Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics Conference Series

Impact of quantum noise on the training of quantum Generative Adversarial Networks

K. Borras, Su Yeon Chang, Lena Funcke, Michele Grossi, Tobias Hartung, Karl Jansen, D. Kruecker, Stefan Kühn, Florian Rehm, Cenk Tüysüz, Sofia Vallecorsa

Published Feb 1, 2023• 24 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Current noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices suffer from various sources of intrinsic quantum noise. Overcoming the effects of noise is a major challenge, for which different error mitigation and error correction techniques have been proposed. In this paper, we conduct a first study of the performance of quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (qGANs) in the presence of different types of quantum noise, focusing on a simplified use case in high-energy physics. In particular, we explore the effects of readout and two-qubit gate errors on the qGAN training process. Simulating a noisy quantum device classically with IBM’s Qiskit framework, we examine the threshold of error rates up to which a reliable training is possible. In addition, we investigate the importance of various hyperparameters for the training process in the presence of different error rates, and we explore the impact of readout error mitigation on the results.

DOI
10.1088/1742-6596/2438/1/012093

Related papers

Impact of quantum noise on the training of quantum Generative Adversarial Networks

K. Borras, Su Yeon Chang, Lena Funcke +8 more

Current noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices suffer from various sources of intrinsic quantum noise. Overcoming the effects of noise is a major challenge, for which different error mitigation and error correction techniques have been proposed. In this paper, we conduct a first study of the performance of quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (qGANs) in the presence of different types of quantum noise, focusing on a simplified use case in high-energy physics. In particular, we explore the effects of readout and two-qubit gate errors on the qGAN training process. Simulating a noisy quantum device classically with IBM's Qiskit framework, we examine the threshold of error rates up to which a reliable training is possible. In addition, we investigate the importance of various hyperparameters for the training process in the presence of different error rates, and we explore the impact of readout error mitigation on the results.

arXiv:2203.01007•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jan 1, 2021•4 citations

Noise Robustness and Experimental Demonstration of a Quantum Generative Adversarial Network for Continuous Distributions

Abhinav Anand, Jonathan Romero, Matthias Degroote +1 more

Abstract The potential advantage of machine learning in quantum computers is a topic of intense discussion in the literature. Theoretical, numerical, and experimental explorations will most likely be required to understand its power. There have been different algorithms proposed to exploit the probabilistic nature of variational quantum circuits for generative modeling. In this paper, a hybrid architecture for quantum generative adversarial networks (QGANs) is employed and their robustness in the presence of noise is studied. A simple way of adding different types of noise to the quantum generator circuit is devised, and the noisy hybrid QGANs (HQGANs) are simulated numerically to learn continuous probability distributions, and to show that the performance of HQGANs remains unaffected. The effect of different parameters on the training time is also investigated to reduce the computational scaling of the algorithm and simplify its deployment on a quantum computer. The training on Rigetti's Aspen‐4‐2Q‐A quantum processing unit is then performed, and the results from the training are presented. The authors' results pave the way for experimental exploration of different quantum machine learning algorithms on noisy intermediate‐scale quantum devices.

arXiv:2006.01976•Advanced Quantum Technologies•Apr 1, 2021•37 citations

Noise-Robust Quantum Generative Models for Distribution Learning and Efficient Data Loading

Ankit Kumar Mandusia

Abstract Quantum machine learning offers powerful advantages in processing high-dimensional data, but loading classical probability distributions into quantum states remains a major challenge. This work extends quantum generative adversarial networks (qGANs) to overcome two critical limitations of early approaches: poor robustness to noise on near-term devices and limited capacity to model complex, multi-modal distributions. We introduce hybrid qGAN architectures that combine Wasserstein GAN with gradient penalty (WGAN-GP) and maximum mean discrepancy (MMD) losses with expressive quantum circuits, including quantum convolutional neural networks (QCNNs) and EfficientSU2 ansätze. Training is performed using seamless PyTorch–Qiskit integration, enabling stable optimization on both simulators and real quantum hardware.Experiments on 2D Gaussian and log-normal distributions—directly relevant to financial modeling—show faster convergence and higher fidelity than prior qGAN designs, with up to 80% lower Wasserstein distance under 5% depolarizing noise. The framework is further validated through European call option pricing via quantum amplitude estimation (QAE), achieving pricing errors below 1% on IBM’s 20-qubit superconducting systems. Theoretical analysis confirms gradient stability under noise, while empirical results include comprehensive noise sweeps, t-SNE latent space visualizations, and rigorous statistical tests (KL divergence, KS tests). This work establishes a practical path toward quantum advantage in generative modeling, with fully open-source code for reproducibility.

