Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Beam Science

Quantum Beam Scattering—Beam’s Coherence Length, Which-Path Information and Weak Values

C. A. Chatzidimitriou‐Dreismann

Published Aug 15, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The conventional theory of neutron beams interacting with many-body systems treats the beam as a classical system, i.e., with its dynamical variables appearing in the quantum dynamics of the scattering process not as operators but only as c-numbers. Moreover, neutrons are described with plane waves, i.e., the concept of a neutron’s (finite) coherence length is here irrelevant. The same holds for electron, atom or X-ray scattering. This simplification results in the full decoupling of the probe particle’s dynamics from the quantum dynamics of the scatterer—a well-known fact also reflected in the standard formalism of time-correlation functions (see textbooks). Making contact with modern quantum-theoretical approaches (e.g., quantum entanglement, “which-path information” versus interference, von Neumann measurement, Weak Values (WV), etc.), new observable effects of non-relativistic quantum beam scattering may be exposed and/or predicted, for instance, a momentum-transfer deficit and an intensity deficit in neutron scattering from protons of hydrogen-containing samples. A new WV-theoretical treatment is provided, which explains both these “deficit effects” from first principles and on equal footing.

DOI
10.3390/qubs7030026

Related papers

Quantum Neutron Scattering — Feynman Paths Information, Weak Values and Intensity Deficit Effect

C. A. Chatzidimitriou‐Dreismann

Abstract The conventional theory of non-relativistic neutron beam scattering from many-body systems treats the beam essentially as a classical system, because the neutron dynamical variables are captured in the main theoretical formulas (e.g. time-correlation functions) not as quantum mechanical operators but as c-numbers only. This simplification results in the full decoupling of the probe particles’ dynamics from the quantum dynamics of the scatterer. Further, neutrons’ wavefunctions are represented with plane waves, and thus the concept of neutron’s finite coherence length in momentum space becomes irrelevant. Making contact with modern quantum theoretical approaches (e.g., quantum entanglement, Feynman paths, “which-path information” versus interference, Weak Values theory) new observable effects of non-relativistic quantum beam scattering may be exposed and/or predicted, such as a surprising intensity deficit in neutron Compton scattering (NCS) of epithermal neutrons from protons of H-containing materials. Here, the NCS-intensity deficit observed in scattering from liquid C6H6 is discussed and interpreted from first principles, in the general frame of Weak Values theory. Moreover, based on Feynman’s didactical argument that there isn’t any interference between distinguishable neutron paths, we show that this NCS-effect cannot be interpreted as being caused by destructive interference of neutron paths scattered from entangled (two or a few) protons, as was earlier proposed by some authors.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Nov 1, 2024•0 citations

Weak Values and Quantum Information in Scattering Physics — New Theoretical and Experimental Effects

C. A. Chatzidimitriou‐Dreismann

Abstract Weak Values (WV) and Two-State-Vector Formalism (TSVF) provide novel insights in various quantum physical and technological fields. In the first part of the paper we consider a new quantum effect of scattering accompanying an elementary collision of two quantum systems A and B, in which the latter interacts with a quantum environment. In clear contrast to a classical environment, the quantum case can exhibit counter-intuitive effects of momentum- and energy-transfer which contradict conventional expectations. Experimental evidence of a new effect—deficit of momentum transfer (equivalently: reduced effective mass) in a neutron-atom collision—is presented and theoretically interpreted. Here, non-relativistic incoherent inelastic neutron scattering (INS) is applied. INS on single H2 molecules confined in multi-walled carbon nanotube channels has been experimentally investigated. Interpreted within conventional theory, the results reveal a counter-intuitive reduced effective mass of the recoiling H2 molecule, i.e. M = 0.64 a.m.u. (atomic mass units). In contrast, this finding has a simple qualitative interpretation within WV and TSVF theory. In the second part of the paper we report on current experimental and theoretical investigations in the field of X-ray diffraction (XRD), which belongs to coherent scattering. Preliminary XRD results from cubic crystalline materials show a surprising variation of the measured lattice parameter (usually called “lattice constant”) with momentum transfer. A first theoretical model of the effect in the light of the new theory is presented. These findings give further evidence for the broad character and significance of the novel WV and TSVF theory.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 1, 2020•0 citations

