Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Approximation Methods

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

Published Sep 14, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

One of the basic rules of the universe is that nothing is perfect. Perfection simply doesn't exist…..Without imperfection, neither you nor I would exist —Stephen Hawking (1942–2018) Approximations are made in mathematics, physics, engineering, and life sciences for a variety of reasons such as (a) obtaining an exact solution is not possible and (b) an exact solution is not necessary, subject to a given context. Both of these factors are important in the development of approximations. We have already seen in Chapter 2 that out of the infinite alternative paths accessible to a system due to their entanglement/superposition, the classical path that makes action stationary results from the condition that action is much larger than the PEB constant. When this condition is satisfied, laws of classical physics provide an excellent approximation to quantum mechanics. In Chapter 2, we observed that the interpretation of the wavefunction as probability amplitude became the basis of the path integral formulation of quantum mechanics, in which the propagator's phase is the action . Considering this relationship, it is appropriate to wonder if the Schrödinger equation could have been predicted from classical mechanics, if only the wavefunction (Eq. 6.22, below) was introduced, even just as a definition . In Section 6.1, we demonstrate, in hindsight , how this could have been possible. Of course, historical development of quantum mechanics took place on a different course. We also demonstrate the inverse of this process, viz., how the classical equation of motion is obtainable as an approximation from quantum mechanics in the limit h →0. An approximation scheme often implemented to solve the Schrödinger equation, called the Wentzel–Kramers–Brilloiun–Jeffrey (WKBJ) method, is based on the connections between classical and quantum mechanics. It is introduced in Section 6.1. In Section 6.2, we discuss perturbation methods to obtain approximate solutions to unsolvable problems. Time-independent perturbation methods are discussed in Section 6.2, and time-dependent perturbation methods in Section 6.3. Major non-perturbative approaches to attack complex problems include the adiabatic approximation, the sudden approximation, and the method of variation. These are introduced in Section 6.4. 6.1 Classical Limit of the Schrödinger Equation and the WKBJ Approximation Readers who are well conversant with the Hamilton–Jacobi (HJ) theory in classical mechanics [1] will be able to skip a significant part of the discussion in this section. It is, however, included here, even if only briefly, for the sake of completeness.

DOI
10.1017/9781009058070.008

Related papers

Approximation Methods

Ravinder Rupchand Puri

Not many problems in quantum mechanics are analytically exactly solvable. The methods of solving the equations approximately therefore play an important role. Though construction of approximate solution would depend on a particular problem, there are methods, discussed in this chapter, which are of general interest as they are applicable to widely occurring situations. These methods can be divided into two categories: one for time-independent and the other for time-dependent Hamiltonians. These categories can be divided further into two classes: one in which the Hamiltonian can be divided in to a strong and a weak part allowing the weak part to be treated as a perturbation, and the other in which certain gross features of the interaction suggest approximation methods for its treatment. The quasi-classical approximation for stationary states, and the adiabatic and sudden approximations for time-dependent Hamiltonians are the examples of non-perturbative techniques. WKB Approximation The quantum theory is expected to approach the classical theory in the limit of de Broglie wavelength becoming small compared with the distances over which the potential varies. In that limit, the Schrödinger equation reduces to the Hamilton–Jacobi equation of classical mechanics. The method outlined in this section consists in finding that solution of the Schrödinger equation which contains lowest order quantum effects when the conditions for the classical approximation hold. We will see that this approximation closely reproduces the quantization rule of the old quantum theory. Consider the time-independent Schrödinger equation of a particle of mass m in the time-independent potential V ( r ),

