Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics Communications

Reply to Comment on: ‘Experimental indications of non-classical brain function’ (2022 Journal of Physics Communications 6 105001)

Christian Kerskens, David López Pérez

Published Mar 1, 2023• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract We have recently suggested a proposal to explore non-classicality in the brain, for which we developed an entanglement witness protocol using MRI. The witness protocol intended to find spin interactions which could not be explained by classical interactions, based on intermolecular multiple quantum coherence (iMQC). As for Warren’s comments, we show in more detail that this was indeed the case; our observations were certainly not generated by interactions based on the iMQC model. Further, we discuss some additional details not present in the original paper.

DOI
10.1088/2399-6528/acc636

Related papers

Experimental evidence of non-classical brain functions

Christian Kerskens, David López Pérez

Abstract Exploring unknown quantum systems is an experimental challenge. Recent proposals exploring quantum gravity have suggested circumventing this problem by considering the unknown system as a mediator between two known systems. If such a mediation can locally generate entanglement in the known systems, then the mediator must be non-classical. The same approach may be applicable to other systems, in particular the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Translated to the brain, the mediator is then an unknown brain function. For the quantum systems, we could use proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with the any brain function. Entanglement in these spins can be witnessed with multiple quantum coherence (MQC). We based our witness protocol on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) whereby potential signals from local properties were minimised. For short repetitive periods, we found ZQC signals in large parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). Similar to HEPs, we also found that the ZQC signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related signals have, to our knowledge, not yet been reported in NMR. Remarkably, we could exclude local properties as contrast mechanism because (a) the ZQC signals had no correlates known in conventional MRI, and (b) the ZQC signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetisation, which are complementary to non-local properties, were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.

•Dec 28, 2021•1 citation

Experimental evidence of non-classical brain functions

Christian Kerskens, David López Pérez

Recent proposals in quantum gravity have suggested that unknown systems can mediate entanglement between two known quantum systems, if and only if the mediator itself is non-classical. This approach may be applicable to the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with any brain function, can act as the known quantum systems. If an unknown mediator exists, then NMR methods based on multiple quantum coherence (MQC) can act as entanglement witness. However, there are doubts that today’s NMR signals can contain quantum correlations in general, and specifically in the brain environment. Here, we used a witness protocol based on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) whereby we minimised the classical signals to circumvent the NMR detection limits for quantum correlation. For short repetitive periods, we found evoked signals in most parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). We found that those signals had no correlates with any classical NMR contrast. Similar to HEPs, the evoked signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related or electrophysiological signals are unknown in NMR. Remarkably, these signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetisation were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.

•Nov 15, 2017•5 citations

Experimental evidence of non-classical brain functions

Christian Kerskens, David López Pérez

Abstract Recent proposals in quantum gravity have suggested that unknown systems can mediate entanglement between two known quantum systems, if and only if the mediator itself is non-classical. This approach may be applicable to the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with any brain function, can act as the known quantum systems. If an unknown mediator exists, then NMR methods based on multiple quantum coherence (MQC) can act as entanglement witness. However, there are doubts that today’s NMR signals can contain quantum correlations in general, and specifically in the brain environment. Here, we used a witness protocol based on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) whereby we minimised the classical signals to circumvent the NMR detection limits for quantum correlation. For short repetitive periods, we found evoked signals in most parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeatevoked potentials (HEPs). We found that those signals had no correlates with any classical NMR contrast. Similar to HEPs, the evoked signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related or electrophysiological signals are unknown in NMR. Remarkably, these signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetisation were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.

