Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Impossibility in Physics

Jesper Lützen

Published Jan 26, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Also physics has its impossibility statements. We compare them with the mathematical impossibility theorems and look into the history of one of them: the impossibility of building a perpetual motion machine. We also consider impossibilities in twentieth-century physics, in particular in quantum mechanics. For example, Heisenberg’s uncertainty relations imply that it is impossible to measure both the place and momentum of a particle accurately. We also discuss von Neumann’s controversial proof that it is impossible to obtain a deterministic version of quantum mechanics by introducing hidden variables.

DOI
10.1093/oso/9780192867391.003.0019

Related papers

What is wrong with von Neumann's theorem on "no hidden variables"

Elemér Elad Rosinger

It is shown that, although correct mathematically, the celebrated 1932 theorem of von Neumann which is often interpreted as proving the impossibility of the existence of "hidden variables" in Quantum Mechanics, is in fact based on an assumption which is physically not reasonable. Apart from that, the alleged conclusion of von Neumann proving the impossibility of the existence of "hidden variables" was already set aside in 1952 by the counterexample of the possibility of a physical theory, such as given by what is usually called the "Bohmian Mechanics". Similar arguments apply to other two well known mathematical theorems, namely, of Gleason, and of Kochen and Specker, which have often been seen as equally proving the impossibility of the existence of "hidden variables" in Quantum Mechanics.

arXiv:quant-ph/0408191•Aug 31, 2004•11 citations

Remarks on Uncertainty Principles

E. U. Condon

Since the publication of Heisenberg’s paper1 on the “anschaulichen Inhalt” of quantum mechanics, discussions of the fundamental limitations on the accuracy of physical measurements have been much in the foreground. According to Heisenberg, the quantum mechanics implies that it is impossible to measure simultaneous values of a coordinate and its conjugate momentum with unlimited precision. Instead, if Δp be the estimated error or uncertainty in a momentum and Δq that in the associated coordinate one must have the inequality, $$ \Delta p\Delta q>\frac{h}{{2\pi}} $$ (1) This inequality has come to be known quite generally as Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation.

Science•May 31, 1929•16 citations

Measurement and Impossibility

Jim Baggott, John L. Heilbron

Abstract As Heisenberg began to promulgate his version of the new quantum philosophy as the ‘Copenhagen spirit’, John von Neumann undertook to purge quantum mechanics of its defects and make it comprehensible to Göttingen’s prince of mathematics, David Hilbert. The result is familiar to any student of physical science. Von Neumann separated the continuous, deterministic, and reversible evolution of the wavefunction from its discontinuous, indeterministic, and irreversible ‘collapse’ in an act of measurement. He saw no reason why the first process should not continue all the way up the chain to the observer’s conscious mind, where the second process occurs. Bohr had little to say about von Neumann’s theory, other than it was ‘wrongly put’. Von Neumann also closed the door that Born had left ajar. Causality could not be restored to the quantum domain by supposing the existence of ‘hidden variables’, as these, according to his reasoning, were mathematically impossible.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 25, 2024•0 citations

The Problem of Hidden Variables in Quantum Mechanics

Simon Kochen, Ernst P. Specker

Forty years after the advent of quantum mechanics the problem of hidden variables, that is, the possibility of imbedding quantum theory into a classical theory, remains a controversial and obscure subject. Whereas to most physicists the possibility of a classical reinterpretation of quantum mechanics remains remote and perhaps irrelevant to current problems, a minority have kept the issue alive throughout this period. (See Freistadt [5] for a review of the problem and a comprehensive bibliography up to 1957.) As far as results are concerned there are on the one hand purported proofs of the non-existence of hidden variables, most notably von Neumann’s proof, and on the other, various attempts to introduce hidden variables such as de Broglie [4] and Bohm [1] and [2]. One of the difficulties in evaluating these contradictory results is that no exact mathematical criterion is given to enable one to judge the degree of success of these proposals. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Birkhäuser Basel eBooks•Jan 1, 1990•57 citations

The de Broglie–Bohm theory is and is not a hidden variable theory

Jean Bricmont

Abstract We will first define what is meant by “hidden variables”. Then, we will review theorems proving the impossibility of theories introducing such variables in a naive way. Next, we will outline the de Broglie-Bohm theory and show that it is not refuted by those theorems. To do that, we will explain how “measurements” work in that theory, using the examples of spin measurements and of momentum measurements. Those measurements do not reveal pre-existing properties of the quantum particle but are the result of interactions between that particle and the measuring apparatus. And this is why the de Broglie-Bohm theory is not refuted by the theorems on the impossibility of hidden variables. We will also explain the relationship between the no “hidden variables” theorems and nonlocality, with and without introducing Bell’s inequalities.

arXiv:2307.05148•Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 1, 2025•2 citations