•Nov 18, 2025•0 citations

Survey of Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGAN) to Generate Images

Mohammadsaleh Pajuhanfard, Rasoul Kiani, Victor S. Sheng

Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) represent a useful development in quantum machine learning, using the particular properties of quantum mechanics to solve the challenges of data analysis and modeling. This paper brings up a general analysis of five QGAN architectures, focusing on their evolution, strengths, weaknesses, and limitations in noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. Primary methods like Entangling Quantum GAN (EQ-GAN) and Quantum state fidelity (QuGAN) concentrate on stability, convergence, and robust performance on small-scale datasets such as 2 × 2 grayscale images. Intermediate models such as Image Quantum GAN (IQGAN) and Experimental Quantum GAN (EXQGAN) provide new ideas like trainable encoders and patch-based sub-generators that are scalable to 8 × 8 datasets with increasing noise resilience. The most advanced method is Parameterized Quantum Wasserstein GAN (PQWGAN), which uses a hybrid quantum-classical structure to obtain high-resolution image processing for 28 × 28 grayscale datasets while trying to maintain parameter efficiency. This study explores, analyzes, and summarizes critical problems of QGANs, including accuracy, convergence, parameter efficiency, image quality, performance metrics, and training stability under noisy conditions. In addition, developing QGANs can generate and train parameters in quantum approximation optimization algorithms. One of the useful applications of QGAN is generating medical datasets that can generate medical images from limited datasets to train specific medical models for the recognition of diseases.

Mathematics•Dec 6, 2024•30 citations

Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks for Intrusion Detection: An Experimentation on Real Quantum Devices

Franco Cirillo, Christian Esposito

Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) are vital for securing modern networks, but traditional machine learning-based anomaly detection methods often struggle with high-dimensional and imbalanced data. Although classical GANs help improve data generation, they are computationally intensive and limited in scalability. Quantum GANs (QGANs) present a promising alternative, but existing approaches are tested only in simulations. Instead, using real devices presents challenges not only because of the impact of quantum noise but, more significantly, due to usage restrictions imposed by their high cost. To cope with this, we propose a lightweight but effective hybrid QGAN for network intrusion detection, adopting a hybrid training approach by switching between an IBM real quantum device and its noisy simulator version, balancing computational feasibility and relevance in the real world. The results show that our model performs consistently, with minimal performance loss on real hardware.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Artificial Intelligence (QAI)•Nov 2, 2025•0 citations

Constructing and Benchmarking Noise Models for Quantum Computing

Tom Weber

Context: The main obstacle of quantum computing on its way to scalability is the noisy nature of current hardware. Various types of errors lead to incorrect computational results,and measures such as quantum error mitigation are needed to counteract these errors. Many error mitigation techniques require a thorough understanding of the noise and its impact on computations. Therefore, accurate noise models are indispensable to facilitate meaningful quantum computing in the near future. They also enable realistic simulations of quantum devices. Since these devices are currently limited and quantum computing is expensive, researchers typically rely on simulations for testing their algorithms.Objective: In this thesis, we aim to construct a realistic noise model for quantum computing and optimise its model parameters. The model construction should build on the underlying physical processes, and the number of parameters should scale well with the system size. We also address the evaluation and comparison of different noise models by benchmarks using quantum circuits specific to real-world applications. Finally, we aim to develop useful graphical representations of noise models based on the existing quantum circuit model.Method: We present a benchmarking framework for quantum computing noise models and evaluate it based on benchmarking quality attributes from the literature. Moreover, we construct a quantum computing noise model and develop a training procedure for its parameters. We analyse the parameters of the trained noise model and the impact ofdifferent types of errors on computations. We benchmark the noise model with the above approach and compare it to a noise model provided by IBM’s software development kit Qiskit. Finally, we develop an extension of the quantum circuit model to represent noise channels.Result: The benchmarks performed in this thesis show that our noise model predicts noisy hardware behaviour of IBM’s ibmq_manila quantum device equally well as the Qiskit model, if not better, based on quantum circuits commonly used for variational quantum algorithms. Within the trained noise model, readout error has the most detrimental impact on computations. Our benchmarking approach satisfies relevant quality criteria by choosing suitable quantum circuits and objective functions to compare model predictionsto hardware data. Moreover, the quantum circuit model can be extended meaningfully by noise channels.Conclusion: Our benchmarking approach is suitable for evaluating and comparing quantum computing noise models. In future work, volumetric benchmarks should be performed for various noise models and application contexts. The parameter optimisation based on learning with training circuits yields accurate noise models and shows the importance of mitigating measurement error. Different optimisation algorithms and quantum circuits should be explored, and more types of noise should be incorporated into the noise model.

