Concern has been expressed against the new theories, Heisenberg uncertainty principle (HUP) and Schrödinger wave/quantum mechanics (SE) that are purported to have replaced Bohr’s theory and equation. The research was undertaken with the following objectives: 1) to review concerns about atomism; 2) appraise the issues of mathematical complexities in HUP and SE; 3) review criticism against SE and HUP; 4) most importantly derive a Planck constant invariant equation for the calculation of any atomic radii; and 5) re-calculate the radii of selected elements chosen for their biological importance. The theoretical research with calculations, showed that the opposing theories are criticised because, they are obsessed with mathematical complexities with ambiguities without common ground that should usher alternative solution to the problem of the size of atom and thus, they cannot be considered as a valid description of reality. Bohr’s equation and variants of it and the Planck constant invariant equation (Eq. (15)) derived in this research are regarded as deterministic in nature and were capable of reproducing Bohr’s radii for any atom; the radii were also capable of reproducing the average ionisation energies of hydrogen and oxygen atoms, chosen for illustration only, when substituted into derived preliminary equation (Eq. (10)).
Concern has been expressed against the new theories, Heisenberg uncertainty principle (HUP) and Schrödinger wave/quantum mechanics (SE) that are purported to have replaced Bohr’s theory and equation. The research was undertaken with the following objectives: 1) to review concerns about atomism; 2) appraise the issues of mathematical complexities in HUP and SE; 3) review criticism against SE and HUP; 4) most importantly derive a Planck constant invariant equation for the calculation of any atomic radii; and 5) re-calculate the radii of selected elements chosen for their biological importance. The theoretical research with calculations, showed that the opposing theories are criticised because, they are obsessed with mathematical complexities with ambiguities without common ground that should usher alternative solution to the problem of the size of atom and thus, they cannot be considered as a valid description of reality. Bohr’s equation and variants of it and the Planck constant invariant equation (Eq. (15)) derived in this research are regarded as deterministic in nature and were capable of reproducing Bohr’s radii for any atom; the radii were also capable of reproducing the average ionisation energies of hydrogen and oxygen atoms, chosen for illustration only, when substituted into derived preliminary equation (Eq. (10)).
With hydrogen apart from other elements, fractions and multiples of ℏ/2, 0.0053–0.0264 corresponding to the radii ranging between a0/100 and a0/20 (a0 is the Bohr’s radius), and 5-26 corresponding to the radii ranging between 4a0 and 49a0 were demonstrated; the probability of locating the position (a) and momentum (p) increases with decreasing radii. The equations for the determination of the fractions and multiples of ℏ/2 were derived. Computation gave values less than and higher than ℏ/2; the latter was found to be restricted to hydrogen atom only. A relation between uncertainties and pa is for future study.
Einstein consider that in a new electromagnetic theory that would settle the problem of the self-energy of electron, the Planck constant h would be given in terms of the elementary electric charge and light velocity. In contrast to this, Haas supposed that h could be deduced from the atomic radius assumed in the Thomson model of the atom and the charge and mass of electron. In connection with this, it should be greatly appreciated concerning in the history of the formation of quantum mechanics that Sommerfeld gave the view that the existence of the molecule is the function and result of the existence of h. It should never be forgotten also that, different from Ritz who tried to explain the combination rule of spectral lines with special mathematical models, Nicholson followed Sommerfeld's view to discuss the spectra of coronae of the sun on the basis of an atomic model of the Nagaoka type with several electrons, in which no assumption is made of the atomic radius, and came to point out the existence of the quantum nature of angular momentum due to h, together with an estimation of the atomic radius. Bohr, who determined the number of electrons in the hydrogen atom from his analysis of the energy loss of α-rays through hydrogen gas, and thus understood that the problem of the stability of atoms could not be solved with the classical mechanics, presented the Bohr model of the atom, in which the existence of atomic discrete energy levels results from the quantum nature of angular momentum, and the combination rule of spectral lines is grasped with the frequency relation.