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 17, 2017•0 citations

Rigorous theories

In this chapter we discuss theories which are rigorous in their formulation but which in order to be useful need to be modified by introducing approximations of some kind. The approximations we are interested in are those which involve introduction of classical mechanical concepts, that is, the classical picture and/or classical mechanical equations of motion in part of the system. At this point, we wish to distinguish between “the classical picture,” which is obtained by taking the classical limit ħ → 0 and the appearance of “classical equations of motion.” The latter may be extracted from the quantum mechanical formulation without taking the classical limit—but, as we shall see later by introducing a certain parametrization of quantum mechanics. Thus there are two ways of introducing classical mechanical concepts in quantum mechanics. In the first method, the classical limit is defined by taking the limit ħ → 0 either in all degrees of freedom (complete classical limit) or in some degrees of freedom (semi-classical theories). We note in passing that the word semi-classical has been used to cover a wide variety of approaches which have also been referred to as classical S-matrix theories, quantum-classical theories, classical path theory, hemi-quantal theory, Wentzel Kramer-Brillouin (WKB) theories, and so on. It is not the purpose of this book to define precisely what is behind these various acronyms. We shall rather focus on methods which we think have been successful as far as practical applications are concerned and discuss the approximations and philosophy behind these. In the other approach, the ħ-limit is not taken—at least not explicitly— but here one introduces “classical” quantities, such as, trajectories and momenta as parameters, and derives equations of motion for these parameters. The latter method is therefore one particular way of parameterizing quantum mechanics. We discuss both of these approaches in this chapter. The Feynman path-integral formulation is one way of formulating quantum mechanics such that the classical limit is immediately visible [3]. Formally, the approach involves the introduction of a quantity S, which has a definition resembling that of an action integral [101].

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 27, 2003•0 citations

Perturbations and approximation methods

Gennaro Auletta, Mauro Fortunato, Giorgio Parisi A

In this chapter, we present some fundamental issues about approximation methods that are often used when a quantum-mechanical system is perturbed and about the relationship between classical and quantum mechanics. In Sec. 10.1 we introduce the stationary perturbation theory, while Sec. 10.2 is devoted to time-dependent perturbations. In Sec. 10.3 we briefly examine the adiabatic theorem. In Sec. 10.4 we introduce the variation method, an approximation method that is not based on perturbation theory. In Sec. 10.5 we discuss the classical limit of the quantum-mechanical equations, whereas in Sec. 10.6 we deal with the semiclassical approximation, in particular the WKB method. On the basis of the previous approximation methods in Sec. 10.7 we present scattering theory. Finally, in Sec. 10.8 we treat a method that has a wide range of applications: the path-integral method. Stationary perturbation theory Perturbation theory is a rather general approximation method that may be applied when a small additional force (the perturbation) acts on a system (the unperturbed system), whose quantum dynamics is fully known. If the disturbance is small, it modifies both the energy levels and the stationary states. This allows us to make an expansion in power series of a perturbation parameter, which is assumed to be small. Perturbation theory may be applied both to the case where the additional force is time-independent (in which case a stationary treatment suffices – the subject of the present section) as well as to the case where it explicitly depends on time.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 16, 2009•0 citations

Approximation methods

Giampiero V. M. Esposito, Giuseppe Marmo, Gennaro Miele +1 more

Since in both classical and quantum mechanics we are rarely dealing with explicitly solvable equations, this chapter is devoted to an elementary introduction to perturbation theory, Jeffreys–Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin (hereafter JWKB) method and scattering theory, which are approximation methods that play a key role in all applications of quantum mechanics to atomic and nuclear physics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 31, 2014•1 citation

Approximation methods

P. C. W. Davies, David S. Betts

As in classical mechanics the number of exactly soluble quantum mechanical problems is very limited and in most cases of practical interest numerical techniques and approximation methods are unavoidable. The availability of fast computers has turned quantum computation into a major industry. This chapter looks at the several approximation techniques. In seeking to solve the Schrodinger equation with the perturbed Hamiltonian, it is convenient to work with series expansions by introducing a dimensionless parameter λ. In many cases the system of interest differs from an exactly soluble system by only a small disturbance, enabling an approximation to be made by expanding in powers of a smallness parameter. The Variational Method provides a very simple method of approximating energy eigenvalues. It is most useful for computing ground state energies and its success depends on our being able to make a reasonable guess for the form of the ground state wave function.

