Bell Inequalities IntroductionFrom the dawn of the quantum age in 1900, there has been an ongoing debate, often fierce and hostile, between the supporters of the classical world view and those of the quantum world view.This debate eventually led to remarkable experiments, the convincing and repeated results of which are claimed by quantum theorists to support the predictions of quantum mechanics (QM) and not those of classical mechanics (CM).However, old paradigms tend to linger on the shelves of science long past their sell-by dates and there are extant schools of theorists that strive to find loopholes in the above-mentioned experiments.That is a legitimate activity up to a point, but the divisive nature of the debate requires commentary, which is the subject matter of this chapter.QM was discovered only by advanced technology, so it stands to reason that any test of QM will require even more advanced technology.In the previous chapter we stressed the differences between active and passive transformations.The experiments discussed here rely on such technically difficult active transformations that the Hidden Variables (HV) theorists (for that is really what they are) opposing QM are frequently able to think of objections, known as loopholes, to the empirical protocols employed by the experimentalists.Some of these loopholes are reasonable but many are not.Closing those loopholes convincingly is an ongoing important activity in experimental quantum physics.A significant feature of the experiments discussed in this chapter is that they go beyond a certain point of complexity in terms of the number of classical and quantum degrees of freedom involved.Historically, before that point had been reached, classical interpretations of quantum wave functions appeared viable and perhaps even attractive, such as that proposed by Bohm (Bohm, 1952).We shall refer to the collective of such interpretations as the hidden variables (HV) paradigm and the point in question as the Heisenberg point.
Bell Inequalities IntroductionFrom the dawn of the quantum age in 1900, there has been an ongoing debate, often fierce and hostile, between the supporters of the classical world view and those of the quantum world view.This debate eventually led to remarkable experiments, the convincing and repeated results of which are claimed by quantum theorists to support the predictions of quantum mechanics (QM) and not those of classical mechanics (CM).However, old paradigms tend to linger on the shelves of science long past their sell-by dates and there are extant schools of theorists that strive to find loopholes in the above-mentioned experiments.That is a legitimate activity up to a point, but the divisive nature of the debate requires commentary, which is the subject matter of this chapter.QM was discovered only by advanced technology, so it stands to reason that any test of QM will require even more advanced technology.In the previous chapter we stressed the differences between active and passive transformations.The experiments discussed here rely on such technically difficult active transformations that the Hidden Variables (HV) theorists (for that is really what they are) opposing QM are frequently able to think of objections, known as loopholes, to the empirical protocols employed by the experimentalists.Some of these loopholes are reasonable but many are not.Closing those loopholes convincingly is an ongoing important activity in experimental quantum physics.A significant feature of the experiments discussed in this chapter is that they go beyond a certain point of complexity in terms of the number of classical and quantum degrees of freedom involved.Historically, before that point had been reached, classical interpretations of quantum wave functions appeared viable and perhaps even attractive, such as that proposed by Bohm (Bohm, 1952).We shall refer to the collective of such interpretations as the hidden variables (HV) paradigm and the point in question as the Heisenberg point.
The final form of quantum physics, in the particular case of wave mechanics, was established in the years 1925–1927 by Heisenberg, Schrödinger, Born and others, but the synthesis was the work of Bohr who gave an epistemological interpretation of all the technicalities built up over those years; this interpretation will be examined briefly in Chapter 10. Although Einstein acknowledged the success of quantum mechanics in atomic, molecular and solid state physics, he disagreed deeply with Bohr’s interpretation. For many years, he tried to find flaws in the formulation of quantum theory as it had been more or less accepted by a large majority of physicists, but his objections were brushed away by Bohr. However, in an article published in 1935 with Podolsky and Rosen, universally known under the acronym EPR, Einstein thought he had identified a difficulty in the by then standard interpretation. Bohr’s obscure, and in part beyond the point, answer showed that Einstein had hit a sensitive target. Nevertheless, until 1964, the so-called Bohr–Einstein debate stayed uniquely on a philosophical level, and it was actually forgotten by most physicists, as the few of them aware of it thought it had no practical implication. In 1964, the Northern Irish physicist John Bell realized that the assumptions contained in the EPR article could be tested experimentally. These assumptions led to inequalities, the Bell inequalities, which were in contradiction with quantum mechanical predictions: as we shall see later on, it is extremely likely that the assumptions of the EPR article are not consistent with experiment, which, on the contrary, vindicates the predictions of quantum physics. In Section 3.2, the origin of Bell’s inequalities will be explained with an intuitive example, then they will be compared with the predictions of quantum theory in Section 3.3, and finally their experimental status will be reviewed in Section 3.4. The debate between Bohr and Einstein goes much beyond a simple controversy, which is after all almost eighty years old and has been settled today. In fact, the concept introduced in this debate, that of entanglement, lies at the heart of many very important developments of modern quantum physics, in particular all those linked to quantum information (Chapter 8). Moreover, we shall see that the phenomenon of non-local correlations compels us to revise in depth our space-time representation of quantum processes. These are the two reasons why a whole chapter is devoted to this debate.
Bell's inequalities(1964) provides a quantitative criterion to test the local hidden variable theory(LHVT) versus quantum mechanics(QM).For the first time,it leads to the possibility to experimentally distinguish LHVT and QM.So far,there have been tens of experiments ever since the first experiment by Clauser et al(1972).An overwhelming majority of these experiments are in good agreement with the predictions of QM yet violate those of LHVT.Some loopholes in these experiments are discussed in Section I,followed by a respective summary to 12 experiments between 1972 to 1982 and 31 experiments from 1985 and on in Sections II and III.It is finally pointed out that so far there is not a single experiment to close both the locality loophole and the detection loophole at the same time,but the experimental outcomes are irreversible.Accordingly,theoretical physicists must admit that the present physics foundation is broken,i.e.quantum mechanics is contradiction with special relativity.
