Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entropy

Gas of Particles Obeying the Monotone Statistics

Francesco Fidaleo

Published Jul 21, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The present note is devoted to the detailed investigation of a concrete model satisfying the block-monotone statistics introduced in a previous paper (joint, with collaborators) of the author. The model under consideration indeed describes the free gas of massless particles in a one-dimensional environment. This investigation can have consequences in two fundamental respects. The first one concerns the applicability of the (block-)monotone statistics to concrete physical models, yet completely unknown. Since the formula for the degeneracy of the energy-levels of the one-particle Hamiltonian of a free particle is very involved, the second aspect might be related to the, highly nontrivial, investigation of the expected thermodynamics of the free gas of particles obeying the block-monotone statistics in arbitrary spatial dimensions. A final section contains a comparison between the various (block, strict, and weak) monotone schemes with the Boltzmann statistics, which describes the gas of classical particles. It is seen that the block-monotone statistics, which takes into account the degeneracy of the energy-levels, seems the unique one having realistic physical applications.

DOI
10.3390/e25071095

Related papers

On the Thermodynamics of Particles Obeying Monotone Statistics

Fabio Ciolli, Francesco Fidaleo, Chiara Marullo

The aim of the present paper is to provide a preliminary investigation of the thermodynamics of particles obeying monotone statistics. To render the potential physical applications realistic, we propose a modified scheme called block-monotone, based on a partial order arising from the natural one on the spectrum of a positive Hamiltonian with compact resolvent. The block-monotone scheme is never comparable with the weak monotone one and is reduced to the usual monotone scheme whenever all the eigenvalues of the involved Hamiltonian are non-degenerate. Through a detailed analysis of a model based on the quantum harmonic oscillator, we can see that: (a) the computation of the grand-partition function does not require the Gibbs correction factor n! (connected with the indistinguishability of particles) in the various terms of its expansion with respect to the activity; and (b) the decimation of terms contributing to the grand-partition function leads to a kind of “exclusion principle” analogous to the Pauli exclusion principle enjoined by Fermi particles, which is more relevant in the high-density regime and becomes negligible in the low-density regime, as expected.

arXiv:2301.11016•Entropy•Jan 22, 2023•1 citation

Quantum Bound State Statistics From Classical Free Particle Action?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In a previous note (1) we argued that both the relativistic A= -mo t sqrt(1-vv) and nonrelativistic A=t .5mvv classical free particle actions may be written with v=x/t and x and t varied independently to yield: dA/dx partial = p and dA/dt partial = -E. Thus A is equivalent to -Et + px for a free particle with x and t being treated as independent. We argue in this note that such an assumption is equivalent to a statistical picture for a free particle even at the classical level because x and t are treated as independent. Thus a constant p may occur at any x because no time is linked to x. Given that all space points are the same for constant p one expects a constant probability at all x points. Knowing p exactly means not knowing anything about which x one has. Secondly, one may create an ensemble of free particle p classical actions for a situation containing a potential V(x). Given that x and t are independent, there cannot be any notion of single p accelerating, although a vrms from an ensemble may. At a given x (x known exactly) one does not know which p is present. Thus the ideas of uncertainty of p and x follow immediately from this picture. If one considers a single particle and an ensemble of free particles in the x-t independent scenario, then each free particle action p is linked to A=-Et+px where E=pp/2m. This ensemble would arguably be stirred up by a potential V(x). If one wishes to consider an equilibrium scenario for which there is an overall En for the bound system one would expect an overall Ent for the system and for -pp/2m t pieces to disappear. Thus we postulate that pp/2m +{p part} G(p’s k’s) = En for all p where {p part}G(p’s, k’s) is an unknown function and V(x)=Sum over k Vk exp(ikx). Next one may consider the spatial situation for which V(x) is the classical potential for a single particle. The kinetic energy follows from an ensemble of free particles with the overall -Et removed. From classical considerations one would expect to have a KE(x). Thus one expects: KE(x) = {Sum over p a(p) f(px) } / {Sum over a(p)f(px) } with f(px), an orthonormal basis set, because the action contains px. (It is orthonormal because one wishes the identity of p to exist if not at a point, then over all of x.) We try to argue in this note that f(px)=exp(ipx), the momentum eigenstate which follows from A=-Et+px. We find G(p’s, k’s) which implies entanglement or mixing of a given p state with other p and k states from the potential V(x)=Sum over k Vk exp(ikx). Thus one expects an entropy linked to this momentum entanglement. Given the form exp(ipx), finding a set of ap’s which satisfy pp/2m + G(p’s, k’s)=En leads to a spatial distribution W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) so there should be an entropy contribution from this spatial part as well. In classical statistical mechanics one has both momentum and spatial contributions to entropy. We argue for S=Sp+Sx, but note that even though px has x, p symmetry as does the Heisenberg uncertainty principle var x var p >= hbar/2, Sp and Sx may not be symmetric in terms of important parameters such as n, energy level. In other words, Sp the entanglement entropy with V(x) may be the driver entropy sensitive to energy level changes while Sx the resulting spatial density may not be as sensitive. Furthermore the overall entropy Sp+Sx gives information about uncertainties in x and p as is already known in the literature where bound state Sp+Sx bounds are given.

