Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Classical Probability Theory and Quantum Wavefunctions

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Published May 17, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In (1), we noted that a Gaussian wavefunction may be a solution to the time-independent Schrodinger equation (e.g. the ground state solution of the quantum oscillator) and simultaneously a solution of maximizing spatial Shannon’s entropy - density(x) ln(density(x)) subject to the constraint V(x) xx constant, where density(x) =W*(x)W(x) with W(x) being the wavefunction. In (2), which deals strictly with classical probabilities and the Maxwell-Boltzmann factor n(ei) = exp(-ei/T), we argued that this function is equivalent to: ln(n(ei)) = -ei/T. This in turn is equivalent to the maximization of ln(n(ei)!) with the constraint ei n(ei) which is part of: ln( N!/ Product over i n(ei)!) with the full constraint Sum over i ei n(ei)=Eave. Here n(ei)=N p(ei) where p(ei) is a probability and N a very large number. Thus a function of exp( something) may indicate that “something” * density(x) is a constraint with -density ln(density) being Shannon’s entropy. Quantum mechanics for a bound system yields a real wavefunction W(x) such that density(x)=W(x)W(x)=probability(x). Thus maximization of Shannon’s entropy - density(x) ln (density) subject to a constraint: density(x)B(x) should correspond to a solution for density of exp( B(x)). B(x) as part of the constraint, however, should represent a physical constraint. Thus if there is a solution to the Schrodinger equation of the form exp(.5B(x)) and B(x)density(x) represents the physical constraint in the system, classical maximization of probability solves the quantum problem in such a case. The above ideas may be applied to the quantum oscillator ground state and essentially repeat what is done in (1). We, however, try to generalize them to see if they may apply to a free quantum particle. In this case the probability used is exp(ipx) which is complex. It corresponds to P(x)=exp(ipx)exp(-ipx)=1 which is a uniform distribution which has maximum lack of information.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.7947001

Related papers

Ground State Quantum Oscillator Density as an Entropy Maximum

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Classical statistical mechanical density maximizes entropy subject to constraints i.e. one has the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) distribution P(x)P(p) proportional to exp(- pp/2mT - V(x)/T). Quantum mechanics is also a statistical theory, but it is not based on the maximization of entropy. Rather it is based on a conditional probability P(p/x) = a(p)exp(ipx)/W(x) where W(x) =wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) such that: Sum over p pp/2m P(p/x) + V(x) = E (bound states). As a result, it has classical densities P(x)=W(x)W(x) and P(p)=a(p)a(p), but these in general do not maximize entropy and so do not match the MB distribution. There is a special case, however, namely the ground state oscillator for which the quantum mechanical results P(x) and P(p) are both Gaussians. It is shown in (1) that for a fixed variance, a Gaussian maximizes entropy. Thus, the MB scenario must be a Gaussian for an oscillator as it is, but the quantum result is also a Gaussian and so matches the classical statistical mechanical result. In this note, we show that the time-independent Schrodinger equation collapses to the equality situation in Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, suggesting that the solution also represents maximum entropy.

•Apr 29, 2022•0 citations

Quantum Bound Information ln(WW), ln(a(p)a(p)) as Statistical Constant Vectors over Variables x,p?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

