Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Research

Finite-size effects and thermodynamic accuracy in many-particle systems

Benedikt M. Reible, Julian F. Hille, Carsten Hartmann, Luigi Delle Site

Published Jun 9, 2023• 12 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Finite-size effects arise when a sample of particles is not sufficient to provide a statistically satisfactory description of the bulk environment of a physical system. As a consequence, a reliable estimate of finite-size effects in many-particle systems is key to judge the validity of a theoretical model or the accuracy of a numerical simulation. In this context, we propose the use of a theorem on the free-energy cost for separating a system into smaller independent subsystems [J. Stat. Mech.: Theory Exp. (2017) 083201; Lett. Math. Phys. 112, 97 (2022)] to estimate the relevance of finite-size effects in thermodynamic quantities from computer simulations. The key aspect of this study is that for two-body potentials, as mostly occurring in physics, the method requires only two-body distribution functions and the particle number density. The calculation of the involved physical quantities can be done numerically on a three-dimensional grid. In some cases even analytical estimates are possible and as an example the uniform interacting electron gas in the ground state is considered; we derive an approximating scaling law for the finite-size effects.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.5.023156

Related papers

Two-sided Bogoliubov inequality to estimate finite size effects in quantum molecular simulations

Benedikt M. Reible, Carsten Hartmann, Luigi Delle Site

Abstract We generalise the two-sided Bogoliubov inequality for classical particles (Delle Site et al. in J Stat Mech Theory Exp 083201, 2017 to systems of quantum particles. As in the classical set-up, the inequality leads to upper and lower bounds for the free energy difference associated with the partitioning of a large system into smaller, independent subsystems. From a thermodynamic modelling point of view, the free energy difference determines the finite size correction needed to consistently treat a small system as a representation of a large system. Applications of the bounds to quantify finite size effects are ubiquitous in physics, chemistry, material science, or biology, to name just a few; in particular, it is relevant for molecular dynamics simulations in which a small portion of a system is usually taken as representative of the idealized large system.

arXiv:2111.10282•Letters in Mathematical Physics•Sep 21, 2022•6 citations

Scaling law for the size dependence of a finite-range quantum gas

Luigi Delle Site, Carsten Hartmann

In a recent work [Reible et al., Phys. Rev. Res. 5, 023156 (2023)], it was shown that the mean particle-particle interaction across an ideal surface that divides a system into two parts can be employed to estimate the size dependence for the thermodynamic accuracy of the system. In this work we propose its application to systems with finite-range interactions that model dense quantum gases and derive an approximate size-dependence scaling law. In addition, we show that the application of the criterion is equivalent to the determination of a free-energy response to a perturbation. The latter result confirms the complementarity of the criterion to other estimates of finite-size effects based on direct simulations and empirical structure or energy convergence criteria.

arXiv:2308.16088•Physical Review A•Feb 9, 2024•3 citations

Overcoming finite-size effects in electronic structure simulations at extreme conditions

Tobias Dornheim, Jan Vorberger

Ab initio quantum Monte Carlo methods, in principle, allow for the calculation of exact properties of correlated many-electron systems but are, in general, limited to the simulation of a finite number of electrons N under periodic boundary conditions. Therefore, an accurate theory of finite-size effects is indispensable to bridge the gap to realistic applications in the thermodynamic limit. In this work, we revisit the uniform electron gas at finite temperature, as it is relevant to contemporary research, e.g., in the field of warm dense matter. In particular, we present a new scheme to eliminate finite-size effects both in the static structure factor S(q) and in the interaction energy v, which is based on the density response formalism. We demonstrate that this method often allows us to obtain v in the thermodynamic limit within a relative accuracy of ∼0.2% from as few as N = 4 electrons without any empirical choices or knowledge of results for other values of N. Finally, we evaluate the applicability of our method upon increasing the density parameter rs and decreasing the temperature T.

arXiv:2101.11364•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Apr 8, 2021•45 citations