One of the most decisive advances in the foundations of quantum mechanics came from a deceptively simple mathematical result published in 1964. John Stewart Bell showed that any theory attempting to preserve both locality and realism–the intuitive classical worldview championed by Einstein–must obey certain statistical inequalities. Quantum mechanics, however, predicts violations of these inequalities. This discovery, known as Bell’s theorem , transformed a long-standing philosophical debate into a question that could be answered by experiment. It stands as one of the most profound results of twentieth-century physics.
Bell’s inequality is derived by resorting to a hidden-variable theory devised for resolving the Einstein-Bohr debate on the conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics. The legitimacy of quantum superposition for describing the physical world is the essence of the debate. Einstein argued against the legitimacy of quantum superposition. Testing Bell’s inequality by experiment with the experimental result explained by Bell’s theorem opened the door to so-called quantum information technologies. In quantum information theory, “quantum bit” (or “qubit” for short) in a form of quantum superposition is supposed to carry quantum information. Although most physicists believe that Einstein’s vision of the physical world contradicts the experimental result of testing Bell’s inequality, actually neither the experimental result nor Bell’s theorem is relevant to Einstein’s viewpoint. In the present paper, a new principle, the general principle of measurements, is proved as a mathematical theorem. Based on this principle, the experiment for testing Bell’s inequality and so-called experimental evidence for physically realizable “qubit” are scrutinized. The findings are as follows. The experimental result of testing Bell’s inequality and the measurement outcomes of experiments involving “qubit” are all erroneously explained. Bell’s inequality failed to capture the essence of the Einstein-Bohr debate, and Bell’s theorem is irrelevant to Einstein’s vision of the physical world. Quantum mechanics can be completed by using disjunction (“or”) as the logical relation between the orthonormal vectors that span an arbitrarily given Hilbert space without resorting to any hidden-variable theory, while the mathematical setting will remain essentially unchanged. All kinds of “qubit” violate the general principle of measurements and can only describe imaginary objects that do not exist in the physical world. The findings inevitably lead to a very regrettable conclusion: Quantum information has no physical carers and all quantum information technologies are not physically realizable.
Bell’s inequality is derived by resorting to a hidden-variable theory devised for resolving the Einstein-Bohr debate on the conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics. The legitimacy of quantum superposition for describing the physical world is the essence of the debate. Einstein argued against the legitimacy of quantum superposition. Testing Bell’s inequality by experiments with the experimental result explained by Bell’s theorem opened the door to so-called quantum information technologies. In quantum information theory, “quantum bit” (or “qubit” for short) in a form of quantum superposition is supposed to carry quantum information. In the present paper, a new principle, the general principle of measurements, has been proved as a mathematical theorem. Based on this principle, the experiment for testing Bell’s inequality and so-called experimental evidence for physically realizable “qubit” have been scrutinized. The findings are as follows. Although most physicists believe that Einstein’s vision of the physical world contradicts the experimental result of testing Bell’s inequality, neither the experimental result nor Bell’s theorem is relevant to Einstein’s viewpoint, because Bell’s inequality failed to capture the essence of the Einstein-Bohr debate. The experimental result and the measurement outcomes of various experiments involving “qubit” are all erroneously explained. Quantum mechanics can be completed by using disjunction (“or”) as the logical relation between the orthonormal vectors that span an arbitrarily given Hilbert space without resorting to any hidden-variable theory, while the mathematical setting will remain essentially unchanged. All kinds of “qubit” violate the general principle of measurements and can only describe imaginary objects that do not exist in the real world. A very regrettable conclusion from the above findings is inevitable: All quantum information technologies are not physically realizable, because quantum information has no physical carriers.
Bell’s inequality is derived by resorting to a hidden-variable theory devised for resolving the Einstein-Bohr debate on the conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics. The legitimacy of quantum superposition for describing the physical world is the essence of the debate. Einstein argued against the legitimacy of quantum superposition. Testing Bell’s inequality by experiments with the experimental results explained by Bell’s theorem opened the door to so-called quantum information technologies. In quantum information theory, “quantum bit” (or “qubit” for short) in a form of quantum superposition is supposed to represent quantum information. In the present paper, a new principle, the general principle of measurements, is introduced and proved as a mathematical theorem. Based on this principle, the experiments for testing Bell’s inequality and so-called experimental evidence for physically realizable “qubit” are scrutinized. The findings are as follows. Although most physicists believe that Einstein’s vision of the physical world contradicts the experimental results of testing Bell’s inequality, actually Einstein’s viewpoint is irrelevant to Bell’s theorem. Bell’s inequality failed to capture the essence of the Einstein-Bohr debate. The experimental results of testing Bell’s inequality and the measurement outcomes of various experiments involving “qubit” are all erroneously explained. Without involving hidden variables, quantum mechanics can be completed based on the general principle of measurements by using disjunction (“or”) as the logical relation between the orthonormal vectors that span an arbitrarily given Hilbert space, and the mathematical setting can remain essentially unchanged. All kinds of “qubit” violate the general principle of measurements and can only describe imaginary objects that do not exist in the real world. A very regrettable conclusion from the above findings is inevitable: Quantum information has no physical carriers, and all quantum information technologies are not physically realizable.