Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Erwin Schrödinger. It’s Not Just About the Cat

Helge Kastrup, Jeffry V. Mallow A

Published Sep 27, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It had been known for decades that matter, like light, had both wave and particle properties, but there was no quantitative description relating the two. Schrödinger derived it. His equation begins with a wave description and leads to clusters of waves that behave like particles. His first success was to predict the average radii of the orbits of electrons in atoms. These matched the values postulated by Bohr. But there is a hitch, embedded in the word “average.” Different measurements of the same property of an object, such as position, give a variety of answers and not due to experimental error. There is at best a probability associated with each property. The Schrödinger equation has been interpreted to argue that every object actually has a mix of the values of a property until you measure it; hence, it “chooses” one. Schrödinger himself was not happy with this and hence the cat. Is it both alive and dead until you look and force it to choose one? Interpretations still raise controversy. The equation itself ranks as one of the most important in all of physics.

DOI
10.1063/9780735421721_013

Related papers

THE ROAD NOT TAKEN: A Different Kind of Physics

Rowan Brad Quni-Gudzinas

Quantum mechanics is our most successful physical theory. It predicts the behavior of atoms, molecules, and light to ten decimal places. No experiment has ever contradicted it. It also contains a crack at its foundation. The theory’s central equation—the Schrodinger equation—describes a smooth, continuous, perfectly predictable evolution of the quantum state. But whenever anyone performs a measurement, they get a single, definite result. Which result they get appears to be random. The transition from smooth evolution to random outcome is called the “collapse of the wavefunction,” and after nearly a century of analysis, there is no agreed-upon explanation for what causes it, when it occurs, or whether it occurs at all. This is the measurement problem. The measurement problem is not a minor puzzle at the margins of the theory. It is a failure to explain the most basic operation in science: looking at the result of an experiment. Around it cluster other puzzles. Light behaves like a wave in some experiments and like a particle in others—two contradictory descriptions. Two particles that have interacted remain correlated across arbitrary distances, as though communicating faster than light. The probabilities that govern measurement outcomes appear as a postulate—the Born rule—inserted by hand with no deeper justification. And the theory offers no unified picture of reality: quantum mechanics, general relativity, and the standard model of particle physics speak incompatible mathematical languages. A century of effort has produced many interpretations of quantum mechanics. Copenhagen. Many-worlds. De Broglie-Bohm. Objective collapse. Quantum Bayesianism. None has achieved consensus. The measurement problem remains. This document proposes that the source of these puzzles is not quantum mechanics itself. It is a single, invisible assumption made at the very beginning of the theory in 1900—an assumption so deeply embedded that nobody noticed they were making it. Change that assumption, and the puzzles do not get solved. They dissolve. They stop being puzzles. They become predictable consequences of geometry.

•May 3, 2026•0 citations

The Wave Equation

M. Srirama Rao

The uncertainty principle comes into force because of the wave like properties of “particles” like electrons and protons. The waves tell the dynamics of the particle – its momentum, its energy and even its angular momentum. Wave packets are made by adding together many simple waves that run forever. If electrons have the wave properties then there must be a wave equation and a wave function to describe the electron waves just as the waves of light, sound and strings are described. The success of wave mechanics was well demonstrated by Erwin Schrödinger before an acceptable interpretation of the wave function was known. Max Born utilized the probability concepts of the uncertainty principle to give us the presently accepted ideas of the wave function.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 13, 2022•0 citations

From Particle-in-a-Box Thought Experiment to a Complete Quantum Theory?

Jixin Chen

Einstein: God does not play dice and nothing travels faster than the speed of light. Schrödinger: My cat cannot be both dead and alive. Dirac: The existing quantum theory should not be considered to be the final solution. Feynman: How does it work? de Broglie: My matter wave has an imaginary part. Me: Great! This could be the missing piece the others have been looking for. In this report, I present an innovative modification to the Schrödinger equation, which yields wavefunctions capable of accurately describing quantum phenomena. Concurrently, this modification introduces an alternative interpretation to the widely recognized Copenhagen interpretation within the realm of quantum theory.

