Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Contradictions between a Quantum-Mechanical Model of the photon and the Detection Principle of FMCW Measurements

André Malz

Published Jul 26, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract This article presents a study that provides robust evidence supporting the continuity of the electromagnetic field, while highlighting contradictions between a quantum-mechanical model of the photon and the detection principle of Frequency-Modulated Continuous Wave (FMCW) measurements. The primary objective was to investigate the detection method of FMCW for extremely weak signals, reaching energy levels akin to photons. Through thorough examination, significant contradictions emerged, favoring classical field theory and challenging the notion of electromagnetic field quantization. To strengthen this claim, a carefully designed experiment was conducted to measure sub-photon energy levels. The comprehensive analysis of both theoretical insights and experimental data presents compelling evidence, demonstrating the untenability of a quantized model for the electromagnetic field. These findings have profound implications for understanding the continuity of the electromagnetic field, prompting further exploration in this field of research.

DOI
10.21203/rs.3.rs-3170886/v1

Related papers

Experimental Evidence for the Continuity of the Electromagnetic Field: Contradictions between a Quantum-Mechanical Model of the Photon and the Detection Principle of FMCW Measurements

André Malz

This article presents a study that provides robust evidence supporting the continuity of the electromagnetic field, while highlighting contradictions between a quantum-mechanical model of the photon and the detection principle of Frequency-Modulated Continuous Wave (FMCW) measurements.The primary objective was to investigate the detection method of FMCW for extremely weak signals, reaching energy levels akin to photons.Through thorough examination, significant contradictions emerged, favoring classical field theory and challenging the notion of electromagnetic field quantization.To strengthen this claim, a carefully designed experiment was conducted to measure sub-photon energy levels.The comprehensive analysis of both theoretical insights and experimental data presents compelling evidence, demonstrating the untenability of a quantized model for the electromagnetic field.These findings have profound implications for understanding the continuity of the electromagnetic field, prompting further exploration in this field of research.

•Jul 13, 2023•0 citations

Disproving the Existence of Photons

André Malz

This article presents a comprehensive study that furnishes compelling evidence bolstering the notion of electromagnetic field continuity, accomplished through the implementation of a self-heterodyne measurement technique.The primary objective was to investigate the detection method of FMCW for extremely weak signals, reaching energy levels akin to photons.Through thorough examination, significant contradictions emerged, favoring classical field theory and challenging the notion of electromagnetic field quantization.To strengthen this claim, a carefully designed experiment was conducted to measure sub-photon energy levels.The comprehensive analysis of both theoretical insights and experimental data presents compelling evidence, demonstrating the untenability of a quantized model for the electromagnetic field.These findings have profound implications for understanding the continuity of the electromagnetic field, prompting further exploration in this field of research.

•Dec 1, 2023•1 citation

From contextuality of a single photon to realism of an electromagnetic wave

Marcin Markiewicz, Dagomir Kaszlikowski, Paweł Kurzyński +1 more

Abstract Violations of Bell inequalities have been an incontestable indicator of non-classicality since the seminal paper by John Bell. However, recent claims of Bell inequalities violations with classical light have cast some doubts on their significance as hallmarks of non-classicality. Here, we challenge those claims. The crux of the problem is that such classical experiments simulate quantum probabilities with intensities of classical fields. However, fields intensities measurements are radically different from single-photon detections, which are primitives of any genuine Bell experiment. We show that this fundamental difference between field intensities measurements and single photon detections shifts the classical bound of relevant Bell inequalities to its non-signaling limit, leaving no place for their violations.

arXiv:1801.02338•The Rochester Conferences on Coherence and Quantum Optics and the Quantum Information and Measurement meeting•Jan 1, 2019•19 citations

Are There Photons? - Heterodyning Ultra Low Intensity Electromagnetic Fields

André Malz

In exploring the true essence of electromagnetic fields, heterodyning emerges as superior to traditional detection methods. Within heterodyning, a segment of the signal operates independently of field-matter interaction, relying solely on field-field interaction. Consequently, this approach facilitates the statistical elimination of detector influence. Analysis of the gathered data unveils energy levels comparable to those of a few photons, which are fractional and may even descend below the threshold of a single photon, thus evading any quantization effects. This unequivocally falsifies the concept of photons.