•Jan 12, 2026•0 citations
Abstract Current noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices suffer from various sources of intrinsic quantum noise. Overcoming the effects of noise is a major challenge, for which different error mitigation and error correction techniques have been proposed. In this paper, we conduct a first study of the performance of quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (qGANs) in the presence of different types of quantum noise, focusing on a simplified use case in high-energy physics. In particular, we explore the effects of readout and two-qubit gate errors on the qGAN training process. Simulating a noisy quantum device classically with IBM’s Qiskit framework, we examine the threshold of error rates up to which a reliable training is possible. In addition, we investigate the importance of various hyperparameters for the training process in the presence of different error rates, and we explore the impact of readout error mitigation on the results.
Current noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices suffer from various sources of intrinsic quantum noise. Overcoming the effects of noise is a major challenge, for which different error mitigation and error correction techniques have been proposed. In this paper, we conduct a first study of the performance of quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (qGANs) in the presence of different types of quantum noise, focusing on a simplified use case in high-energy physics. In particular, we explore the effects of readout and two-qubit gate errors on the qGAN training process. Simulating a noisy quantum device classically with IBM's Qiskit framework, we examine the threshold of error rates up to which a reliable training is possible. In addition, we investigate the importance of various hyperparameters for the training process in the presence of different error rates, and we explore the impact of readout error mitigation on the results.
Abstract The potential advantage of machine learning in quantum computers is a topic of intense discussion in the literature. Theoretical, numerical, and experimental explorations will most likely be required to understand its power. There have been different algorithms proposed to exploit the probabilistic nature of variational quantum circuits for generative modeling. In this paper, a hybrid architecture for quantum generative adversarial networks (QGANs) is employed and their robustness in the presence of noise is studied. A simple way of adding different types of noise to the quantum generator circuit is devised, and the noisy hybrid QGANs (HQGANs) are simulated numerically to learn continuous probability distributions, and to show that the performance of HQGANs remains unaffected. The effect of different parameters on the training time is also investigated to reduce the computational scaling of the algorithm and simplify its deployment on a quantum computer. The training on Rigetti's Aspen‐4‐2Q‐A quantum processing unit is then performed, and the results from the training are presented. The authors' results pave the way for experimental exploration of different quantum machine learning algorithms on noisy intermediate‐scale quantum devices.
Abstract Quantum machine learning offers powerful advantages in processing high-dimensional data, but loading classical probability distributions into quantum states remains a major challenge. This work extends quantum generative adversarial networks (qGANs) to overcome two critical limitations of early approaches: poor robustness to noise on near-term devices and limited capacity to model complex, multi-modal distributions. We introduce hybrid qGAN architectures that combine Wasserstein GAN with gradient penalty (WGAN-GP) and maximum mean discrepancy (MMD) losses with expressive quantum circuits, including quantum convolutional neural networks (QCNNs) and EfficientSU2 ansätze. Training is performed using seamless PyTorch–Qiskit integration, enabling stable optimization on both simulators and real quantum hardware.Experiments on 2D Gaussian and log-normal distributions—directly relevant to financial modeling—show faster convergence and higher fidelity than prior qGAN designs, with up to 80% lower Wasserstein distance under 5% depolarizing noise. The framework is further validated through European call option pricing via quantum amplitude estimation (QAE), achieving pricing errors below 1% on IBM’s 20-qubit superconducting systems. Theoretical analysis confirms gradient stability under noise, while empirical results include comprehensive noise sweeps, t-SNE latent space visualizations, and rigorous statistical tests (KL divergence, KS tests). This work establishes a practical path toward quantum advantage in generative modeling, with fully open-source code for reproducibility.
Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) represent a useful development in quantum machine learning, using the particular properties of quantum mechanics to solve the challenges of data analysis and modeling. This paper brings up a general analysis of five QGAN architectures, focusing on their evolution, strengths, weaknesses, and limitations in noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. Primary methods like Entangling Quantum GAN (EQ-GAN) and Quantum state fidelity (QuGAN) concentrate on stability, convergence, and robust performance on small-scale datasets such as 2 × 2 grayscale images. Intermediate models such as Image Quantum GAN (IQGAN) and Experimental Quantum GAN (EXQGAN) provide new ideas like trainable encoders and patch-based sub-generators that are scalable to 8 × 8 datasets with increasing noise resilience. The most advanced method is Parameterized Quantum Wasserstein GAN (PQWGAN), which uses a hybrid quantum-classical structure to obtain high-resolution image processing for 28 × 28 grayscale datasets while trying to maintain parameter efficiency. This study explores, analyzes, and summarizes critical problems of QGANs, including accuracy, convergence, parameter efficiency, image quality, performance metrics, and training stability under noisy conditions. In addition, developing QGANs can generate and train parameters in quantum approximation optimization algorithms. One of the useful applications of QGAN is generating medical datasets that can generate medical images from limited datasets to train specific medical models for the recognition of diseases.
Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) are vital for securing modern networks, but traditional machine learning-based anomaly detection methods often struggle with high-dimensional and imbalanced data. Although classical GANs help improve data generation, they are computationally intensive and limited in scalability. Quantum GANs (QGANs) present a promising alternative, but existing approaches are tested only in simulations. Instead, using real devices presents challenges not only because of the impact of quantum noise but, more significantly, due to usage restrictions imposed by their high cost. To cope with this, we propose a lightweight but effective hybrid QGAN for network intrusion detection, adopting a hybrid training approach by switching between an IBM real quantum device and its noisy simulator version, balancing computational feasibility and relevance in the real world. The results show that our model performs consistently, with minimal performance loss on real hardware.
Context: The main obstacle of quantum computing on its way to scalability is the noisy nature of current hardware. Various types of errors lead to incorrect computational results,and measures such as quantum error mitigation are needed to counteract these errors. Many error mitigation techniques require a thorough understanding of the noise and its impact on computations. Therefore, accurate noise models are indispensable to facilitate meaningful quantum computing in the near future. They also enable realistic simulations of quantum devices. Since these devices are currently limited and quantum computing is expensive, researchers typically rely on simulations for testing their algorithms.Objective: In this thesis, we aim to construct a realistic noise model for quantum computing and optimise its model parameters. The model construction should build on the underlying physical processes, and the number of parameters should scale well with the system size. We also address the evaluation and comparison of different noise models by benchmarks using quantum circuits specific to real-world applications. Finally, we aim to develop useful graphical representations of noise models based on the existing quantum circuit model.Method: We present a benchmarking framework for quantum computing noise models and evaluate it based on benchmarking quality attributes from the literature. Moreover, we construct a quantum computing noise model and develop a training procedure for its parameters. We analyse the parameters of the trained noise model and the impact ofdifferent types of errors on computations. We benchmark the noise model with the above approach and compare it to a noise model provided by IBM’s software development kit Qiskit. Finally, we develop an extension of the quantum circuit model to represent noise channels.Result: The benchmarks performed in this thesis show that our noise model predicts noisy hardware behaviour of IBM’s ibmq_manila quantum device equally well as the Qiskit model, if not better, based on quantum circuits commonly used for variational quantum algorithms. Within the trained noise model, readout error has the most detrimental impact on computations. Our benchmarking approach satisfies relevant quality criteria by choosing suitable quantum circuits and objective functions to compare model predictionsto hardware data. Moreover, the quantum circuit model can be extended meaningfully by noise channels.Conclusion: Our benchmarking approach is suitable for evaluating and comparing quantum computing noise models. In future work, volumetric benchmarks should be performed for various noise models and application contexts. The parameter optimisation based on learning with training circuits yields accurate noise models and shows the importance of mitigating measurement error. Different optimisation algorithms and quantum circuits should be explored, and more types of noise should be incorporated into the noise model.