•Aug 28, 2023•0 citations

From Particle-in-a-Box Thought Experiment to a Complete Quantum Theory?

Jixin Chen

Einstein: God does not play dice and nothing travels faster than the speed of light. Schrödinger: My cat cannot be both dead and alive. Dirac: The existing quantum theory should not be considered to be the final solution. Feynman: How does it work? de Broglie: My matter wave has an imaginary part. Me: Great! This could be the missing piece the others have been looking for. In this report, I present an innovative modification to the Schrödinger equation, which yields wavefunctions capable of accurately describing quantum phenomena. Concurrently, this modification introduces an alternative interpretation to the widely recognized Copenhagen interpretation within the realm of quantum theory.

•Aug 3, 2023•0 citations

Consciousness and Quantum Mechanics

Max R. Bennett

Quantum mechanics provides a theory for the behavior of elementary particles and atoms. The problem which confronted the founding fathers of quantum mechanics, concerning the behavior of subatomic particles, is best illustrated by means of the following experiment. Schrodinger’s cat escapes the dilemma of being neither dead nor alive in David Bohm’s intepretation of how the Schrodinger wave equation should be applied in quantum mechanics. Schrodinger’s cat also escapes the dilemma of being neither dead nor alive in the Gell-Mann and Zurek interpretation of how Schrodinger’s equation should be interpreted. All interpretations of quantum mechanics so far enumerated require the concept of non-local reality. A synaptic bouton may then have a paracrystalline structure which requires Schrodinger’s equation to describe its quantum states. Non-local reality may arise in a different way in the brain through quantum correlations involving phonons, as first suggested by Frohlich.