A quantum Monte Carlo study of the two-dimensional electron gas

Yongkyung Kwon

Quantum Monte Carlo has recently made great progress as a computational tool for quantum many-body systems. We have extended previous Monte Carlo methods to study both ground state and excited states of the two-dimensional electron gas. For ground state properties we have used variational and fixed-node diffusion Monte Carlo methods, the latter of which is a nearly exact method for a system of many fermions. With introduction of backflow and three-body correlations, we find significant improvements in both variational and fixed-node energies over the Slater-Jastrow results which consider only two-body correlations. It is found that the backflow effect is dominant over the three-body effect at high density ($r\sb{s} \sim 1)$ while they are of equal importance at the lowest density considered $(r\sb{s} \sim 20)$. The effects are comparable to those in bulk $\sp3$He. The numerical results are used to provide an analytic expression for the correlation energy of the two-dimensional electron gas as a function of the density. For particle-hole excitations of the system, variational Monte Carlo is employed. Correlated sampling is introduced to calculate small energy differences between different excitations. The usual pair-product (Slater-Jastrow) trial wave function is found to lack certain correlations entirely so that backflow correlation is crucial. From the excitation energies calculated here, we determine Fermi liquid parameters and related physical quantities such as the effective mass and Lande g factor of the two-dimensional electron gas, which are compared with previous analytic calculations. Finally, the validity of our fixed-node calculations for the ground state and variational ones for the excitations is tested by transient-estimate calculations, which allow for relaxation of the fixed-node conditions.

•Jan 1, 1994•0 citations

Random phase approximation and the finite size errors in many body simulations

Simone Chiesa, David M. Ceperley, Richard M. Martin +1 more

We address the problem of finite size errors on the energy computed in quantum Monte Carlo simulations. We introduce a scheme based on the random phase approximation that, within a single calculation, allows to retrieve the leading order correction and produces practically converged results for modest numbers of particles. Applications to the electron gas and silicon are presented.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2007•3 citations

Properties of a finite fully spin-polarized free homogeneous one-dimensional electron gas

Orion Ciftja

The homogeneous electron gas model has been quite successful to predict the bulk properties of systems of electrons at various densities. In many occasions, a simplified free homogeneous electron gas model represents a powerful first approximation to a real system. Despite our considerable knowledge on the bulk properties of a homogeneous electron gas, advances in nanoscience and nanotechnology call for a greater effort to understand the opposite limit of small finite systems of electrons with size-dependent properties. In this work, we provide a detailed description of the properties of a finite fully spin-polarized (spinless) free homogeneous one-dimensional electron gas, the simplest of the free homogeneous electron gases. We derive exact analytical results for various quantities such as the one-particle density function, two-particle density function, one-particle density matrix, pair correlation function and energy of finite systems with an arbitrary number of electrons. The results obtained provide a detailed view on how various quantities corresponding to a finite system approach their bulk (thermodynamic limit) value.

