Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Approximation Methods

Uri Peskin

Published May 11, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Exact solutions to the Schrödinger equation for realistic nanoscale systems are beyond reach, hence, different strategies for approximating the solutions are necessary. Perturbation theory relies on a “zero-order Hamiltonian” to express the desired eigenvalues and eigenvectors of “the full Hamiltonian.” We derive working equations for the Rayleigh–Schrödinger perturbation theory, and the validity of the approach is analyzed for a generic two-level system. Applications are given to atoms perturbed by point charges or static fields, and for electrons in quantum wells. An alternative strategy is the variation method, which replaces exact solutions by their projection on a reduced space of “trial functions,” varied to minimize the associated error. Particularly important is the method of linear variation, which can potentially converge to the exact Hamiltonian eigenstates. The mean-field approximation, commonly used for many-particle systems, is derived by optimizing a trial function in the form of product of single-particle functions.

DOI
10.1017/9781108877787.013

Related papers

The Functional Schrödinger Picture Approach to Many-Particle Systems

Chul Koo Kim, Sang Koo You

A self-contained pedagogical introduction to the functional Schrödinger picture method of many-body theory is given at a level suitable for graduate students and also for many-body physicists who have not been exposed to the functional Schrödinger picture method previously. Mathematical tools necessary for the functional Schrödinger picture calculation are introduced. The method is first applied to various condensed matter problems including the electron gas, the Hubbard model, the BCS superconductivity, and dilute bose gas within the variational approximation. It is shown that the variational approximation with the Gaussian trial functional invariably leads into the Hartree-Fock results for both zero and finite temperature cases. In order to go beyond the Gaussian results, concepts of variational and optimized perturbation theories are introduced using simple quantum mechanical languages. Then, the variational perturbation theory in the functional Schrödinger picture is applied to the $λϕ^4$ model to yield the effective potential to the third order. The optimized perturbation theory is also applied to the $λϕ^4$ model to yield a general expression up to the second order.

arXiv:cond-mat/0212557•Dec 23, 2002•7 citations

Common quantum mechanics and statistical mechanics results

Douglas Natelson

A review of perturbation theory Most quantum mechanics problems are not solvable in closed form with analytical techniques. To extend our repertoire beyond just particle-in-a-box, a number of approximation techniques have been developed. A large class of these fall under the heading of “perturbation theory”, in which we consider our system to obey Hamiltonian H that may be written as H = H 0 + λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , (A.1) where H 0 is an exactly solvable Hamiltonian, λ is a small parameter, and the other terms may therefore be taken as small corrections. These notes are a quick review of how to deal with systems that obey such Hamiltonians. We'll be using Dirac notation and the Schrödinger formalism, in which the states are time-dependent. We begin with time-independent perturbation theory, and will then move on to consider time-dependent problems. For now, we'll only deal with single-particle problems, too. Time-independent We're going to use the time-independent Schrödinger equation, and look for the energy eigenvalues and eigenstates of H . First, suppose that our unperturbed problem, H 0 |ψ 0 〉 = E 0 |ψ 0 〉 (A.2) may be solved exactly, giving an energy eigenvalue spectrum E 0 j with corresponding eigenstates |ψ 0 j 〉. Remember, because H 0 is a Hermitian operator, its eigenvalues are real, and its eigenvectors |ψ 0 j 〉 form a complete set. The strategy we're going to take is straightforward. We're going to assume that our perturbative corrections to the Hamiltonian, λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , lead to corresponding perturbative corrections to the eigenvalues and eigenstates. That is, E j = E 0 j + λ E 1 j + λ 2 E 2 j + … , |ψ j 〉 = |ψ 0 j 〉 + λ|ψ 1 j 〉 + λ 2 |ψ 2 j 〉 + ….

