. A subatomic entity is described by the theory as exhibiting the properties and behavior of both particle-like phenomena and wave­like phenomena. Since it seems unreasonable that a single entity could be both a point-like mass and a wave spread out through a region of space, quantum theory would seem to be less than satisfactory or less than complete at the interpretational level. The purpose of this dissertation is to investigate the underlying causes of this paradox. The dissertation proceeds by reviewing the development of quantum theory and the emergence of the paradox. Next, the prob­lem of physical interpretation is examined and several of the more significant existing interpretations are discussed and analyzed. Finally, the foundations of science and the general structure of scientific theory are examined in a search for the origins of the paradox. As a result of these investigations and analyses, it is con­cluded that the paradoxical nature of the physical interpretation of quantum theory is the consequence of certain paradigms and preconceptualizations about physical reality which have been incorporated into the theory at the foundational level. These fundamental assU14p­tions produce, within quantum theory, a forced marriage of the plenum and atomic views of physical reality. They also produce an ambiguity with respect to the nature of causality which is charaeteristic of the theory. These problems are reflected in the mathematical formalisms and physical concepts of the theory as well as in its meta­physical foundations. Lastly, methods of resoling the paradox are discussed. It is argued that a successful solution is possible, but that it would involve the creation of a new metaphor-an extension of the present language--which would lead science to a deeper, subquantum level in terms of which the present paradox would vanish.
One of the first inklings of a problem in physics at the end of the 19th century was the nature of the radiation emission spectrum from a black body. This could not be explained in terms of established and irrefutable methods of statistical mechanics. It was Planck’s idea to divide up the energy spectrum of a series of harmonic oscillators each with a different state of energy but whose energy steps depended upon the frequency of the oscillation that marked the beginning of quantum physics. As a result, Planck introduced a fundamental constant of nature, Planck’s constant.