Weak measurement and weak values — New insights and effects in reflectivity and scattering processes

C. A. Chatzidimitriou‐Dreismann

Recently, the notions of Weak Measurement (WM), Weak Value (WV) and Two-State-Vector Formalism (TSVF), firstly introduced by Aharonov and collaborators, have extended the theoretical frame of standard quantum mechanics, thus providing a quantum-theoretical formalism for extracting new information from a system in the limit of small disturbance to its state. Here we provide an application to the case of two-body scattering with one body weakly interacting with its environment — e.g. a neutron being scattered from a H 2 molecule physisorbed in a carbon nanotube. In particular, we make contact with the field of incoherent inelastic neutron scattering from condensed systems. We provide a physically compelling prediction of a new quantum effect — a momentum transfer deficit; or equivalently, an enhanced energy transfer; or an apparent reduction of the mass of the struck particle. E.g., when a neutron collides with a H 2 molecule in a C-nanotube and excites its translational motion along the nanotube, it apparently exchanges energy and momentum with a fictitious particle with mass of 0.64 atomic mass units. Experimental results are shown and discussed in the new theoretical frame. The effect under consideration has no conventional interpretation, thus also supporting the novelty of the quantum theoretical framework of WV and TVSF. Some speculative remarks about possible applications being of technological interest (fuel cells and hydrogen storage; Li + batteries; information and communication technology) are shortly mentioned.

arXiv:1803.00836•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 1, 2018•2 citations

Weak Measurement and Two-State-Vector Formalism: Deficit of Momentum Transfer in Scattering Processes

C. A. Chatzidimitriou‐Dreismann

The notions of weak measurement, weak value, and two-state-vector formalism provide a new quantum-theoretical frame for extracting additional information from a system in the limit of small disturbances to its state. Here, we provide an application to the case of two-body scattering with one body weakly interacting with an environment. The direct connection to real scattering experiments is pointed out by making contact with the field of impulsive incoherent neutron scattering from molecules and condensed systems. In particular, we predict a new quantum effect in neutron-atom collisions, namely an observable momentum transfer deficit; or equivalently, a reduction of effective mass below that of the free scattering atom. Two corroborative experimental findings are shortly presented. Implications for current and further experiments are mentioned. An interpretation of this effect and the associated experimental results within conventional theory is currently unavailable. Quanta 2016; 5: 61–84.

arXiv:1611.00272•Quanta•Oct 28, 2016•10 citations

Toward a Quantum Information Foundation for Neutron Scattering

Michael J. Landry, Yongqiang Cheng, Daniel M. Pajerowski +2 more

Neutron scattering is a central probe of quantum materials, yet what quantum information can, in principle, be extracted from a scattering experiment remains unclear. Here we formulate neutron scattering as a quantum measurement, with the scattering amplitudes acting as Kraus operators on the material state. This provides a unified description of conventional intensity, coherent scattering, interferometric measurements, and entanglement witnesses, including those based on quantum Fisher information. We then ask how far this connection can be extended to nonlinear properties of a quantum state. For two independently prepared samples, we derive the general structure of probe-mediated measurement probabilities and show that, for spin-projection-conserving dynamics, low-order scattering cannot resolve certain many-body coherences required to determine purity. Conversely, an idealized single-spin protocol shows how probe-mediated exchange can access purity when the appropriate two-copy operation is realized. Our results establish a quantum-information description of neutron scattering and delineate the information accessible through conventional and interferometric measurements.