•Jun 16, 2022•0 citations

Experimental indications of non-classical brain functions

Christian Kerskens, David López Pérez

Abstract Recent proposals in quantum gravity have suggested that unknown systems can mediate entanglement between two known quantum systems, if the mediator itself is non-classical. This approach may be applicable to the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with any brain function, can act as the known quantum systems. If an unknown mediator exists, then NMR methods based on multiple quantum coherence (MQC) can act as an entanglement witness. However, there are doubts that today’s NMR signals can contain quantum correlations in general, and specifically in the brain environment. Here, we used a witness protocol based on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) where we minimized the classical signals to circumvent the NMR detection limits for quantum correlation. For short repetitive periods, we found evoked signals in most parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). We found that those signals had no correlates with any classical NMR contrast. Similar to HEPs, the evoked signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related or electrophysiological signals are unknown in NMR. Remarkably, these signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetization were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.

arXiv:1806.07998•Journal of Physics Communications•Sep 26, 2022•103 citations

Response to a comment on "Vindication of entanglement-based witnesses in hybrid quantum systems"

Chiara Marletto, Emanuele Marconato

In a recent paper, we vindicated a general entanglement-based witness of non-classicality in hybrid quantum systems. Our vindication refutes a counterexample to the witness, proposed by Hall and Reginatto. These authors recently commented further, claiming to expose "a huge number of errors and misconceptions" in it. However, their comment contains no refutation of our arguments, nor does it expose any error or misconception in them. But it does include a number of misconceptions about the witness of non-classicality. Here we respond to those.

arXiv:2112.15074•Dec 30, 2021•0 citations

Reply to Comment on “Experimental Test of an Event-Based Corpuscular Model Modification as an Alternative to Quantum Mechanics”

