Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

“A call to action”: Schrödinger's representation of quantum mechanics via Hamilton's principle

Michele Marrocco

Published Jan 23, 2023• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A few years ago, one of the former Editors of this journal launched “a call to action” (E. F. Taylor, Am. J. Phys. 71, 423–425 (2003)) for a revision of teaching methods in physics in order to emphasize the importance of the principle of least action. In response, we suggest the use of Hamilton's principle of stationary action to introduce the Schrödinger equation. When considering the geometric interpretation of the Hamilton–Jacobi theory, the real part of the action S defines the phase of the wave function exp iS/ℏ, and requiring the Hamilton–Jacobi wave function to obey wave-front propagation (i.e., Re(S) is a constant of the motion) yields the Schrödinger equation.

DOI
10.1119/5.0083015

Related papers

Schroedinger revisited:How the time-dependent wave equation follows from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation

Alex Granik

It is shown how using the classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation one can arrive at the time-dependent wave equation. Although the former equation was originally used by E.Schroedinger to get the wave equation, we propose a different approach. In the first place, we do not use the principle of least action and, in addition, we arrive at the time-dependent equation, while Schroedinger (in his first seminal paper) used the least action principle and obtained the stationary wave equation. The proposed approach works for any classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation. In addition, by introducing information loss into the Hamilton-Jacobi equation we derive in an elementary fashion the wave equations (ranging from the Shroedinger to Klein-Gordon, to Dirac equations). We also apply this technique to a relativistic particle in the gravitational field and obtain the respective wave equation. All this supports 't Hooft's proposal about a possibility of arriving at quantum description from a classical continuum in the presence of information loss.

arXiv:quant-ph/0409018•Sep 3, 2004•1 citation

Derivation and application of quantum Hamilton equations of motion

Jeanette Köppe, Wilfried Grecksch, Wolfgang Paul

Non‐relativistic quantum systems are analyzed theoretically or by numerical approaches using the Schrödinger equation. Compared to the options available to treat classical mechanical systems this is limited, both in methods and in scope. However, based on Nelson's stochastic mechanics, the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics has in some aspects been developed into a form analogous to classical analytical mechanics. We show here that finding the Nash equilibrium for a stochastic optimal control problem, which is the quantum equivalent to Hamilton's principle of least action, allows to derive two things: i) the Schrödinger equation as the Hamilton‐Jacobi‐Bellman equation of this optimal control problem and ii) a set of quantum dynamical equations which are the generalization of Hamilton's equations of motion to the quantum world. We derive their general form for the non‐stationary and the stationary case. For the harmonic oscillator, the stationary equations lead to the coherent states, and we establish a numerical procedure to solve for the ground state properties without using the Schrödinger equation. image

Annalen der Physik•Dec 13, 2016•15 citations

Schrodinger Equation and Hamilton's Equations

Ruggeri, Francesco R.

In (1), it is suggested that one may obtain the Schrodinger equation by using Hamilton’s equations as a starting point, i.e dp/dt = - dH/dq and dq/dt = dH/dp. (1) defines new variables phi(x,t) = ap+ibq and phi*(x,t) and writes: iC dphi/dt partial = {phi, H} and iC dphi*/dt partial ={ phi*, H}, where {} are the Poisson brackets. (1) then changes phi(x,t) into a stochastic variable which still follows these Hamilton-like relations iC dphi/dt = Integral dx H1(x1,x) phi(x) + b(x,t) where H= Integral dx1dx H1 phi*(x1)phi(x) and b(x,t is a random function. In other words, Hamilton’s theory with an added stochastic b(x,t) is applied to a stochastic variable in order to obtain the Schrodinger equation. The catch, however, is that (1) introduces a number of conditions and assumptions to simplify the problem and actually obtains iC dphi/dt = Integral dx H1(x1,x)phi(x) with b(x,t) gone. We suggest that this implies that one may apply the Hamilton-like form directly to a stochastic variable without b(x,t) present. To strengthen this argument, one may consider a bound state in which b(x,t) may be said to average to 0. Basically, the idea of (1) seems to be that quantum mechanics follows from introducing stochastic physics linked to usual Newtonian trajectory physics, in this case Hamilton’s theory. We argue that this is very similar to the classical action approach we used in (2) to obtain exp(-iEt+ipx) from the classical free particle action applied to stochastic motion and so we compare the two approaches.

•Dec 12, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Theory In The Classical Limit

Jack Cohn

The problem of the reduction of quantum mechanics to classical mechanics is considered. It is demonstrated that the customary derivation of classical mechanics from the Schrödinger equation via the Hamilton-Jacobi action equation is incomplete. An improved derivation, involving the expectation value of the action, rather than the action itself, is given. Under this formulation the Hamilton-Jacobi description of classical mechanics is obtained from quantum mechanics, for suitable wave packets as h goes to zero.

American Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 1972•11 citations

Hamilton-Jacobi Theory and the Quantum Action Variable

Robert A. Leacock, Michael J. Padgett

A quantum action variable is defined in the context of a quantum Hamilton-Jacobi theory. The action variable can be used to find the exact bound-state energy levels of a quantum system without solving an equation of motion for the system wave functions.