•Mar 12, 2022•0 citations

Derivation of a kinetic equation for an inhomogeneous gas of particles bearing a spin and obeying quantum statistics

Michel De Haan

Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications•May 1, 1990•9 citations

Single-component Sutherland model

Yoshio Kuramoto, Yusuke S. Kato

In the present chapter, we discuss the Sutherland model for particles without internal degrees of freedom such as spin. We call this model the singlecomponent Sutherland model. For two particles, the eigenenergies and eigenstates of the Sutherland model (1.3) have been obtained explicitly in the previous chapter. The most striking feature of the Sutherland model is that one can derive not only the energy spectrum but also the dynamics for the many-particle case with an exact account of interaction effects. Thus, the Sutherland model provides an ideal framework to study a one-dimensional quantum liquid in detail. In Section 2.1, we derive the eigenenergies of eigenstates. In Section 2.2, we present different but equivalent physical pictures for the energy spectrum. Namely, the energy spectrum is naturally regarded as that of interacting bosons or fermions. The same spectrum can also be interpreted as that of free particles obeying nontrivial quantum statistics, i.e., free anyons in one dimension. The exclusion statistics proposed by Haldane will be explained on this occasion. Spectrum and statistics of elementary excitations are derived in Section 2.3. In Section 2.4, we discuss thermodynamic properties, which can be rewritten as those of free anyons. In Section 2.5, we identify the eigenfunctions with Jack symmetric polynomials, and discuss their basic properties. In Section 2.6, we consider dynamical correlation functions such as Green's functions and the density correlation function. These quantities are derived with the use of Jack polynomials, and are naturally interpreted in terms of elementary excitations with fractional charge. The Sutherland model is the simplest model to realize the Tomonaga–Luttinger liquid.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 6, 2009•0 citations

Intermediate statistics

A. M. Guénault, D. K. C. MacDonald

The properties of a gas of particles obeying a hypothetical ‘intermediate statistics’ (first proposed by Gentile) are discussed. Although of no known direct application to a physical system, the theoretical results can help in understanding the physical properties of Fermi-Dirac and Bose-Einstein statistics.