CRC Press eBooks•Jul 9, 2020•9 citations

Quantum Entanglement

Yanhua H. Shih

In quantum theory, a particle is allowed to be in a state of coherent superposition among a set of orthogonal states. A vivid picture of this concept is the “Schrödinger cat”: a cat is alive and dead simultaneously. This would be no surprise if one means a large number of an ensemble of cats with 50% alive and 50% dead. But, “Schrödinger cat” is a cat. People are talking about a cat being alive and dead simultaneously. In mathematics, the best word to characterize the relationship between states “alive” and “dead” is perhaps “orthogonal”. In quantum mechanics, the superposition of orthogonal states is used to describe the state of a quantum object, or a particle. The superposition principle is indeed a mystery compared to our everyday classical life experience. Beyond the superposition of orthogonal single-particle states, the superposition of orthogonal multi-particle states represents an even more troubling concept in classical theory.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 16, 2020•0 citations
It had been known for decades that matter, like light, had both wave and particle properties, but there was no quantitative description relating the two. Schrödinger derived it. His equation begins with a wave description and leads to clusters of waves that behave like particles. His first success was to predict the average radii of the orbits of electrons in atoms. These matched the values postulated by Bohr. But there is a hitch, embedded in the word “average.” Different measurements of the same property of an object, such as position, give a variety of answers and not due to experimental error. There is at best a probability associated with each property. The Schrödinger equation has been interpreted to argue that every object actually has a mix of the values of a property until you measure it; hence, it “chooses” one. Schrödinger himself was not happy with this and hence the cat. Is it both alive and dead until you look and force it to choose one? Interpretations still raise controversy. The equation itself ranks as one of the most important in all of physics.
Quantum mechanics is our most successful physical theory. It predicts the behavior of atoms, molecules, and light to ten decimal places. No experiment has ever contradicted it. It also contains a crack at its foundation. The theory’s central equation—the Schrodinger equation—describes a smooth, continuous, perfectly predictable evolution of the quantum state. But whenever anyone performs a measurement, they get a single, definite result. Which result they get appears to be random. The transition from smooth evolution to random outcome is called the “collapse of the wavefunction,” and after nearly a century of analysis, there is no agreed-upon explanation for what causes it, when it occurs, or whether it occurs at all. This is the measurement problem. The measurement problem is not a minor puzzle at the margins of the theory. It is a failure to explain the most basic operation in science: looking at the result of an experiment. Around it cluster other puzzles. Light behaves like a wave in some experiments and like a particle in others—two contradictory descriptions. Two particles that have interacted remain correlated across arbitrary distances, as though communicating faster than light. The probabilities that govern measurement outcomes appear as a postulate—the Born rule—inserted by hand with no deeper justification. And the theory offers no unified picture of reality: quantum mechanics, general relativity, and the standard model of particle physics speak incompatible mathematical languages. A century of effort has produced many interpretations of quantum mechanics. Copenhagen. Many-worlds. De Broglie-Bohm. Objective collapse. Quantum Bayesianism. None has achieved consensus. The measurement problem remains. This document proposes that the source of these puzzles is not quantum mechanics itself. It is a single, invisible assumption made at the very beginning of the theory in 1900—an assumption so deeply embedded that nobody noticed they were making it. Change that assumption, and the puzzles do not get solved. They dissolve. They stop being puzzles. They become predictable consequences of geometry.
The uncertainty principle comes into force because of the wave like properties of “particles” like electrons and protons. The waves tell the dynamics of the particle – its momentum, its energy and even its angular momentum. Wave packets are made by adding together many simple waves that run forever. If electrons have the wave properties then there must be a wave equation and a wave function to describe the electron waves just as the waves of light, sound and strings are described. The success of wave mechanics was well demonstrated by Erwin Schrödinger before an acceptable interpretation of the wave function was known. Max Born utilized the probability concepts of the uncertainty principle to give us the presently accepted ideas of the wave function.
Einstein: God does not play dice and nothing travels faster than the speed of light. Schrödinger: My cat cannot be both dead and alive. Dirac: The existing quantum theory should not be considered to be the final solution. Feynman: How does it work? de Broglie: My matter wave has an imaginary part. Me: Great! This could be the missing piece the others have been looking for. In this report, I present an innovative modification to the Schrödinger equation, which yields wavefunctions capable of accurately describing quantum phenomena. Concurrently, this modification introduces an alternative interpretation to the widely recognized Copenhagen interpretation within the realm of quantum theory.
Einstein: God does not play dice and nothing travels faster than the speed of light. Schrödinger: My cat cannot be both dead and alive. Dirac: The existing quantum theory should not be considered to be the final solution. Feynman: How does it work? de Broglie: My matter wave has an imaginary part. Me: Great! This could be the missing piece the others have been looking for. In this report, I present an innovative modification to the Schrödinger equation, which yields wavefunctions capable of accurately describing quantum phenomena. Concurrently, this modification introduces an alternative interpretation to the widely recognized Copenhagen interpretation within the realm of quantum theory.
Quantum mechanics provides a theory for the behavior of elementary particles and atoms. The problem which confronted the founding fathers of quantum mechanics, concerning the behavior of subatomic particles, is best illustrated by means of the following experiment. Schrodinger’s cat escapes the dilemma of being neither dead nor alive in David Bohm’s intepretation of how the Schrodinger wave equation should be applied in quantum mechanics. Schrodinger’s cat also escapes the dilemma of being neither dead nor alive in the Gell-Mann and Zurek interpretation of how Schrodinger’s equation should be interpreted. All interpretations of quantum mechanics so far enumerated require the concept of non-local reality. A synaptic bouton may then have a paracrystalline structure which requires Schrodinger’s equation to describe its quantum states. Non-local reality may arise in a different way in the brain through quantum correlations involving phonons, as first suggested by Frohlich.
In quantum theory, a particle is allowed to be in a state of coherent superposition among a set of orthogonal states. A vivid picture of this concept is the “Schrödinger cat”: a cat is alive and dead simultaneously. This would be no surprise if one means a large number of an ensemble of cats with 50% alive and 50% dead. But, “Schrödinger cat” is a cat. People are talking about a cat being alive and dead simultaneously. In mathematics, the best word to characterize the relationship between states “alive” and “dead” is perhaps “orthogonal”. In quantum mechanics, the superposition of orthogonal states is used to describe the state of a quantum object, or a particle. The superposition principle is indeed a mystery compared to our everyday classical life experience. Beyond the superposition of orthogonal single-particle states, the superposition of orthogonal multi-particle states represents an even more troubling concept in classical theory.