AIP Advances•Jan 1, 2015•8 citations
Finite-size effects arise when a sample of particles is not sufficient to provide a statistically satisfactory description of the bulk environment of a physical system. As a consequence, a reliable estimate of finite-size effects in many-particle systems is key to judge the validity of a theoretical model or the accuracy of a numerical simulation. In this context, we propose the use of a theorem on the free-energy cost for separating a system into smaller independent subsystems [J. Stat. Mech.: Theory Exp. (2017) 083201; Lett. Math. Phys. 112, 97 (2022)] to estimate the relevance of finite-size effects in thermodynamic quantities from computer simulations. The key aspect of this study is that for two-body potentials, as mostly occurring in physics, the method requires only two-body distribution functions and the particle number density. The calculation of the involved physical quantities can be done numerically on a three-dimensional grid. In some cases even analytical estimates are possible and as an example the uniform interacting electron gas in the ground state is considered; we derive an approximating scaling law for the finite-size effects.
Abstract We generalise the two-sided Bogoliubov inequality for classical particles (Delle Site et al. in J Stat Mech Theory Exp 083201, 2017 to systems of quantum particles. As in the classical set-up, the inequality leads to upper and lower bounds for the free energy difference associated with the partitioning of a large system into smaller, independent subsystems. From a thermodynamic modelling point of view, the free energy difference determines the finite size correction needed to consistently treat a small system as a representation of a large system. Applications of the bounds to quantify finite size effects are ubiquitous in physics, chemistry, material science, or biology, to name just a few; in particular, it is relevant for molecular dynamics simulations in which a small portion of a system is usually taken as representative of the idealized large system.
In a recent work [Reible et al., Phys. Rev. Res. 5, 023156 (2023)], it was shown that the mean particle-particle interaction across an ideal surface that divides a system into two parts can be employed to estimate the size dependence for the thermodynamic accuracy of the system. In this work we propose its application to systems with finite-range interactions that model dense quantum gases and derive an approximate size-dependence scaling law. In addition, we show that the application of the criterion is equivalent to the determination of a free-energy response to a perturbation. The latter result confirms the complementarity of the criterion to other estimates of finite-size effects based on direct simulations and empirical structure or energy convergence criteria.
Ab initio quantum Monte Carlo methods, in principle, allow for the calculation of exact properties of correlated many-electron systems but are, in general, limited to the simulation of a finite number of electrons N under periodic boundary conditions. Therefore, an accurate theory of finite-size effects is indispensable to bridge the gap to realistic applications in the thermodynamic limit. In this work, we revisit the uniform electron gas at finite temperature, as it is relevant to contemporary research, e.g., in the field of warm dense matter. In particular, we present a new scheme to eliminate finite-size effects both in the static structure factor S(q) and in the interaction energy v, which is based on the density response formalism. We demonstrate that this method often allows us to obtain v in the thermodynamic limit within a relative accuracy of ∼0.2% from as few as N = 4 electrons without any empirical choices or knowledge of results for other values of N. Finally, we evaluate the applicability of our method upon increasing the density parameter rs and decreasing the temperature T.
Quantum Monte Carlo has recently made great progress as a computational tool for quantum many-body systems. We have extended previous Monte Carlo methods to study both ground state and excited states of the two-dimensional electron gas. For ground state properties we have used variational and fixed-node diffusion Monte Carlo methods, the latter of which is a nearly exact method for a system of many fermions. With introduction of backflow and three-body correlations, we find significant improvements in both variational and fixed-node energies over the Slater-Jastrow results which consider only two-body correlations. It is found that the backflow effect is dominant over the three-body effect at high density ($r\sb{s} \sim 1)$ while they are of equal importance at the lowest density considered $(r\sb{s} \sim 20)$. The effects are comparable to those in bulk $\sp3$He. The numerical results are used to provide an analytic expression for the correlation energy of the two-dimensional electron gas as a function of the density. For particle-hole excitations of the system, variational Monte Carlo is employed. Correlated sampling is introduced to calculate small energy differences between different excitations. The usual pair-product (Slater-Jastrow) trial wave function is found to lack certain correlations entirely so that backflow correlation is crucial. From the excitation energies calculated here, we determine Fermi liquid parameters and related physical quantities such as the effective mass and Lande g factor of the two-dimensional electron gas, which are compared with previous analytic calculations. Finally, the validity of our fixed-node calculations for the ground state and variational ones for the excitations is tested by transient-estimate calculations, which allow for relaxation of the fixed-node conditions.
The homogeneous electron gas model has been quite successful to predict the bulk properties of systems of electrons at various densities. In many occasions, a simplified free homogeneous electron gas model represents a powerful first approximation to a real system. Despite our considerable knowledge on the bulk properties of a homogeneous electron gas, advances in nanoscience and nanotechnology call for a greater effort to understand the opposite limit of small finite systems of electrons with size-dependent properties. In this work, we provide a detailed description of the properties of a finite fully spin-polarized (spinless) free homogeneous one-dimensional electron gas, the simplest of the free homogeneous electron gases. We derive exact analytical results for various quantities such as the one-particle density function, two-particle density function, one-particle density matrix, pair correlation function and energy of finite systems with an arbitrary number of electrons. The results obtained provide a detailed view on how various quantities corresponding to a finite system approach their bulk (thermodynamic limit) value.