Most of the physicians that I know are chary of Physics, especially the theory of elementary particles. Even if in Isaac Newton's mathematically precise universe, everything follows clear-cut laws and predictions are easy given appropriate starting conditions. Perhaps, however, physicians coping with this uncertainty will perhaps feel more in tune with Heisenberg's uncertainty law. Heisenberg (1901–76) described a theory of quantum mechanics, published in 1925, when he was only 23 years old. The uncertainty principle describes an imprecision in nature resulting in a limit to what we can know about the behaviour of quantum particles and, hence the smallest scales of nature. Heisenberg was awarded the Nobel Prize for Physics for 1932 for this theory and its application that resulted amongst other things the discovery of allotropic forms of hydrogen. His theory stated that we cannot always give an electron a position in space at a given time, nor follow it in its orbit, so that we cannot assume that the planetary orbits proposed by Niels Bohr exist. Mechanical quantities, such as position and velocity, should be represented, not by ordinary numbers, but by abstract mathematical structures called ‘matrices’ and he formulated his new theory in terms of matrix equations. The principle of uncertainty, says that the determination of the position and momentum of a mobile particle necessarily contains errors the product of which cannot be less than the quantum constant h and that, although these errors are negligible on the human scale, they cannot be ignored in studies. We cannot measure the position (x) and the momentum (p) of a particle with absolute precision. The more accurately we know one of these values, the less accurately we know the other. There are many ways of looking at this and in medicine we need to take account of uncertainty. Uncertainty in medicine can be resolved in many ways and can include Occam's razor. In medicine, all presenting symptoms in a patient may be explained by a few possible causes. In medicine, all presenting symptoms in a patient may be due to several disease and social processes at the same time. How can this be relevant to a working physician? The whole of medical practice has parallels with the certainties of Newton and Bohr. The object of a clinical consultation is to give a sign or complaint a diagnostic named description to be followed by a treatment regime which resolves the problem. Yet every physician knows and automatically models his understanding of a clinical problem perhaps unknowingly on a model based on Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. A core process, which is complicated by factors understood or not. The same principles are relevant to so many other features of life. There are certain fixed points in the diagnostic and clinical process. Gender, race, age, weight to height ratio, privileged and social life and intelligence. Some people age at different rates to their age cohort? Similarly, obesity does not always matter. The patient′s family history is another variable, complicated occasionally when the putative father with a family health trait may not be the actual father. The social story is a minefield, with the possibility of every phase of a person’s life being of relevance. A further element is how well the physician and the patient and their caring team relate. The clinical examination then gives a further array of data. From all of this comes a diagnosis which gives a pathway to a treatment schedule the ability of the patient to manage their treatment regime becomes important. There is a tendency that as soon as the diagnosis is made then the other elements fade away from the care plan, though of course it persists in the person's life. We are all consciously or unconsciously aware of the complex fabric of clinical care. It is intriguing to appreciate that other disciplines have been presented with the same multifactorial uncertainties. The era in Physics when Heisenberg introduced his view of nuclear physics was one when a precise physical model was being completed and gave certainty to a complex problem. His principle while obviously reintroducing uncertainty gave freedom of thinking and allowed further fruitful progress. We physicians do not enjoy uncertainty, and to have it formalized is uncomfortable. So we instinctively identify the major problem and treat that. By and large this is a useful process. It is however important to see this as a convenience. A convenience that may not always suit the patient. Applying the Heisenberg principles gives a broader view of a patient's concerns and problems and better care.
The new quantum theory was a mathematical description of the way in which an electron behaves when bounded by some kind of potential – such as being in an electric field, acting as a harmonic oscillator or simply being confined to a certain area of space. This mathematical description was then interpreted to be a description of the electron as being probabilistic. It was Schrödinger’s wave equation, together with de Broglie’s concept of a matter wave, that led to various important concepts like the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, an explanation of the emission and absorption of photons in atoms, quantum tunnelling and so on. This chapter explains what Schrödinger did – the marriage of waves and particles.
This paper further explores a dual interpretation of the Uncertainty Principle as applied to the classical Rutherford-Bohr calculations of the geometry of the hydrogen electron orbitals. It shows the Rutherford-Bohr model has some advantages over the quantum-mechanical model (Schrodinger’s equation for the hydrogen atom). As such, it basically continues a development started in my previous paper (http://vixra.org/abs/1812.0028). What is novel in this paper is the exploration of the mathematical equivalence between both models.