arXiv:2611.05466•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

Quantum mechanics illustrated with neutrons

Vladimir K. Ignatovich

The book contains four chapters. The first one deals with elementary problems of one dimensional quantum mechanics of scalar particles, and their solution is given by much more simpler method than in standard textbooks. Attention should be paid to problems with periodic potentials. In the second chapter methods of one-dimensional quantum mechanics are applied to three-dimensional scattering problems. Here a new approach to the dynamic diffraction theory based on multiple wave scattering method is proposed. Diffraction on a crystalline plane is solved exactly, and is shown to vanish in contradiction with experimental observations. In the third chapter, all the problems of the first one are generalized to spinor particles. The most interesting questions are related to polarization of particles and rotation of polarization by means of radio-frequency fields, which create superpositions of states with different energies and speeds. The fourth chapter is devoted to fundamental questions of quantum mechanics. The theory of weak measurements is criticized. Some experiments related to wave packets and to determination of quantization axis of non polarized neutron beams are proposed.

•Jun 15, 2018•0 citations
The conventional theory of neutron beams interacting with many-body systems treats the beam as a classical system, i.e., with its dynamical variables appearing in the quantum dynamics of the scattering process not as operators but only as c-numbers. Moreover, neutrons are described with plane waves, i.e., the concept of a neutron’s (finite) coherence length is here irrelevant. The same holds for electron, atom or X-ray scattering. This simplification results in the full decoupling of the probe particle’s dynamics from the quantum dynamics of the scatterer—a well-known fact also reflected in the standard formalism of time-correlation functions (see textbooks). Making contact with modern quantum-theoretical approaches (e.g., quantum entanglement, “which-path information” versus interference, von Neumann measurement, Weak Values (WV), etc.), new observable effects of non-relativistic quantum beam scattering may be exposed and/or predicted, for instance, a momentum-transfer deficit and an intensity deficit in neutron scattering from protons of hydrogen-containing samples. A new WV-theoretical treatment is provided, which explains both these “deficit effects” from first principles and on equal footing.
Abstract The conventional theory of non-relativistic neutron beam scattering from many-body systems treats the beam essentially as a classical system, because the neutron dynamical variables are captured in the main theoretical formulas (e.g. time-correlation functions) not as quantum mechanical operators but as c-numbers only. This simplification results in the full decoupling of the probe particles’ dynamics from the quantum dynamics of the scatterer. Further, neutrons’ wavefunctions are represented with plane waves, and thus the concept of neutron’s finite coherence length in momentum space becomes irrelevant. Making contact with modern quantum theoretical approaches (e.g., quantum entanglement, Feynman paths, “which-path information” versus interference, Weak Values theory) new observable effects of non-relativistic quantum beam scattering may be exposed and/or predicted, such as a surprising intensity deficit in neutron Compton scattering (NCS) of epithermal neutrons from protons of H-containing materials. Here, the NCS-intensity deficit observed in scattering from liquid C6H6 is discussed and interpreted from first principles, in the general frame of Weak Values theory. Moreover, based on Feynman’s didactical argument that there isn’t any interference between distinguishable neutron paths, we show that this NCS-effect cannot be interpreted as being caused by destructive interference of neutron paths scattered from entangled (two or a few) protons, as was earlier proposed by some authors.
Abstract Weak Values (WV) and Two-State-Vector Formalism (TSVF) provide novel insights in various quantum physical and technological fields. In the first part of the paper we consider a new quantum effect of scattering accompanying an elementary collision of two quantum systems A and B, in which the latter interacts with a quantum environment. In clear contrast to a classical environment, the quantum case can exhibit counter-intuitive effects of momentum- and energy-transfer which contradict conventional expectations. Experimental evidence of a new effect—deficit of momentum transfer (equivalently: reduced effective mass) in a neutron-atom collision—is presented and theoretically interpreted. Here, non-relativistic incoherent inelastic neutron scattering (INS) is applied. INS on single H2 molecules confined in multi-walled carbon nanotube channels has been experimentally investigated. Interpreted within conventional theory, the results reveal a counter-intuitive reduced effective mass of the recoiling H2 molecule, i.e. M = 0.64 a.m.u. (atomic mass units). In contrast, this finding has a simple qualitative interpretation within WV and TSVF theory. In the second part of the paper we report on current experimental and theoretical investigations in the field of X-ray diffraction (XRD), which belongs to coherent scattering. Preliminary XRD results from cubic crystalline materials show a surprising variation of the measured lattice parameter (usually called “lattice constant”) with momentum transfer. A first theoretical model of the effect in the light of the new theory is presented. These findings give further evidence for the broad character and significance of the novel WV and TSVF theory.