Routledge eBooks•Apr 27, 2018•0 citations

Stationary Perturbation Theory and the Variational Method

Ana María Cetto, Luis de la Peña

Stationary Perturbation Theory and the Variational MethodIn most cases of interest, there is no exact analytical solution to the Schrödinger equation for the given problem.In other cases, the exact solution can be found, but its structure is so complicated that it lacks transparency or becomes impractical.Nowadays, it is possible to resort to computational methods, which can be very powerful but have the disadvantage of hiding the qualitative behavior of the solution.In such cases, it is useful or even at times necessary to use a method that allows an approximate solution to be found.There is no universal recipe: in each instance the method to be used must be chosen carefully, because although there may be more than one method that can serve similar purposes, one of them may have advantages over the others for some specific reason.In this chapter we will review two of the most useful approximation methods for time-independent problems: perturbation theory and the variational method, with applications of specific interest.1 Quantum perturbation theory has its origins in classical perturbation theory.The prototypical example of the latter is the solar system, in which the orbit of each planet can be studied separately, as if the other planets and other minor elements of the system did not exist.The combined effects of all these neglected bodies can normally be considered as small disturbances, which are to be calculated separately, one by one.It is on this idea that the astronomical perturbation theory was proposed and successfully developed over the last three centuries.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations
One of the basic rules of the universe is that nothing is perfect. Perfection simply doesn't exist…..Without imperfection, neither you nor I would exist —Stephen Hawking (1942–2018) Approximations are made in mathematics, physics, engineering, and life sciences for a variety of reasons such as (a) obtaining an exact solution is not possible and (b) an exact solution is not necessary, subject to a given context. Both of these factors are important in the development of approximations. We have already seen in Chapter 2 that out of the infinite alternative paths accessible to a system due to their entanglement/superposition, the classical path that makes action stationary results from the condition that action is much larger than the PEB constant. When this condition is satisfied, laws of classical physics provide an excellent approximation to quantum mechanics. In Chapter 2, we observed that the interpretation of the wavefunction as probability amplitude became the basis of the path integral formulation of quantum mechanics, in which the propagator's phase is the action . Considering this relationship, it is appropriate to wonder if the Schrödinger equation could have been predicted from classical mechanics, if only the wavefunction (Eq. 6.22, below) was introduced, even just as a definition . In Section 6.1, we demonstrate, in hindsight , how this could have been possible. Of course, historical development of quantum mechanics took place on a different course. We also demonstrate the inverse of this process, viz., how the classical equation of motion is obtainable as an approximation from quantum mechanics in the limit h →0. An approximation scheme often implemented to solve the Schrödinger equation, called the Wentzel–Kramers–Brilloiun–Jeffrey (WKBJ) method, is based on the connections between classical and quantum mechanics. It is introduced in Section 6.1. In Section 6.2, we discuss perturbation methods to obtain approximate solutions to unsolvable problems. Time-independent perturbation methods are discussed in Section 6.2, and time-dependent perturbation methods in Section 6.3. Major non-perturbative approaches to attack complex problems include the adiabatic approximation, the sudden approximation, and the method of variation. These are introduced in Section 6.4. 6.1 Classical Limit of the Schrödinger Equation and the WKBJ Approximation Readers who are well conversant with the Hamilton–Jacobi (HJ) theory in classical mechanics [1] will be able to skip a significant part of the discussion in this section. It is, however, included here, even if only briefly, for the sake of completeness.
Not many problems in quantum mechanics are analytically exactly solvable. The methods of solving the equations approximately therefore play an important role. Though construction of approximate solution would depend on a particular problem, there are methods, discussed in this chapter, which are of general interest as they are applicable to widely occurring situations. These methods can be divided into two categories: one for time-independent and the other for time-dependent Hamiltonians. These categories can be divided further into two classes: one in which the Hamiltonian can be divided in to a strong and a weak part allowing the weak part to be treated as a perturbation, and the other in which certain gross features of the interaction suggest approximation methods for its treatment. The quasi-classical approximation for stationary states, and the adiabatic and sudden approximations for time-dependent Hamiltonians are the examples of non-perturbative techniques. WKB Approximation The quantum theory is expected to approach the classical theory in the limit of de Broglie wavelength becoming small compared with the distances over which the potential varies. In that limit, the Schrödinger equation reduces to the Hamilton–Jacobi equation of classical mechanics. The method outlined in this section consists in finding that solution of the Schrödinger equation which contains lowest order quantum effects when the conditions for the classical approximation hold. We will see that this approximation closely reproduces the quantization rule of the old quantum theory. Consider the time-independent Schrödinger equation of a particle of mass m in the time-independent potential V ( r ),