For a classical ideal gas or single particle quantum system with energy levels {ei}, both average energy E=Sum over i ei P(ei/T) and Shannon’s entropy S= - Sum over i P(ei/T) ln(P(ei/T) change (for mechanical parameters kept fixed) in terms of d(P(ei/T)). In fact, in this case ln(P(ei/T)) appears as a “constant vector” in dS i.e. dS= - Sum over i ln(P(ei/T)) dP(ei/T). Both dE (mechanical parameter fixed) and dS change as dP(ei/T), thus there are two vectors {ei/T} and {ln(P(ei/T))} which represent constants over ei’s for a small range of dT where T is temperature. In this case, however, the two vectors are strongly linked as P(ei/T)=exp(-ei/T)/C(T) so ln(P) = -ei/T - ln(C). This is why the relationship E-TS = -T ln(C(T)) exists. For a quantum bound state one may write: e = Integral dp a(p)a(p) pp/2m + Integral dx V(x) W(x)W(x) where W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) is the wavefunction. Instead of having vectors of ei’s, one has two vectors, one over x and the other p (momenta) where a(p)a(p) = P(p) and P(x)=W(x)W(x) (bound states). Thus d e thermal = Integral dp pp/2m dPe(p) + Integral dx V(x) dPe(x) ((1)). In other words de thermal changes linearly in terms of dPe(p) and dPe(x) whereas for a classical ideal gas or many ei system it changes linearly in terms of dP(ei/T). Ei is the variable instead of x and p in that case. In other words {pp/2m} is a constant vector in p space and {V(x)} in x space. Mathematically Shannon’s entropy Sp = - Sum over p Pe(p) ln(Pe(p)) and Sx =- Sum over x Pe(x) ln(Pe(x)) also yield constant vectors in their respective spaces namely ln(Pe(p)) and ln(Pe(x)) which are called information. In particular dSp = - Sum over p ln(Pe(p)) dPe(p) then ln(Pe(p)) behaves like a constant vector within a region of small dPe(p) changes. Note: Sum over p dPe(p)=0. One may consider a set of single valued energy levels ei which are very close (imagine a particle in a box with infinite walls) as a region in which dPe(p) changes (or dPe(x) ones) are very small. In this region, ln(Pe(p)) and ln(Pe(x)), information, represents a constant vector statistically defining the small region of ei states. This we argue is the statistical significance of information ln(P). One may note that both de ((1)) adn dSp and dSx change linearly with dPe(p) and dPe(x), but the vectors {pp/2m} and {V(x)} over p and x space and ln(Pe(p)) and ln(Pe(x)) over the same space are constant vectors, but not equivalent except for the ground state of the quantum oscillator for which they become very similar because Pe(p)=exp(-app) and Pe(x)=exp(-xx/a) with a being proportional to 1/ e which plays the same role as temperature in the classical ideal gas case. For other quantum bound systems, the two sets of vectors are different, but the information vectors seem to give a kind of statistical identity to small regions containing very close ei levels for which dPe(p) and dPe(x) are small. Thus, though one may argue for the presence of ln(P) in Shannon’s entropy S=-Sum over i P(i)ln(P(i)) in many ways, it seems that ln(P(i)) is a constant vector in a certain space i for small dP(i) and gives a statistical identity to that small region.

•Mar 5, 2022•0 citations

Speculation on an Alternative Quantum Entropy

Francesco R. Ruggeri

The notion of entropy originates historically in classical physics and is intertwined with thermodynamics. Shannon’s entropy: - Sum over i P(i) ln(P(i)), where P(i) is the probability for i, however, seems to apply to any probability, but in quantum mechanics appears to be particularly linked to spatial and momentum entropy (1) i.e. - Integral dx W*(x)W(x) ln[ W*(x)W(x)] and - Sum over p a*(p)a(p) ln[ a*(p)a(p) ] where W(x)= wavefunction = Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx). In this note we speculate that one may create an entropy from the real part of exp(ipx) i.e. cos(px) as this term is associated with probability within a wavelength even though the “center of mass” of the particle may be moving uniformly at v=x/t=constant and W*(x)W(x)=1 or a constant. The latter implies an entropy independent of p but there is uncertainty in a free particle due to its wavelength which is experimentally manifested. We argue there is no reason to limit entropy to x or p considerations. For a bound state, a pattern of crests and troughs of different lengths and heights may be produced and so again there is a pattern of unnormalized probability distributions with different weights. The absolute value may be taken so negative wavefunction values are not an issue. For both the free particle and the bound state two features emerge. First the shape of the distributions is linked to the curvature which in turn is associated with the kinetic energy. Thus the probability distributions which describe the quantum system are governed by kinetic energy. Secondly, a pattern of distributions, both negative and positive, ensures that exp(ipx) is perpendicular to other exp(ip1 x) functions and Wn(x) is perpendicular to other Wn1(x)’s. In other words energy identifies the statistical state which exists throughout space and one cannot confuse the identity of one state with another. Thus they are orthogonal throughout space and probability distributions (linked to entropy) seem to enforce this. The inner product of W*(x) and W(x) is like an inner product of a product probability of a state and its time reversed state. We suggest one should be able to define a Shannon’s entropy expression for both |cos(px)|/C1 from exp(ipx) over a half wavelength where C1 is a normalization factor and |W(x)|/C2 roughly over the length over which it has humps i.e. roughly the classical turning points for an oscillator for example. This entropy is not additive and does not map to classical entropy in the large n (energy level) limit. Furthermore it may not be linked to thermodynamics because it is not linked to x or p. Nevertheless, it might be used to describe uncertainty within the quantity system and equilibrium/stable scenarios which are observed in nature. For example, different Wn(x) states are statistically stable states, but one may knock out the particle and it will be in an exp(ipx) state which is also stable. Furthermore, a photon may excite Wn1(x) to Wn2(x), thus this new entropy seems to be linked to stable states allowed in nature. The “price to pay”, however, seems to be uncertainty in wavelength regions for a free particle and the crest/trough regions for a bound state. We also consider some properties of a similar entropy for bound states.