Physical Review Letters•Jan 3, 1983•145 citations

Hamilton-Jacobi/action-angle quantum mechanics

Robert A. Leacock, Michael J. Padgett

A quantum mechanics is constructed which is patterned on classical Hamilton-Jacobi theory. The dynamical basis of the theory is a quantum Hamilton-Jacobi equation with accompanying physical boundary conditions. Basic objects of the formulation are quantum Hamilton's principal and characteristic functions. As an application of the formalism a theory of quantum action-angle variables is set up. The central feature of this theory is the definition of the quantum action variable which permits the determination of the bound-state energy levels without solving the dynamical equation.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Nov 15, 1983•150 citations
A few years ago, one of the former Editors of this journal launched “a call to action” (E. F. Taylor, Am. J. Phys. 71, 423–425 (2003)) for a revision of teaching methods in physics in order to emphasize the importance of the principle of least action. In response, we suggest the use of Hamilton's principle of stationary action to introduce the Schrödinger equation. When considering the geometric interpretation of the Hamilton–Jacobi theory, the real part of the action S defines the phase of the wave function exp iS/ℏ, and requiring the Hamilton–Jacobi wave function to obey wave-front propagation (i.e., Re(S) is a constant of the motion) yields the Schrödinger equation.
It is shown how using the classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation one can arrive at the time-dependent wave equation. Although the former equation was originally used by E.Schroedinger to get the wave equation, we propose a different approach. In the first place, we do not use the principle of least action and, in addition, we arrive at the time-dependent equation, while Schroedinger (in his first seminal paper) used the least action principle and obtained the stationary wave equation. The proposed approach works for any classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation. In addition, by introducing information loss into the Hamilton-Jacobi equation we derive in an elementary fashion the wave equations (ranging from the Shroedinger to Klein-Gordon, to Dirac equations). We also apply this technique to a relativistic particle in the gravitational field and obtain the respective wave equation. All this supports 't Hooft's proposal about a possibility of arriving at quantum description from a classical continuum in the presence of information loss.
Non‐relativistic quantum systems are analyzed theoretically or by numerical approaches using the Schrödinger equation. Compared to the options available to treat classical mechanical systems this is limited, both in methods and in scope. However, based on Nelson's stochastic mechanics, the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics has in some aspects been developed into a form analogous to classical analytical mechanics. We show here that finding the Nash equilibrium for a stochastic optimal control problem, which is the quantum equivalent to Hamilton's principle of least action, allows to derive two things: i) the Schrödinger equation as the Hamilton‐Jacobi‐Bellman equation of this optimal control problem and ii) a set of quantum dynamical equations which are the generalization of Hamilton's equations of motion to the quantum world. We derive their general form for the non‐stationary and the stationary case. For the harmonic oscillator, the stationary equations lead to the coherent states, and we establish a numerical procedure to solve for the ground state properties without using the Schrödinger equation. image
In (1), it is suggested that one may obtain the Schrodinger equation by using Hamilton’s equations as a starting point, i.e dp/dt = - dH/dq and dq/dt = dH/dp. (1) defines new variables phi(x,t) = ap+ibq and phi*(x,t) and writes: iC dphi/dt partial = {phi, H} and iC dphi*/dt partial ={ phi*, H}, where {} are the Poisson brackets. (1) then changes phi(x,t) into a stochastic variable which still follows these Hamilton-like relations iC dphi/dt = Integral dx H1(x1,x) phi(x) + b(x,t) where H= Integral dx1dx H1 phi*(x1)phi(x) and b(x,t is a random function. In other words, Hamilton’s theory with an added stochastic b(x,t) is applied to a stochastic variable in order to obtain the Schrodinger equation. The catch, however, is that (1) introduces a number of conditions and assumptions to simplify the problem and actually obtains iC dphi/dt = Integral dx H1(x1,x)phi(x) with b(x,t) gone. We suggest that this implies that one may apply the Hamilton-like form directly to a stochastic variable without b(x,t) present. To strengthen this argument, one may consider a bound state in which b(x,t) may be said to average to 0. Basically, the idea of (1) seems to be that quantum mechanics follows from introducing stochastic physics linked to usual Newtonian trajectory physics, in this case Hamilton’s theory. We argue that this is very similar to the classical action approach we used in (2) to obtain exp(-iEt+ipx) from the classical free particle action applied to stochastic motion and so we compare the two approaches.
The problem of the reduction of quantum mechanics to classical mechanics is considered. It is demonstrated that the customary derivation of classical mechanics from the Schrödinger equation via the Hamilton-Jacobi action equation is incomplete. An improved derivation, involving the expectation value of the action, rather than the action itself, is given. Under this formulation the Hamilton-Jacobi description of classical mechanics is obtained from quantum mechanics, for suitable wave packets as h goes to zero.
A quantum mechanics is constructed which is patterned on classical Hamilton-Jacobi theory. The dynamical basis of the theory is a quantum Hamilton-Jacobi equation with accompanying physical boundary conditions. Basic objects of the formulation are quantum Hamilton's principal and characteristic functions. As an application of the formalism a theory of quantum action-angle variables is set up. The central feature of this theory is the definition of the quantum action variable which permits the determination of the bound-state energy levels without solving the dynamical equation.