The Uncertainty Principle: Limits of Knowledge

One of the most profound and unsettling discoveries of the twentieth century is that nature imposes fundamental limits on what we can know about the physical world. This is the essence of the Uncertainty Principle , formulated by Werner Heisenberg in 1927 [Heisenberg (1927)]. The principle states that certain pairs of physical properties cannot be known simultaneously with arbitrary precision. The most famous example is that the more precisely we know a particle's position, the less precisely we can know its momentum, and vice versa as shown in Fig. 12.1. This is not a limitation of our measuring instruments or experimental technique—it is a fundamental property of nature itself at the quantum scale.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations
Abstract Also physics has its impossibility statements. We compare them with the mathematical impossibility theorems and look into the history of one of them: the impossibility of building a perpetual motion machine. We also consider impossibilities in twentieth-century physics, in particular in quantum mechanics. For example, Heisenberg’s uncertainty relations imply that it is impossible to measure both the place and momentum of a particle accurately. We also discuss von Neumann’s controversial proof that it is impossible to obtain a deterministic version of quantum mechanics by introducing hidden variables.
It is shown that, although correct mathematically, the celebrated 1932 theorem of von Neumann which is often interpreted as proving the impossibility of the existence of "hidden variables" in Quantum Mechanics, is in fact based on an assumption which is physically not reasonable. Apart from that, the alleged conclusion of von Neumann proving the impossibility of the existence of "hidden variables" was already set aside in 1952 by the counterexample of the possibility of a physical theory, such as given by what is usually called the "Bohmian Mechanics". Similar arguments apply to other two well known mathematical theorems, namely, of Gleason, and of Kochen and Specker, which have often been seen as equally proving the impossibility of the existence of "hidden variables" in Quantum Mechanics.
Since the publication of Heisenberg’s paper1 on the “anschaulichen Inhalt” of quantum mechanics, discussions of the fundamental limitations on the accuracy of physical measurements have been much in the foreground. According to Heisenberg, the quantum mechanics implies that it is impossible to measure simultaneous values of a coordinate and its conjugate momentum with unlimited precision. Instead, if Δp be the estimated error or uncertainty in a momentum and Δq that in the associated coordinate one must have the inequality, ΔpΔq>h2π \Delta p\Delta q>\frac{h}{{2\pi}} ΔpΔq>2πh​ (1) This inequality has come to be known quite generally as Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation.
Abstract As Heisenberg began to promulgate his version of the new quantum philosophy as the ‘Copenhagen spirit’, John von Neumann undertook to purge quantum mechanics of its defects and make it comprehensible to Göttingen’s prince of mathematics, David Hilbert. The result is familiar to any student of physical science. Von Neumann separated the continuous, deterministic, and reversible evolution of the wavefunction from its discontinuous, indeterministic, and irreversible ‘collapse’ in an act of measurement. He saw no reason why the first process should not continue all the way up the chain to the observer’s conscious mind, where the second process occurs. Bohr had little to say about von Neumann’s theory, other than it was ‘wrongly put’. Von Neumann also closed the door that Born had left ajar. Causality could not be restored to the quantum domain by supposing the existence of ‘hidden variables’, as these, according to his reasoning, were mathematically impossible.
Forty years after the advent of quantum mechanics the problem of hidden variables, that is, the possibility of imbedding quantum theory into a classical theory, remains a controversial and obscure subject. Whereas to most physicists the possibility of a classical reinterpretation of quantum mechanics remains remote and perhaps irrelevant to current problems, a minority have kept the issue alive throughout this period. (See Freistadt [5] for a review of the problem and a comprehensive bibliography up to 1957.) As far as results are concerned there are on the one hand purported proofs of the non-existence of hidden variables, most notably von Neumann’s proof, and on the other, various attempts to introduce hidden variables such as de Broglie [4] and Bohm [1] and [2]. One of the difficulties in evaluating these contradictory results is that no exact mathematical criterion is given to enable one to judge the degree of success of these proposals. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Abstract We will first define what is meant by “hidden variables”. Then, we will review theorems proving the impossibility of theories introducing such variables in a naive way. Next, we will outline the de Broglie-Bohm theory and show that it is not refuted by those theorems. To do that, we will explain how “measurements” work in that theory, using the examples of spin measurements and of momentum measurements. Those measurements do not reveal pre-existing properties of the quantum particle but are the result of interactions between that particle and the measuring apparatus. And this is why the de Broglie-Bohm theory is not refuted by the theorems on the impossibility of hidden variables. We will also explain the relationship between the no “hidden variables” theorems and nonlocality, with and without introducing Bell’s inequalities.
One of the most profound and unsettling discoveries of the twentieth century is that nature imposes fundamental limits on what we can know about the physical world. This is the essence of the Uncertainty Principle , formulated by Werner Heisenberg in 1927 [Heisenberg (1927)]. The principle states that certain pairs of physical properties cannot be known simultaneously with arbitrary precision. The most famous example is that the more precisely we know a particle's position, the less precisely we can know its momentum, and vice versa as shown in Fig. 12.1. This is not a limitation of our measuring instruments or experimental technique—it is a fundamental property of nature itself at the quantum scale.