•Sep 23, 2022•0 citations

Conditional Quantum Probability P(p/x) and Entropic Dynamics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In previous notes, we suggested that quantum bound states may be analysed in terms of the conditional probability P(p/x)= a(p)exp(ipx)/W(x) (where W(x) is the wavefunction) which allows for the calculation of average kinetic energy at each point x i.e. [Sum over p pp/2m P(p/x)]/ W(x). This added to V(x) yields E (average energy) at each x and yields the time-independent Schrodinger equation). We argued that probability is handled at the level of W(x)=Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx). Measurements (even internal) may knock a particle from one p1 state to another so another set of probabilities (P(x) and P(p)) arise, P(x) being based on: a(p1)exp(i p1x) exp(i p2x). Averages of f(p,x) follow from P(x) f(p,x) P(p/x). Thus, there are two sets of probabilities in quantum mechanics. Entropic dynamics (1) appears to begin with the probability P(x) and considers a transition probability P(x1 |x) with x1-x= an infinitesimal quantity. A product of transition probabilities is then taken to allow for finite x1-x differences. It is stated in (1) that there exists information about x but not p. The maximization of entropy density may be used to determine the form of P(x1 | x). A “drift velocity” is also included (which is later shown to be related to the phase of the wavefunction). Ultimately, the Schrodinger equation is also obtained. We argue one may use P(p/x) to also calculate P(x1 | x) and compare this result with that obtained through the maximization of entropy density. A type of drift velocity appears naturally in this approach. We argue that the form a(p)exp(ipx) already incorporates statistical ideas (i.e. maximum entropy) in that the modulus of exp(ipx) is identical for all x, endowing all x points with a “kind” of equivalent status. exp(ipx) is a function of p and x because one must calculate average kinetic energy at each x and this must change with x i.e. KEave(x) + V(x) = E. Thus, we think there are strong similarities between entropic dynamics and the approach of using P(p/x). There are also some differences in that the coefficient A of delta(x)delta(x) in P(x1 | x) = 1/Z exp{ A delta(x)delta(x) + B d Phi/dx delta(x)} is treated as independent of x in entropic dynamics, but is a specific function of x (related to d ln(W)/dx d ln(W)/dx + 1/W d/dx d/dx W) in the P(p/x) approach.

•Nov 14, 2020•0 citations

Three Quantum Bound Probabilities and Entropy

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Given a single particle bound wavefunction, W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx), it is traditionally stated that W(x)W(x) is the probability to find a particle at x. We have argued that W(x)W(x) is actually a resolution profile or a probability for interaction and does not indicate whether a particle is at x or not. (We discuss this briefly in the note.) It is linked to an observer trying to find the particle, on average at x, not if the particle is present there and interacting with V(x). If one normalizes Integral dx W(x)W(x)=1, then it follows that Sum over p a(p)a(p) = 1. Thus, a(p)a(p) has the appearance of a probability as well and one might argue that it is the probability to have a momentum p. The catch is that with W(x)W(x) one considers spatial resolution/interaction without knowing p and with a(p)a(p), one knows nothing about x. Given exp(ipx), the probability for a free particle impulse hit at x, one knows both p and x and may use this probability to calculate KEave(x) = {Sum over p a(p)pp/2m exp(ipx)} / W(x). We note that this probability does not have 0 points when W(x)=0. It shows the particle does not avoid W(x)=0 points in internal interactions with V(x), we argue. a(p)exp(ipx) / W(x) is a third probability. Given that it holds at a fixed x and ranges over p (it is sometimes called P(p/x)) it should be linked to a(p)a(p), but it considers spatial issues. We suggest that it should be combined with W(x)W(x) as this demonstrates resolution or measuring interaction hits and is linked to an external observer. The product probability, however, imposes the 0 points of W(x). This simply means, we argue, that a person making measurements does not interact with the particle at these W(x)=0 points, not that the particle does not exist there. Using this probability, as we have shown before, yields an average of the Shannon’s entropies created using W(x)W(x) and a(p)a(p) as probabilities. Here we try to understand the relationship between these three probabilities more closely without using the usual P(x)=W(x)W(x), P(p) = a(p)a(p) and P(p/x) = a(p)exp(ipx)/W.