Molecular Physics•Sep 1, 1962•9 citations

On the generalized Boltzmann equation of a quantum gas II

Shigeji Fujita

Physica•Oct 1, 1963•6 citations
The present note is devoted to the detailed investigation of a concrete model satisfying the block-monotone statistics introduced in a previous paper (joint, with collaborators) of the author. The model under consideration indeed describes the free gas of massless particles in a one-dimensional environment. This investigation can have consequences in two fundamental respects. The first one concerns the applicability of the (block-)monotone statistics to concrete physical models, yet completely unknown. Since the formula for the degeneracy of the energy-levels of the one-particle Hamiltonian of a free particle is very involved, the second aspect might be related to the, highly nontrivial, investigation of the expected thermodynamics of the free gas of particles obeying the block-monotone statistics in arbitrary spatial dimensions. A final section contains a comparison between the various (block, strict, and weak) monotone schemes with the Boltzmann statistics, which describes the gas of classical particles. It is seen that the block-monotone statistics, which takes into account the degeneracy of the energy-levels, seems the unique one having realistic physical applications.
The aim of the present paper is to provide a preliminary investigation of the thermodynamics of particles obeying monotone statistics. To render the potential physical applications realistic, we propose a modified scheme called block-monotone, based on a partial order arising from the natural one on the spectrum of a positive Hamiltonian with compact resolvent. The block-monotone scheme is never comparable with the weak monotone one and is reduced to the usual monotone scheme whenever all the eigenvalues of the involved Hamiltonian are non-degenerate. Through a detailed analysis of a model based on the quantum harmonic oscillator, we can see that: (a) the computation of the grand-partition function does not require the Gibbs correction factor n! (connected with the indistinguishability of particles) in the various terms of its expansion with respect to the activity; and (b) the decimation of terms contributing to the grand-partition function leads to a kind of “exclusion principle” analogous to the Pauli exclusion principle enjoined by Fermi particles, which is more relevant in the high-density regime and becomes negligible in the low-density regime, as expected.
In a previous note (1) we argued that both the relativistic A= -mo t sqrt(1-vv) and nonrelativistic A=t .5mvv classical free particle actions may be written with v=x/t and x and t varied independently to yield: dA/dx partial = p and dA/dt partial = -E. Thus A is equivalent to -Et + px for a free particle with x and t being treated as independent. We argue in this note that such an assumption is equivalent to a statistical picture for a free particle even at the classical level because x and t are treated as independent. Thus a constant p may occur at any x because no time is linked to x. Given that all space points are the same for constant p one expects a constant probability at all x points. Knowing p exactly means not knowing anything about which x one has. Secondly, one may create an ensemble of free particle p classical actions for a situation containing a potential V(x). Given that x and t are independent, there cannot be any notion of single p accelerating, although a vrms from an ensemble may. At a given x (x known exactly) one does not know which p is present. Thus the ideas of uncertainty of p and x follow immediately from this picture. If one considers a single particle and an ensemble of free particles in the x-t independent scenario, then each free particle action p is linked to A=-Et+px where E=pp/2m. This ensemble would arguably be stirred up by a potential V(x). If one wishes to consider an equilibrium scenario for which there is an overall En for the bound system one would expect an overall Ent for the system and for -pp/2m t pieces to disappear. Thus we postulate that pp/2m +{p part} G(p’s k’s) = En for all p where {p part}G(p’s, k’s) is an unknown function and V(x)=Sum over k Vk exp(ikx). Next one may consider the spatial situation for which V(x) is the classical potential for a single particle. The kinetic energy follows from an ensemble of free particles with the overall -Et removed. From classical considerations one would expect to have a KE(x). Thus one expects: KE(x) = {Sum over p a(p) f(px) } / {Sum over a(p)f(px) } with f(px), an orthonormal basis set, because the action contains px. (It is orthonormal because one wishes the identity of p to exist if not at a point, then over all of x.) We try to argue in this note that f(px)=exp(ipx), the momentum eigenstate which follows from A=-Et+px. We find G(p’s, k’s) which implies entanglement or mixing of a given p state with other p and k states from the potential V(x)=Sum over k Vk exp(ikx). Thus one expects an entropy linked to this momentum entanglement. Given the form exp(ipx), finding a set of ap’s which satisfy pp/2m + G(p’s, k’s)=En leads to a spatial distribution W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) so there should be an entropy contribution from this spatial part as well. In classical statistical mechanics one has both momentum and spatial contributions to entropy. We argue for S=Sp+Sx, but note that even though px has x, p symmetry as does the Heisenberg uncertainty principle var x var p >= hbar/2, Sp and Sx may not be symmetric in terms of important parameters such as n, energy level. In other words, Sp the entanglement entropy with V(x) may be the driver entropy sensitive to energy level changes while Sx the resulting spatial density may not be as sensitive. Furthermore the overall entropy Sp+Sx gives information about uncertainties in x and p as is already known in the literature where bound state Sp+Sx bounds are given.
In the present chapter, we discuss the Sutherland model for particles without internal degrees of freedom such as spin. We call this model the singlecomponent Sutherland model. For two particles, the eigenenergies and eigenstates of the Sutherland model (1.3) have been obtained explicitly in the previous chapter. The most striking feature of the Sutherland model is that one can derive not only the energy spectrum but also the dynamics for the many-particle case with an exact account of interaction effects. Thus, the Sutherland model provides an ideal framework to study a one-dimensional quantum liquid in detail. In Section 2.1, we derive the eigenenergies of eigenstates. In Section 2.2, we present different but equivalent physical pictures for the energy spectrum. Namely, the energy spectrum is naturally regarded as that of interacting bosons or fermions. The same spectrum can also be interpreted as that of free particles obeying nontrivial quantum statistics, i.e., free anyons in one dimension. The exclusion statistics proposed by Haldane will be explained on this occasion. Spectrum and statistics of elementary excitations are derived in Section 2.3. In Section 2.4, we discuss thermodynamic properties, which can be rewritten as those of free anyons. In Section 2.5, we identify the eigenfunctions with Jack symmetric polynomials, and discuss their basic properties. In Section 2.6, we consider dynamical correlation functions such as Green's functions and the density correlation function. These quantities are derived with the use of Jack polynomials, and are naturally interpreted in terms of elementary excitations with fractional charge. The Sutherland model is the simplest model to realize the Tomonaga–Luttinger liquid.