This paper presents a feasibility analysis of GEO-based quantum key distribution (QKD) particularly amenable for regional services. Also the factors impacting link performance with optimum choice of parameters and the challenges associated with such an implementation are discussed. The major factors limiting the utility of GEO-based $QKD$ solution are requirement of large apertures, pointing capabilities for very narrow beams $\sim\mu rad$ and a tight filtering mechanism to limit background noise. Based on an evaluation / trade-off of determining factors, it is found that GEO link can be sustained using available technology in terms of optics & detector efficiencies, even with moderate atmospheric transmittance. In an example use-case over the Indian region, it could potentially provide key rates up to 216 Mb keys per day (vs 180 Mb keys per day in LEO case) which are comparable. Whereas a single GEO based satellite can cater to a large regional footprint, a constellation of LEO satellites would be required to meet similar functional demands with obvious under-utilization of on-board capacities. This feasibility study thus validates GEO-based QKD as a technically viable and preferable option for secure regional services.
This paper presents a feasibility analysis of GEO-based quantum key distribution (QKD) particularly amenable for regional services. Also the factors impacting link performance with optimum choice of parameters and the challenges associated with such an implementation are discussed. The major factors limiting the utility of GEO-based QKD solution are requirement of large apertures, pointing capabilities for very narrow beams ∼μrad and a tight filtering mechanism to limit background noise. Based on an evaluation / trade-off of determining factors, it is found that GEO link can be sustained using available technology in terms of optics & detector efficiencies, even with moderate atmospheric transmittance. In an example use-case over the Indian region, it could potentially provide key rates up to 216 Mb keys per day (vs 180 Mb keys per day in LEO case) which are comparable. Whereas a single GEO based satellite can cater to a large regional footprint, a constellation of LEO satellites would be required to meet similar functional demands with obvious under-utilization of on-board capacities. This feasibility study thus validates GEO-based QKD as a technically viable and preferable option for secure regional services.
Due to the distance limitation of quantum communication via ground-based fibre networks, space-based quantum key distribution (QKD) is a viable solution to extend such networks over continental and, ultimately, over global distances. Compared to LEO, QKD from GEO would offer substantial advantages, i.e. large coverage, continuous link to ground stations (cloud cover limited), 24/24h operation (background limited), no tracking required, however, coming with large link losses seen the space-ground distance. TNO, together with Eutelsat and CGI-NL, performed a detailed study on the feasibility of QKD from GEO, including a high level system design of payload and ground segment. We conclude that QKD from GEO is technically feasible, and a favourable solution if the satellite needs to act as an untrusted node (that is, no security assumptions required for the space segment). However, the optimal solution, generating a higher value-for-money, is to use a hybrid system, implementing an untrusted and trusted mode BBM92 QKD protocol. In order to arrive at a minimum required secure bit rate of ~1 bit/s in untrusted mode, a 2x ~0.5m diameter telescope in the space segment is required with <0.25µrad pointing accuracy, a <1GHz entangled photon source, in combination with ~2m diameter telescopes on ground. Details on our assumptions and results and drawings of the high level system design will be presented, as well as the development roadmap describing the required technology improvements and building blocks for the overall hybrid approach, which is applicable to non-GEO applications as well.
This study aims at extending the concept of QKD to the optical free-space quantum communications domain. Moreover, the feasibility of a global satellite based quantum key distribution, in the low earth orbit (LEO) is investigated. Inline with this, three different link scenarios, including ground-to-ground, ground-to-satellite and satellite-to-satellite are considered. Moreover, system performance is analysed to show the sensitivity of the link to effect such as atmospheric attenuation, turbulence and detector noise. Generally, these factors are assumed to impair system performance by causing an overall increase in the systems quantum bit error rate (QBER), let alone limiting the communication bit rate and transmission distance of the link. The obtained results reveal the feasibility of satellite-based quantum key distribution in the LEO platform, a concept which could be potentially extended to geostationary earth orbit (GEO).