•Apr 23, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics and Orthonormal Basis Functions

Francesco R. Ruggeri

For quantum bound states, classical style probabilities P(p)=a(p)a(p) and P(x)=W(x)W(x) [where W(x)= the wavefunction = Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx)] exist. These are real and normalized to one, but unusually, they separate p and x completely. For example, P(p) is the probability to find a momentum p anywhere in the system - no information about x is known. This seems to suggest that the P(p/x) is not defined in a classical sense. (Similar arguments hold for P(x).) We have argued in a previous note (1), that due to a lack of time reversal balance, there is no clear classical notion of P(p/x) in quantum mechanics while in classical statistical mechanics, there is a time reversal balance of two-body collisions and so P(p/x) is well-defined. In particular, a momentum p collides with a pj to form another momentum pk. There is ambiguity if p is changing, but if at the same time a pk is changing (colliding) back into a p at x, then the ambiguity is removed. In quantum mechanics, the ambiguity is not removed at x, but one may discern one p state from another throughout the entire x space. This suggests orthonormal probabilities e.g. say exp(ip1 x) and exp(i p2 x). These exp(i p x) probabilities comprise the wavefunction which is linked to P(p/x) = a(p) exp(ipx)/W(x), but although Sum over p P(p/x)=1, P(p/x) is complex with the real and complex portions taking on positive and negative values. Nevertheless, it is W(x) which is the solution of the Schrodinger (and other) equations. It is known that solutions Wn(x) of the Schrodinger equation have discrete En (energy) values. It is possible to have [H, Operator]=0 and possibly to have H written in terms of this operator. In such a case, Wn(x) might be both an eigenfunction of H and the Operator. Alternatively, a linear combination of Operator eigenfunctions may be used. If En is discrete, one may expect the operator eigenfunctions to also be discrete, leading to quantization of the Operator eigenvalues. In some cases, one may have two operators which commute with H, e.g. LL and Lz (related to angular momentum). Lz eigenfunctions might not be linked to H so one might ask why Lz should be quantized. Another H, however, may distinguish between Lz eigenfunctions and so they also have discrete eigenvalues. In this note, we try to consider why one should have orthonormal eigenfunctions of these commuting operators which make up the wavefunction and try to interpret their physical meaning.