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 18, 2015•0 citations

Perturbation theory

Giampiero V. M. Esposito, Giuseppe Marmo, Gennaro Miele +1 more

Many realistic problems that arise in theoretical physics lead to equations which cannot be given exact general solutions. Therefore, many attempts have been made to produce satisfactory methods to provide approximate solutions. The most common ones search for solutions in terms of power series and in terms of asymptotic expansions. The main idea behind approximation methods is to try to find approximate solutions of a given system by means of exact solutions of an approximate system (a ‘nearby’ system). We start with the eigenvalue equation associated with the Hamiltonian H and consider an approximating one, say H0, whose equations of motion can be explicitly solved. We introduce an interpolating family of Hamiltonians Hε = H0 + εH1 such that, for a given value of ε, say ε, Hε ≡ H. Both eigenvalues and eigenvectors for Hε may be expanded as a series in ε and solved order by order. The simplest example to illustrate what we have in mind is provided by a second-order algebraic equation, e.g.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 31, 2014•0 citations

On exact analytical solutions for the few-particle Schrödinger equation. I. A perturbation study

Cheryl L. Davis, E. N. Maslen, J.N. Varghese

Abstract As the first stage in a project aimed at finding exact bound-state solutions for the few-particle Schrödinger equation, some restricted two-and three- body systems are treated by Rayleigh–Schrödinger perturbation theory. Formal solutions for the perturbation equations are obtained by using standard techniques for solving differential equations. Particular attention is given to justifying the various boundary conditions, since the same conditions apply to formal solutions of the eigenvalue equations. It is shown that boundary conditions designed to preserve the Hermitian character of the Hamiltonian are sufficient to determine all parameters in the formal solutions. The procedure is demonstrated by application to a hydrogen atom perturbed by stationary point charges. Results are given for the ground and some excited states.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Nov 8, 1982•6 citations

The Calculable Approximate: A Narrative Review of Approximation Methods in Quantum Mechanics, from Rayleigh's Perturbations to the Divergence of Series

Zen Revista, 10 PHYSICS

Exactly solvable quantum systems are rare—the harmonic oscillator, the hydrogen atom, the square well—and the physics of everything else is the physics of approximation. This article presents a narrative review of the primary literature that built quantum mechanics' approximation methods, from Rayleigh's Theory of Sound, whose treatment of slightly perturbed vibrating systems gave perturbation theory its name and scheme, and Ritz's 1909 variational method, which converted boundary-value problems into energy minimizations, through Schrödinger's 1926 wave mechanics, which equipped the new quantum theory with perturbation theory from the start, Born and Oppenheimer's 1927 adiabatic separation of electronic and nuclear motion, the 1926 papers of Wentzel, Kramers, and Brillouin that independently derived the semiclassical expansion bearing their initials, Hartree's 1928 self-consistent field and Hylleraas's 1929 variational computation of helium, which made the many-electron atom calculable, Kato's 1949 mathematical foundation of the perturbation method's convergence, Landau and Lifshitz's codifying textbook, and Bender and Wu's 1969 demonstration that the anharmonic oscillator's perturbation series diverges—the asymptotic character that defines the method's limits. The synthesis is organized around three themes: the perturbation program, in which small parameters turned the solvable cases into engines for the unsolvable; the variational program, in which upper bounds and trial functions turned minimization into the many-body atom's working instrument; and the semiclassical bridge, in which the WKB expansion connected wave mechanics to action-angle quantization and exposed tunneling. It is concluded that the three programs are complementary solutions to one problem—the gap between what can be solved and what must be calculated—and that their asymptotic character, made precise by Bender and Wu, is not a defect but the field's realistic self-understanding.