Quantum key distribution (QKD) via geostationary Earth orbit (GEO) satellites offers a compelling route to continuous, continental-scale secure communications. However, operation in this regime entails extreme channel loss and significant background noise, particularly if daylight operation is desired. We present a comprehensive end-to-end feasibility study of a decoy-state BB84 protocol in a GEO downlink configuration, incorporating variable-length finite-key security and tight statistical bounds to expand the achievable positive-key regime. Our analysis encompasses the principal receiver architectures relevant to downlink QKD and employs a physically realistic channel model that captures the dominant loss and noise mechanisms. We evaluate performance across rural, urban, and coastal environments at multiple wavelengths, including visible Fraunhofer absorption minima and the telecom band. Using historical cloud data across Europe, we forecast the annual secret-key yield across the continent. Through a systematic exploration of the high-dimensional parameter space, we identify key trade-offs and performance bottlenecks that determine feasibility. These results establish practical operating thresholds and provide actionable design guidelines for future GEO-QKD missions.
As Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) seems to turn towards satellite communication infrastructure to interconnect distant nodes aiming to a global quantum secured network, the number of assisting satellites is expected to increase. In this work, a feasibility analysis of a large-scale Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellite constellation supporting LEO to ground QKD links is presented. A software tool to simulate the physical properties of a large-scale satellite constellation and a link budget calculator tailored for LEO satellite to ground QKD links have been developed. A large-scale LEO satellite constellation with 100 satellites orbiting at 550km altitude with 53deg inclination angle in ten different orbital planes (10 satellites per orbital plane) has been simulated and subsatellite points for 1 year have been obtained. Assuming, an optical ground station network consisting of nine different optical ground stations located in observatories across Europe, the performance of this large-scale constellation is evaluated in terms of availability and Secure Key Rate (SKR) employing the prepare and measure Decoy-State BB84 QKD protocol, during nighttime, under different atmospheric conditions including cloud coverage and turbulence effects among others, while two different wavelengths (i.e., 800nm and 1550nm) are examined. For each Optical Ground Station (OGS) location, Gbits of distilled keys per year per ground station and key rates up to Kbps are reported.
The usage of QKD protocols through the current terrestrial infrastructure is limited to a hundred kilometers due to attenuation problems with fiber. This implies that the satellite will be necessary for the transmission of quantum keys in order to avoid these terrestrial limitations. Therefore, the current debate does not lie in the need for the satellite but rather in what type of infrastructure will be best suited, and specifically the usage of GEO vs LEO satellites. This analysis is not trivial and should not consider only the link budgets and the physical layer as it has been done up to date. It should also consider even more important factors, as the service KPIs that the end user will request such as key rate, availability, security of the keys and their maintenance, etc., as well as the possible communications architectures to provide the service. Therefore, the analysis should introduce the market oriented component, and provide the optimal solutions based on the scenarios and requirements requested by the customer. In this frame, and under ESA ARTES funding, a Spanish consortium led by Hispasat is defining an operational GEO QKD mission that shall fly as hosted payload in 2025. The quantum communications payload proposed in this mission represents a step beyond the state of the art since it is the first implementation of a quantum key distribution channel from geostationary orbit. This new service will involve the implementation of a complete communications system not currently available that will require the development of new technological elements and the adaptation for their operation in space of technologies such as photon sources, telescopes for optical communications compatible with quantum state transmission or processors for the distillation of quantum keys, as well as a whole new ground segment to control and manage the new quantum key distribution service and its integration into a future European secure quantum communications network. Details of the challenges and approach of this mission shall be presented
Quantum key distribution (QKD) has gained a lot of attention over the past few years, but the implementation of quantum security applications is still challenging to accomplish with the current technology. Towards a global-scale quantum-secured network, satellite communications seem to be a promising candidate to successfully support the quantum communication infrastructure (QCI) by delivering quantum keys to optical ground terminals. In this research, we examined the feasibility of satellite-to-ground QKD under daylight and nighttime conditions using the decoy-state BB84 QKD protocol. We evaluated its performance on a hypothetical constellation with 10 satellites in sun-synchronous Low Earth Orbit (LEO) that are assumed to communicate over a period of one year with three optical ground stations (OGSs) located in Greece. By taking into account the atmospheric effects of turbulence as well as the background solar radiance, we showed that positive normalized secure key rates (SKRs) up to 3.9×10−4 (bps/pulse) can be obtained, which implies that satellite-to-ground QKD can be feasible for various conditions, under realistic assumptions in an existing infrastructure.