•Aug 3, 2021•0 citations
In (1), we noted that a Gaussian wavefunction may be a solution to the time-independent Schrodinger equation (e.g. the ground state solution of the quantum oscillator) and simultaneously a solution of maximizing spatial Shannon’s entropy - density(x) ln(density(x)) subject to the constraint V(x) xx constant, where density(x) =W*(x)W(x) with W(x) being the wavefunction. In (2), which deals strictly with classical probabilities and the Maxwell-Boltzmann factor n(ei) = exp(-ei/T), we argued that this function is equivalent to: ln(n(ei)) = -ei/T. This in turn is equivalent to the maximization of ln(n(ei)!) with the constraint ei n(ei) which is part of: ln( N!/ Product over i n(ei)!) with the full constraint Sum over i ei n(ei)=Eave. Here n(ei)=N p(ei) where p(ei) is a probability and N a very large number. Thus a function of exp( something) may indicate that “something” * density(x) is a constraint with -density ln(density) being Shannon’s entropy. Quantum mechanics for a bound system yields a real wavefunction W(x) such that density(x)=W(x)W(x)=probability(x). Thus maximization of Shannon’s entropy - density(x) ln (density) subject to a constraint: density(x)B(x) should correspond to a solution for density of exp( B(x)). B(x) as part of the constraint, however, should represent a physical constraint. Thus if there is a solution to the Schrodinger equation of the form exp(.5B(x)) and B(x)density(x) represents the physical constraint in the system, classical maximization of probability solves the quantum problem in such a case. The above ideas may be applied to the quantum oscillator ground state and essentially repeat what is done in (1). We, however, try to generalize them to see if they may apply to a free quantum particle. In this case the probability used is exp(ipx) which is complex. It corresponds to P(x)=exp(ipx)exp(-ipx)=1 which is a uniform distribution which has maximum lack of information.
Classical statistical mechanical density maximizes entropy subject to constraints i.e. one has the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) distribution P(x)P(p) proportional to exp(- pp/2mT - V(x)/T). Quantum mechanics is also a statistical theory, but it is not based on the maximization of entropy. Rather it is based on a conditional probability P(p/x) = a(p)exp(ipx)/W(x) where W(x) =wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) such that: Sum over p pp/2m P(p/x) + V(x) = E (bound states). As a result, it has classical densities P(x)=W(x)W(x) and P(p)=a(p)a(p), but these in general do not maximize entropy and so do not match the MB distribution. There is a special case, however, namely the ground state oscillator for which the quantum mechanical results P(x) and P(p) are both Gaussians. It is shown in (1) that for a fixed variance, a Gaussian maximizes entropy. Thus, the MB scenario must be a Gaussian for an oscillator as it is, but the quantum result is also a Gaussian and so matches the classical statistical mechanical result. In this note, we show that the time-independent Schrodinger equation collapses to the equality situation in Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, suggesting that the solution also represents maximum entropy.
For a classical ideal gas or single particle quantum system with energy levels {ei}, both average energy E=Sum over i ei P(ei/T) and Shannon’s entropy S= - Sum over i P(ei/T) ln(P(ei/T) change (for mechanical parameters kept fixed) in terms of d(P(ei/T)). In fact, in this case ln(P(ei/T)) appears as a “constant vector” in dS i.e. dS= - Sum over i ln(P(ei/T)) dP(ei/T). Both dE (mechanical parameter fixed) and dS change as dP(ei/T), thus there are two vectors {ei/T} and {ln(P(ei/T))} which represent constants over ei’s for a small range of dT where T is temperature. In this case, however, the two vectors are strongly linked as P(ei/T)=exp(-ei/T)/C(T) so ln(P) = -ei/T - ln(C). This is why the relationship E-TS = -T ln(C(T)) exists. For a quantum bound state one may write: e = Integral dp a(p)a(p) pp/2m + Integral dx V(x) W(x)W(x) where W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) is the wavefunction. Instead of having vectors of ei’s, one has two vectors, one over x and the other p (momenta) where a(p)a(p) = P(p) and P(x)=W(x)W(x) (bound states). Thus d e thermal = Integral dp pp/2m dPe(p) + Integral dx V(x) dPe(x) ((1)). In other words de thermal changes linearly in terms of dPe(p) and dPe(x) whereas for a classical ideal gas or many ei system it changes linearly in terms of dP(ei/T). Ei is the variable instead of x and p in that case. In other words {pp/2m} is a constant vector in p space and {V(x)} in x space. Mathematically Shannon’s entropy Sp = - Sum over p Pe(p) ln(Pe(p)) and Sx =- Sum over x Pe(x) ln(Pe(x)) also yield constant vectors in their respective spaces namely ln(Pe(p)) and ln(Pe(x)) which are called information. In particular dSp = - Sum over p ln(Pe(p)) dPe(p) then ln(Pe(p)) behaves like a constant vector within a region of small dPe(p) changes. Note: Sum over p dPe(p)=0. One may consider a set of single valued energy levels ei which are very close (imagine a particle in a box with infinite walls) as a region in which dPe(p) changes (or dPe(x) ones) are very small. In this region, ln(Pe(p)) and ln(Pe(x)), information, represents a constant vector statistically defining the small region of ei states. This we argue is the statistical significance of information ln(P). One may note that both de ((1)) adn dSp and dSx change linearly with dPe(p) and