Recently, the notions of Weak Measurement (WM), Weak Value (WV) and Two-State-Vector Formalism (TSVF), firstly introduced by Aharonov and collaborators, have extended the theoretical frame of standard quantum mechanics, thus providing a quantum-theoretical formalism for extracting new information from a system in the limit of small disturbance to its state. Here we provide an application to the case of two-body scattering with one body weakly interacting with its environment — e.g. a neutron being scattered from a H 2 molecule physisorbed in a carbon nanotube. In particular, we make contact with the field of incoherent inelastic neutron scattering from condensed systems. We provide a physically compelling prediction of a new quantum effect — a momentum transfer deficit; or equivalently, an enhanced energy transfer; or an apparent reduction of the mass of the struck particle. E.g., when a neutron collides with a H 2 molecule in a C-nanotube and excites its translational motion along the nanotube, it apparently exchanges energy and momentum with a fictitious particle with mass of 0.64 atomic mass units. Experimental results are shown and discussed in the new theoretical frame. The effect under consideration has no conventional interpretation, thus also supporting the novelty of the quantum theoretical framework of WV and TVSF. Some speculative remarks about possible applications being of technological interest (fuel cells and hydrogen storage; Li + batteries; information and communication technology) are shortly mentioned.
The notions of weak measurement, weak value, and two-state-vector formalism provide a new quantum-theoretical frame for extracting additional information from a system in the limit of small disturbances to its state. Here, we provide an application to the case of two-body scattering with one body weakly interacting with an environment. The direct connection to real scattering experiments is pointed out by making contact with the field of impulsive incoherent neutron scattering from molecules and condensed systems. In particular, we predict a new quantum effect in neutron-atom collisions, namely an observable momentum transfer deficit; or equivalently, a reduction of effective mass below that of the free scattering atom. Two corroborative experimental findings are shortly presented. Implications for current and further experiments are mentioned. An interpretation of this effect and the associated experimental results within conventional theory is currently unavailable. Quanta 2016; 5: 61–84.
Neutron scattering is a central probe of quantum materials, yet what quantum information can, in principle, be extracted from a scattering experiment remains unclear. Here we formulate neutron scattering as a quantum measurement, with the scattering amplitudes acting as Kraus operators on the material state. This provides a unified description of conventional intensity, coherent scattering, interferometric measurements, and entanglement witnesses, including those based on quantum Fisher information. We then ask how far this connection can be extended to nonlinear properties of a quantum state. For two independently prepared samples, we derive the general structure of probe-mediated measurement probabilities and show that, for spin-projection-conserving dynamics, low-order scattering cannot resolve certain many-body coherences required to determine purity. Conversely, an idealized single-spin protocol shows how probe-mediated exchange can access purity when the appropriate two-copy operation is realized. Our results establish a quantum-information description of neutron scattering and delineate the information accessible through conventional and interferometric measurements.
The book contains four chapters. The first one deals with elementary problems of one dimensional quantum mechanics of scalar particles, and their solution is given by much more simpler method than in standard textbooks. Attention should be paid to problems with periodic potentials. In the second chapter methods of one-dimensional quantum mechanics are applied to three-dimensional scattering problems. Here a new approach to the dynamic diffraction theory based on multiple wave scattering method is proposed. Diffraction on a crystalline plane is solved exactly, and is shown to vanish in contradiction with experimental observations. In the third chapter, all the problems of the first one are generalized to spinor particles. The most interesting questions are related to polarization of particles and rotation of polarization by means of radio-frequency fields, which create superpositions of states with different energies and speeds. The fourth chapter is devoted to fundamental questions of quantum mechanics. The theory of weak measurements is criticized. Some experiments related to wave packets and to determination of quantization axis of non polarized neutron beams are proposed.