•Mar 28, 2024•0 citations

A quantum model of communication systems

M. Dayne Aldridge

The problem of including quantum effects within existing methods of communication system analysis is investigated.A mathematical model is postulated for describing narrow bandwidth systems.Utilizing the Glauber P representation, the model permits analysis of both real field detection (measurement of electric and magnetic field magnitudes) and photon detection.The resulting equation which describes photon detection is shown to be consistent with previous work which has been proven experimentally.Unique aspects of the postulated model are its ability to describe both random and deterministic modulation functions in conventional terms, and its ability to demonstrate the inapplicability of the "photon channel" model for describing present-day systems.An analysis of quantum effects at the transmitter shows that modulation of the radiated field must take place by one of two distinctly different processes.Wave modulation is defined as a process which conveys information in the amplitude and phase of the electromagnetic field.Photon modulation is defined as a process which conveys information in the exact number of photons per pulse of the transmitted field (i.e., the "photon channel" of Stern, Gordon, ani othfrs).A wave modulated signal is shown to describe present-day modulation schemes and, moreover, to yield random photon fluctuations.It is concluded a wave modulated signal is not capable of describing a photon modulated signal.In contrast, a photon modulated signal is shown to possess a completely random phase fluctuation thus demonstrating the inability of the "photon channel" to describe presently used wave modulation schemes.For wave modulation the Glauber P function is shown to be identical (with a change of variable) to the classical joint probability density of the quadrature components of a narrowband sinusoid used in conventional analysis.Equations are derived which "transform" classical probability distributions into distributions which include quantum effects.The "partitioning noise" studied by Hagfors and Bowen is found to constitute a source of noise only in the "photon channel."The "partitioning effect" is shown to merely preserve the Poisson character of photon counts in wave modulated fields and therefore does not introduce a noise in present-day systems.For a wave modulated system with real field detection it is shown that photon noise can be included in conventional analysis by adding to the normal input noise, a noise density of hf c /2 Watts/Hertz where h is Planck's constant and f is the system carrier frequency.Use of photon heterodyne detection requires the addition of an input noise density of hf c Watts/Hertz.The photon noise is exactly additive Gaussian for real field detection and approximately additive Gaussian for photon heterodyne detection.Detection by counting the received photons is shown to yield neither Gaussian nor Poissonian statistics.However, with an "ideal measurement process," when the effective received noise density n c is much less than hf c , the variance of the counts are found to approach that of a Poisson distribution.Conversely, when nc is much larger than hf c , the .variance approaches that derivable from a classical analysis.A channel capacity equation for a wave modulated system is found which is equal to those derived by Lachs and Jelsma.The equation is shown to give capacities less than that derived by Gordon.

•Jun 1, 1968•0 citations

Can the quantum theory of light contain the classical electromagnetic theory of light?