dPe(x), but the vectors {pp/2m} and {V(x)} over p and x space and ln(Pe(p)) and ln(Pe(x)) over the same space are constant vectors, but not equivalent except for the ground state of the quantum oscillator for which they become very similar because Pe(p)=exp(-app) and Pe(x)=exp(-xx/a) with a being proportional to 1/ e which plays the same role as temperature in the classical ideal gas case. For other quantum bound systems, the two sets of vectors are different, but the information vectors seem to give a kind of statistical identity to small regions containing very close ei levels for which dPe(p) and dPe(x) are small. Thus, though one may argue for the presence of ln(P) in Shannon’s entropy S=-Sum over i P(i)ln(P(i)) in many ways, it seems that ln(P(i)) is a constant vector in a certain space i for small dP(i) and gives a statistical identity to that small region.
The notion of entropy originates historically in classical physics and is intertwined with thermodynamics. Shannon’s entropy: - Sum over i P(i) ln(P(i)), where P(i) is the probability for i, however, seems to apply to any probability, but in quantum mechanics appears to be particularly linked to spatial and momentum entropy (1) i.e. - Integral dx W*(x)W(x) ln[ W*(x)W(x)] and - Sum over p a*(p)a(p) ln[ a*(p)a(p) ] where W(x)= wavefunction = Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx). In this note we speculate that one may create an entropy from the real part of exp(ipx) i.e. cos(px) as this term is associated with probability within a wavelength even though the “center of mass” of the particle may be moving uniformly at v=x/t=constant and W*(x)W(x)=1 or a constant. The latter implies an entropy independent of p but there is uncertainty in a free particle due to its wavelength which is experimentally manifested. We argue there is no reason to limit entropy to x or p considerations. For a bound state, a pattern of crests and troughs of different lengths and heights may be produced and so again there is a pattern of unnormalized probability distributions with different weights. The absolute value may be taken so negative wavefunction values are not an issue. For both the free particle and the bound state two features emerge. First the shape of the distributions is linked to the curvature which in turn is associated with the kinetic energy. Thus the probability distributions which describe the quantum system are governed by kinetic energy. Secondly, a pattern of distributions, both negative and positive, ensures that exp(ipx) is perpendicular to other exp(ip1 x) functions and Wn(x) is perpendicular to other Wn1(x)’s. In other words energy identifies the statistical state which exists throughout space and one cannot confuse the identity of one state with another. Thus they are orthogonal throughout space and probability distributions (linked to entropy) seem to enforce this. The inner product of W*(x) and W(x) is like an inner product of a product probability of a state and its time reversed state. We suggest one should be able to define a Shannon’s entropy expression for both |cos(px)|/C1 from exp(ipx) over a half wavelength where C1 is a normalization factor and |W(x)|/C2 roughly over the length over which it has humps i.e. roughly the classical turning points for an oscillator for example. This entropy is not additive and does not map to classical entropy in the large n (energy level) limit. Furthermore it may not be linked to thermodynamics because it is not linked to x or p. Nevertheless, it might be used to describe uncertainty within the quantity system and equilibrium/stable scenarios which are observed in nature. For example, different Wn(x) states are statistically stable states, but one may knock out the particle and it will be in an exp(ipx) state which is also stable. Furthermore, a photon may excite Wn1(x) to Wn2(x), thus this new entropy seems to be linked to stable states allowed in nature. The “price to pay”, however, seems to be uncertainty in wavelength regions for a free particle and the crest/trough regions for a bound state. We also consider some properties of a similar entropy for bound states.
In previous notes, we suggested that quantum bound states may be analysed in terms of the conditional probability P(p/x)= a(p)exp(ipx)/W(x) (where W(x) is the wavefunction) which allows for the calculation of average kinetic energy at each point x i.e. [Sum over p pp/2m P(p/x)]/ W(x). This added to V(x) yields E (average energy) at each x and yields the time-independent Schrodinger equation). We argued that probability is handled at the level of W(x)=Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx). Measurements (even internal) may knock a particle from one p1 state to another so another set of probabilities (P(x) and P(p)) arise, P(x) being based on: a(p1)exp(i p1x) exp(i p2x). Averages of f(p,x) follow from P(x) f(p,x) P(p/x). Thus, there are two sets of probabilities in quantum mechanics. Entropic dynamics (1) appears to begin with the probability P(x) and considers a transition probability P(x1 |x) with x1-x= an infinitesimal quantity. A product of transition probabilities is then taken to allow for finite x1-x differences. It is stated in (1) that there exists information about x but not p. The maximization of entropy density may be used to determine the form of P(x1 | x). A “drift velocity” is also included (which is later shown to be related to the phase of the wavefunction). Ultimately, the Schrodinger equation is also obtained. We argue one may use P(p/x) to