G. Brida, Ivo Pietro Degiovanni, Marco Genovese +4 more

We have presented an experimental result, where we show that the predictions of an Event-Based Corpuscular Model (EBCM) from Ref. 2, a model that belongs to a class of non-ergodic models first described by Buonomano, are inconsistent with our measurements. We concluded that traditional quantum mechanics adequately describes our experiment, where pure single photons were used, and that our findings agree with earlier verification experiments by Summhammer, where a poissonian source of heavy particles was used. In their comment, Michielsen et al. disagree with the above conclusions. The central point of their argument is that EBCM predictions would be compatible with the observation, if the Mach–Zehnder interferometer (MZI) under test is modeled as a single system, and not as two independent, non-communicating beam splitters (BS). Unfortunately, the physics of interaction and a quantitative model of communication among the parts of MZI that would make it possible to reduce the model to effectively one memory register are not offered. Furthermore, no modification for a verification experiment that would guarantee the absence of an unspecified interaction is offered. An argument resorting to communication between the MZI parts is not a surprise. It is identical to invoking a locality loophole in Bell inequalities: when one considers communication among the different parts of the experimental apparatus, it is well known that hidden variable models can reproduce the results of Quantum Mechanics (QM). But by invoking an undescribed locality loophole, the EBCM and its verification experiment largely loses its appeal, because it becomes a sub-class of hidden variable theories falsifiable via a locality loophole free Bell test. In this sense, the class of local variable theories with noncommunicating memories per each optical element was by far more interesting and unique, because they provide an independent way for testing. We point out that the argument of Michielsen et al. begs the question by suggesting that more experiments are needed while providing no details on how one may avoid any and all interactions that may lead to replacing the two independent registers in the two beam splitters (as originally proposed in their model) with one collective register. Ultimately, we believe that it is not possible to suggest an experiment, even in principle, that would allow a test similar to that from Ref. 2 with the two beam splitters outside of the light cone, i.e., where one could guarantee that no sub-luminal communication occurs, because the ‘‘message carriers’’ are photons that travel with a luminal speed. Given that this loophole can never be closed, it is really hard to define what ‘‘independent’’ means. In view of this, it is unfortunate that Michielsen et al. do not offer any discussion on how to ensure that optical parts are ‘‘independent’’. Particularly, no details are offered on how to reduce independent BSs to a single system that guarantees that the functionality of the device before and after reduction is consistent with QM. How would that reduction occur in nature? Is this reduction adiabatic or discontinuous? How can one control the transition from a set of non-interacting EBCM elements to a single EBCM element? In other words, where are new registers located, and why are they to be moved from the BS as initially asserted, and how does such a device reproduce laws of QM before, during and after such a drastic transition? We believe that, by invoking a non-formalized locality loophole, Michielsen et al. commend the experimental efforts of Ref. 1, acknowledging that all other aspects of the experiment are flawless. That is, the authors of Ref. 1 conducted a fair experiment, in strict accordance with their initial theoretical proposal, and free of an unintentional bias. In conclusion, the comment does not explain how and why the EBCM model is modified to overcome the Ref. 1 test. Further, it neither clarifies the relevance of the model in its new version nor proposes new tests of it. By invoking a non-formalized locality loophole, the authors implicitly moved their model to a much larger class of local realism models.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Jul 29, 2013•0 citations
Abstract We have recently suggested a proposal to explore non-classicality in the brain, for which we developed an entanglement witness protocol using MRI. The witness protocol intended to find spin interactions which could not be explained by classical interactions, based on intermolecular multiple quantum coherence (iMQC). As for Warren’s comments, we show in more detail that this was indeed the case; our observations were certainly not generated by interactions based on the iMQC model. Further, we discuss some additional details not present in the original paper.
Abstract Exploring unknown quantum systems is an experimental challenge. Recent proposals exploring quantum gravity have suggested circumventing this problem by considering the unknown system as a mediator between two known systems. If such a mediation can locally generate entanglement in the known systems, then the mediator must be non-classical. The same approach may be applicable to other systems, in particular the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Translated to the brain, the mediator is then an unknown brain function. For the quantum systems, we could use proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with the any brain function. Entanglement in these spins can be witnessed with multiple quantum coherence (MQC). We based our witness protocol on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) whereby potential signals from local properties were minimised. For short repetitive periods, we found ZQC signals in large parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). Similar to HEPs, we also found that the ZQC signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related signals have, to our knowledge, not yet been reported in NMR. Remarkably, we could exclude local properties as contrast mechanism because (a) the ZQC signals had no correlates known in conventional MRI, and (b) the ZQC signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetisation, which are complementary to non-local properties, were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.
Recent proposals in quantum gravity have suggested that unknown systems can mediate entanglement between two known quantum systems, if and only if the mediator itself is non-classical. This approach may be applicable to the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with any brain function, can act as the known quantum systems. If an unknown mediator exists, then NMR methods based on multiple quantum coherence (MQC) can act as entanglement witness. However, there are doubts that today’s NMR signals can contain quantum correlations in general, and specifically in the brain environment. Here, we used a witness protocol based on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) whereby we minimised the classical signals to circumvent the NMR detection limits for quantum correlation. For short repetitive periods, we found evoked signals in most parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). We found that those signals had no correlates with any classical NMR contrast. Similar to HEPs, the evoked signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related or electrophysiological signals are unknown in NMR. Remarkably, these signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetisation were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.