•Aug 29, 2026•0 citations

Infinite-Order Perturbation Theory for Finite Systems

C. Alton Coulter

A perturbation theory is described which leads to two alternative methods for calculating the eigenvalues and normalized eigenstates of a perturbed Hamiltonian, the results being given to all orders in the perturbation. The expansions obtained are formulated in terms of two sets of partial sums which have simple, easily characterized forms, and they combine some of the advantages of both the Rayleigh-Schr\"odinger and Brillouin-Wigner perturbation methods while avoiding some of the difficulties of each. In particular, one form of the perturbation expansions given here will in most cases of interest have a larger radius of convergence than the Rayleigh-Schr\"odinger series. As is usual for infinite-order treatments, the explicit form of the final result applies only to nondegenerate levels. However, some of the intermediate relations obtained in the derivation are of general validity. Since certain classes of unlinked diagrams appear in the expansions, the method described here is not suitable for application to systems containing a large number of particles.

Physical Review•May 25, 1967•0 citations
Exact solutions to the Schrödinger equation for realistic nanoscale systems are beyond reach, hence, different strategies for approximating the solutions are necessary. Perturbation theory relies on a “zero-order Hamiltonian” to express the desired eigenvalues and eigenvectors of “the full Hamiltonian.” We derive working equations for the Rayleigh–Schrödinger perturbation theory, and the validity of the approach is analyzed for a generic two-level system. Applications are given to atoms perturbed by point charges or static fields, and for electrons in quantum wells. An alternative strategy is the variation method, which replaces exact solutions by their projection on a reduced space of “trial functions,” varied to minimize the associated error. Particularly important is the method of linear variation, which can potentially converge to the exact Hamiltonian eigenstates. The mean-field approximation, commonly used for many-particle systems, is derived by optimizing a trial function in the form of product of single-particle functions.
A self-contained pedagogical introduction to the functional Schrödinger picture method of many-body theory is given at a level suitable for graduate students and also for many-body physicists who have not been exposed to the functional Schrödinger picture method previously. Mathematical tools necessary for the functional Schrödinger picture calculation are introduced. The method is first applied to various condensed matter problems including the electron gas, the Hubbard model, the BCS superconductivity, and dilute bose gas within the variational approximation. It is shown that the variational approximation with the Gaussian trial functional invariably leads into the Hartree-Fock results for both zero and finite temperature cases. In order to go beyond the Gaussian results, concepts of variational and optimized perturbation theories are introduced using simple quantum mechanical languages. Then, the variational perturbation theory in the functional Schrödinger picture is applied to the λϕ4λϕ^4λϕ4 model to yield the effective potential to the third order. The optimized perturbation theory is also applied to the λϕ4λϕ^4λϕ4 model to yield a general expression up to the second order.
A review of perturbation theory Most quantum mechanics problems are not solvable in closed form with analytical techniques. To extend our repertoire beyond just particle-in-a-box, a number of approximation techniques have been developed. A large class of these fall under the heading of “perturbation theory”, in which we consider our system to obey Hamiltonian H that may be written as H = H 0 + λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , (A.1) where H 0 is an exactly solvable Hamiltonian, λ is a small parameter, and the other terms may therefore be taken as small corrections. These notes are a quick review of how to deal with systems that obey such Hamiltonians. We'll be using Dirac notation and the Schrödinger formalism, in which the states are time-dependent. We begin with time-independent perturbation theory, and will then move on to consider time-dependent problems. For now, we'll only deal with single-particle problems, too. Time-independent We're going to use the time-independent Schrödinger equation, and look for the energy eigenvalues and eigenstates of H . First, suppose that our unperturbed problem, H 0 |ψ 0 〉 = E 0 |ψ 0 〉 (A.2) may be solved exactly, giving an energy eigenvalue spectrum E 0 j with corresponding eigenstates |ψ 0 j 〉. Remember, because H 0 is a Hermitian operator, its eigenvalues are real, and its eigenvectors |ψ 0 j 〉 form a complete set. The strategy we're going to take is straightforward. We're going to assume that our perturbative corrections to the Hamiltonian, λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , lead to corresponding perturbative corrections to the eigenvalues and eigenstates. That is, E j = E 0 j + λ E 1 j + λ 2 E 2 j + … , |ψ j 〉 = |ψ 0 j 〉 + λ|ψ 1 j 〉 + λ 2 |ψ 2 j 〉 + ….
