Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Synthese Library/Synthese library

Understanding Defective Theories: The Case of Quantum Mechanics and Non-individuality

Moisés Macías-Bustos, María del Rosario Martínez-Ordaz

Published Jan 1, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/978-3-031-31840-5_6

Related papers

Making Sense of Nonindividuals in Quantum Mechanics

Jonas R. Becker Arenhart, Otávio Bueno, Décio Krause

In this work, we focus on a very specific case study: assuming that quantum theories deal with “particles” of some kind (point particles in orthodox non-relativistic quantum mechanics, field excitations in quantum field theories), what kind of entity can such particles be? One possible answer, the one we shall examine here, is that they are not the usual kind of object found in daily life: individuals. Rather, we follow a suggestion by Erwin Schrödinger, according to which quantum mechanics poses a revolutionary kind of entity: non-individuals. While physics, as a scientific field, is not concerned with whether entities posited by a specific physical theory are individuals or not, answering this question is part of the quest for a better understanding of physical reality. Here lies, in large measure, the relevance of ontology.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 11, 2019•38 citations

Non-Individuality in the Formal Structure of Quantum Mechanics

Graciela Domenech, Christian DE RONDE

Manuscrito•Jan 1, 2010•1 citation

Quantum mechanics as a broken symmetry

H.A. Kastrup

Nuclear Physics B•Nov 1, 1968•2 citations

Topological defect formation in quantum phase transitions

Edward Gillman

The Kibble Zurek mechanism describes the universal formation of topological defects during continuous symmetry breaking phase transitions. It has been confirmed in a wide variety of systems and is of interest within theoretical high energy physics and cosmology. While during high temperature phase transitions classical methods can be used to study topological defect formation, in zero temperature quantum phase transitions, quantum effects can dominate dynamics such that classical approximations fail. This is problematic in quantum field theory because topological defect formation constitutes a non-perturbative non-equilibrium phenomenon, yet there are at present no well-developed non-perturbative non-equilibrium methods available for calculations. Nonetheless, due to its generality and confirmation in other cases, the Kibble-Zurek mechanism is expected to hold. This means that in addition to being of physical interest in its own right, the Kibble-Zurek mechanism is also an excellent test for any potential non-perturbative non-equilibrium techniques. In this thesis, tensor network techniques are applied to the problem of confirming the Kibble Zurek mechanism in the phi^4 quantum field theory in D = (1 + 1) spacetime dimensions. Such techniques have already been highly successful in condensed matter and to some extent in quantum field theory. The kink defects of the theory are studied both in equilibrium and in the non-equilibrium scenario of their formation. Results consistent with the Kibble-Zurek mechanism are found, which provides evidence that the mechanism holds in this case and confirms tensor networks as a promising non-perturbative non-equilibrium method for quantum field theory. As tensor network methods are developed further to higher dimensions and more sophisticated theories, they could one day provide a powerful method for the non-perturbative study of non-equilibrium high energy physics and cosmology, an area of physics which remains essentially unexplored yet important for our understanding of nature.

•May 1, 2018•0 citations

Individualistic and Statistical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Peter Mittelstaedt

Boston studies in the philosophy of science•Jan 1, 2000•1 citation

Understanding metaphysical misunderstanding: (non-)individuals and the metaphysical nature of quantum objects

Raoni Wohnrath Arroyo, Jonas R. Becker Arenhart

Abstract Deep scientific realism is scientific realism plus the claim that science requires a metaphysical interpretation. Metaphysics is supposed to fill an intelligibility gap: science by itself, it is argued, does not provide a clear image of reality. The metaphysics needed to deliver the goods comes from a toolbox of concepts furnished by free range metaphysics. Such concepts are developed in connection with a world that is familiar to us, and by being applied to science, they carry this familiarity to the most unfamiliar confines of reality. This article examines the prospects of such a strategy. Focusing on the case of quantum objects’ (non-)individuality, it argues that deep realism fails to deliver the promised intelligibility. Construing quantum entities as non-individuals faces an empty toolbox, ‘non-individuality’ being too closely attached to quantum mechanics itself. Dressing quantum entities as individuals distorts the usual familiarity brought by the concept of individuality, since it now has to conform to the unusual demands of quantum mechanics to the point of being unrecognizable. Instead of enhancing our grasp of quantum reality, the imposition of metaphysical categories risks producing not understanding, but metaphysical misunderstanding.

Synthese•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations
In this work, we focus on a very specific case study: assuming that quantum theories deal with “particles” of some kind (point particles in orthodox non-relativistic quantum mechanics, field excitations in quantum field theories), what kind of entity can such particles be? One possible answer, the one we shall examine here, is that they are not the usual kind of object found in daily life: individuals. Rather, we follow a suggestion by Erwin Schrödinger, according to which quantum mechanics poses a revolutionary kind of entity: non-individuals. While physics, as a scientific field, is not concerned with whether entities posited by a specific physical theory are individuals or not, answering this question is part of the quest for a better understanding of physical reality. Here lies, in large measure, the relevance of ontology.
The Kibble Zurek mechanism describes the universal formation of topological defects during continuous symmetry breaking phase transitions. It has been confirmed in a wide variety of systems and is of interest within theoretical high energy physics and cosmology. While during high temperature phase transitions classical methods can be used to study topological defect formation, in zero temperature quantum phase transitions, quantum effects can dominate dynamics such that classical approximations fail. This is problematic in quantum field theory because topological defect formation constitutes a non-perturbative non-equilibrium phenomenon, yet there are at present no well-developed non-perturbative non-equilibrium methods available for calculations. Nonetheless, due to its generality and confirmation in other cases, the Kibble-Zurek mechanism is expected to hold. This means that in addition to being of physical interest in its own right, the Kibble-Zurek mechanism is also an excellent test for any potential non-perturbative non-equilibrium techniques. In this thesis, tensor network techniques are applied to the problem of confirming the Kibble Zurek mechanism in the phi^4 quantum field theory in D = (1 + 1) spacetime dimensions. Such techniques have already been highly successful in condensed matter and to some extent in quantum field theory. The kink defects of the theory are studied both in equilibrium and in the non-equilibrium scenario of their formation. Results consistent with the Kibble-Zurek mechanism are found, which provides evidence that the mechanism holds in this case and confirms tensor networks as a promising non-perturbative non-equilibrium method for quantum field theory. As tensor network methods are developed further to higher dimensions and more sophisticated theories, they could one day provide a powerful method for the non-perturbative study of non-equilibrium high energy physics and cosmology, an area of physics which remains essentially unexplored yet important for our understanding of nature.
Abstract Deep scientific realism is scientific realism plus the claim that science requires a metaphysical interpretation. Metaphysics is supposed to fill an intelligibility gap: science by itself, it is argued, does not provide a clear image of reality. The metaphysics needed to deliver the goods comes from a toolbox of concepts furnished by free range metaphysics. Such concepts are developed in connection with a world that is familiar to us, and by being applied to science, they carry this familiarity to the most unfamiliar confines of reality. This article examines the prospects of such a strategy. Focusing on the case of quantum objects’ (non-)individuality, it argues that deep realism fails to deliver the promised intelligibility. Construing quantum entities as non-individuals faces an empty toolbox, ‘non-individuality’ being too closely attached to quantum mechanics itself. Dressing quantum entities as individuals distorts the usual familiarity brought by the concept of individuality, since it now has to conform to the unusual demands of quantum mechanics to the point of being unrecognizable. Instead of enhancing our grasp of quantum reality, the imposition of metaphysical categories risks producing not understanding, but metaphysical misunderstanding.