Yongchao Gan

Based on the theoretical derivation and experimental data, the declaration that the quantum theory of light can contain the classical electromagnetic theory of light is oppugned, and two dead-points are put forward. One is the nonconservation of the energy of the electromagnetic field before and after quantization due to a number of zero point energy, and the other is that the real electromagnetic wave, as a matter, will lose its real material nature in theory, or only as a substitute of photons. Finally, a crucial experiment is designed to demonstrate and compare the accuracy of quantum theory and classical electromagnetic theory in the classical condition.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 20, 2009•1 citation
Abstract This article presents a study that provides robust evidence supporting the continuity of the electromagnetic field, while highlighting contradictions between a quantum-mechanical model of the photon and the detection principle of Frequency-Modulated Continuous Wave (FMCW) measurements. The primary objective was to investigate the detection method of FMCW for extremely weak signals, reaching energy levels akin to photons. Through thorough examination, significant contradictions emerged, favoring classical field theory and challenging the notion of electromagnetic field quantization. To strengthen this claim, a carefully designed experiment was conducted to measure sub-photon energy levels. The comprehensive analysis of both theoretical insights and experimental data presents compelling evidence, demonstrating the untenability of a quantized model for the electromagnetic field. These findings have profound implications for understanding the continuity of the electromagnetic field, prompting further exploration in this field of research.
This article presents a study that provides robust evidence supporting the continuity of the electromagnetic field, while highlighting contradictions between a quantum-mechanical model of the photon and the detection principle of Frequency-Modulated Continuous Wave (FMCW) measurements.The primary objective was to investigate the detection method of FMCW for extremely weak signals, reaching energy levels akin to photons.Through thorough examination, significant contradictions emerged, favoring classical field theory and challenging the notion of electromagnetic field quantization.To strengthen this claim, a carefully designed experiment was conducted to measure sub-photon energy levels.The comprehensive analysis of both theoretical insights and experimental data presents compelling evidence, demonstrating the untenability of a quantized model for the electromagnetic field.These findings have profound implications for understanding the continuity of the electromagnetic field, prompting further exploration in this field of research.
This article presents a comprehensive study that furnishes compelling evidence bolstering the notion of electromagnetic field continuity, accomplished through the implementation of a self-heterodyne measurement technique.The primary objective was to investigate the detection method of FMCW for extremely weak signals, reaching energy levels akin to photons.Through thorough examination, significant contradictions emerged, favoring classical field theory and challenging the notion of electromagnetic field quantization.To strengthen this claim, a carefully designed experiment was conducted to measure sub-photon energy levels.The comprehensive analysis of both theoretical insights and experimental data presents compelling evidence, demonstrating the untenability of a quantized model for the electromagnetic field.These findings have profound implications for understanding the continuity of the electromagnetic field, prompting further exploration in this field of research.
Abstract Violations of Bell inequalities have been an incontestable indicator of non-classicality since the seminal paper by John Bell. However, recent claims of Bell inequalities violations with classical light have cast some doubts on their significance as hallmarks of non-classicality. Here, we challenge those claims. The crux of the problem is that such classical experiments simulate quantum probabilities with intensities of classical fields. However, fields intensities measurements are radically different from single-photon detections, which are primitives of any genuine Bell experiment. We show that this fundamental difference between field intensities measurements and single photon detections shifts the classical bound of relevant Bell inequalities to its non-signaling limit, leaving no place for their violations.
In exploring the true essence of electromagnetic fields, heterodyning emerges as superior to traditional detection methods. Within heterodyning, a segment of the signal operates independently of field-matter interaction, relying solely on field-field interaction. Consequently, this approach facilitates the statistical elimination of detector influence. Analysis of the gathered data unveils energy levels comparable to those of a few photons, which are fractional and may even descend below the threshold of a single photon, thus evading any quantization effects. This unequivocally falsifies the concept of photons.
The problem of including quantum effects within existing methods of communication system analysis is investigated.A mathematical model is postulated for describing narrow bandwidth systems.Utilizing the Glauber P representation, the model permits analysis of both real field detection (measurement of electric and magnetic field magnitudes) and photon detection.The resulting equation which describes photon detection is shown to be consistent with previous work which has been proven experimentally.Unique aspects of the postulated model are its ability to describe both random and deterministic modulation functions in conventional terms, and its ability to demonstrate the inapplicability of the "photon channel" model for describing present-day systems.An analysis of quantum effects at the transmitter shows that modulation of the radiated field must take place by one of two distinctly different processes.Wave modulation is defined as a process which conveys information in the amplitude and phase of the electromagnetic field.Photon modulation is defined as a process which conveys information in the exact number of photons per pulse of the transmitted field (i.e., the "photon channel" of Stern, Gordon, ani othfrs).A wave modulated signal is shown to describe present-day modulation schemes and, moreover, to yield random photon fluctuations.It is concluded a wave modulated signal is not capable of describing a photon modulated signal.In contrast, a photon modulated signal is shown to possess a completely random phase fluctuation thus demonstrating the inability of the "photon channel" to describe presently used wave modulation schemes.For wave modulation the Glauber P function is shown to be identical (with a change of variable) to the classical joint probability density of the quadrature components of a narrowband sinusoid used in conventional analysis.Equations are derived which "transform" classical probability distributions into distributions which include quantum effects.The "partitioning noise" studied by Hagfors and Bowen is found to constitute a source of noise only in the "photon channel."The "partitioning effect" is shown to merely preserve the Poisson character of photon counts in wave modulated fields and therefore does not introduce a noise in present-day systems.For a wave modulated system with real field detection it is shown that photon noise can be included in conventional analysis by adding to the normal input noise, a noise density of hf c /2 Watts/Hertz where h is Planck's constant and f is the system carrier frequency.Use of photon heterodyne detection requires the addition of an input noise density of hf c Watts/Hertz.The photon noise is exactly additive Gaussian for real field detection and approximately additive Gaussian for photon heterodyne detection.Detection by counting the received photons is shown to yield neither Gaussian nor Poissonian statistics.However, with an "ideal measurement process," when the effective received noise density n c is much less than hf c , the variance of the counts are found to approach that of a Poisson distribution.Conversely, when nc is much larger than hf c , the .variance approaches that derivable from a classical analysis.A channel capacity equation for a wave modulated system is found which is equal to those derived by Lachs and Jelsma.The equation is shown to give capacities less than that derived by Gordon.
Based on the theoretical derivation and experimental data, the declaration that the quantum theory of light can contain the classical electromagnetic theory of light is oppugned, and two dead-points are put forward. One is the nonconservation of the energy of the electromagnetic field before and after quantization due to a number of zero point energy, and the other is that the real electromagnetic wave, as a matter, will lose its real material nature in theory, or only as a substitute of photons. Finally, a crucial experiment is designed to demonstrate and compare the accuracy of quantum theory and classical electromagnetic theory in the classical condition.