also calculate P(x1 | x) and compare this result with that obtained through the maximization of entropy density. A type of drift velocity appears naturally in this approach. We argue that the form a(p)exp(ipx) already incorporates statistical ideas (i.e. maximum entropy) in that the modulus of exp(ipx) is identical for all x, endowing all x points with a “kind” of equivalent status. exp(ipx) is a function of p and x because one must calculate average kinetic energy at each x and this must change with x i.e. KEave(x) + V(x) = E. Thus, we think there are strong similarities between entropic dynamics and the approach of using P(p/x). There are also some differences in that the coefficient A of delta(x)delta(x) in P(x1 | x) = 1/Z exp{ A delta(x)delta(x) + B d Phi/dx delta(x)} is treated as independent of x in entropic dynamics, but is a specific function of x (related to d ln(W)/dx d ln(W)/dx + 1/W d/dx d/dx W) in the P(p/x) approach.
Given a single particle bound wavefunction, W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx), it is traditionally stated that W(x)W(x) is the probability to find a particle at x. We have argued that W(x)W(x) is actually a resolution profile or a probability for interaction and does not indicate whether a particle is at x or not. (We discuss this briefly in the note.) It is linked to an observer trying to find the particle, on average at x, not if the particle is present there and interacting with V(x). If one normalizes Integral dx W(x)W(x)=1, then it follows that Sum over p a(p)a(p) = 1. Thus, a(p)a(p) has the appearance of a probability as well and one might argue that it is the probability to have a momentum p. The catch is that with W(x)W(x) one considers spatial resolution/interaction without knowing p and with a(p)a(p), one knows nothing about x. Given exp(ipx), the probability for a free particle impulse hit at x, one knows both p and x and may use this probability to calculate KEave(x) = {Sum over p a(p)pp/2m exp(ipx)} / W(x). We note that this probability does not have 0 points when W(x)=0. It shows the particle does not avoid W(x)=0 points in internal interactions with V(x), we argue. a(p)exp(ipx) / W(x) is a third probability. Given that it holds at a fixed x and ranges over p (it is sometimes called P(p/x)) it should be linked to a(p)a(p), but it considers spatial issues. We suggest that it should be combined with W(x)W(x) as this demonstrates resolution or measuring interaction hits and is linked to an external observer. The product probability, however, imposes the 0 points of W(x). This simply means, we argue, that a person making measurements does not interact with the particle at these W(x)=0 points, not that the particle does not exist there. Using this probability, as we have shown before, yields an average of the Shannon’s entropies created using W(x)W(x) and a(p)a(p) as probabilities. Here we try to understand the relationship between these three probabilities more closely without using the usual P(x)=W(x)W(x), P(p) = a(p)a(p) and P(p/x) = a(p)exp(ipx)/W.
For quantum bound states, classical style probabilities P(p)=a(p)a(p) and P(x)=W(x)W(x) [where W(x)= the wavefunction = Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx)] exist. These are real and normalized to one, but unusually, they separate p and x completely. For example, P(p) is the probability to find a momentum p anywhere in the system - no information about x is known. This seems to suggest that the P(p/x) is not defined in a classical sense. (Similar arguments hold for P(x).) We have argued in a previous note (1), that due to a lack of time reversal balance, there is no clear classical notion of P(p/x) in quantum mechanics while in classical statistical mechanics, there is a time reversal balance of two-body collisions and so P(p/x) is well-defined. In particular, a momentum p collides with a pj to form another momentum pk. There is ambiguity if p is changing, but if at the same time a pk is changing (colliding) back into a p at x, then the ambiguity is removed. In quantum mechanics, the ambiguity is not removed at x, but one may discern one p state from another throughout the entire x space. This suggests orthonormal probabilities e.g. say exp(ip1 x) and exp(i p2 x). These exp(i p x) probabilities comprise the wavefunction which is linked to P(p/x) = a(p) exp(ipx)/W(x), but although Sum over p P(p/x)=1, P(p/x) is complex with the real and complex portions taking on positive and negative values. Nevertheless, it is W(x) which is the solution of the Schrodinger (and other) equations. It is known that solutions Wn(x) of the Schrodinger equation have discrete En (energy) values. It is possible to have [H, Operator]=0 and possibly to have H written in terms of this operator. In such a case, Wn(x) might be both an eigenfunction of H and the Operator. Alternatively, a linear combination of Operator eigenfunctions may be used. If En is discrete, one may expect the operator eigenfunctions to also be discrete, leading to quantization of the Operator eigenvalues. In some cases, one may have two operators which commute with H, e.g. LL and Lz (related to angular momentum). Lz eigenfunctions might not be linked to H so one might ask why Lz should be quantized. Another H, however, may distinguish between Lz eigenfunctions and so they also have discrete eigenvalues. In this note, we try to consider why one should have orthonormal eigenfunctions of these commuting operators which make up the wavefunction and try to interpret their physical meaning.