Abstract Recent proposals in quantum gravity have suggested that unknown systems can mediate entanglement between two known quantum systems, if and only if the mediator itself is non-classical. This approach may be applicable to the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with any brain function, can act as the known quantum systems. If an unknown mediator exists, then NMR methods based on multiple quantum coherence (MQC) can act as entanglement witness. However, there are doubts that today’s NMR signals can contain quantum correlations in general, and specifically in the brain environment. Here, we used a witness protocol based on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) whereby we minimised the classical signals to circumvent the NMR detection limits for quantum correlation. For short repetitive periods, we found evoked signals in most parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeatevoked potentials (HEPs). We found that those signals had no correlates with any classical NMR contrast. Similar to HEPs, the evoked signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related or electrophysiological signals are unknown in NMR. Remarkably, these signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetisation were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.
Abstract Recent proposals in quantum gravity have suggested that unknown systems can mediate entanglement between two known quantum systems, if the mediator itself is non-classical. This approach may be applicable to the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with any brain function, can act as the known quantum systems. If an unknown mediator exists, then NMR methods based on multiple quantum coherence (MQC) can act as an entanglement witness. However, there are doubts that today’s NMR signals can contain quantum correlations in general, and specifically in the brain environment. Here, we used a witness protocol based on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) where we minimized the classical signals to circumvent the NMR detection limits for quantum correlation. For short repetitive periods, we found evoked signals in most parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). We found that those signals had no correlates with any classical NMR contrast. Similar to HEPs, the evoked signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related or electrophysiological signals are unknown in NMR. Remarkably, these signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetization were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.
In a recent paper, we vindicated a general entanglement-based witness of non-classicality in hybrid quantum systems. Our vindication refutes a counterexample to the witness, proposed by Hall and Reginatto. These authors recently commented further, claiming to expose "a huge number of errors and misconceptions" in it. However, their comment contains no refutation of our arguments, nor does it expose any error or misconception in them. But it does include a number of misconceptions about the witness of non-classicality. Here we respond to those.
We have presented an experimental result, where we show that the predictions of an Event-Based Corpuscular Model (EBCM) from Ref. 2, a model that belongs to a class of non-ergodic models first described by Buonomano, are inconsistent with our measurements. We concluded that traditional quantum mechanics adequately describes our experiment, where pure single photons were used, and that our findings agree with earlier verification experiments by Summhammer, where a poissonian source of heavy particles was used. In their comment, Michielsen et al. disagree with the above conclusions. The central point of their argument is that EBCM predictions would be compatible with the observation, if the Mach–Zehnder interferometer (MZI) under test is modeled as a single system, and not as two independent, non-communicating beam splitters (BS). Unfortunately, the physics of interaction and a quantitative model of communication among the parts of MZI that would make it possible to reduce the model to effectively one memory register are not offered. Furthermore, no modification for a verification experiment that would guarantee the absence of an unspecified interaction is offered. An argument resorting to communication between the MZI parts is not a surprise. It is identical to invoking a locality loophole in Bell inequalities: when one considers communication among the different parts of the experimental apparatus, it is well known that hidden variable models can reproduce the results of Quantum Mechanics (QM). But by invoking an undescribed locality loophole, the EBCM and its verification experiment largely loses its appeal, because it becomes a sub-class of hidden variable theories falsifiable via a locality loophole free Bell test. In this sense, the class of local variable theories with noncommunicating memories per each optical element was by far more interesting and unique, because they provide an independent way for testing. We point out that the argument of Michielsen et al. begs the question by suggesting that more experiments are needed while providing no details on how one may avoid any and all interactions that may lead to replacing the two independent registers in the two beam splitters (as originally proposed in their model) with one collective register. Ultimately, we believe that it is not possible to suggest an experiment, even in principle, that would allow a test similar to that from Ref. 2 with the two beam splitters outside of the light cone, i.e., where one could guarantee that no sub-luminal communication occurs, because the ‘‘message carriers’’ are photons that travel with a luminal speed. Given that this loophole can never be closed, it is really hard to define what ‘‘independent’’ means. In view of this, it is unfortunate that Michielsen et al. do not offer any discussion on how to ensure that optical parts are ‘‘independent’’. Particularly, no details are offered on how to reduce independent BSs to a single system that guarantees that the functionality of the device before and after reduction is consistent with QM. How would that reduction occur in nature? Is this reduction adiabatic or discontinuous? How can one control the transition from a set of non-interacting EBCM elements to a single EBCM element? In other words, where are new registers located, and why are they to be moved from the BS as initially asserted, and how does such a device reproduce laws of QM before, during and after such a drastic transition? We believe that, by invoking a non-formalized locality loophole, Michielsen et al. commend the experimental efforts of Ref. 1, acknowledging that all other aspects of the experiment are flawless. That is, the authors of Ref. 1 conducted a fair experiment, in strict accordance with their initial theoretical proposal, and free of an unintentional bias. In conclusion, the comment does not explain how and why the EBCM model is modified to overcome the Ref. 1 test. Further, it neither clarifies the relevance of the model in its new version nor proposes new tests of it. By invoking a non-formalized locality loophole, the authors implicitly moved their model to a much larger class of local realism models.