Many realistic problems that arise in theoretical physics lead to equations which cannot be given exact general solutions. Therefore, many attempts have been made to produce satisfactory methods to provide approximate solutions. The most common ones search for solutions in terms of power series and in terms of asymptotic expansions. The main idea behind approximation methods is to try to find approximate solutions of a given system by means of exact solutions of an approximate system (a ‘nearby’ system). We start with the eigenvalue equation associated with the Hamiltonian H and consider an approximating one, say H0, whose equations of motion can be explicitly solved. We introduce an interpolating family of Hamiltonians Hε = H0 + εH1 such that, for a given value of ε, say ε, Hε ≡ H. Both eigenvalues and eigenvectors for Hε may be expanded as a series in ε and solved order by order. The simplest example to illustrate what we have in mind is provided by a second-order algebraic equation, e.g.
Abstract As the first stage in a project aimed at finding exact bound-state solutions for the few-particle Schrödinger equation, some restricted two-and three- body systems are treated by Rayleigh–Schrödinger perturbation theory. Formal solutions for the perturbation equations are obtained by using standard techniques for solving differential equations. Particular attention is given to justifying the various boundary conditions, since the same conditions apply to formal solutions of the eigenvalue equations. It is shown that boundary conditions designed to preserve the Hermitian character of the Hamiltonian are sufficient to determine all parameters in the formal solutions. The procedure is demonstrated by application to a hydrogen atom perturbed by stationary point charges. Results are given for the ground and some excited states.
Exactly solvable quantum systems are rare—the harmonic oscillator, the hydrogen atom, the square well—and the physics of everything else is the physics of approximation. This article presents a narrative review of the primary literature that built quantum mechanics' approximation methods, from Rayleigh's Theory of Sound, whose treatment of slightly perturbed vibrating systems gave perturbation theory its name and scheme, and Ritz's 1909 variational method, which converted boundary-value problems into energy minimizations, through Schrödinger's 1926 wave mechanics, which equipped the new quantum theory with perturbation theory from the start, Born and Oppenheimer's 1927 adiabatic separation of electronic and nuclear motion, the 1926 papers of Wentzel, Kramers, and Brillouin that independently derived the semiclassical expansion bearing their initials, Hartree's 1928 self-consistent field and Hylleraas's 1929 variational computation of helium, which made the many-electron atom calculable, Kato's 1949 mathematical foundation of the perturbation method's convergence, Landau and Lifshitz's codifying textbook, and Bender and Wu's 1969 demonstration that the anharmonic oscillator's perturbation series diverges—the asymptotic character that defines the method's limits. The synthesis is organized around three themes: the perturbation program, in which small parameters turned the solvable cases into engines for the unsolvable; the variational program, in which upper bounds and trial functions turned minimization into the many-body atom's working instrument; and the semiclassical bridge, in which the WKB expansion connected wave mechanics to action-angle quantization and exposed tunneling. It is concluded that the three programs are complementary solutions to one problem—the gap between what can be solved and what must be calculated—and that their asymptotic character, made precise by Bender and Wu, is not a defect but the field's realistic self-understanding.
A perturbation theory is described which leads to two alternative methods for calculating the eigenvalues and normalized eigenstates of a perturbed Hamiltonian, the results being given to all orders in the perturbation. The expansions obtained are formulated in terms of two sets of partial sums which have simple, easily characterized forms, and they combine some of the advantages of both the Rayleigh-Schr\"odinger and Brillouin-Wigner perturbation methods while avoiding some of the difficulties of each. In particular, one form of the perturbation expansions given here will in most cases of interest have a larger radius of convergence than the Rayleigh-Schr\"odinger series. As is usual for infinite-order treatments, the explicit form of the final result applies only to nondegenerate levels. However, some of the intermediate relations obtained in the derivation are of general validity. Since certain classes of unlinked diagrams appear in the expansions, the method described here is not suitable for application to systems containing a large number of particles.