In this chapter we discuss theories which are rigorous in their formulation but which in order to be useful need to be modified by introducing approximations of some kind. The approximations we are interested in are those which involve introduction of classical mechanical concepts, that is, the classical picture and/or classical mechanical equations of motion in part of the system. At this point, we wish to distinguish between “the classical picture,” which is obtained by taking the classical limit ħ → 0 and the appearance of “classical equations of motion.” The latter may be extracted from the quantum mechanical formulation without taking the classical limit—but, as we shall see later by introducing a certain parametrization of quantum mechanics. Thus there are two ways of introducing classical mechanical concepts in quantum mechanics. In the first method, the classical limit is defined by taking the limit ħ → 0 either in all degrees of freedom (complete classical limit) or in some degrees of freedom (semi-classical theories). We note in passing that the word semi-classical has been used to cover a wide variety of approaches which have also been referred to as classical S-matrix theories, quantum-classical theories, classical path theory, hemi-quantal theory, Wentzel Kramer-Brillouin (WKB) theories, and so on. It is not the purpose of this book to define precisely what is behind these various acronyms. We shall rather focus on methods which we think have been successful as far as practical applications are concerned and discuss the approximations and philosophy behind these. In the other approach, the ħ-limit is not taken—at least not explicitly— but here one introduces “classical” quantities, such as, trajectories and momenta as parameters, and derives equations of motion for these parameters. The latter method is therefore one particular way of parameterizing quantum mechanics. We discuss both of these approaches in this chapter. The Feynman path-integral formulation is one way of formulating quantum mechanics such that the classical limit is immediately visible [3]. Formally, the approach involves the introduction of a quantity S, which has a definition resembling that of an action integral [101].
In this chapter, we present some fundamental issues about approximation methods that are often used when a quantum-mechanical system is perturbed and about the relationship between classical and quantum mechanics. In Sec. 10.1 we introduce the stationary perturbation theory, while Sec. 10.2 is devoted to time-dependent perturbations. In Sec. 10.3 we briefly examine the adiabatic theorem. In Sec. 10.4 we introduce the variation method, an approximation method that is not based on perturbation theory. In Sec. 10.5 we discuss the classical limit of the quantum-mechanical equations, whereas in Sec. 10.6 we deal with the semiclassical approximation, in particular the WKB method. On the basis of the previous approximation methods in Sec. 10.7 we present scattering theory. Finally, in Sec. 10.8 we treat a method that has a wide range of applications: the path-integral method. Stationary perturbation theory Perturbation theory is a rather general approximation method that may be applied when a small additional force (the perturbation) acts on a system (the unperturbed system), whose quantum dynamics is fully known. If the disturbance is small, it modifies both the energy levels and the stationary states. This allows us to make an expansion in power series of a perturbation parameter, which is assumed to be small. Perturbation theory may be applied both to the case where the additional force is time-independent (in which case a stationary treatment suffices – the subject of the present section) as well as to the case where it explicitly depends on time.
As in classical mechanics the number of exactly soluble quantum mechanical problems is very limited and in most cases of practical interest numerical techniques and approximation methods are unavoidable. The availability of fast computers has turned quantum computation into a major industry. This chapter looks at the several approximation techniques. In seeking to solve the Schrodinger equation with the perturbed Hamiltonian, it is convenient to work with series expansions by introducing a dimensionless parameter λ. In many cases the system of interest differs from an exactly soluble system by only a small disturbance, enabling an approximation to be made by expanding in powers of a smallness parameter. The Variational Method provides a very simple method of approximating energy eigenvalues. It is most useful for computing ground state energies and its success depends on our being able to make a reasonable guess for the form of the ground state wave function.
Stationary Perturbation Theory and the Variational MethodIn most cases of interest, there is no exact analytical solution to the Schrödinger equation for the given problem.In other cases, the exact solution can be found, but its structure is so complicated that it lacks transparency or becomes impractical.Nowadays, it is possible to resort to computational methods, which can be very powerful but have the disadvantage of hiding the qualitative behavior of the solution.In such cases, it is useful or even at times necessary to use a method that allows an approximate solution to be found.There is no universal recipe: in each instance the method to be used must be chosen carefully, because although there may be more than one method that can serve similar purposes, one of them may have advantages over the others for some specific reason.In this chapter we will review two of the most useful approximation methods for time-independent problems: perturbation theory and the variational method, with applications of specific interest.1 Quantum perturbation theory has its origins in classical perturbation theory.The prototypical example of the latter is the solar system, in which the orbit of each planet can be studied separately, as if the other planets and other minor elements of the system did not exist.The combined effects of all these neglected bodies can normally be considered as small disturbances, which are to be calculated separately, one by one.It is on this idea that the astronomical perturbation theory was proposed and successfully developed over the last three centuries.